Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask where in UK has consistently good hospital and health care so we can plan a move there in later life?

84 replies

Scandala · 10/11/2022 12:27

We are not ready to move yet (young DC and careers in London) but we won’t be fit forever so I have one eye on the future decade/s.

Inspired by another thread about over-stretched local hospital, I wondered whether there are any hospitals/trusts that are consistently well run, despite current cuts and pressures?

I know nothing stays the same forever but where would you move to based on performance in previous years for later life if you wanted access to hassle-free NHS care?

Are there any areas of the UK that offer great quality of life and great healthcare?

OP posts:
MeanderingGently · 10/11/2022 13:12

You need to look at the areas of the country you are interested in first, and then take a careful look at the NHS provision for those areas and base your decision on that.

When I lived down south, I had the choice of London or more locally (Windsor area). There were some very good hospitals, but the sheer numbers of people (higher density of population) meant services were extremely overstretched, especially for things like cancer treatments.

These days I live very rurally, on the border of three counties. There are many advantages, partly because there are so few people, there just aren't the waiting lists. There is also more choice, I can choose any hospital I like for my care. For instance, I can go to a local hospital for X-rays but for other needs, I choose to travel to Nottingham's QMC because it has exceptionally good provision for my particular health problem. However, QMC is being investigated for historically poor maternity care, so if I were having babies, it certainly wouldn't be on my list. You need to think what sorts of services you will require.

Some rural areas provide extra services that large towns don't; for instance, here you can get some treatments and all medications provided at the GP surgery. I never need to take prescriptions to the chemist; everything is all dispensed by the surgery itself and even delivered to my home if I couldn't get there.

Coffeewinecake · 10/11/2022 13:11

You need at least one hospital nearby that will be able to provide complex care - ideally several

Coffeewinecake · 10/11/2022 13:10

Never leave London - you will have primary PCI, stroke thrombolysis, dialysis units, huge number of high dependency and critical care beds, imaging on tap and large number of expert physicians, surgeons, radiologists, pathologists, specialist nurses etc you have general as well as niche interests.
Plus lots of options for transport without relying on being able to drive.

Crikeyalmighty · 10/11/2022 13:09

@maxelly extremely good advice- don't move for the life you 'think' you will be having and then do none of it. Same applies to moving from a city environment to deepest wales just for a big house etc

Crikeyalmighty · 10/11/2022 13:07

I've lived in a lot of places- based on healthcare both GP and the odd A&E experience, the best I've experienced(not perfect but better than others) have been London, Bath, Guildford, oxford (the Radcliffexwas very good imo) and Winchester. Mainly well to do areas admittedly- but also university places and not full of retired people.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 10/11/2022 13:05

Interesting advice from others to avoid the retirement areas…. Does that mean avoid Dorset, Devon, Norfolk?!

I'd avoid those anyway because a) I grew up in Devon and couldn't wait to get to London b) I don't drive and c) my tolerance for rural life is about 2 weeks. My plan is somewhere near a decent hospital ( I have a condition that needs regular checking and medication tweaking) that's within reasonable distance of London.

Kokapetl · 10/11/2022 13:05

If you want to consider GP services as well as secondary care, this map may be useful: https://www.gponline.com/map-parts-england-patients-per-gp/article/1591001
It's from 2019 so will have got slightly worse all round as we've lost qualified GPs but the distribution is unlikely to have changed much.

Based on that maybe areas near Bristol, Norwich, York or Exeter might be good when taking into account other ideas from this thread. Probably a few others too. These are all cities with medical schools and decent universities so the hospitals should attract good doctors if a previous poster is right. Or maybe Suffolk but near the Cambridgeshire border.

MarshaBradyo · 10/11/2022 13:04

Stay in London but think about weight and health now too. Not that everything can be helped but do active ageing etc

The pp re high level of elderly population in some areas is a good one. Social care causing back log is a big issue.

maxelly · 10/11/2022 13:04

The other thing I would say on 'quality of life' (massive, sweeping generalisation incoming) is that generally the people I see as having a happy, healthy retirement are those that remain active (both physically and mentally) and engaged socially whether that's with family, friends or 'the wider community' so that is what you need to prioritize above all else. I think where people can go wrong is thinking that by moving to some picturesque, stereotypical lovely area to retire in, often rural or coastal they'll automatically have great quality of life without really considering the reality of living in that place. It may have been what they've assumed for years they'll do but they don't fully take into account what they actually find fulfilling and what 'quality of life' means to them. It's no good moving to the a 'retirement town' coast miles away from all your friends and family so you can take up windsurfing when actually what gives you meaning in life is spending time with your friends and family. It's no good buying a small-holding in the middle of nowhere if you're hoping to attend lots of cultural and educational events. I know it sounds obvious when I say it that way but as someone coming up to this age myself, I think people's thought patterns when they lose the tie of needing to be in a particular area for work and once DC have left home is often that they'll fix everything that's wrong in their life by changing area, perhaps to somewhere they've been on nice holidays or similar, when in fact the things that will really make them happy like their grandchildren, their friends, their hobbies or voluntary work or church are all where they are now and actually you can overlook a lot of non ideal stuff in urban areas if you have those things around you...

ColeensBoot · 10/11/2022 13:03

Beneden healthcare is a middle ground between NHS and private. Maybe look into that.

Scandala · 10/11/2022 13:01

@maxelly That is super helpful advice, thank you. Must admit I find it slightly depressing too though to think this is as good as it gets! We have utterly rubbish GP practice and the whole of our part of London is the same as they’ve been put into some sort of chain. The hospital is walking distance but very tired and not one of the ones you mentioned. Also, god forbid you need urgent patient care as you will be waiting in a waiting room reeking of alcohol abuse etc.

