Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To resent putting all my savings into a house deposit when DH has none

217 replies

CaffeineFreeEarlGrey · 10/11/2022 06:49

So we are buying a house, and need a 15% deposit. I worked hard for years, and I need to put most of my savings into the deposit. My DH has hardly any savings, and I feel he is taking it for granted that I'm using my savings. He will pay equally for monthly payments.
I am nervous that we are making a mistake buying a house. We live in the UK where interest rates are going up. I'm scared that I'll lose my life savings if property prices fall. DH has no such fears. I wonder if he would be more nervous if he had to put his own hard earned savings into it?
I don't resent him for not having the savings I do, but I resent him for being so blasé about a huge life decision. I'm so scared that property prices will tank, and I'll lose my life savings. I feel that because he's not putting any of his own savings into this, it's like monopoly money to him. I wonder if he would be more fearful of the potential pitfalls of buying a house with rising interest rates if it was his hard earned savings at risk?
Then again, I love him dearly. He is a good DH in general. And I don't know if there is ever a good time to buy a house. AIBU not only for resenting his blasé attitude to the potential risks of buying a UK house right now, but also, AIBU for buying a house right now at all. Is that a stupid financial decision? He argues that we'd lose money on rent, so even if we lost a bit of money on buying, we wouldn't lose any more than we'd lose on renting...

OP posts:
Snoken · 10/11/2022 09:09

CaffeineFreeEarlGrey · 10/11/2022 07:23

He's a greatl husband, and I'm very lucky (sorry, a good DH in general wasn't strong enough). I don't at all blame him for not having the same deposit I do. He is 5 years younger than me, and in a different industry. But I do wonder if he'd be more risk-averse or wary of the potential cons of the investment if it was his money. For him, it's a bit like buying a monopoly house. For me, I'm thinking that this real money could turn into negative equity if the housing market crashes

But what do you want him to do? Say you shouldn't buy because prices might go down? What is the benefit of him being more risk-averse in this situation? You are married, so you are a union and who is putting what in is not really relevant. If the price of your house goes down, so does everyone elses, if you go into negative equity then you wait it out. I'm guessing you are buying to live somewhere for at least a number of years.

I bought a place at the beginning of the year, it has now gone down in value by about 7%, but it doesn't matter to me because I am not planning on moving so it's irrelevant at this point. If I were to move it would be within the same city I am in, so those places will have also lost about the same in value.

theworldhas · 10/11/2022 09:07

The only circumstances in which I wouldn’t be willing to out contribute a life partner would be if they were lazy/unambitious/unmotivated in terms of work, domestic chores, relationship etc etc. But then why marry someone like that in the first place.

BaconMassive · 10/11/2022 09:06

Why settle for average?

notmyrealmoniker · 10/11/2022 09:06

Ring fence your deposit. It works if you're not married, and might work if the marriage is short lived

theworldhas · 10/11/2022 09:04

IMO part of the whole idea of marriage involves being open to paying an unequal share of costs - if required - for the larger long term benefit of the relationship. In the context of a (hopefully) 40+ year relationship with a life partner, a deposit of say 10k isn’t all that big a deal.

But I agree, you should do your sums re.house prices. Most economists think this time next year most housing stock will have plummeted circa 10%. I’d be tempted to wait until the end of next year.

GerbilsForever24 · 10/11/2022 09:03

I think there are two separate issues going on here.

The first is about finances - you're contributing more, saving more etc. That's something you shoudl take a long hard look at, especially if you want children. If you're married, there needs to be some parity. So, for example, you've saved and he hasn't. is that purely because he has had a less well paid career and is younger? Or is t because he b lows money on silly things and as a result as less to save?

The second is about the risk of buying a house. I was surprised to read you're 37 because to be honest, you sound quite immature re the house buying thing. Ultimately, you have to pay to live somewhere. If you rent, you have less stability and have zero chance of ever recouping any of that money. If you buy, you are safe in that home and, assuming your mortgage is not interest only (a terrible idea - always ensure you pay the capital too), over time you are gaining an asset. Even if that property decreases in value (very unlikely over the long term), you nonetheless will eventually be able to sell it and recoup some of the money you have spent in mortgage payments. If rent is much much cheaper than a mortgage then there might be an argument for investing the difference between a rental payment and a mortgage, but personally, for the stability and security of your actual home, I would not.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 10/11/2022 09:02

Do you both earn the same?

user1471538283 · 10/11/2022 08:58

I would try not to use all your savings just in case you need big things like a new boiler.

But from my experience when I bought at the top of the market years ago, I went virtually straight into negative equity. But I had no plans to sell and when I did sell 15 years later, I made money.

I think you are right to be cautious. I can still remember all the repossessions and huge mortgages. Can you ring fence your deposit so if you did split up you would get that back?

TheaBrandt · 10/11/2022 08:58

You sound rather sour. I paid all my savings for our first house deposit Dh was 3 years behind me age wise so hadn’t accrued much. Didn’t give it a second thought. We’re a team. I was then a sahm for 6 years which he was brilliantly supportive of and is now the highest earner though I’m catching up. We are a team otherwise what is the point of being married?

adriftabroad · 10/11/2022 08:53

My husband bought us a house (not in UK) 20 years ago and did not shut up about it for one single day of those 20 years.

I am divorcing him now. He has changed the locks on the bloody house to prevent his young DD and I entering.

I will end up with half and he will die alone.

Resentment is hideous. Buy the house and mean it or do not. Marriage, as a pp said, is a financial contract.

Extreme example but you get my point.

