Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Children and Christmas

191 replies

Gropiuschair · 10/11/2022 10:00

My younger children of 8 and 5 want to spend Christmas with the in-laws, their half-sister on their dad’s side and their cousins.

This would mean that me and my elder daughter would be alone with my mother.

The reason why we can’t all go is my eldest daughter would have one present and would have to watch her step and half-sisters and their cousins open tons of presents.

I am heartbroken but my husband just thinks it’s inevitable and is amazed it’s the first time it’s come up.

My eldest girl has no relationship with her father or his side.

Just don’t know what to do.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ClocksGoingBackwards · 13/11/2022 21:02

Yes, there will always be a disparity between children in a set up like this. The DH was right, it is inevitable.

Dontwanttoberudeorwastetime · 13/11/2022 18:57

ClocksGoingBackwards · 13/11/2022 18:55

Not being isolated and treated differently form your siblings is a need.

I agree. So why isn’t the answer to just buy more presents instead of stopping three children being where they want to be?

The DSD will be back with her own mum next year and OP can have all her children in her home then.

Because then the parents are buying more presents for one of their children which still leaves a disparity

ClocksGoingBackwards · 13/11/2022 18:55

Not being isolated and treated differently form your siblings is a need.

I agree. So why isn’t the answer to just buy more presents instead of stopping three children being where they want to be?

The DSD will be back with her own mum next year and OP can have all her children in her home then.

Ponoka7 · 13/11/2022 18:26

This should have been addressed before you had a second child. I can understand someone holding back on treating a child as a grandchild, but not four years in and a biological grandchild being born. They've been in her life since she was a toddler, it's disgraceful. Another pair of pjs, embroidered sack wouldn't have cost much. The first year that she was excluded, your children shouldn't have gone again. Your DH should have a word to even out the presents, or you should get her extra to open there. If that can't happen, then I'd shorten the visit, so most of the day is spent together then the children go off to the in-laws and you to your Mum's with your DD.

Dontwanttoberudeorwastetime · 13/11/2022 18:12

ClocksGoingBackwards · 13/11/2022 17:48

The stop mum in this situation is entirely right to want all the children together in her home, the problem they have is that the three out of four children don’t want to do that!

Its not a case of step mum = evil. It’s that sometimes in families, especially blended ones, children’s genuine needs are in direct conflict with each other. That can’t be washed away and problem solved by having all the children in OPs home because the problem will still exist for the OPs DSD who already has to split her life between her parents.

Being fair to one child is always going to be unfair on the other. There is no getting round that fact. I just have slightly more sympathy for the dsd who misses out on her family rather than the dd who misses out on presents. The parents who created this problem could compensate for those, but dsd can’t get Christmas Day with her grandparents and cousins back.

Spending Christmas with grandparents is a want.

Not being isolated and treated differently form your siblings is a need.

ClocksGoingBackwards · 13/11/2022 17:48

The stop mum in this situation is entirely right to want all the children together in her home, the problem they have is that the three out of four children don’t want to do that!

Its not a case of step mum = evil. It’s that sometimes in families, especially blended ones, children’s genuine needs are in direct conflict with each other. That can’t be washed away and problem solved by having all the children in OPs home because the problem will still exist for the OPs DSD who already has to split her life between her parents.

Being fair to one child is always going to be unfair on the other. There is no getting round that fact. I just have slightly more sympathy for the dsd who misses out on her family rather than the dd who misses out on presents. The parents who created this problem could compensate for those, but dsd can’t get Christmas Day with her grandparents and cousins back.

Dontwanttoberudeorwastetime · 13/11/2022 17:34

ClocksGoingBackwards · 13/11/2022 16:17

And that’s why I’d hate someone with your attitude to be step mother to my child. And why many children are much worse off with step parents in their lives than they would have been if their parents had just separated and let them grow up before starting new families.

Incredible.

Stepmum wants all her children and stepchild to have Christmas together and with their dad and be treated completely equally- evil step mum

Stepchild wants to go to grandparents which will either divide the family or make it do that her stepsister is ignored and sidelined on Christmas- reasonable

this place is wild sometimes

Tinkerbyebye · 13/11/2022 16:36

Just say no. Surely you and your husband should be starting your own christmas traditions now?

they can go and see them Boxing Day but the cynic in me is saying they just want the presents

ancientgran · 13/11/2022 16:26

DisforDarkChocolate · 13/11/2022 16:22

I give thanks every day that my in-laws treated my 3 eldest children as bonus grandchildren when they were young. It says everything about them you need to know, all they saw was more children to love.

You can't leave this as it is because it's driving a wedge between your children.

That's lovely and everyone is a winner in your scenario.

ancientgran · 13/11/2022 16:25

I don't know why it is difficult.

Ops in laws should invite OPs mother if they want all their family together, they are adults and must see it would be unfair to leave her on her own so they can have all their GC for the day.

Ops in laws don't just buy one present for the eldest DD. She's been in their lives for 9 years minimum so they need to realise she is part of the family.

