Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

AIBU to not want a man and his son using girls changing rooms

236 replies

shatteredmama · 10/11/2022 17:08

Took dd 7 for her swimming lesson, there are separate open plan girls and boys changing rooms (it’s in a school). Was surprised to see a man come in with his young son for him use the showers.

I felt uncomfortable with this, especially as the boy goes to the same school as dd. Also pissed off at the air of entitlement from the man. Couldn’t think of any valid reason for both males to use the girls room.

No other women in there batted an eyelid though. I’ve emailed the swim school to complain but not heard anything back.

Its left me second guessing myself and wondering if I’m making a big deal out of this, and given it was children only getting changed, not women, or the man thankfully!, does that make it ok??

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
JennyNotFromTheBlock · 13/11/2022 14:03

To anyone who still doesn't understand just how vulnerable women are to males, read this thread. The stories in the thread (that have made me cry with grief and sadness for these teen girls and women) of sexual abuse, of groping, of a male stalking a woman on trains and following her to a train station and supermarket and police taking the stalker's side, to accosting/over-powering and dragging a woman somewhere, etc, show just why so desperately VITAL is that women have spaces away from men. It's not about 'nudity' or being a prude. It's about women who are stalked, groped, followed, raped, harassed and abused. It's about men being dangerous to women, and women needing a safe place to escape from men. It's about women being in danger and being vulnerable. It's about the survival for our lives.

www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4673471-whats-the-most-wildly-inappropriate-thing-to-ever-happen-to-you?page=1

OMG12 · 13/11/2022 13:44

J0CASTA · 12/11/2022 19:33

How about the people who think male and female changing facilities are not sufficient for their needs get off their arses and campaign for additional facilities, I'm happy to lend my voice of support but I am not going to acquiesce to ransom demands. Woman are saying no

This.

This 100%

J0CASTA · 12/11/2022 19:33

How about the people who think male and female changing facilities are not sufficient for their needs get off their arses and campaign for additional facilities, I'm happy to lend my voice of support but I am not going to acquiesce to ransom demands. Woman are saying no

This.

WindyHedges · 11/11/2022 21:29

Nudity is an expected and accepted state in them, so why is it fundamentally wrong for men and women to be in there together?

Because 98% of sexual crimes are committed by men/boys.

Sexual crimes include voyeurism and flashing.

wackamole · 11/11/2022 21:05

*some 9 and under may NEED the accomodation..

wackamole · 11/11/2022 21:03

SeasonsHeatings · 11/11/2022 18:13

The man being in there is unacceptable, well done for emailing.

Can I just ask peoples opinions because I don't want to make people uncomfortable but I am a woman married to a woman and we have a son and daughter. Our son is 8 but he is autistic and can't yet go into changing rooms or public toilets by himself.

I've seen people here saying 8 is the cut off in the UK. I do take him into family bathrooms or disabled if available but I also take him into female toilets with me too and at a swimming baths I'd probably take him the female changing room too. Is this wrong? I'm hoping to start taking him swimming in the new year but now I'm not sure, do swimming baths have disabled changing rooms? We could use those. I'd hate to make any women feel uncomfortable or threatened.

Just as a point of reference/interest as I understand there's no legal cut-off in the UK:

I'm in a US state which is debating legislation to require single space usage of any lavatories and changing rooms designated as single sex (this doesn't prevent unisex or family facilities from existing too; they usually do). The bill keeps being sent back for amendment in the state legislature, but my city has passed its own local ordinance. (Which is basically a deterrant ,or a tool to be used in cases where something that is already considered harm occurs, as it's generally unenforceable).

Both sets of laws (would) exempt a "child younger than 10 years of age entering a multiple-occupancy bathroom or changing facility designated for the biological sex opposite to the child's biological sex" when accompanied by a parent of the sex matching the lavatory's designation. (This language is so torturous!) So the law to exclude boys/men from the ladies' and girls/women from the gents applies to age 10 and up.

It seemed to be the general consensus (well, among legislators anyway) that 10 is too old but some 9 and under may the accomodation, although I know many people think it should be younger. There are separate exemptions for disabled people with an opposite-sex carer, because the disabled facilities are usually inside the sex-specific multi-cubicle areas, and not key-secured from the outside.