Interesting advice from others to avoid the retirement areas…. Does that mean avoid Dorset, Devon, Norfolk?!

I wouldn’t want to live anywhere too rural anyway BUT I do hanker after somewhere cleaner, more beautiful with less of the anti-social grind of London. Is there nowhere in the UK that fits this AND has reasonable healthcare?

also how expensive is private insurance if it’s not subsidised by an employer? Once we are older and inevitably fired we won’t have access to this (not that we avail ourselves of it now as thankfully had little need).

OP posts:
sashagabadon · 10/11/2022 12:57

Stay in London, for the public transport too

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 10/11/2022 12:57

Plexie · 10/11/2022 12:40

You might as well stay in London. Just because a health care trust is performing well at the moment doesn't mean it will still be performing well in 10/20/30 years.

Plus in London we seem to have access to more than one 'big' hospital, so that offers more opportunities.

I was about to say that as well. SW London and have a teaching hospital just down the road whose treatment of my condition has been exemplary.

Septemberintherain · 10/11/2022 12:56

good health care

Septemberintherain · 10/11/2022 12:55

By the time any of us get to old age the NHS will be completely fucked or (most likely), non-existent so doesn’t really matter where you reside. Best to start saving real hard because it looks like only the well off or those with a decent private health scheme will enjoy good health care in the future.

PeekabooAtTheZoo · 10/11/2022 12:50

Wombat27A · 10/11/2022 12:38

I live in a retirement area. The hospital here is really stressed by the older demographic plus tourist influx. It's now in special measures & friends cry if they have to be admitted.

Think really carefully.

This. I had to leave the town I grew up in because it is full of retirees and students so there isn’t enough council tax being paid to fund basic services and all the medical stuff is overstretched, even the gynae ward was packed with elderly bed blockers. I don’t know how funding is allocated relevant to amount of income tax paid but that’s something to look into as well.

The car parks are perpetually full because so many people can’t walk far and there is very little left for maternity and other services relevant to the economically active younger people who the elderly need to care for them, so the younger ones move away as soon as they can.

We really don’t need people flocking to create age-related ghettoes based on idealised views of certain places, society needs mixtures.

Wombat27A · 10/11/2022 12:48

And I'm not being ageist here, it's the prevalence of chronic conditions (common as you age) plus lack of social care that makes things very difficult.

MissyB1 · 10/11/2022 12:48

Surely you are better off in London than anywhere else! Far more NHS facilities in London, so more chance of accessing care.
Yes it’s pretty shit all over, but some places are having a shittier time than others.

Don’t bother coming to Gloucestershire, we’ve totally imploded.

RaininSummer · 10/11/2022 12:43

Nowhere really but definitely nowhere known as a retirement area.

SEND2022 · 10/11/2022 12:43

I'm in a retirement area and the hospital is filled with 40% of people requiring social care provision. The hospital isn't so much the issue, the lack of care has a huge knock on effect.

justasking111 · 10/11/2022 12:43

Wombat27A · 10/11/2022 12:38

I live in a retirement area. The hospital here is really stressed by the older demographic plus tourist influx. It's now in special measures & friends cry if they have to be admitted.

Think really carefully.

We're the same in North Wales retirees swamping our health board

maxelly · 10/11/2022 12:43

I mean the problems the NHS faces with resources, demand, workforce are fairly universal so you aren't doing to be able to escape those anywhere in the UK unless you can afford to go fully private for everything (and possibly not even then, the private sector is struggling to keep up with hugely surging demand too).

Personally I think the best thing you can do in your old age in terms of access to healthcare is live centrally in a major city, ideally London but also Manchester, Birmingham, Bristol, Edinburgh, Cardiff, Oxford, Cambridge. There you will find (a) several major teaching hospitals and also specialist hospitals e.g. an eye hospital, a neuro hospital, a cardiac hospital - the very best clinical staff will usually be attracted to larger/more specialist hospitals with strong associations with well-reputed universities and this also attracts resources and funding into the hospital. (b) you will have easier practical access to different hospitals and different specialists which can mitigate the impact of changes over time e.g. in London if Guys and Tommys has a disaster and becomes rubbish you could go to Kings or UCLH or Georges instead. Or within a specialism, if you need access to a sub-specialist consultant or simply to see someone different it's much easier in a big department with say 20 oncologists than a smaller hospital with 5 (I know it's not that easy to change hospital or change consultant before anyone leaps on me, but certainly easier than if you lived very rurally with only a DGH in easy driving distance and a single major tertiary centre 50 miles away). (c) you will have much more of a choice of GPs and other healthcare providers within easy reach including on public transport e.g. physio, social care, hospices, voluntary organisations. In smaller towns you are often stuck with what you've got especially for older people with limited mobility.

MarshaBradyo · 10/11/2022 12:42

A retirement area is not going to be a good bet

Plus I can’t see it improving as the population ageing issue gets worse

Stay close to your dc and maybe they’ll be a benefit when you age - just lower level caring stuff so you’re not too isolated from help

justasking111 · 10/11/2022 12:42

Pay BUPA or the Spire for private healthcare would be my advice

HoisttheMainSail · 10/11/2022 12:41

No real idea. Only thing I would note is that some rural areas can be pretty poorly served. It’s not that the hospitals are no good, it’s just that it can take ages to get there.

for example, I really love Cornwall, but the poor hospital provision is one of the many major factors that would put me off.