Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To resent putting all my savings into a house deposit when DH has none

217 replies

CaffeineFreeEarlGrey · 10/11/2022 06:49

So we are buying a house, and need a 15% deposit. I worked hard for years, and I need to put most of my savings into the deposit. My DH has hardly any savings, and I feel he is taking it for granted that I'm using my savings. He will pay equally for monthly payments.
I am nervous that we are making a mistake buying a house. We live in the UK where interest rates are going up. I'm scared that I'll lose my life savings if property prices fall. DH has no such fears. I wonder if he would be more nervous if he had to put his own hard earned savings into it?
I don't resent him for not having the savings I do, but I resent him for being so blasé about a huge life decision. I'm so scared that property prices will tank, and I'll lose my life savings. I feel that because he's not putting any of his own savings into this, it's like monopoly money to him. I wonder if he would be more fearful of the potential pitfalls of buying a house with rising interest rates if it was his hard earned savings at risk?
Then again, I love him dearly. He is a good DH in general. And I don't know if there is ever a good time to buy a house. AIBU not only for resenting his blasé attitude to the potential risks of buying a UK house right now, but also, AIBU for buying a house right now at all. Is that a stupid financial decision? He argues that we'd lose money on rent, so even if we lost a bit of money on buying, we wouldn't lose any more than we'd lose on renting...

OP posts:
ItsNotReallyChaos · 10/11/2022 10:40

I've reached a point where I won't pool my resources with anyone who has less to put in than I do. It would need to be an equal investment. I also wouldn't buy property with a partner putting in significantly more than me.

The risk is too great. It has taken me years to get to this point of financial security and if a relationship failed and my partner took half of my assets, I'd be financially screwed and would never afford to get back on the property ladder.

Cheeseandabsolutelycrackers · 10/11/2022 10:33

Buy a house. You're mid thirties and by the time you find something and negotiate, you could actually use market uncertainty to your advantage and get a good price. You are first time buyers with no chain which will also be an advantage in negotiations.

FWIW, I have been married over a decade. We bought our house pre kids in my name and I paid the whole deposit and all mortgage payments and bills. We also bought our overseas property with savings that were in my name and that's legally solely in my name too and I pay all the costs of it. I earn a lot more than my husband. Despite things being in my name and paid for entirely by me (I also pay the kids school fees and all holidays etc - I don't really know what he spends his money on other than I know he works hard and contributes a lot to his own pension), he is essential to the function and enjoyment of my life and that of my children, that has enabled my career (although I was already a high earner when we met) and my well-being, and if he left me tomorrow I would not contest that he was entitled to half of everything.

If you plan to have children then you need to change your mindset. What each brings to the relationship cannot be solely measured in £.

RealBecca · 10/11/2022 10:33

HuggsBosom · 10/11/2022 10:26

Why would there be an uproar?

A poster has just posted below, which also seems perfectly reasonable:

My boyfriend paid the large deposit on our first home. We got it protected at the solicitors, so he would get it in case we split. You can do the same, to protect your deposit.

Because there is a world of difference between being married and in a relationship where finances are concerned.

Hence why if boyfriend/girlfriend relationships break up there isnt an automatic starting point of 5050. You leave with what you came with unless you set up a specific legal arrangement that says otherwise - like that poster did.

malificent7 · 10/11/2022 10:33

You are best off putting mone into bricks and mortar. House prices fluctuate but you will have your most important asset. It will only get harder to buy.

We put a huge deposit down ( mostly dh inheritance...we are not savers sadly). But our monthly repayments are minimal. I dread to think how much the'd be if we hadn't over invested.

pinkyredrose · 10/11/2022 10:32

RedHelenB · 10/11/2022 06:58

You sound overly anxious. Try to be more relaxed like your dh.

Are you the husband? Being 'relaxed' about money is a recipe for disaster unless you're the kind of person who gets other people to bankroll them

Slapmyslapmyass · 10/11/2022 10:30

There's no bad time to buy a house. They can go up and down in value, but they ultimately go up. Rent is completely wasted money, and is enabling someone else to own a second house (I say this as a LL).

What I don't understand is why you're wavering about the deposit. Part of marriage is bestowing all your worldly goods on someone else, and sharing all you have with them. You are supposed to be a unit. If you're not keen to do that, I'm not sure why you got married (this applies to about 75% of people on MN, too - there are endless threads about married couples who don't share their money).

This is one reason I would never re-marry. I don't want to share my worldly goods with anyone apart from my children.

FacebookPhotos · 10/11/2022 10:29

As others have said, I think you are conflating two issues.
Firstly, worry about property prices. I'm a ftb at the moment and it is scary. I could lose my life savings within a year if house prices drop a lot. But that is the wrong way of thinking about it - you are looking at the home you are going to live in as a financial investment rather than a secure place to live. The value of the house is irrelevant unless you want to sell.
Secondly, you and DH have different attitudes to this. I would say you need to try to figure out exactly what the difference is. Is it because he has a different attitude to money in general (ie more spendy while you are a saver) as this could be a significant problem. Or is it that you are a worrier and he is more laid back? If it is the second then (provided you listen to and respect each other) you could be a fantastic team.

Musti · 10/11/2022 10:29

So buy a cheaper place and keep half of your savings. Get your husband to contribute more to the monthly mortgage payments until you’re even. See what he thinks of that.

HuggsBosom · 10/11/2022 10:26

Glitteratitar · 10/11/2022 10:21

I’m amazed by the comments on here.

You’re married. You’re meant to be a team. A unit. If that’s not how you view it then perhaps you shouldn’t have got married to him.

Also, imagine the uproar if it was the other way round…

Why would there be an uproar?