Failing that OP, her husband and all her children stay at home with invite to DSD who can spend all or part of the day with them.

No way should it involve a 12 year old sitting looking on while her siblings get loads more than her.

DisforDarkChocolate · 13/11/2022 16:22

I give thanks every day that my in-laws treated my 3 eldest children as bonus grandchildren when they were young. It says everything about them you need to know, all they saw was more children to love.

You can't leave this as it is because it's driving a wedge between your children.

ClocksGoingBackwards · 13/11/2022 16:17

And that’s why I’d hate someone with your attitude to be step mother to my child. And why many children are much worse off with step parents in their lives than they would have been if their parents had just separated and let them grow up before starting new families.

Dontwanttoberudeorwastetime · 13/11/2022 15:08

ClocksGoingBackwards · 13/11/2022 15:04

There is absolutely no reason another date can’t be accommodated for the grandparents to hold a Christmas for all their biological grandchildren while the OP does something nice with her daughter.

How do you know there’s no reason they can’t do another date? The grandparents have other children and grandchildren to accommodate, and those adult children will also have in laws of their own to accommodate too. The OPs dsd also has her own maternal family to spend time with. There could well be many valid reasons why it’s not that easy to do it on another day, but even if they did do it on another day, it’s still not going to solve the issue of OPs dd being given less than the other children.

This whole thing is based on spite and greed and it’s disgusting.

What, so when OPs dsd and younger children want to have the fun family Christmas at their grandparents house, thats all about greed and spite, but when the other child in the story doesn’t want to go to her step grandparents because she gets fewer presents, that’s ok and not based on greed at all?

I get that it will feel unfair to her if she goes but shes not being made to go. She can have Christmas with her mum and gran. Her choice of where to spend the day shouldn’t stop her siblings being able to have Christmas they want. OP and her DH just have to suck up having a split Christmas, because this is the situation that they chose to create for their own benefit.

I think I’ve clearly set out why I disagree with you.
There’s no chance I would be having a Christmas where my children are separated from me and another sibling. I’d make a firm stance that we have it at home. Stepdaughter encouraged to come. Grandparents encouraged to choose another day to have an exclusionary Christmas.
No way would I pander to a family who want to exclude my child.

ClocksGoingBackwards · 13/11/2022 15:04

There is absolutely no reason another date can’t be accommodated for the grandparents to hold a Christmas for all their biological grandchildren while the OP does something nice with her daughter.

How do you know there’s no reason they can’t do another date? The grandparents have other children and grandchildren to accommodate, and those adult children will also have in laws of their own to accommodate too. The OPs dsd also has her own maternal family to spend time with. There could well be many valid reasons why it’s not that easy to do it on another day, but even if they did do it on another day, it’s still not going to solve the issue of OPs dd being given less than the other children.

This whole thing is based on spite and greed and it’s disgusting.

What, so when OPs dsd and younger children want to have the fun family Christmas at their grandparents house, thats all about greed and spite, but when the other child in the story doesn’t want to go to her step grandparents because she gets fewer presents, that’s ok and not based on greed at all?

I get that it will feel unfair to her if she goes but shes not being made to go. She can have Christmas with her mum and gran. Her choice of where to spend the day shouldn’t stop her siblings being able to have Christmas they want. OP and her DH just have to suck up having a split Christmas, because this is the situation that they chose to create for their own benefit.

Sceptre86 · 13/11/2022 10:07

You are directing your anger on the wrong place. If course your middle child wants to gp where she gets more presents, she is a child. Blame your arse of a partner who expects a 12 year old to just suck it up. Your kids haven't abandoned you and that's a shitty blame to put upon them. I'd say speak to your partner and his family but you won't.

Dontwanttoberudeorwastetime · 13/11/2022 09:58

ClocksGoingBackwards · 13/11/2022 09:42

It’s a bit of a unfair leap to assume it’s based on greed!

Leave the presents out of it. This child’s options are

  1. Christmas Day with Dad, younger siblings, grandparents, aunts uncles and cousins.

  2. Christmas Day with Dad, step mum, younger siblings, step sister and step grandma.

Why would a 12 year old choose to spend their Christmas Day primarily with a new step family instead of their own real biological family that she has known since birth? The presents are just an added bonus, and the child shouldn’t be put in this position in the first place. It’s not her problem that her Dad got together with someone who already has a child and then went on to have two more kids.

The options are:

  1. one daughter is completely left out, isolated and made to feel separate from her family on Christmas
  2. another daughter doesn’t get to see her grandparents be cousins on Christmas Day but spend it with her dad and siblings.
  3. the whole family is split in half

There is absolutely no reason another date can’t be accommodated for the grandparents to hold a Christmas for all their biological grandchildren while the OP does something nice with her daughter.
This whole thing is based on spite and greed and it’s disgusting.