Stripedbag101 · 11/11/2022 20:53

NurseBernard · 11/11/2022 18:20

I’m going to be honest @SeasonsHeatings - the older he gets, the more people will feel uncomfortable and because he has an invisible disability, you probably will be questioned.

You’re just going to have to have a few responses up your sleeve for when that happens.

If he needs to be accompanied, he needs to be accompanied. You’ll just need to be sure that he does his best not to make others feel uncomfortable when he’s in there.

The only place in the UK I now see with open plan male and female changing facilities is school pools which can be rented out at weekends for swim lessons.

all public pools I have been to on the last ten years or so have had family style changing rooms with larger family and disabled changing facilities.

SeasonsHeatings · 11/11/2022 19:57

I couldn't take him home in a dressing gown, he couldn't cope with being in his wet clothes.

I'll just make sure any we go to have disabled changing rooms.

MultiTulip · 11/11/2022 19:42

SeasonsHeatings · 11/11/2022 18:13

The man being in there is unacceptable, well done for emailing.

Can I just ask peoples opinions because I don't want to make people uncomfortable but I am a woman married to a woman and we have a son and daughter. Our son is 8 but he is autistic and can't yet go into changing rooms or public toilets by himself.

I've seen people here saying 8 is the cut off in the UK. I do take him into family bathrooms or disabled if available but I also take him into female toilets with me too and at a swimming baths I'd probably take him the female changing room too. Is this wrong? I'm hoping to start taking him swimming in the new year but now I'm not sure, do swimming baths have disabled changing rooms? We could use those. I'd hate to make any women feel uncomfortable or threatened.

I’ve never been to a swimming pool in the U.K. that doesn’t have both individual and disabled changing cubicles. I guess the communal ones must be more common in certain areas of the country.

AgathaMystery · 11/11/2022 18:59

Rainbowqueeen · 11/11/2022 18:50

@SeasonsHeatings it’s unfortunate but it is not appropriate for your son to go into the womens change rooms.

You will need to find a pool that has individual cubicles or take your son home in a dressing gown to get changed or use the disabled change facilities.

This.

Rainbowqueeen · 11/11/2022 18:50

@SeasonsHeatings it’s unfortunate but it is not appropriate for your son to go into the womens change rooms.

You will need to find a pool that has individual cubicles or take your son home in a dressing gown to get changed or use the disabled change facilities.

FOJN · 11/11/2022 18:45

I think instead of always doubling down that we need to have just female only we should be aiming higher and asking for more overall because that benefits everyone in the long run and protects female only spaces by providing appropriate alternatives.

Until about 5 minutes ago it was uncontroversial for women to want and expect single sex spaces and now because some men want to invade our spaces we have to expend energy finding a solution which enables us to retain the facilities we campaigned for and rely on in order to participate in public life.

How about the people who think male and female changing facilities are not sufficient for their needs get off their arses and campaign for additional facilities, I'm happy to lend my voice of support but I am not going to acquiesce to ransom demands. Woman are saying no.

lifeturnsonadime · 11/11/2022 18:34

SeasonsHeatings I think you will need to start seeking out swimming pools with accessible changing areas as otherwise your son will be making others uncomfortable.

I do have sympathy with this situation but that is what disabled facilities/changing areas are for at the end of the day.

PuttingDownRoots · 11/11/2022 18:34

@SeasonsHeatings lots of pool have all cubicles now not single sex open-plan rooms, so swimming should be ok with your son.

NurseBernard · 11/11/2022 18:20

I’m going to be honest @SeasonsHeatings - the older he gets, the more people will feel uncomfortable and because he has an invisible disability, you probably will be questioned.

You’re just going to have to have a few responses up your sleeve for when that happens.

If he needs to be accompanied, he needs to be accompanied. You’ll just need to be sure that he does his best not to make others feel uncomfortable when he’s in there.

SeasonsHeatings · 11/11/2022 18:13

The man being in there is unacceptable, well done for emailing.

Can I just ask peoples opinions because I don't want to make people uncomfortable but I am a woman married to a woman and we have a son and daughter. Our son is 8 but he is autistic and can't yet go into changing rooms or public toilets by himself.

