Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To withdraw consent for photos for dc at school

30 replies

ShouldntHaveBeenSoHasty · 10/11/2022 11:18

I agreed consent for photos for my dc at their primary school when they joined a few years ago. I didn’t think anything of it and assumed you only withhold consent if you have quite serious safeguarding concerns as I know it’s probably a bit of a pita for the staff to be sorting out kids who have/ haven’t got permission if loads of people decline just for the sake of it.

But my kids photos have been used in every piece of promotional material for the school. If they ever visit local businesses it will be my kids front and centre in the photos. I think it’s a bit ridiculous and it’s probably a bit irritating for other parents too. I’m under no illusions that it’s because my dc are particularly photogenic or anything, it’s just because they’re the only mixed race kids in an otherwise entirely white school.

Would I sound like a dick if I point this out to the school or withdraw consent? The school probably haven’t even realised or if they have they’ll think they’re doing a good thing by pushing my dc forward as it’s “inclusive” or whatever.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
PurpleButterflyWings · 11/11/2022 13:54

After reading some of the comments on here, I am SO glad mine were at school before bloody facebook/twitter/instagram/snapchat/tiktok/youtube etc! The pics and videos of them in school plays/sports days etc were only on the school's website.

LondonWolf · 11/11/2022 13:52

That would really irritate me. Yes I would withdraw permission and I would say why too!

YellowHpok · 11/11/2022 13:30

We withdrew consent after a previous school went mad on twitter in the run to to an ofstead inspection. Every day an new tweet with pics of the kids in class. It was way over the top. We rescinded consent and told them why. All fine.

New school much more respectful of photos but we still refused consent for external photos and they have been absolutely fine about it. Never asked why.

catandcoffee · 11/11/2022 13:05

Do it OP.

PurpleButterflyWings · 11/11/2022 11:26

@ShouldntHaveBeenSoHasty

You're not being unreasonable. My DCs school used to do this... When they were at senior school, there were 900 children in the school, and you could literally count on the fingers of two hands the amount of non white children. Four mixed race children, a couple of black children and three Asian children - out of 900.

There was a big billboard, maybe 10 foot high and 20 foot wide by the front gates at school, with seven children on it, jumping up and looking happy and having fun and smiling, with 'COME JOIN OUR WONDERFUL SCHOOL' emblazoned above them ! SIX out of the seven children were mixed race, Asian or black. Literally six out of the seven children. ONE white child. Even though only 1% of the children in the school were non-white.

It genuinely smacks of trying to desperately be politically correct and it's pathetic. It's also giving a wrong impression of the school and suggesting there's a massive complement of non white children there, when there's literally less than 10 out of 900.

If they want to be more inclusive then try to encourage many more black and Asian children there. Don't do fuck-all to encourage them to join your school, have 99% white children, and then pretend you're all inclusive and politically correct, by having just ONE WHITE child out of seven children on your colossal billboard.

It's like these big companies - like the BBC. They promote how 'woke' and politically correct they are, (along with the producers of most adverts,) because there are so many non white faces on the TV. Yet you rarely ever see any at the top of the company, and running the place, and very VERY few of the big executives will be black, mixed race, or Asian. It'll be run by overprivileged white men. Want to be more fucking inclusive? Stop letting the vast majority of your high, privileged, and super well-paid positions be taken by white males.

Going back to your dilemma OP. I would absolutely take away the consent as well, seen as they're letting businesses use your childrens images to put on their Facebook pages!!! What the actual fuck have I just read? Definitely withdraw consent.

PurpleButterflyWings · 11/11/2022 11:26

YANBU..

PurpleButterflyWings · 11/11/2022 11:25

YANBU.

NeedAChangeAsIAmSoooOuting · 10/11/2022 23:34

The school let's various local businesses post pics of the children?! Wow. Yea definitely remove consent.

ScoobyBooby · 10/11/2022 22:59

You gave permission for school to take photographs and use them . Not local business. I would be so annoyed and remove my consent. If our school wants to use my children's photographs for marketing / outside the school community they ask first .

Id be inclined to raise it as a safe guarding issue given how much their photographs are used, the tourist village you live and the amount of members that the Facebook page has .

Purplepepsi · 10/11/2022 22:47

I work in a school, quite a few kids don't have photo consent for many different reasons. Its a shame when we can't use a nice photo, but we would never question a parent for their reasons. It may be worth just drawing their attention to it though, it's quite lazy.