ClocksGoingBackwards · 13/11/2022 09:42

Dontwanttoberudeorwastetime · 12/11/2022 19:48

Because one is based on greed. The other is based on feeling excluded and isolated by her own family, at Christmas

It’s a bit of a unfair leap to assume it’s based on greed!

Leave the presents out of it. This child’s options are

  1. Christmas Day with Dad, younger siblings, grandparents, aunts uncles and cousins.

  2. Christmas Day with Dad, step mum, younger siblings, step sister and step grandma.

Why would a 12 year old choose to spend their Christmas Day primarily with a new step family instead of their own real biological family that she has known since birth? The presents are just an added bonus, and the child shouldn’t be put in this position in the first place. It’s not her problem that her Dad got together with someone who already has a child and then went on to have two more kids.

Dinoteeth · 12/11/2022 23:57

I'm missing a NOT in there.
Why should the Mum & Dad, two kids and two joint kids not all spend Christmas together?

Dinoteeth · 12/11/2022 23:56

Cuppasoupmonster · 12/11/2022 23:53

But it isn’t his duty to do this for OP’s daughter. Why should he ‘step up’? Her kids should be free to spend Christmas with their dad and other sister, and it’s OP’s duty to make sure her older daughter has a nice Christmas with her mum and gran.

You're talking as if the couple are split.
Why should the Mum & Dad, two kids and two joint kids all spend Christmas together?

Why is the Dads daughter not spending Christmas in the Dads house?

Cuppasoupmonster · 12/11/2022 23:53

Murdoch1949 · 12/11/2022 19:56

Why does your husband not talk to his family about this? If they have closed ears, he needs to step up with an embroidered sack & extra presents for your daughter. She is already putting up with an absent dad. What about her bio grandparents on dad’s side, do they send anything that could be used?

But it isn’t his duty to do this for OP’s daughter. Why should he ‘step up’? Her kids should be free to spend Christmas with their dad and other sister, and it’s OP’s duty to make sure her older daughter has a nice Christmas with her mum and gran.

Cuppasoupmonster · 12/11/2022 23:50

Gropiuschair · 10/11/2022 10:17

When we used to go there the in- laws bought my daughter a present but their actual grandchildren got sacks with their names embroidered on them.

Well of course because they’re their grandchildren. It was nice of them to get your older daughter a gift but she isn’t their grandchild.

So your younger kids never get Christmas with their dad and that half of their family because it makes you and your older daughter feel left out?! That’s very much on you for choosing to have a blended family I’m afraid 🤷🏼‍♀️

Why can’t you have Christmas with just your mum and older daughter? You sound a bit selfish if I’m honest.

Dinoteeth · 12/11/2022 23:46

The bit that doesn't make sense is why are the 4 children in the family split up on Christmas Day.

Why are Gran and cousin being prioritised over mum and the mums DD.?

Why don't Mum and Dad host, DGPs from both sides, keeping their 4 children in one house to make their own Christmas memories?

I think some people on the thread are forgetting the Op and her DH will end up spending Christmas Day apart too. They are meant to be a couple.

5128gap · 12/11/2022 22:57

ZoeCM · 12/11/2022 17:57

The younger children can bond with their extended family at less emotionally charged times.

Their half-sister on their father's side is not their "extended family". She's immediate family, just like their sister on their mother's side.

It's bizarre that people are saying the OP's younger kids should never have a Christmas with their own half-sister because "families shouldn't be separated at Christmas"! WTF? It makes no sense. Unless all four kids are together, the family will be separated.

No you're right. I overlooked the fact there was a sister for some reason, and was thinking only of GP/cousins. It does make a difference.

Dontwanttoberudeorwastetime · 12/11/2022 20:02

ZoeCM · 12/11/2022 19:59

I think calling a kid greedy in this context is a bit unfair. It's hardly surprising a child would want to spend Christmas at a house where they get Hamley's levels of gifts. The deal for kids of separated parents is utterly shit, no matter how much MN likes to insist "children are happier with two happy parents apart".

It’s not unfair. It’s totally accurate. It might be unpalatable but it’s the truth.
Theres nothing wrong with to being greedy as a child. In fact, it’s perfectly natural but it shouldn’t be prioritised over a child being excluded by the only family she knows and has.
On a basic level, the stepdaughter wants lots of presents and doesn’t seem to care about spending time with her dad and siblings.
The daughter wants to spend time with her siblings and dad but will be upset by feeling ignored completely by their family.

If the grandparents said “No presents this year” what do you think the two girls’ reactions would be?

ZoeCM · 12/11/2022 19:59

Dontwanttoberudeorwastetime · 12/11/2022 19:48

Because one is based on greed. The other is based on feeling excluded and isolated by her own family, at Christmas

I think calling a kid greedy in this context is a bit unfair. It's hardly surprising a child would want to spend Christmas at a house where they get Hamley's levels of gifts. The deal for kids of separated parents is utterly shit, no matter how much MN likes to insist "children are happier with two happy parents apart".

Swipe left for the next trending thread