I've seen people here saying 8 is the cut off in the UK. I do take him into family bathrooms or disabled if available but I also take him into female toilets with me too and at a swimming baths I'd probably take him the female changing room too. Is this wrong? I'm hoping to start taking him swimming in the new year but now I'm not sure, do swimming baths have disabled changing rooms? We could use those. I'd hate to make any women feel uncomfortable or threatened.

lifeturnsonadime · 11/11/2022 17:44

I think instead of always doubling down that we need to have just female only we should be aiming higher and asking for more overall because that benefits everyone in the long run and protects female only spaces by providing appropriate alternatives.

Well this would be very lovely but it isn't what certain factions of males and their allies are advocating for. Whilst those males and their allies are trying to make ALL women's spaces unisex what is happening is that the boundaries of females are being eroded. This enables men like this father to get away with it because some women are also more anxious to appease the males and their allies than to protect women, see Nicola Sturgeon as a case in point.

Cw112 · 11/11/2022 16:23

Orangello · 11/11/2022 15:22

I'm not suggesting that is the answer, just saying what's right for one 8 year old might not be OK for another.

Yes kids are different, but there has to be a line somewhere, otherwise some mothers will also claim that they need to wash their 15-year old son's back. And most facilities with changing rooms in the UK have decided that 8 is the age where most kids can manage themselves, and below that age they can be in opposite sex changing rooms. If an 8-year old can't be let into a changing room by themselves, it's up to a parent to find suitable family changing rooms (or use disabled, if it's due to disability, of course). I have a 9yo DS, he's almost 5ft tall and while he is still my baby boy, I still fully recognise that he would make girls in a changing room uncomfortable, and it is not their job to accommodate him.

"it's up to a parent to find suitable family changing rooms (or use disabled, if it's due to disability, of course)."

Yes I agree but that isn't always available which is why I said before we need to be advocating for female/male/ communal spaces so that everyone's needs are catered for. This takes nothing away from female only spaces but allows for families/disability etc. I think instead of always doubling down that we need to have just female only we should be aiming higher and asking for more overall because that benefits everyone in the long run and protects female only spaces by providing appropriate alternatives.

Orangello · 11/11/2022 15:22

I'm not suggesting that is the answer, just saying what's right for one 8 year old might not be OK for another.

Yes kids are different, but there has to be a line somewhere, otherwise some mothers will also claim that they need to wash their 15-year old son's back. And most facilities with changing rooms in the UK have decided that 8 is the age where most kids can manage themselves, and below that age they can be in opposite sex changing rooms. If an 8-year old can't be let into a changing room by themselves, it's up to a parent to find suitable family changing rooms (or use disabled, if it's due to disability, of course). I have a 9yo DS, he's almost 5ft tall and while he is still my baby boy, I still fully recognise that he would make girls in a changing room uncomfortable, and it is not their job to accommodate him.

bythere · 11/11/2022 15:04

@Pearfacebanana "Why is it not ok for his daughters to go in the mens room but ok for him to come in the girls?"

I've never understood how someone can have this mindset either.

Lampedsomeoiks · 11/11/2022 14:46

*deleted.

Lampedsomeoiks · 11/11/2022 14:46

Lockheart · 11/11/2022 14:13

Well no it's not all you were doing. You were also telling other posters to fuck off.

I wish a deletec post could be privately accessible so it can be edited as I stand by what I said. I would remove the hurt fee-fees element but it all stands.

The reasons for my strong feelings come from an awful stage of my life that has led to how I feel.

lifeturnsonadime · 11/11/2022 14:38

It is a shame that that post was deleted (and I agree with Jenny's interpretation of what it said) because it made a very valid point that I mentioned in the post that was deleted for quoting it, which is :

In what way do women benefit from the removal of single sex spaces? The only people who benefit are male.

Unless you think that a woman's role is merely as support human and our needs are less worthy than those of males who wish to be in our spaces for any reason, then I have no idea why any woman would think that making women's spaces unisex is OK.

JennyNotFromTheBlock · 11/11/2022 14:23

Lockheart · 11/11/2022 14:13

Well no it's not all you were doing. You were also telling other posters to fuck off.

That's a stretch. They didn't address anyone specifically and told them to fuck off. They said that people who thought women should have no rights to be safe from men should fuck off. And who here, would out themselves and disagree with that?

Lockheart · 11/11/2022 14:13

Lampedsomeoiks · 11/11/2022 13:07

Great message deleted. All I was doing was stating things that have lead me not wanting biological males in female only spaces.

Bravo.

Well no it's not all you were doing. You were also telling other posters to fuck off.