Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To resent putting all my savings into a house deposit when DH has none

217 replies

CaffeineFreeEarlGrey · 10/11/2022 06:49

So we are buying a house, and need a 15% deposit. I worked hard for years, and I need to put most of my savings into the deposit. My DH has hardly any savings, and I feel he is taking it for granted that I'm using my savings. He will pay equally for monthly payments.
I am nervous that we are making a mistake buying a house. We live in the UK where interest rates are going up. I'm scared that I'll lose my life savings if property prices fall. DH has no such fears. I wonder if he would be more nervous if he had to put his own hard earned savings into it?
I don't resent him for not having the savings I do, but I resent him for being so blasé about a huge life decision. I'm so scared that property prices will tank, and I'll lose my life savings. I feel that because he's not putting any of his own savings into this, it's like monopoly money to him. I wonder if he would be more fearful of the potential pitfalls of buying a house with rising interest rates if it was his hard earned savings at risk?
Then again, I love him dearly. He is a good DH in general. And I don't know if there is ever a good time to buy a house. AIBU not only for resenting his blasé attitude to the potential risks of buying a UK house right now, but also, AIBU for buying a house right now at all. Is that a stupid financial decision? He argues that we'd lose money on rent, so even if we lost a bit of money on buying, we wouldn't lose any more than we'd lose on renting...

OP posts:
pattihews · 10/11/2022 09:49

On BBC Radio 4's Moneybox yesterday the experts stated that at the moment, even though rents seem very high, it's cheaper to rent than to buy because of the rising mortgage interest rates etc. House prices are already nudging downwards. I wouldn't buy now if I was living somewhere I liked and could afford to keep renting.

In a couple of years, when the property market has dropped 10 or 15%, I'd jump in. That will give your partner a change to save up his half of the deposit, won't it?

If/ when you do buy, have it noted by the solicitor that you are paying the deposit. Because if you split up down the line, you'll need that deposit to be taken into account.

WhiteRabbitCandy · 10/11/2022 09:48

Hmm, I think marriage is a bit like this tbh. When we bought our first house together the deposit all came from DH - I didn't have anything but did contribute equally to the mortgage. Over time, there have been times when I have earnt more and saved more, and times when he has - we just consider it all family money now not his/hers. Although the market is tricky at the moment, property is a long term investment so it should work out for you in the end. Still better than renting.

adriftabroad · 10/11/2022 09:47

Do you have DCs, are you going to have DCs?

Schlaar · 10/11/2022 09:45

Snoken · 10/11/2022 09:36

It is already a marital asset. If they were to split, savings are split too,

This is a common misconception. Yes, if the money was saved during the marriage then it’s an asset of the marriage and would be split. Yes, if OP puts it into a joint account or spends it on a joint purchase such as a house then it’s an asset of the marriage and would be split. But if OP had the money before marriage and has bank statements to prove this, and if the money was always kept entirely separate in her own private account, then the money is NOT an asset of the marriage and she would have a pretty good case for NOT splitting it in a divorce settlement.

LillianGish · 10/11/2022 09:45

Sorry - I've just seen your post about him being five years younger and in a different industry. So totally understandable that he hasn't saved as much.

Mummyoflittledragon · 10/11/2022 09:44

SimonaRazowska · 10/11/2022 07:28

I’d wait a year

I agree. The market is very unpredictable and prices are likely to go down. More of a reset so 10/15% than a slump but that could change.

TheGoogleMum · 10/11/2022 09:43

You are willing to buy a huge joint asset, but your finances aren't shared? When I bought with DH all money earned was 'our money' and so savings were all one pot rather than mine or his. Obviously if he's unreliable financially don't combine finances (but then maybe don't buy a house together either!) But if he is why not? Should one get more spending money if they outearn the other? We've always had a spending money allowance each which is the same no matter who earns what (it's actually very similar now but I used to earn more)

PotentiallyPolly · 10/11/2022 09:43

I’m saying YANBU in terms of worrying about him not contributing an equal deposit. It’s you that loses out if you split and have to sell the house.

However YABU to worry about the housing market crashing and the house not being worth as much. Even if the market crashes you still have a house to live in, the same house you had to live in before the crash. It doesn’t matter how much the house is worth if you’re living there.

LillianGish · 10/11/2022 09:42

You don't give any figures. How much is your deposit and how much do you pay in rent? What proportion of your deposit are you throwing away in rent every month? There is never a good time buy, but if you you are buying a home to live in (ie not a studio flat purely as an investment) then there's never a bad time. Even if you find yourself in negative equity for a few years it only really matters if you need to/want to move. I have no idea about your personal circumstances - whether your DH has no savings because he is feckless and a spendthrift or whether it's just because he's younger than you, earns less or has just had more outgoings for whatever reason. I do wonder why you would be married to someone if you're not prepared to share your finances with them to buy a home and not doing so means you can't afford to get on the ladder. Owning a home together seems to me the very least you might do even if all your other finances are kept separate.

HarvestThyme · 10/11/2022 09:40

There are never any guarantees, but buying a home is generally a sound investment. If you have stable jobs and salaries that can withstand rising interest rates, I would buy.

In the end, you married this man. It's a legal contract that means if you divorce, you could be handing him 50% of the equity (even if your deposit is ringfenced).

I understand your fear about investing your hard-earned money. It might be worth talking to an independent financial advisor about your concerns.

Your dh's idea that you two should buy a home is a sensible one. Only you know if it outweighs concerns about either negative equity or the splitting of assets in case of divorce.

