Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To resent putting all my savings into a house deposit when DH has none

217 replies

CaffeineFreeEarlGrey · 10/11/2022 06:49

So we are buying a house, and need a 15% deposit. I worked hard for years, and I need to put most of my savings into the deposit. My DH has hardly any savings, and I feel he is taking it for granted that I'm using my savings. He will pay equally for monthly payments.
I am nervous that we are making a mistake buying a house. We live in the UK where interest rates are going up. I'm scared that I'll lose my life savings if property prices fall. DH has no such fears. I wonder if he would be more nervous if he had to put his own hard earned savings into it?
I don't resent him for not having the savings I do, but I resent him for being so blasé about a huge life decision. I'm so scared that property prices will tank, and I'll lose my life savings. I feel that because he's not putting any of his own savings into this, it's like monopoly money to him. I wonder if he would be more fearful of the potential pitfalls of buying a house with rising interest rates if it was his hard earned savings at risk?
Then again, I love him dearly. He is a good DH in general. And I don't know if there is ever a good time to buy a house. AIBU not only for resenting his blasé attitude to the potential risks of buying a UK house right now, but also, AIBU for buying a house right now at all. Is that a stupid financial decision? He argues that we'd lose money on rent, so even if we lost a bit of money on buying, we wouldn't lose any more than we'd lose on renting...

OP posts:
Claudia84 · 10/11/2022 07:45

Houses have always increased in value over time, even when prices have fallen in the short term. You are not going to 'lose' your savings.
You're married. Yes he's getting the benefit from your savings habit but going into buying a house with the attitude that it's all on you isn't the best way of thinking in a partnership.

Doingmybest12 · 10/11/2022 07:44

Your thread title doesn't reflect your post. So you are OK with him not having savings but not ok with him seeming to take for granted/not care about the risk to your money. Is this his personality that he is a glass half full type. Either you love him and you just get on with it or you stay in rented. Presumably generally you like his attitude to life ? Is there more to this and he actually is really passive and that begins to feel unsupportive?

Keepitrealnomists · 10/11/2022 07:43

Does DH earn less than you? Is he rubbish with money, is that why he hasn't saved as much? Buying a home is always better than renting. Get on with it.

Fraaahnces · 10/11/2022 07:43

Ensure that you ringfence it legally before you sign anything. Also sit down and discuss bills, mortgage repayments, food and may leave, childcare, etc….

Ginglymostomatidae · 10/11/2022 07:41

Well if you want him to be more 'risk adverse' like you, stay renting until he's saved the same amount.

Decorhate · 10/11/2022 07:41

Leaving aside the current financial climate…

I had a very similar situation when we bought our first house. However Dh went on to have a higher paid career which enabled me to be a sahm for a few years further down the line (and replenish our joint savings). If you are in the relationship for the long haul there will be times when one person is supporting the family unit more but it should (ideally) balance out.

sheepdogdelight · 10/11/2022 07:40

This is only an issue if you pay exactly 50% for everything and intend to for the whole of your marriage.

I put more money into our house deposit than DH. But he paid for the mortgage when I was on maternity leave, and paid the lions share when I went part time when our DC were little. Who has paid more for the house over the years? Not a clue.

I've written it down like that so you can see the point. In reality we have a family pot and share everything. If your situation is that your DH is a spender and you're a saver so you're always going to pay more for things, I'd maybe reconsider what you're doing.

ladycarlotta · 10/11/2022 07:38

If you want to protect your contribution then make sure you go on the deeds at tenants in common rather than joint tenants. Presumably you can still do this if you're married, although the default would be joint tenants - your solicitor can sort it out for you.
I did this when we bought our house because I contributed the whole deposit and since I'm self-employed I wanted to protect and hopefully built capital on that nest-egg that I might not get again. We weren't married though. If we were to sell the house I'd get back 15% of its value (I could have specified the sum instead) and the other 85% would be shared equally between us. You can easily set up something like this if you choose.

NoSquirrels · 10/11/2022 07:37

I do wonder if he'd be more risk-averse or wary of the potential cons of the investment if it was his money

Maybe he would. Depends on his personality. But how would that help you? Then you’d both be fretting, that would be the only benefit.

If your financial situation and jobs are stable, buy the property. Choose wisely, keep an eye on the market.

Westendbuoys · 10/11/2022 07:32

Why doesn't he have any savings?

taliaG · 10/11/2022 07:31

Are you planning on DC?

I think once you're married the idea of your money and his money does t make a lot of sense any more. You are a unit.

dudsville · 10/11/2022 07:31

Just to give a rl example of some advice here. My oh and i weren't married when we bought, and i put about 30% down we made wills ring fencing the money. We paid 50/50 into the mortgagee and oh saved up to equal my down payment. We're now nearly paid off but absolutely 50/50, and now we're getting a civil partnership so none of that really matters anymore anyway, but I wanted to give an example of it being fine when you're oh can't match you financially.

