Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask where in UK has consistently good hospital and health care so we can plan a move there in later life?

84 replies

Scandala · 10/11/2022 12:27

We are not ready to move yet (young DC and careers in London) but we won’t be fit forever so I have one eye on the future decade/s.

Inspired by another thread about over-stretched local hospital, I wondered whether there are any hospitals/trusts that are consistently well run, despite current cuts and pressures?

I know nothing stays the same forever but where would you move to based on performance in previous years for later life if you wanted access to hassle-free NHS care?

Are there any areas of the UK that offer great quality of life and great healthcare?

OP posts:
Hbh17 · 10/11/2022 14:13

It is impossible to predict the future. Hopefully the NHS will have become an insurance-based system by the time you retire. But presumably a city would have more options & better access. I am close to retirement & wish I could afford to move to London (for lots of reasons), so why not just stay put?

LynneBenfield · 10/11/2022 14:11

Your best bet is prevention. Do as much as you can now to secure your physical and mental health & wellbeing now and into the future. No smoking, moderate alcohol intake, regular cardio, flexibility & strength exercise, eating a healthy balanced diet and maintains a healthy weight. Maintain normal blood pressure range. Keep your brain active with reading and puzzles like sudoku. Plus look after your mental health and stress levels, get help as soon as things start to get on top of you.

maxelly · 10/11/2022 14:11

Scandala · 10/11/2022 13:58

@Goldbar Interesting point! We live 14 minutes walk from one! BUT even though we have access to multiple hospitals, I would guess that the waiting times would be worse because of demand in urban centres.

I understand the best specialists are at teaching hospitals and many still want to come to London. But I also wonder whether doctors eventually go somewhere else for lifestyle reasons and if so, where do they flock and to?

Erm, Australia? Only semi-kidding, like I say pressures, lack of resources, lack of staffing are real issues anywhere in the country, and can sometimes be worse outside London. I don't think there are many hospital consultants anywhere in the NHS that have an easy ride. Of course lots of doctors do train in London then move out for their own personal reasons but usually that would be to return to their home towns or to the popular areas outside London like the home counties, or nice rural areas, I don't think I can point to any one area that is particularly popular.There is a big push from Health Education England to move more doctor's training posts out of London and major cities to more understaffed areas like Norfolk, the rural North West, parts of the midlands, in the hope those trainees will eventually stay there as consultants but that will take many years to work through in terms of on the ground improvements and many people feel it won't work (already some training posts in these areas go unfilled as some trainees would rather apply to a different training scheme or take a non-training post than move to an 'undesirable' part of the country and it can be a bit of a vicious circle).

I think if you don't want London it's a good call to look at the outskirts and suburbs of more middle sized cities that have very well-respected universities such as Cambridge, Oxford, Bristol, Manchester, York, Exeter as you will usually find good hospitals there are well as nice villages or small towns with easy access to the city?

antelopevalley · 10/11/2022 14:10

@Scandala The GP chain thing is awful. We saw this before we moved. It is an American private firm that runs them and they are dreadful. It is what the whole NHS would be like if it was all privatised.
The GP surgery we are now in is run by a couple of GP partners and dedicated GPs and nurses. They are brilliant.

idonotmind · 10/11/2022 14:10

Private or move abroad

antelopevalley · 10/11/2022 14:08

London seems terrible for GP practices but good for hospital care.
We moved to Scotland in the summer and our local GP practice is fabulous. I can get appointments fairly easily on the same day except on a Monday. Only have experience with Edinburgh Royal Infirmary, but they were amazing as well. With the hospital, the only way treatment could have been improved in a fancy private hospital was with Michelin-star quality meals. It really was superb. This was just a few months ago and I was shocked at how amazing it was.