Zilla1 · 10/11/2022 08:52

HNRTT but perhaps try and unpack your 'monopoly money' concerns about DH not contributing to the deposit from your anxiety about future prospects for house prices. If you see the purchase as a long term home, short to medium term price falls might feel slightly differently. You my think you';ll wish you waited, equally rent will be obviated. Good luck.

minipie · 10/11/2022 08:52

It sounds like this is not about the money. You don’t mind that you’re putting more in. It’s about the fact you’re worrying and fretting and he’s not.

You’ve connected this to the fact the deposit isn’t his money but as PP said, maybe he just isn’t a worrier? Or maybe he is comfortable that you both like the house and so can stay in it through any negative equity periods? Are his earnings likely to increase (you said he is younger), if so maybe that also makes him less likely to worry as it provides another cushion?

I understand he may seem cavalier but it could just be that he has considered fears at the time of making the offer and got over them, and now the decision is made he isn’t overthinking it. Quite a good trait to have especially if you are a worrier or an overthinker yourself.

I don’t agree with the PP who say you’re being mean/bad wife etc, I don’t think they’ve read your posts properly.

Littlewhitecat · 10/11/2022 08:52

I paid the entire deposit (25k 22 years ago) on our first house as I came from a much wealthier background than my DH and he had very little savings. Never occurred to me to be worried about this as we were married and a team. DH now earns 3x what I earn and paid the mortgage entirely on his own for years when I was a SAHP and then when I was working p/t. I think you should be exploring why this is making you feel uncomfortable. What are your plans if you have kids? Your DH is younger than you so is his career trajectory behind yours? Does he have a pension and is he saving money now or are you worried because he's rubbish with money generally?

Naunet · 10/11/2022 08:49

Pleasecreateausername13 · 10/11/2022 08:35

In my opinion you seem like a shit wife to come on here and say these things. You chose to marry this man knowing he had no savings, when you get married you become a unit. It’s not your money or his money, it’s both your money.

Fucking charming!

BankseyVest · 10/11/2022 08:49

Can you ring fence your savings should anything happen and you leave your dh (don't know if it's possible as you're married). It's always scary buying a house, especially in this economic environment. You won't lose your life savings as house prices will always go back up, as long as you always pay your mortgage

Roselilly36 · 10/11/2022 08:48

I can see your concern, OP. Only you can make that decision. Property prices are looking likely to fall, but always come up in the end, so if the property you are wanting to purchase will be a long term home, you will be fine. We were trapped in negativity equity in the early 90’s we eventually managed to sell in 2000. Good luck.

Funkyblues101 · 10/11/2022 08:48

Sarahcoggles · 10/11/2022 08:43

Do you have to put in all your savings to get the house you want? You could just keep some back.

With inflation as it is there is zero point in keeping savings back when a larger deposit reduces the amount borrowed (and therefore interest being paid).

MothBat · 10/11/2022 08:47

EternalStench · 10/11/2022 06:57

How about he pays more for the monthly payments and you build up some savings again?

This.

Funkyblues101 · 10/11/2022 08:46

Your life savings are currently losing over 10% a year with inflation so better to turn it into bricks and mortar asap before it is no longer enough for a deposit. Rents will go up, everything will go up except for your savings earning their pitiful 5% or whatever you've got them on.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 10/11/2022 08:45

House prices in the UK won't "tank" - you're making a sound financial investment and getting a home.

^^
this!

It’s both a sound investment and a home. You need a home, and otherwise are throwing money away renting. It’s really unlikely property prices will tank - level off maybe, but that’s not a problem.

If you fix your interest rate at a level where you can afford the payments (presumably you’ve passed the stage of finding out what offers are there for you) then you shouldn’t lose money as you’ll still have your home even if prices do dip a bit. They’ll go up again at some point even if so, so if you can keep paying the payments you’ll be ok.

ZenNudist · 10/11/2022 08:45

Buy a home for the long term. Worry about affordability not price fluctuations. Your savings more likely to go up in value invested in property compared to losing value in real terms sat in the bank.

I don't get your attitude. Your savings are for him too. It's not like you're buying him something only he can enjoy. You are both paying a mortgage to buy the property.

Sarahcoggles · 10/11/2022 08:43

Do you have to put in all your savings to get the house you want? You could just keep some back.

MakkaPakkas · 10/11/2022 08:41

There are two issues here; should you buy a house now? and should finances be shared in marriage?
I don't know whether you should buy a house now, do you like the house? Will you live in it for a long term? Can you afford the mortgage repayments taking into account interest rates?

I do think that in a marriage the money is family money and that you work as a team. I'm pretty sure that legally once married it's considered family money too. It's understandable to feel stressed when moving house so maybe that's why you're focusing on this aspect?

billy1966 · 10/11/2022 08:41

SimonaRazowska · 10/11/2022 07:28

I’d wait a year

I would too.

OP, your gut is trying to warn you.
Listen to it.

Hold onto your savings tightly.

I think the next year or two may be a rough ride.

This is your decision, these are YOUR savings.

Is he really saving hard?

If not, tell him he needs to over the next 2 years.

He sounds very cavalier with your savings.

WorldAtWon · 10/11/2022 08:41

Think carefully. I put in all of our deposit (savings + inheritance) and DH put in nothing. Didn't feel bad about it at all at the time - I was lucky to have inheritance and to have been able to save. Things not possible for my DH.

However, he didn't engage with process v. much at all .Just signed on the dotted line and packed a couple of boxes.

Few years down the line and he has become lazier and nastier by the year. And now I want to leave. And now I feel so bitter about it. he has contributed nothing and yet half this house is his. I know I'm the stupid one.

But I think really it's the getting married thing that makes us vulnerable. Whoever puts in what - all assets are 5050. Biggest regret of my life marrying rather than keeping him as a DP.