Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Skint Wife and Rich Husband

256 replies

TheSkintWife · 10/11/2022 15:04

I have name changed for this thread.

My husband of 3 years is in a much stronger financial situation than I am. He earns a little bit more but has a lot of savings thanks to a large inheritance. The house is in both names but we're in a fairly low value area so not worth a big sum. We each pay half towards all bills and mortgage. He is earning a decent amount of interest every month on his savings whereas I'm getting into debt to try and make my share of the monthly costs.

We are married but it's been a short marriage so far and I don't want to split with him for this. Even if we were to split at a later date I wouldn't be entitled to his inheritance. We don't have children and both work.

He is really quite tight with his money and he has designer labels on all of his clothes and drives a nice car. I'm in Sainsburys clothes and knackered old Fiesta (which I love but that's not the point).

Is this how marriage should work? We were equal when we married for all those thinking I married him for his money I didn't. He inherited after marriage and I didn't know about the wealth of this relation.

OP posts:
NewYorkLassie · 10/11/2022 16:12

TheSkintWife · 10/11/2022 15:41

He inherited a life changing sum of money as far as I'm concerned but it's not mine and I understand that. He's working out how he wants to spend/invest it.

Does that not involve considering his wife?

this is totally bizarre.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 10/11/2022 16:11

There seems to be near unanimity on here when it comes to sharing an inheritance, with everyone saying that when it comes to a woman it’s hers alone, but if it comes to a man it should be shared

Well, not quite everyone, but I agree it's said a lot

In a so-far short marriage I can't say I blame him for being guarded about his capital, but would have thought he could contribute more from the interest earned

That said, since you're working and even with bills going up, it's unclear why you're getting into debt to pay "your half". Unless you're living beyond the means of one of you, in which case I'd force the issue by saying you'll have to move/cut back/whatever and see what the reaction is

Wishimaywishimight · 10/11/2022 16:11

Whatever the legalities of what you are "entitled to", this is not how a loving marriage works. I would be only too happy to share my good fortune (sorry, I don't mean to imply that an inheritance is 'good fortune', it's far from it I know, I just mean a windfall in general) with DH and he with me. I absolutely could not watch someone I love struggle while I had tons of money stashed away, I just wouldn't enjoy it!

bewarethetides · 10/11/2022 16:10

He should be paying more based on her higher earnings towards bills, food, etc.

Then go from there if you're still skint and he's flush. Surely if he loves you, he wouldn't feel that was appropriate. His response will be telling.

aloris · 10/11/2022 16:09

How is this going to work if you become pregnant? You're going to take all the financial downside and health risks/consequences of pregnancy, childbirth, maternity leave, etc. How is he going to make that equitable between you? Will you come up with a money amount that represents the burdens you carry as a pregnant woman and a mother, by which he'll compensate you? Bear in mind that many women find that they take on the majority of the childcare because the husband refuses, and their projected income suffers from that. And what if the physical/health burden is really big, let's say you have a really difficult pregnancy or you are never quite as healthy after the birth compared to before you had a kid, compromising your career trajectory, or your ability to work full time? Will you come up with some money number by which he will fairly compensate you for your greater sacrifice in the marriage? Or will he just count that burden as zero financial value because it's your lot as a woman to bear the children? What if you have a child with special needs, or a child who needs fulltime care from a parent. Will he give up his job, or expect you to give up yours? How will that be managed in terms of sharing the load?

I know these questions sound like speculation but any woman of childbearing age, who is in a sexually active, long-term heterosexual relationship, has a strong possibility of facing these questions in the future. When you're pregnant, it's too late to negotiate how the money will be shared. If you are stuck with a stingy man, I think it's likely that he will continue to be stingy if you have children. That can be heartbreaking and soul-destroying for a woman. Even if you extricate yourself from the marriage, you would still be tied to the person because of the children. So as you proceed, I think it's important for you to evaluate how this behavior of his could affect you if you have kids together.

DevaleraSpawnOfSatan · 10/11/2022 16:09

I am due to inherit a six figure sum soon, I have told DH that it is mine all mine for seven days ( I just want the buzz of seeing it in my account Grin,) then we will work out what needs doing to the house and then the rest will be invested for both our benefits and to leave to our DS and help him with a deposit.

We have a joint account and I have my own account also (always important to have more than one line of credit available) but everything is split 50/50% otherwise it is not a partnership. IMO

Shoxfordian · 10/11/2022 16:07

It doesn’t sound like you’re much of a team or a partnership tbh. He sounds selfish

Blondeshavemorefun · 10/11/2022 16:07

TheSkintWife · 10/11/2022 15:41

He inherited a life changing sum of money as far as I'm concerned but it's not mine and I understand that. He's working out how he wants to spend/invest it.

Pay the mortgage off would be my first one

Oddieconvert · 10/11/2022 16:07

Op

what was your parents marriage like? Your friends marriages?

Surely You have some kind of benchmark to know that this is most certainly not a healthy loving marriage to be in on the basis of how he behaves re money and your worries

Paq · 10/11/2022 16:07

It all sounds so loveless. Like you are flatmates, not married.

Does he love you? How does he show it?

ChocolateCakeYum · 10/11/2022 16:06

I don’t know how you can bare to look at him never mind still sleep with him. What he’s doing is most unattractive.

Marriage is a partnership. Not an excuse to hoard money while the other goes without. That’s disgusting.