BeanCounterBabe · 10/11/2022 14:06

You’re better off staying in or near a large city. Anywhere with large retired population will be dire and limited in range of services. I live on Devon/Cornwall border working for large hospital in Plymouth. It’s grim in the whole of Devon and Cornwall. Not as bad as the in-laws in West Wales. We really wish they had retired to Cardiff. Their healthcare provision is a disgrace.

socialmedia23 · 10/11/2022 14:04

Scandala · 10/11/2022 13:01

@maxelly That is super helpful advice, thank you. Must admit I find it slightly depressing too though to think this is as good as it gets! We have utterly rubbish GP practice and the whole of our part of London is the same as they’ve been put into some sort of chain. The hospital is walking distance but very tired and not one of the ones you mentioned. Also, god forbid you need urgent patient care as you will be waiting in a waiting room reeking of alcohol abuse etc.

Interesting advice from others to avoid the retirement areas…. Does that mean avoid Dorset, Devon, Norfolk?!

I wouldn’t want to live anywhere too rural anyway BUT I do hanker after somewhere cleaner, more beautiful with less of the anti-social grind of London. Is there nowhere in the UK that fits this AND has reasonable healthcare?

also how expensive is private insurance if it’s not subsidised by an employer? Once we are older and inevitably fired we won’t have access to this (not that we avail ourselves of it now as thankfully had little need).

we live in north london and my DH went to whittington A & E yesterday. went there at 8 am, was sorted by 12 noon. Pretty ok for today's standards.

Goldbar · 10/11/2022 14:03

@Scandala. Demand may be higher although the younger population demographic probably means different services are under pressure (for example, frequent closures of maternity units). But I would have thought the concentration of services allows for better management of spikes in demand than if there is only one major hospital in a particular area (I might be wrong though!).

VenusClapTrap · 10/11/2022 14:02

Best hospital experience I’ve had was on Orkney! We were on holiday and ds got an infected foot. We popped into a pharmacy, they took one look at it and told us to drive him to hospital. I forget now if it was A&E or an out of hours doctor service (weekend, daytime), but it was a shiny new hospital, we could park pretty much outside the door (for free!) and when I walked into the empty reception area carrying ds a doctor popped his head round a door and said a cheery “Hello, this must be Bob, come straight through”. It was unreal.

2bazookas · 10/11/2022 14:02

Glasgow.
Excellent teaching hospitals.
NHS Scotland is separate from NHS in EnglandandWales.. and very different.

Somuchgoo · 10/11/2022 13:59

South Wilshire isn't too bad, but it depends what you're after!

Waiting lists aren't too bad here and occasionally you can be seen very quickly - to the extent we've queued before whether they were doing it under the 2w pathway, to be told, no, they just have space.

Maternity care (including the postnatal ward) was excellent and when I had SPD, i had a physio referral and appointment within a week.

When my family or I have been to A&E, the wait has been less than half an hour each time. Whilst that's probably lucky timing, I don't think the 12hr+ waits that people talk about are a thing here

GP service is frustrating but still just about ok. Trying to book an appointment for something routine is very difficult, but I've sheets been able to get a same day appointment when needed for myself and the children.

We have a walk in clinic from 6-10pm every evening (and in the day at weekends) so anyone can see a GP same day if they want to. I think this helps reduce the pressure in the hospital

I don't think you'd get the same service in many big cities. However, the down side is that for some stuff, you'd have to travel...

JusteanBiscuits · 10/11/2022 13:59

I don't work for the NHS, but deal with a lot of Trusts and health data. Dorset is by far the best area in my opinion. Their mental health care has been the best in the country for a long time especially.

Scandala · 10/11/2022 13:58

@Goldbar Interesting point! We live 14 minutes walk from one! BUT even though we have access to multiple hospitals, I would guess that the waiting times would be worse because of demand in urban centres.

I understand the best specialists are at teaching hospitals and many still want to come to London. But I also wonder whether doctors eventually go somewhere else for lifestyle reasons and if so, where do they flock and to?

OP posts:
Goldbar · 10/11/2022 13:47

Coffeewinecake · 10/11/2022 13:10

Never leave London - you will have primary PCI, stroke thrombolysis, dialysis units, huge number of high dependency and critical care beds, imaging on tap and large number of expert physicians, surgeons, radiologists, pathologists, specialist nurses etc you have general as well as niche interests.
Plus lots of options for transport without relying on being able to drive.

This. We live in SW London and nearest hospital is within 10 minutes drive (slower in traffic though!). We have four large hospitals within 25 minutes of us. All with multiple public transport options.

