Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why do SMs seem to struggle much more than SDs?

33 replies

Laneyy · 10/11/2022 15:34

I've seen this quite a lot on MN and in real life. SMs struggling with non RP SCs visiting/staying they might come stay EOW or a couple of nights a week. SDs don't seem to complain as much and the SC are resident so there the vast bulk of the time. They do school pick ups, drop offs. What's the cause of it? Is it biological jealousy? Unable to bond , different pressures ?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
pastafairyan · 10/11/2022 18:47

*hunter gatherer

pastafairyan · 10/11/2022 18:47

I think it's biological. it's certainly most certainly not of course, there's some other explanation. But in my 40 years and all I've seen I do believe mothers have a different type of bond with children, a different type of nurturing ability and inclination.

No, I have nothing robust to debate with, but it's what I think. I feel it, see it, hear about it, read about it, and believe in evolutionary biology. Think hunger gatherer and the fact they are in our womb and need us to feed them (biologically of course, not socially) until up to age 7.

Men can easily see their kids every weekend, I don't know a woman who would be okay with that, in fact it would devastate her to her core.

We're different. Men and women are different. I said it, I mean it, I stand by it.

FacebookPhotos · 10/11/2022 18:20

I think most SDs go into it with open eyes. Because kids are usually resident with the mum, right from the start of dating the relationship is impacted by the children. Whereas the SMs I know were generally able to have a “normal” early part of the relationship, and the impact from kids comes later on when they’re already attached to their partner and less likely to end things.

Being resident step-parent also has advantages - the actual parent is less likely to take a Disney approach, for instance.

Then there’s the sex differences in expectations. As a rule of thumb, mums and step mums are expected to do more unpaid childcare / housework etc than dads and step dads.

None of these are true for all couples / families, of course. I’ve known some amazing step mums and some shockingly bad step dads.

Heatherland77 · 10/11/2022 18:14

I was girlfriend to a divorced man with two adult stepdaughters in their 20s. The mum had had an affair with his best friend, to the point where she was booking holidays abroad with this man and passing them off as week long work conferences. They split up after he found texts from the other man on her phone which she'd accidentally left at home whilst working a night shift (or was it a night shift? Who knows!).

The whole family, including daughters, disowned her for a while but that all changed when I started dating him four years later. His first girlfriend after divorce. Almost immediately, the two daughters struck up a fierce loyalty bond to their mum, all was forgiven and the younger daughter who was living with dad, started being extremely rude and aggressive towards me. Lots of passive aggressive backhanders and social media posts making snide comments about me indirectly.

Also, the mum was still sending texts to him signed off with kisses and still calling him by his marital nickname. I saw this as a red line.
I managed two years but their jealous behaviour towards me escalated until, for his 50th birthday, the younger daughter secretly invited her mother to the party I'd arranged.

I walked out and put a full stop to it all.

Younger daughter then encouraged him to go on Tinder and find a replacement. Three months later, blonde thing appears.

In this case, it wasn't jealousy on my part. It was all theirs. I called out what I saw as unreasonable behaviour and my partner did zero to manage it.

I still can't quite get over the mum's behaviour after she was that deceitful.

MangyInseam · 10/11/2022 17:57

I would wonder if they tend to represent a different demographic group.

RedAppleGirl · 10/11/2022 17:52

I'm a step parent, we have vast differences in parenting styles. It's caused quite a clash at times. He's just laid-back with his girls, a loose routine. I like a strict routine.
Hence the clash, he does take on some of what I say, he just ignored the rest.

Testina · 10/11/2022 17:35

Posted too soon!

No issues or resentment.
But as we’re trading in anecdotes, I’d say we’re the extreme end of only the women managing the children. But, among my friends, it’s a similar direction - women do a disproportionate amount of parenting both as mothers and stepmothers.

Testina · 10/11/2022 17:34

Well as OP is working on anecdotes…
In my house, I do almost everything for my children, and my second husband does nothing. I don’t want him to parent them. He’s a benign presence, but like an uncle. He’s not here to parent.

Now take their other house… and they tell me that it’s stepmother who does everything for them. I can well believe it, having been married to her husband myself!

