Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask where in UK has consistently good hospital and health care so we can plan a move there in later life?

84 replies

Scandala · 10/11/2022 12:27

We are not ready to move yet (young DC and careers in London) but we won’t be fit forever so I have one eye on the future decade/s.

Inspired by another thread about over-stretched local hospital, I wondered whether there are any hospitals/trusts that are consistently well run, despite current cuts and pressures?

I know nothing stays the same forever but where would you move to based on performance in previous years for later life if you wanted access to hassle-free NHS care?

Are there any areas of the UK that offer great quality of life and great healthcare?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Heatherland77 · 10/11/2022 19:28

Dorchester, Dorset. Lovely acute hospital and my parents have always had brilliant healthcare from GP, physics and in-ward teams. Can't fault them.

Didiplanthis · 10/11/2022 19:26

Services in rural areas are often very poor, even areas you wouldn't think of as being particularly 'rural'. We are 45 mins from nearest hospital in an affluent mixed demographic area. All the services are concentrated in the big towns with very little reaching us as its not cost effective so send people out that far to a small population group. The services my parents got in Croydon were vastly superior to that available to similar patient groups locally. Public transport to reach them is dire and taxis prohibitively expensive, and in many cases patients are deemed 'out of area' for services and are not eligible...

WuTangGran · 10/11/2022 19:23

Sheffield has several teaching hospitals and is next door to the Peak District national park.

Wildmamma · 10/11/2022 19:17

Op lancaster is a small city. It is surrounded by countryside.. near the sea and it has a hospital in the city centre ( all walk distance )and a regional hospital half hour away . So it is possible .

Lifelessordinary1 · 10/11/2022 16:09

Pointless question - a good area now may not be in 5 years' time - never mind longer.

I would say London as you have a much greater choice, and many specialist hospitals are there but that's the only one that is different

Mosik · 10/11/2022 16:04

Major city.
I had breast cancer treatment in 2019 and made contact with several others going through the same process.
Those being treated in London and Manchester had a completly different experience in so many ways from the trivial to the serious.
I saw an oncologist once during the whole 9 month process. The rest was all done second hand via nurse specialists. Those in the cities saw their oncologists every couple of weeks.
I had to travel a 2 hour round trip for many, many appointments because my local hospital had limited facilities (even fewer now)

KnittedCardi · 10/11/2022 16:04

heldinadream · 10/11/2022 12:32

The whole of the NHS is underfunded, understaffed and poorly run (by the UK Govt, not the NHS hierarchy). None of it is going to get better soon, if ever.
I agree that time-travel is as likely to get you what you want as taking a punt on any area.

I disagree. There is a huge postcode lottery. The difference in the management of trusts can be substantial. The best run (NHS Managers - not government), are way ahead of the worst.

I personally wouldn't go back to the 1960's. Regardless of the current state of NHS care now, we have so many more (and expensive), treatments and cures available now than back then.

Crikeyalmighty · 10/11/2022 15:52

@gogohmm Out of curiosity where do you live- sounds good

Hugasauras · 10/11/2022 15:36

I'm in the n-east of Scotland and can't fault the NHS care I've had in recent years. My mum is in Glasgow and getting excellent cancer care, even though it was diagnosed during lockdown. Her treatment started immediately despite all the various restrictions.

I had a breast abscess recently and my wonderful GP was straight on the phone to the hospital, who were waiting for me to arrive at 5pm on a Friday night. I was seen immediately (I had 6wo DD with me who the staff were so accommodating to) then had ongoing appointments with breast clinic for a further six weeks, all of which happened without a hitch. I've also had two babies in three years and felt well looked after and cared for. I've also never had issues getting GP care when I've needed it.

I know it's a postcode lottery, but I've been very fortunate, having read some of the horrible stories on here.

essex42 · 10/11/2022 15:34

We live in the north east of england and love it. We have excellent hospitals and decent schools. Close to the beautiful coastline of northumberland and short drive to the Lakes, North Yorkshire and the borders. council tax is high though.

gogohmm · 10/11/2022 15:30

Best thing to do is to live in a place where you can adapt to reduced mobility both within your home (eg compatible with a stairlift), close to public transport and you can get to most day to day things on foot without a car eg on a mobility scooter. I have this - supermarket and bus stop 200m, drs 1/2 mile, cafes, library 1/2 mile, active community with drop ins, games afternoons, crafts etc, big city 30 mins on bus (stops by theatre!) for health get insurance!

Scandala · 10/11/2022 15:25

What fantastic advice. I need to get into shape - really neglected myself these last few years. Basically based on this post I think we are stuffed! No family in this country outside our nuclear unit. So no obvious place to retire to, no network of school or uni chums etc. We are rootless metropolitans!
@maxelly ’s point about not thinking somewhere beautiful is the answer is correct. The problem is we have very little outside of work/education/travel and no time for hobbies outside ferrying DC around! So there is no obvious place to call home.

As for private healthcare, I have just spent 15 minutes on hold for Axa and gave up. Their chat bot online even cuts you off! Emails come back saying ‘we will respond in five working days’. Basically, you can’t even buy your way out of queues!

In the meantime, does anyone have advice for where you can get a type of well woman scan? Would like to explore HRT but not before I know whether I have estrogen sensitivity (cervical polyp found so just want to see if there is anything else going on, very sore breasts before period etc). Maybe that’s a different thread!

OP posts:
antelopevalley · 10/11/2022 15:17

And in cities cleaners, delivery of meals and carers are easier to find than in rural areas.