Lcb123 · 10/11/2022 07:30

Depends why he has no savings, if he’s always had low income with only enough for essentials then fair enough. I’d get your deposit ring fenced, the solicitor can sort this for you, then if you divorce you’d get this back, plus half of the rest of the money from the property. We did this when me and my boyfriend bought a flat (luckily still together and now married!).

MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 10/11/2022 07:29

LovelyBitOfSquirrel69 · 10/11/2022 07:02

You've had some really bad advice so far. Get your deposit ringfenced and an agreement written up that should anything happen, that money is yours.

Pretty sure that doesn't work and can be challenged in a split. In fact I know it can as my mother did it and won.

SimonaRazowska · 10/11/2022 07:28

I’d wait a year

SimonaRazowska · 10/11/2022 07:27

We did this (but not in a tanking market, and also, as I put my savings in an DH did not have any, he paid a bigger share of the mortgage)

your DH sounds very cavalier about YOUR money

CaffeineFreeEarlGrey · 10/11/2022 07:27

HarvestThyme · 10/11/2022 06:57

How old are you? Where are you living now? Renting? How long have you been married? Are you both in stable employment? Could you afford the mortgage if interest rates rose by 2%?

I'm 37, he's 32. We are renting, and we both feel that's a waste of money. We are married 3 years. We both have okay jobs, but is any job stable? With our current salaries, we could afford the mortgage if interest rates went up.

OP posts:
GemLettuce · 10/11/2022 07:26

House prices in the UK won't "tank" - you're making a sound financial investment and getting a home.

Get DH on Dave Ramsey's Baby Steps. He's an adult-a homeowner now so needs emergency fund etc.

AutumnCrow · 10/11/2022 07:24

Doesn’t necessarily matter that they’re married. They are ways of preserving savings and assets in the event of divorce. House deposits being one, especially savings held going into the marriage.

Talk to a solicitor, @CaffeineFreeEarlGrey. Some of the advice on here is inaccurate and misleading, and your circumstances are unique to you.

I do however think the posters asking if/why your husband is crap with money have a point.

GnomeDePlume · 10/11/2022 07:24

There is never a 'good' time to buy a home. You only really find out in hindsight.

My advice is to buy somewhere which you can imagine staying in for a number of years. Don't look at it as an investment from the start. It may drop in value but then in all likelihood it will recover.

We bought our first house in 1991. Property prices then bombed. We were in negative equity for a number of years.

But it didn't matter. The house met our needs. We stayed there for 9 years. By the time we moved on house prices had recovered. We bought the house we are in now in 2006. Property prices then slumped. But again it didn't matter because what we bought was a home.

CaffeineFreeEarlGrey · 10/11/2022 07:23

megletthesecond · 10/11/2022 06:55

"Good DH in general" makes him sound like he probably isn't.

He's a greatl husband, and I'm very lucky (sorry, a good DH in general wasn't strong enough). I don't at all blame him for not having the same deposit I do. He is 5 years younger than me, and in a different industry. But I do wonder if he'd be more risk-averse or wary of the potential cons of the investment if it was his money. For him, it's a bit like buying a monopoly house. For me, I'm thinking that this real money could turn into negative equity if the housing market crashes

OP posts:
Ekátn · 10/11/2022 07:19

Op what’s the plan for the savings if you don’t buy a house?

If you have been married for a reasonable length of time and then divorced, those savings would go in the communal pot anyway.

The decision about wether the time is right to buy now is a slightly separate issue. You need to decide that.

When you marry you legally share finances. It’s only yours at the moment as you have kept it separate. I would feel similar to you. But that’s why I won’t get married or a buy a house with someone in these circumstances. That’s not helping you though. But I just wanted you know I do understand the feeling.

I think that you need to decide if now is the right time to buy and then talk to him about his attitude to money and how it’s causing Bad feeling. if it’s not sorted now, it will likely cause problems in the future. And, as I said, in divorce you could find it still gets a huge chunk of money that you worked for that he has never contributed to.

TabithaTittlemouse · 10/11/2022 07:11

My Dh has saved for a deposit because I pay the bills. I don’t resent him for having savings, it works well for both of us.
He does the big things, I do day to day.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 10/11/2022 07:10

I would feel the same, especially if there is no reason he shouldn't have savings. It would also bother me that he is casual about the fact you are giving up all the money you have built up through years of painful saving - I would want some recognition of that tbh.

I don't think you will lose by buying though, it is just a big step and natural to be nervous.

luxxlisbon · 10/11/2022 07:08

What exactly do you expect him to do to show he isn’t being blasé about it though? Cry with stress? Talk about how worried he is all the time?
It sounds like actually you are resentful that is isn’t contributing to the deposit as much as you are and this is how that resentment is manifesting.

Your life savings would also dwindle away inflation but you don’t mention that.