This is how it works in my house. All money goes in one pot. After bills, food and expenses come out whatever is left over is divided equally in two so that we both have the same amount of fun money.

With things like inheritance we use it on things that would benefit the household. So oh got some money when his grandma died. It went on the mortgage. I got some money from an aunt, we used it for a holiday. None of this my money is my money and you can suffer bullshit.

x2boys · 10/11/2022 16:05

I dont understand couples who dont have joint finances personally although i guess it works for some ,that aside i could never swan around in designer gear whilst my dh wears cheap clothes,in our case we both wear cheap clothes but you get my drift!

FlowerArranger · 10/11/2022 16:04

It isn't clear to me what discussions you have had to end up with this unequal financial setup?

And how is he able to live with himself and see you scrimping and struggling?

All very strange and dysfunctional.

FloydPepper · 10/11/2022 16:03

Blondeshavemorefun · 10/11/2022 15:32

How much was inheritance

why hasn’t he shared it

He doesn’t have to. Almost all of the posts where a woman has inheritance it’s said she should keep it separate

id say split bills in proportion to income, his income including interest. The inheritance itself though, that’s his.

jtaeapa · 10/11/2022 16:03

Marriage is a partnership. You are supposed to be a team. I don't believe that he loves you if he is lavishing designer goods on himself and watching you use your credit card for essentials. You need to divorce him.

SleeplessInEngland · 10/11/2022 16:02

Have you actually brought this up with him? He might think it’s normal because you haven’t mentioned it, but the idea that you feel poor while he doesn’t is strange. Why even get married if that burden can’t be shared?

Dixiechickonhols · 10/11/2022 16:02

How does it work on day to day level? Don’t be putting yourself into debt. Eg food shopping. If you lived alone and money was tight due to dental bill you’d just cut back on food more lentils, value range, beans on toast not meat. If you are in supermarket and you are putting value beans and essentials oats in trolley and he’s putting in steak and wine do you say I’m not paying half put it back.

Merryoldgoat · 10/11/2022 16:02

Basically I’d have one conversation about how unfair it is and if he didn’t want to remedy it then it would be over for me. And it wouldn’t be an ultimatum, he should WANT to share his good fortune with you.

Alexandernevermind · 10/11/2022 16:00

This is awful. If he won't help you at all financially then tell him the house must go up for sale, so that you can move to something you can both afford. I'm ignoring the inheritance BTW, because that doesn't factor in. Unless he earns more because he works longer hours etc then he is being very unfair. I bet he let you do the lion's share of the housework too, he sounds like to type.

ItsaMetalBand · 10/11/2022 15:59

TheSkintWife · 10/11/2022 15:41

He inherited a life changing sum of money as far as I'm concerned but it's not mine and I understand that. He's working out how he wants to spend/invest it.

My husband (fiancé at the time) inherited the family home. From the very beginning he's seen it as belonging to both of us. He won't do so much as paint a wall without asking me my opinion.

When we met, he was on excellent money, and I worked in a min wage call centre. We moved in and all income became 'ours'. In all the time we've been together, there's been a couple of job losses, maternity leave and just recently he got redundancy.

It is and always will be pooled. He could not enjoy his money and not share, and I would be the exactly the same.

HideTheCroissants · 10/11/2022 15:58

Sorry OP but marriage is a partnership. Since we decided to buy a home together we have shared all finances. He’s been unemployed and I supported him; I’ve been a SAHM and he supported me; he got a big payout for something and WE had an extension built; he earns six times what I do but I actually spend more money than him; 35 years of being totally equal - we’ve been skint, we’ve been okay, we’ve been comfortable but it’s always a joint situation.

Lil50 · 10/11/2022 15:56

One of our marriage vows was “all my worldly goods I thee endow.” We have always shared everything. Joint bank accounts, etc. Any inheritances we shared either way. It’s called ‘love’. But then splitting was never on the agenda.

wednesday32 · 10/11/2022 15:56

Forget about the inheritance, as that isn't the issue here. You need to look at what you both earn and divided the bills by percentage not £. If you both paid the same percentage it would be fair, and you would be financially better off each month. ie if your other half earns £2,000 and you earn £1,500 (total £3,500), and lets say your total bills come to £1,950. divide the total bill value by total income amount gives you 0.56%. Then you x 0.56 by your other half amount of £2k, which gives his amount to pay as £1,114.00 and your income of £1,500 x 56% your contribution would be £836 (or thereabouts.) You would both be paying the same percentage so its fair and you would both be left with some money afterwards as well.

IfIGoThereWillBeTrouble · 10/11/2022 15:55

The mortgage should be paid off. There’s no point paying interest on a mortgage when he can clear it.

I was initially going to say that as he earns a bit more than you and has the interest on the inheritance, the interest must be huge for him to not be in debt AND be able to afford expensive clothes and car. Then I read your post which said he has £500 pm more than you. I’m wondering if you know his actual current salary (has it increased since he last told you/have you guessed at what he earns/has he lied) AND the actual amount he is earning in interest.

Then, if you know how high his actual income is, does he know how low your income is in comparison? Eg maybe you never told him/he forgot/he guessed at what it is.

Kevinbaconsrealwife · 10/11/2022 15:55

Nothing worse than a mean man or an honest mirror !! Seriously my lovely, you need to talk to him about this massive disparity between you financially….and if you can’t talk to him , the one person who should have your back, then quite honestly think long and hard about remaining married to him…..he’s very self serving… good luck x

Swipe left for the next trending thread