KenCoff · 10/11/2022 15:15

You are better staying in London or another major city. They tend to have a demographic of more young people who move to cities for jobs.

Younger people tend to use healthcare less. You really don't want an area where loads of people retire to as health and social care will be swamped!

Also in rural areas delivery of healthcare is more problematic and expensive

antelopevalley · 10/11/2022 15:14

ItsOverUnder · 10/11/2022 14:24

The NHS is over stretched and under funded but medical care is best in areas where there is a teaching hospital linked to an excellent medical school.

So (sweeping generalisation apart, and from my own experience) London, Cambridge, Manchester, Leeds and Newcastle have medical schools, teaching hospitals and much better healthcare than Durham, Staffordshire, Somerset and North Wales, where there are none.

Our brilliant GP practice is linked to a teaching hospital. So people training as GPs do placements there. Maybe that is why it is so excellent? Or maybe it has been accepted as a linked GP practice because it is so excellent?

antelopevalley · 10/11/2022 15:09

Garysmum · 10/11/2022 14:21

I would agree. It also suffers from right to chose where lots of people flock to the specialists from a broad area meaning that the services are often overwhelmed.
I am under 2 departments there and in general the consultants are excellent BUT access to them is atrocious. At one stage on the major departments in the hospital had 1/3-1/2 its staff off sick for over a year recently - straight from the consultant's mouth.
Above all a good GP is needed. I am not convinced they exist anymore really. My mum died at home with terminal cancer because she had a great GP to support her. The GP did regular home visits while she was dying. She'd known my mum for probably 20 years at that point (maybe more), knew her health issues well.

There are still great GPs, we have one.
But you need to avoid the American health chain GP practices like the plague. I can only assume they suck so much money out for profit, that they have very little left to run the practice. I heard so many horror stories about a very large practice like this where we used to live in England.

Clovacloud · 10/11/2022 14:54

Avoid West/North Norfolk like the plague. Kings Lynn Hospital is currently crumbling and being held up by more than 3,000 metal props. Also West Suffolk has the same problem, but they are at least getting a new hospital in 9 years. There is nothing in the pipeline for Kings Lynn.

Addenbrookes is good, but starting to suffer with the increased population. Our winters are a little bleak North of a Cambridge but the upside is very few people (mostly because it looks bleak 😁)

Pompomsfantastix · 10/11/2022 14:39

I have had fantastic healthcare and hospital treatment in Berks (RBH) and Oxon (JR and surrounding community hospitals), as has my family. Couldn’t fault them actually but I appreciate this is purely anecdotal! More generally, Oxfordshire is just a blimmin lovely place to live ❤️

ItsOverUnder · 10/11/2022 14:24

The NHS is over stretched and under funded but medical care is best in areas where there is a teaching hospital linked to an excellent medical school.

So (sweeping generalisation apart, and from my own experience) London, Cambridge, Manchester, Leeds and Newcastle have medical schools, teaching hospitals and much better healthcare than Durham, Staffordshire, Somerset and North Wales, where there are none.

KimberleyClark · 10/11/2022 14:23

VenusClapTrap · 10/11/2022 14:02

Best hospital experience I’ve had was on Orkney! We were on holiday and ds got an infected foot. We popped into a pharmacy, they took one look at it and told us to drive him to hospital. I forget now if it was A&E or an out of hours doctor service (weekend, daytime), but it was a shiny new hospital, we could park pretty much outside the door (for free!) and when I walked into the empty reception area carrying ds a doctor popped his head round a door and said a cheery “Hello, this must be Bob, come straight through”. It was unreal.

DH and I go to the Isle of Skye every year via Fort William. Twice now we’ve had to go to Fort William A& E and each time had much the same experience as you!

Garysmum · 10/11/2022 14:21

Sloth66 · 10/11/2022 14:13

Addenbrookes has centres of excellence, but overall seems overwhelmed, the population growth has not been matched by increased provision. DS living in London, had treatment there, seemed much better.

I would agree. It also suffers from right to chose where lots of people flock to the specialists from a broad area meaning that the services are often overwhelmed.
I am under 2 departments there and in general the consultants are excellent BUT access to them is atrocious. At one stage on the major departments in the hospital had 1/3-1/2 its staff off sick for over a year recently - straight from the consultant's mouth.
Above all a good GP is needed. I am not convinced they exist anymore really. My mum died at home with terminal cancer because she had a great GP to support her. The GP did regular home visits while she was dying. She'd known my mum for probably 20 years at that point (maybe more), knew her health issues well.

Jaxhog · 10/11/2022 14:19

If you own your own place in London, I'd sit tight at the moment. Move out when you really need to, because who knows where will be best in the future.

Coffeewinecake · 10/11/2022 14:17

Move to another part of London if can afford it. It is not one big homogenous place

Coffeewinecake · 10/11/2022 14:14

Scandala · 10/11/2022 13:58

@Goldbar Interesting point! We live 14 minutes walk from one! BUT even though we have access to multiple hospitals, I would guess that the waiting times would be worse because of demand in urban centres.

I understand the best specialists are at teaching hospitals and many still want to come to London. But I also wonder whether doctors eventually go somewhere else for lifestyle reasons and if so, where do they flock and to?

The consultants in the major London teaching hospitals don’t tend to move for lifestyle reasons. If they move, it maybe to set up a service or develop research elsewhere but usually within London or possibly to another major city.

Sloth66 · 10/11/2022 14:13

Addenbrookes has centres of excellence, but overall seems overwhelmed, the population growth has not been matched by increased provision. DS living in London, had treatment there, seemed much better.

Swipe left for the next trending thread