Pumpkinpatchlookinggood · 10/11/2022 09:40

Imo he needs to repay your savings pot his 50%..word it as you worry he will feel it is just your home if he doesn't.. Me and dh have separate money (I had dc already and my preference) but ime you manage your OWN money better than someone else's!

Snoken · 10/11/2022 09:36

Schlaar · 10/11/2022 09:33

As soon as you move that money from your personal account and put it into the house, it becomes an asset of the marriage and he owns half. Don’t do it! Or at the very least get legal documents drawn up that clarify that you own a greater share of the house.

It is already a marital asset. If they were to split, savings are split too,

Softplayhooray · 10/11/2022 09:35

CaffeineFreeEarlGrey · 10/11/2022 07:23

He's a greatl husband, and I'm very lucky (sorry, a good DH in general wasn't strong enough). I don't at all blame him for not having the same deposit I do. He is 5 years younger than me, and in a different industry. But I do wonder if he'd be more risk-averse or wary of the potential cons of the investment if it was his money. For him, it's a bit like buying a monopoly house. For me, I'm thinking that this real money could turn into negative equity if the housing market crashes

I think this ultimately makes you a good team. Of my DH and I, I'm more impulsive (not in a reckless way, more a considered risk go for it type way), whereas he is always more cautious. If we were both the same as each other it'd probably be a disaster but we balance eachother out! I think it'll work for you both. It's fine to feel resentful in some ways if it's all your money but that feeling can pass, just let yourself acknowledge it and find a healthy way to move past it. My DH put the bulk of his money into our home and it was stressy for him originally but he got more comfortable with the idea over time and it was fine.

For what it's worth I think that putting your savings into property is the best thing you can do.

Schlaar · 10/11/2022 09:33

As soon as you move that money from your personal account and put it into the house, it becomes an asset of the marriage and he owns half. Don’t do it! Or at the very least get legal documents drawn up that clarify that you own a greater share of the house.

Sixpence1977 · 10/11/2022 09:29

It is a difficult time for anyone as a first time buyer due to the fear of negative equity.

I am older than DH and I had more money when we got together. I had maternity leave twice and have now ended up retiring very early due to some health issues. So it has most definitely been up and down with who contributes most. I even paid off his graduate loan when we got together because it saved money.

I do have two friends that married much poorer men, it has caused issues. But these are quite wealthy women, one owns a second house and the other owns land.

KettrickenSmiled · 10/11/2022 09:28

RedHelenB · 10/11/2022 06:58

You sound overly anxious. Try to be more relaxed like your dh.

😂😂😂
If OP were as 'relaxed' as her DH - they'd have no deposit, so wouldn't be buying a house.

Pleasecreateausername13 · 10/11/2022 09:27

FlatWhiteExtraHot · 10/11/2022 09:17

Only on MN. If the husband has money or savings, it’s FAMILY MONEY and the wife should be able to spend it as and when she pleases or he’s a tight bastard or financially abusive. If the wife has money she should “ringfence” it so the greedy bastard doesn’t get his grubby hands on it 😂🙄.

This!!!!!!

KettrickenSmiled · 10/11/2022 09:26

sorrynotathome · 10/11/2022 06:53

Your post actually contradicts the title. If you’re a team it doesn’t matter who puts the money down. What matters is that you don’t overreach yourselves on the mortgage in case interest rates rise, one of you loses job etc.

Of course it bloody matters.
"You're a team" is just words.
As is "thanks for the hefty deposit, I want a divorce & my 50% equity now please."

As we're a few pages in, I won't bang on about lawyers & ringfencing, as plenty of PP will also have said something sensible to that effect.

catnip1990 · 10/11/2022 09:25

I put down all my savings into a. 15% deposit and my husband put nothing down as he also had no savings due to a low paid job for around a decade whilst doing additional training. He pays 65% of the mortgage and I pay 35% to balance this out, especially as he now earns more than myself. I also think he doesn't quite understand the reality of saving, putting all this money into deposits etc. but we are a team and it has worked out for us.

museumum · 10/11/2022 09:24

I owned a flat alone for 5 years 2005 - 2010. That was a horrible time (2008/9 banking crash). I sold for 2.5k more than I bought for (so roughly even when legal fees considered). Some might consider that a failure. But I think if the rent I didn’t pay. £500/month at that time for five years is £30k!!!

Buy somewhere you can stay for 5-10 years minimum and not an expensive service charge or a new build in a saturated area it’s probably ok.

what Would be the benefit of your dh stressing and being anxious too? Sounds like you’ve got cold feet and want him to agree with you to not buy.

Elfonthewealth · 10/11/2022 09:24

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

mug2018 · 10/11/2022 09:18

How would you feel if it was the other way around : he had the savings but he didn't want to put it into your future ?

denimsocks · 10/11/2022 09:18

@CaffeineFreeEarlGrey just buy it as "Tenants in Common" rather than joint owners, with you owning a greater than 50% stake to reflect your deposit. However, if you do this, he may question the atrangement further down the line, for example if he contributes more to the mortgage after you start a family.

You're either in it together, for richer or poorer, or you keep your finances separate. You just need to decide.

FlatWhiteExtraHot · 10/11/2022 09:17

Only on MN. If the husband has money or savings, it’s FAMILY MONEY and the wife should be able to spend it as and when she pleases or he’s a tight bastard or financially abusive. If the wife has money she should “ringfence” it so the greedy bastard doesn’t get his grubby hands on it 😂🙄.

LIZS · 10/11/2022 09:16

Agree it is about how you have savings vs him. If his income has funded a large share of living costs while yours has been saved then effectively it is joint. If you had it saved pre-marriage or because you were more frugal it might make sense to reflect it in your title.