Yayasisterhood · 10/11/2022 22:41

I refused consent for my kids - for no reason other than I don’t want their picture to be public. It’s fine. They put a big heart emoji over their face or whatever if it’s a group picture or choose one that doesn’t have them in. It’s awkward for them but I don’t care!

forevercooking · 10/11/2022 22:38

I've never consented. Didn't stop them putting the Christmas nativity on fucking YouTube!

ShouldntHaveBeenSoHasty · 10/11/2022 18:56

@Needmorelego kids are oblivious but certainly not ones t to rush to get their photos taken in normal situations. They’ve both individually mentioned that they’re the only brown ones in their school though and it won’t be long until they figure out why it’s always them being pushed front and centre.

I can’t remember exactly what it was I signed for dc but I know I didn’t put any stipulations on the photos. I’ll speak to the teacher tomorrow as I’m sure she won’t have even thought about it. I don’t want to speak to the local businesses. It’s a really small place and I don’t want to be the woman that makes a fuss. I’m worried they’ll think I’m accusing them of some form of racism when I’m not, it just makes me uncomfortable.

OP posts:
TeenDivided · 10/11/2022 15:25

I'd withdraw consent too for future photos.
And I'd say why - that they always seem to be picked and it's too much.

chocolatemmmmm · 10/11/2022 15:21

I would withdraw under these circumstances.

Thereisnolight · 10/11/2022 15:17

The school is using your children as promotional/marketing material, unpaid. That’s annoying and not in the spirit of your consent at all.

DarkShade · 10/11/2022 15:14

It's fine to withdraw and it's not that unusual nowadays. My kids aren't online at all. Our childcare lets us choose what photo permissions to give, might that be an option? So we consent to the ones on in school app and on walls at school, but not to ones for marketing purposes or freely seen on public websites.

MeridianB · 10/11/2022 15:13

YANBU! Especially as you suspect their motivation here.

I wouldn't want my children's photos pasted over every bit of school promo/website.

When they started school I allowed photos but then suddenly the school went from a password-protected weekly update to an external blog. They also got stuck into social media, so I asked to be switched to internal only.

If you want them to remove the existing images from their website then they should do that without hesitation.

Needmorelego · 10/11/2022 14:57

Maybe your kids love it. Maybe the sight of a camera and they rush to pose.
Have you talked to your kids?

MintChocCornetto · 10/11/2022 14:54

It's not cheeky to withdraw consent at all. Do not be made to feel bad about that for one minute. I work in a school and it's just not something anyone there would be resentful of, we all have GDPR drummed into us every time we have an inset day!

The individual businesses I would contact myself. One by one, get those pics taken down. And they shouldn't have an issue with it either. You are perfectly within your rights to ask them to be removed.

And you can do it retrospectively. PP saying there isn't anything you can do about past images is wrong.

CredibilityProblem · 10/11/2022 14:51

I absolutely see why it's getting to you, but withdrawing consent for photos completely would perhaps mean them being singled out more and you and them losing out on nice things like group photos from school plays or whatever.

Could you have a conversation with the head teacher to share your concerns about your children being used as Benetton poster-kids and ask for how they might be able to rein it back when it comes to promotional material, on a best endeavours basis. Eg OP's DCs to be included only in group photos of ten or more. Form teacher to intervene when the village newspaper photographer is trying to move them to the front of the group photo as usual.

FacebookPhotos · 10/11/2022 14:05

I'm surprised the school allowed the children to be photographed for other businesses to use as promotional material. In my current school the permission options are:

  • none
  • internal use only
  • school promotional material and social media sites
We don't even have a space you can consent to the children being used by other businesses!

I'd ask to speak to someone senior - a deputy head perhaps? Ask if it is possible to change the permission to internal only. That way they can use photos for a wall display at school, but not online.

I'd also definitely ask the businesses to remove the photos from their facebook and / or websites. I'm not sure if you can force them to though.

Dotjones · 10/11/2022 13:48

You can't do much about the images that have already been taken and used if you signed a consent form. But you can withdraw consent for future images.

TheWurst · 10/11/2022 13:25

That’s really bad! Do you have a copy of the release you signed?

ShouldntHaveBeenSoHasty · 10/11/2022 12:25

There are only 60 odd kids in the school, no operations manager or anything like that. We live in a very touristy village and they kids spend one day a week out of the classroom where they inevitably end up in the cafe/ pub/ lifeboat station to write up what they’ve been doing. The businesses then use the photos for marketing which go on the village FB page which has nearly a quarter of a million followers. It’s more those photos that bother me but obviously they were taken due to me consenting through school and I do t know if it will sound cheeky asking them to remove stuff retrospectively. I just Googled the name of my village and there are photos of my kids on the first page of Google images.

OP posts: