Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Children and Christmas

191 replies

Gropiuschair · 10/11/2022 10:00

My younger children of 8 and 5 want to spend Christmas with the in-laws, their half-sister on their dad’s side and their cousins.

This would mean that me and my elder daughter would be alone with my mother.

The reason why we can’t all go is my eldest daughter would have one present and would have to watch her step and half-sisters and their cousins open tons of presents.

I am heartbroken but my husband just thinks it’s inevitable and is amazed it’s the first time it’s come up.

My eldest girl has no relationship with her father or his side.

Just don’t know what to do.

OP posts:
Murdoch1949 · 12/11/2022 19:56

Why does your husband not talk to his family about this? If they have closed ears, he needs to step up with an embroidered sack & extra presents for your daughter. She is already putting up with an absent dad. What about her bio grandparents on dad’s side, do they send anything that could be used?

Dontwanttoberudeorwastetime · 12/11/2022 19:48

ZoeCM · 12/11/2022 19:39

But by that logic, the OP's daughter could spend Christmas with her siblings this year if she went to the other house! She's choosing not to, which is her right. Her siblings want to spend Christmas with their other half-sister for once. What's wrong with that?

Because one is based on greed. The other is based on feeling excluded and isolated by her own family, at Christmas

ZoeCM · 12/11/2022 19:39

Dontwanttoberudeorwastetime · 12/11/2022 18:50

But that’s because she chooses to not spend it with her siblings and dad. She’d prefer to be spoilt at the grandparents.
The daughter of OP is not making her choice based on where she gets most presents, she’s choosing to not go there and feel like a sore part with her own family.

I think OP’s in-laws are disgusting and her husband is wet.

But by that logic, the OP's daughter could spend Christmas with her siblings this year if she went to the other house! She's choosing not to, which is her right. Her siblings want to spend Christmas with their other half-sister for once. What's wrong with that?

mygrandchildrenrock · 12/11/2022 19:07

@Dontwanttoberudeorwastetime
Thank you

Dontwanttoberudeorwastetime · 12/11/2022 18:50

ZoeCM · 12/11/2022 18:42

But the OP's stepdaughter has only ever had one Christmas Day with one of her siblings. And unless I've misunderstood, it doesn't sound as though she's had a Christmas Day with her own dad for years either. And now, when her own siblings have asked to finally spend Christmas with her, people are saying it shouldn't be allowed because they should be with their other half-sister instead, and the stepdaughter should be put in the position of choosing between her cousins and half-siblings.

But that’s because she chooses to not spend it with her siblings and dad. She’d prefer to be spoilt at the grandparents.
The daughter of OP is not making her choice based on where she gets most presents, she’s choosing to not go there and feel like a sore part with her own family.

I think OP’s in-laws are disgusting and her husband is wet.

ZoeCM · 12/11/2022 18:42

Dontwanttoberudeorwastetime · 12/11/2022 18:13

I’d give her the choice, spend it with your siblings and dad or grandparents and cousins.
“We have Christmas at home and we’d love for you to be here but will also understand if you want to go to your grandparents”

But the OP's stepdaughter has only ever had one Christmas Day with one of her siblings. And unless I've misunderstood, it doesn't sound as though she's had a Christmas Day with her own dad for years either. And now, when her own siblings have asked to finally spend Christmas with her, people are saying it shouldn't be allowed because they should be with their other half-sister instead, and the stepdaughter should be put in the position of choosing between her cousins and half-siblings.

ClocksGoingBackwards · 12/11/2022 18:41

I’d give her the choice, spend it with your siblings and dad or grandparents and cousins

Maybe, as she’s already given her own daughter the choice, you’re right and the DSD should have the choice too. But then if she gets the choice then so should the younger two, and they’ve already chosen to be at their paternal grandparents house. Which pretty much leaves OP in the same situation.

lunar1 · 12/11/2022 18:39

Children need to be treated the same when they are together, spoiling certain children because you have a different relationship with them can be done at a different time.

I have traditions with my children on the last day of school before Christmas, this year I've got my friends child for 4 nights as she is having surgery. He's been added to our tradition (my version of Christmas Eve boxes) because he's a child, with feelings who will be in my home!

The matching pj's for 3 of four siblings is bloody disgusting.

Bignanny30 · 12/11/2022 18:32

Sorry my last message was meant for the idiot who said that at 12 she should understand. I’m affraid I don’t have an answer. I’m surprised that your in laws don’t treat their son’s step daughter the same as their other grandchildren, that’s pretty disgusting. Maybe you could have them all to yours for Christmas and ask them not to bring all of the presents just the same amount for each child and then maybe if he takes the other children to see his parents again on another day (say Boxing Day) an you and your eldest do something special just for you two.

PamelaShipman80 · 12/11/2022 18:27

I feel really sad that the in laws wouldn’t treat her as though she was their grandchild. She’s a child make her feel part of the family?! If I was having another child with us for the day everything would be equal.

Bignanny30 · 12/11/2022 18:20

At 12 why should she even have to understand that her siblings will get more from their grandparents.

TrashyPanda · 12/11/2022 18:17

aSofaNearYou · 12/11/2022 16:57

The OP's children have another sister on their father's side.

I think this is being forgotten by so many. The younger siblings deserve to be able to spend some Christmas' with their half sibling on their dad's side, and that side of the family. It isn't fair for all Christmas' to be with OPs side of the family that her DSD doesn't want to see.

Agreed

its complicated.
i don’t see an easy answer.

your eldest DD doesn’t want to go to DHs parents

his eldest DD doesn’t want to go to your DMs. I’m guessing that she doesn’t live with you and that she only gets to spend every second Xmas with her dad and younger siblings?

nobody is going to get 100% what they want.

you listened to your eldest DD when she told you she didn’t want to go to the inlaws. I think you also have to listen to the younger ones, who do want to go. And also think of your DSD, who doesn’t get to live with her younger siblings and possibly feels a bit left out at your house, because she isn’t a part of the family that live there all the time.

sorry - no easy solution. Everyone’s feelings are important here.

Dontwanttoberudeorwastetime · 12/11/2022 18:13

ClocksGoingBackwards · 12/11/2022 17:58

But the daughter (OP’s DSD) would be left out of the day with her cousins if that’s happening on Christmas Day. And she doesn’t want to. Why should she when her own family is having a Christmas Day that she would enjoy and is welcome at?

There are only so many special days around Christmas, and it’s not only about what suits OPs family. There’s the families of the cousins, and they will have their own in laws to accommodate too.

The grandparents can only be expected to host Christmas once a year, you seem to think they should have multiple full on days to accommodate their childrens step children.

I’d give her the choice, spend it with your siblings and dad or grandparents and cousins.
“We have Christmas at home and we’d love for you to be here but will also understand if you want to go to your grandparents”

De88 · 12/11/2022 18:08

It IS inevitable. Will you hold back your eldest from you all being together for forever, just because she doesn't have as much to open? Is this more about how you feel? At 12 she will be old enough to understand it is not about the presents, and with some support will be able to understand ( though maybe don't expect her to accept) other people's perpectives. I suspect she will make less of it than you think.

BadNomad · 12/11/2022 18:05

Why can you not just have Christmas in your own house? All the children. Others can go off to see rich granny in the evening.

ClocksGoingBackwards · 12/11/2022 17:58

But the daughter (OP’s DSD) would be left out of the day with her cousins if that’s happening on Christmas Day. And she doesn’t want to. Why should she when her own family is having a Christmas Day that she would enjoy and is welcome at?

There are only so many special days around Christmas, and it’s not only about what suits OPs family. There’s the families of the cousins, and they will have their own in laws to accommodate too.

The grandparents can only be expected to host Christmas once a year, you seem to think they should have multiple full on days to accommodate their childrens step children.

ZoeCM · 12/11/2022 17:57

The younger children can bond with their extended family at less emotionally charged times.

Their half-sister on their father's side is not their "extended family". She's immediate family, just like their sister on their mother's side.

It's bizarre that people are saying the OP's younger kids should never have a Christmas with their own half-sister because "families shouldn't be separated at Christmas"! WTF? It makes no sense. Unless all four kids are together, the family will be separated.

Dontwanttoberudeorwastetime · 12/11/2022 17:48

ClocksGoingBackwards · 12/11/2022 17:34

Have Christmas Day together, then husband can go with youngest on Boxing Day whilst you and eldest chill at home/go for a walk/online sales.

But what about the OPs DSD? What if she needs to go back and spend time with her own Mum on Boxing Day and the only opportunity she will have to celebrate with her grandparents, aunts, uncles and cousins is on Christmas Day? Why should she be forced to miss out on a fun day with her own extended family for the sake of her step sister and her step sisters gran?

Why can’t the daughter spend Christmas at OP’s house?

The obvious solution here is all the children at OP’s house for Christmas and an alternative day organised to go to the grandparents. Then on the day they’re at the grandparents mum and oldest daughter have a special day out planned.

That way no one feels left out. No one is left at home missing children, siblings or parents. The biological grand children get spoilt on the same day the oldest daughter gets spoilt.

ClocksGoingBackwards · 12/11/2022 17:34

Have Christmas Day together, then husband can go with youngest on Boxing Day whilst you and eldest chill at home/go for a walk/online sales.

But what about the OPs DSD? What if she needs to go back and spend time with her own Mum on Boxing Day and the only opportunity she will have to celebrate with her grandparents, aunts, uncles and cousins is on Christmas Day? Why should she be forced to miss out on a fun day with her own extended family for the sake of her step sister and her step sisters gran?

CaitoftheCantii · 12/11/2022 17:29

Have Christmas Day together, then husband can go with youngest on Boxing Day whilst you and eldest chill at home/go for a walk/online sales.

whilst it’s up to the grandparents how much they spend, not everything has to come back home - keep some gifts at grandparents to be played with on visits.

MosmanP · 12/11/2022 17:25

The only time we ever had this situation was with the grandparents buying the biological children premium bonds when they were born so they had £500 each that my eldest didn’t have this that was easily resolved by me buying £500 in premium bonds for the eldest. Christmas and birthdays this has simply never been an issue and had it been it would’ve well and truly nipped in the bud early on. the grandparents treated all of the children the same.

ClocksGoingBackwards · 12/11/2022 17:22

The OP and her DH have created a situation where it’s impossible for all their children to have an ideal Christmas. The younger children are automatically going to miss out on being with one of their sisters even if the grandparents do give them all the same because otherwise the other granny will be alone. I agree with the DH, problems like this were inevitable.

OP can’t expect the grandparents to give their grandchildren less because there are cousins involved as well. OP or her DH don’t get to dictate how much is spent on their nieces and nephews. They could (wrongly) insist that they same is spent on all the children they have between them and there could still be a disparity. This is the shit people should think about before they blend families.

Whatsleftnow · 12/11/2022 17:15

I’ve never forgotten how lovely my dsis’ gm was to me; I had no idea that having three grannies wasn’t a normal thing until a nasty nun put me right at school.
My dsis was her only gc, and her own ds had died, so if anyone ever had the right to play favourites it was her. But she didn’t and she encouraged my dm to move on with her life too. It was messy and painful and she was a woman of grace, kindness and courage.

If I ever have unrelated gc, she will be my template of how to behave. Shame on your pils and shame on your dh.

I don’t know what I’d advise you to do op. I think I would be insisting on buying her matching pjs and a similar sack loads of gifts and bring her along anyway. I’d sacrifice an awful lot of other things before I’d allow a dc to feel like that.

5128gap · 12/11/2022 17:11

As a family, you need to spend Christmas in a way that suits you all, not in a way that pleases two children, makes one child and one adult miserable, and about which the other adult seems to be shrugging passively.
The younger children can bond with their extended family at less emotionally charged times. Sleepovers in the school holidays for example. I'd tell them no and that Christmas is for your family of 5 (+ your mum) at your house and that's final.

Balloonsarethebest · 12/11/2022 17:09

My mil doesn't get on with my eldest. But at Christmas she spoils all three of my girls with an absolute mountain of presents, even though her son is only father to the youngest. Pil are definitely AH and you need to put your foot down and keep everyone home with you rather than splitting off. Your husband is definitely an AH too as this is not inevitable, it's evil.

Swipe left for the next trending thread