Now in our case there’s no

Clymene · 10/11/2022 17:31

Because women end up doing all the childcare? Because men often remarry so that they don't have to? Because stepdads are treated like heroes for taking on 'another man's children'?

Dollyparton3 · 10/11/2022 17:29

SM here. I carry most of the mental load of our household and so when SC hit teenage years and it's Thursday evening and you don't know how many people you're expected to cater for on Friday night it's frustrating. When you don't know by what time you'll find out it's frustrating.

When you live in a home with EOW contact and you witness your SC saying "no" to anything DH says because aged 14 she's made up all the rules and the ex wife is high conflict with your DH so you can't check if no bedtime applies on a Friday night and phones are allowed unmonitored 24/7 it's frustrating.

When as a foresighted female you know this will lead to them staying awake until 4am, wanting to sleep until midday then screaming at the whole house because they're over tired it's frustrating.

When you now realise that Saturday night will now also be high tension because of all the above it's frustrating.

When the SC starts holding a gun to your DH's head on whether she will or won't be coming because she might have better plans it's more frustrating. When the utter entitled shite phrases start kicking in "I'll come on Saturday if you take me to Nando's" or "only if we go to Wagamamas" it's whole new levels of annoying. Extra points if your DH says yes even though your household budget doesn't stretch to that.

I could go on. Add to this the expectation that SM's will love this batshit madness "like their own" but don't you dare express an opinion in front of or about the SC because "won't someone just think of the children".

All of that and I think I'm yet to see a SD post on here about EOW contact. It's not dadsnet

RedWingBoots · 10/11/2022 17:04

Men seem to be applauded for stepping up to raise a stepchild, while stepmothers need to know their place, be mind readers, and automatically love the children as their own.

Oh and a man stepping up just needs to ensure the step-child has somewhere to sleep and something to eat when the step-child is with them. He isn't expected to do hands on day-to-day care with his step-child as that's for his female partner to do.

phoenixrosehere · 10/11/2022 16:59

Societal. Women are still being seen as the caretakers regardless of circumstances. Let’s also not forget the “evil stepmother” tropes that young children grow up with. Stepfathers do not have the same expectations and views placed on them that Stepmothers do. If a stepdad
didn’t want to spend some time with his stepchildren, it is shrugged at by many but if a stepmother doesn’t, she is seemingly a horrible person and asked why did she get with a man with kids. Men seem to be applauded for stepping up to raise a stepchild, while stepmothers need to know their place, be mind readers, and automatically love the children as their own.

RedWingBoots · 10/11/2022 16:56

The tone on this thread isn't particularly set up for genuinely empathising with step parents though, I have to say.

Added to that it is worth considering the history of the law and society's imposition of gender roles on people.

You are aware that some fathers are still questioned and some case interrogated by healthcare professionals and teachers when they turn up to deal with their child's healthcare and education? There as a woman even though she is clearly not the child's mother isn't?

funinthesun19 · 10/11/2022 16:42

The stepmum is in a relationship with the father. Not a good start. I doubt the stepdad has to put up with a lazy partner who makes him parent her kids for her.

Then add to that, the stepdad doesn’t get anywhere near as much aggro from the ex husband as the stepmum does from the ex wife. If the exh was cheeky enough to expect the stepdad to pick the dsc up on his days, he would be told to fuck off by the ex wife/stepdad and the stepdad gets to carry on with his day. The poor stepmum wouldn’t hear the end of it though from the ex wife and there would be lots of talk about how the kids come first etc..

Stepdads don’t have to put up with silly favouritism of the stepchildren by his in laws. Nor would his wife allow any of her children from either of her marriages be treated differently by her parents. But this seems to be a big problem when it comes to the dad’s parents and favouritism.
I don’t know what it is. It’s weird. I think the dad and his parents care too much about not upsetting the older children and/or the father doesn’t have a back bone to tell his parents to treat all of his children the same. The stepmum sees all of this unfolding and yes it does lead to resentment.

Those are a few points I can think of at the top of my head. But even those alone are enough to widen the gap between stepmum and stepdad. They are completely different.

AnneLovesGilbert · 10/11/2022 16:35

aSofaNearYou · 10/11/2022 16:15

The tone on this thread isn't particularly set up for genuinely empathising with step parents though, I have to say.

A lot of people here don't really want to consider that perspective and are predisposed to judge. It's not going to welcome opinions from Step parents to come on to loads of comments from people that aren't step parents trying to tell them how they feel (and usually getting it wrong). Those opinions need taking with a pinch of salt because they don't actually know what they're talking about, they're guessing.

Indeed. Or worse, adult step children who have an axe to grind and gleefully kick any woman who’s a step mum and might not “love them like her own”…

Or, does love them like her own but shouldn’t. Who spends her money on the DSC thereby showing mum up. Or doesn’t and is a cheap hateful cow.

So many options to choose from!

aSofaNearYou · 10/11/2022 16:15

The tone on this thread isn't particularly set up for genuinely empathising with step parents though, I have to say.

A lot of people here don't really want to consider that perspective and are predisposed to judge. It's not going to welcome opinions from Step parents to come on to loads of comments from people that aren't step parents trying to tell them how they feel (and usually getting it wrong). Those opinions need taking with a pinch of salt because they don't actually know what they're talking about, they're guessing.

aSofaNearYou · 10/11/2022 16:12

All of the things others have said (besides the thick stuff about SMs just being jealous of their SDs that totally ignores all the very real issues faced).

But I'd also add that Step dad's are usually dating RPs, and you'd most likely run a mile before doing that if you weren't really at happy with it all. It's much more likely that you'd underestimate how many struggles could arise from dating someone that only has their kid EOW.

JacobReesMoggsSocialConscience · 10/11/2022 16:09

I'm not convinced of the premise. It's likely there are more stepmothers than stepfathers posting on MN just because it's more marketed toward women (although I'm not sure MNHQ collects stats on this - I've never been asked my sex by them).

But there are often posts about stepdads who aren't coping well. There's one right now about a son who's come home from university depressed and possibly suicidal and the stepdad (who has moved into the mum's house and doesn't pay rent) is insisting the son stay at a hotel so his own preteen daughters don't have to share a room.

Precipice · 10/11/2022 16:05

Dads don’t appear to notice the little resentments and slights and will stay in a relationship where their DC are not 100% welcome,

Yes, or when they do "notice", it's only to the extent that the child "doesn't like" the stepmother or isn't positive enough towards her (I don't mean rude or negative, just not overly friendly, most kids are no good at pretending enthusiasm and love) and they're inclined to blame it on the mother 'setting the child up against the stepmum' rather than that actually the stepmother's making the child feel unwelcome. The effect is that the child's relationship with the father also suffers, because the child feels/is unsupported by the father.

BananaBlue · 10/11/2022 15:55

I think there are loads of reasons, but a RL that I’ve noticed is mums tend to walk away quite early on if there appears to be any resentment from SD towards their children.
They view themselves and DC as a package deal.

Dads don’t appear to notice the little resentments and slights and will stay in a relationship where their DC are not 100% welcome, don’t see it as a package deal.

These are generalisations, I know some parents just don't out their child first.

HuggsBosom · 10/11/2022 15:55

It's not due to jealousy.

I think it's due to higher societal expectations of step-mums. They are expected to be defacto mothers when it suits the bio parents. So many post on MN about having to cook and clean for step-children.

There are much lower expectations for step-dads.

PeekAtYou · 10/11/2022 15:53

I think mums generally do more than dads (so stepdads do less than stepmums) and have lower expectations of new partners.
I suspect that stepdads are more likely to leave sooner than stepmums too.

AnneLovesGilbert · 10/11/2022 15:49

Different expectations. And you sound like you’ve got issues with one “friend” and are using it as a way of slagging off step mums as a group. Yuck.

Laneyy · 10/11/2022 15:48

JellyBabiesSaveLives · 10/11/2022 15:47

Different pressures.

Step-mums do the majority of the work looking after all the kids, especially the mental load and picking up the slack when things go wrong, like sickness.

Step-dads have wives for all that.

I know, Not All Men …

2 days a fortnight thought ? It can't be that difficult Vs being a RP to SC.

OP posts:
Squirrelblanket · 10/11/2022 15:48

Because if you have a vagina it's assumed that you will love and treasure all children at any opportunity.