Yes, all of these hospitals are underfunded and under pressure and frequently have to divert patients to other hospitals, but there is a huge difference in being diverted to a hospital 10-15 minutes away, rather than to the next nearest one over an hour away when you need urgent care.

waterlego · 10/11/2022 13:37

I think West Suffolk (not Sussex) is Matt Hancock’s constituency.

West Sussex is quite a big area and we have 8 constituencies here, I think. (The part of W Sussex I’m in has the delightful Peter Bottomley as our MP 😒)

Spanielsarepainless · 10/11/2022 13:34

Devon seems fine, even for A&E and GP appointments.

Oblomov22 · 10/11/2022 13:22

It's a very big criteria for me. Dh and I have talked about it. As a T1 all my life, won't move anywhere without being able to have decent access to all healthcare, GP and big hospital.
From Surrey for the last 20 years I can get to kings twice a year, in just over an hour, train to Waterloo 40 minutes. We can be down at our caravan in Dorset by car in just over 1.5 hours. We have considered retiring to Dorset. I'm not sure where is best though.

Tigofigo · 10/11/2022 13:20

maxelly · 10/11/2022 12:43

I mean the problems the NHS faces with resources, demand, workforce are fairly universal so you aren't doing to be able to escape those anywhere in the UK unless you can afford to go fully private for everything (and possibly not even then, the private sector is struggling to keep up with hugely surging demand too).

Personally I think the best thing you can do in your old age in terms of access to healthcare is live centrally in a major city, ideally London but also Manchester, Birmingham, Bristol, Edinburgh, Cardiff, Oxford, Cambridge. There you will find (a) several major teaching hospitals and also specialist hospitals e.g. an eye hospital, a neuro hospital, a cardiac hospital - the very best clinical staff will usually be attracted to larger/more specialist hospitals with strong associations with well-reputed universities and this also attracts resources and funding into the hospital. (b) you will have easier practical access to different hospitals and different specialists which can mitigate the impact of changes over time e.g. in London if Guys and Tommys has a disaster and becomes rubbish you could go to Kings or UCLH or Georges instead. Or within a specialism, if you need access to a sub-specialist consultant or simply to see someone different it's much easier in a big department with say 20 oncologists than a smaller hospital with 5 (I know it's not that easy to change hospital or change consultant before anyone leaps on me, but certainly easier than if you lived very rurally with only a DGH in easy driving distance and a single major tertiary centre 50 miles away). (c) you will have much more of a choice of GPs and other healthcare providers within easy reach including on public transport e.g. physio, social care, hospices, voluntary organisations. In smaller towns you are often stuck with what you've got especially for older people with limited mobility.

Great post and one of the reasons I want to stay urban!

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 10/11/2022 13:18

West Sussex is your best bet. Apparently everything is hunky dory there as their sitting MP has been able to take an extender jungle holiday half way across the world.

Crikeyalmighty · 10/11/2022 13:17

As others have said though-London is strong on specialists and you are rarely far from an A&E- you would be suprised once you get outside London how many places are easily 14 or 15 miles from one!!

Buteverythingsfine · 10/11/2022 13:15

Cornwall doesn't have enough provision for the holiday season. Devon is fine, my family have always had prompt treatment, apart from A and E. Once in the system, it's very good and a choice of hospitals is offered.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 10/11/2022 13:15

I live in Sheffield. Have a fair amount of chronic conditions. Never seem to have to wait very long. Dental hospital is really fast

Lovely go you can book f2f whenever you want. No waiting in a call queue. Just get straight through.

Crikeyalmighty · 10/11/2022 13:14

@Scandala I was impressed by the John Radcliffe in Oxford I must admit and for its size the Royal United in Bath. Both were clean, seemed as well managed as anywhere can be these days- and GP provision was decent- also if you wanted /are able to pay for private tests or specialists etc- it was easy to access in person

Ifailed · 10/11/2022 13:14

I agree with PPs, stay in London. When my DP was being treated for cancer they were seen at Kings, Guys & St Thomas'. It was always noticeable in the waiting rooms how many people had travelled for miles/hours to see the same specialist teams.