A poster has just posted below, which also seems perfectly reasonable:

My boyfriend paid the large deposit on our first home. We got it protected at the solicitors, so he would get it in case we split. You can do the same, to protect your deposit.

Glitteratitar · 10/11/2022 10:21

I’m amazed by the comments on here.

You’re married. You’re meant to be a team. A unit. If that’s not how you view it then perhaps you shouldn’t have got married to him.

Also, imagine the uproar if it was the other way round…

Raindancer411 · 10/11/2022 10:11

You can set up to but as tenants in common to protect yourself with a higher percentage of ownership, rather than joint. Speak to solicitor about this.

Obviously no one knows what the property market will do so it's always a risk, even years down the line.

MrKlaw · 10/11/2022 10:11

are you able to afford the monthly payments if interest rates go up (or do you have a fix)?
Are you planning to be in the house for several years so don't expect to have to suddenly move?

if the answer to both of the above is 'yes' then you should be ok. Even if prices fall a little they'll recover. Negative equity is only an issue if you need to sell.

bigbird50 · 10/11/2022 10:07

To be honest my DH put in the large deposit for our home. We weren't married at the time either but had been together for ten years and had 3 DC together. We both worked and he had more ability to save money as he was working in a sector where he got highly paid.

He didn't choose to protect his deposit which was substantial, and it wasn't even something we considered, we have a joint mortgage and I pay half. We are now married and not an issue however it depends if your concerns are that your marriage is not strong enough or you are worried he is not good with money and isn't bothered about the risk of house buying as he isn't the person losing his savings? I wouldn't be buying now anyway and would pause until a bit of stability in the market and mortgage rates

Chesterdrawsseriously · 10/11/2022 10:06

How are you knocking on 40 and have so little understanding, bricks and mortar always increase in value. Because the value of money decreases. A pound today buys you much less than it did 20 years ago. The risk is if you see this as short term. If you’re buying the house and intend to be there for a good few years and can decide when to sell then your risk is pretty much non existent. It is irrelevant if the value crashes for a couple of years , it will rise again.

Negative equity is only an issue if you are forced to sell during that period. If you’re buying a property as a short term investment yes it’s stupid to do it now. If you’re buying it as a longer term home, crack on.

js there another issue, do you not want to buy with him? Because on one side you’re a;L but slagging him off and on the other saying but i luffs him

make a call. Are you in or out.

Tessasanderson · 10/11/2022 10:06

You are married. Half that money is his........ Or in other words, its family money so you do not have savings, you both do.

You need to deal with his attitude to money rather than worrying about how you split it. Here is your opportunity to get everything under control. Pay it all into one account, make some clear rules for everyone and have complete transparency.

Pinkcadillac · 10/11/2022 10:06

OP, if you are really worried about losing your deposit, just continue renting. Your fears have nothing to do with your DH's lack of savings, IMO. It looks as if you want certainty and no one can give you that.

Personally, I would buy.

NicLondon1 · 10/11/2022 10:06

Buying a property is the best way to invest money, you are absolutely doing the right thing!

Please don't throw it away on rent your husband is correct.
And if the market goes down for a bit, it will come up again later... You are playing a longterm game, and longterm your property will definitely increase in value, they always do.

Try to buy a property with longterm potential if you can. But even if it's a 2-bed flat, it should increase in value and you'll be on the property ladder.

Beautiful3 · 10/11/2022 10:03

My boyfriend paid the large deposit on our first home. We got it protected at the solicitors, so he would get it in case we split. You can do the same, to protect your deposit.

Googlecanthelpme · 10/11/2022 10:01

Sorry didn’t see catch that you are married - well thems the breaks I’m afraid. You get married, you generally split the assets if anything should ever happen. Especially if you stay together a long time, have a family and he has contributed to the home etc.

This is a good reminder for women in the better financial position to seriously consider whether being married or not is in their best interest or not (highly cynical and unromantic but hey, a girls gotta look after her money as we’re inevitably the ones to see the financial impact once kids and family life comes along)

HuggsBosom · 10/11/2022 09:59

Please please speak separately to a solicitor about how you can protect yourself.

Don't rely on love alone.

Googlecanthelpme · 10/11/2022 09:57

Well hold on a minute - if you buy a house it needs to be seen as a long term investment. Yes occasionally people make money in the short term due to renovations or they get lucky with a great deal and then market explodes and they capitalise on that but for the vast majority of every day people, a house is a long term asset and you will (usually) always recover your money and make money long term.
There are exceptions of course - generally new builds don’t fare as well because of the price you pay for it being brand new. They don’t hold up well for a good few years, but eventually all property tends to come good. Assuming half decent area, it’s not falling to bits and you’ve done your research on the current market value - ie you are paying what it is worth or thereabouts and not massively inflated prices, making it harder of course to recover any market drop.

But this is the reality! The other thing OP is leaving your money in cash isn’t all that safe either, unless you have a very good investment plan and your savings are working for you, then you’ll actually be worse off just sitting on your cash for the same years it’s invested in a property. The property market tends to ebb and flow but over time you generally end up with equity or longer term - the whole asset when mortgage is repaid. With cash, it just depreciates and that is that.

If you are concerned about the split of money then have the mortgage drawn up in such a way that you would get back say 60% of any resale and he would get 40%. That is what me and my partner did when I put the deposit down and he didn’t have any money at the time.

Regarding his blase attitude - well some people are just generally more accepting of the risk in markets. Personally I would not be worrying if I felt the property I am buying is a good long term bet. You can’t make someone worry about something they inherently aren’t that concerned about (and it isn’t necessarily because it isn’t his money).

TheOrigRights · 10/11/2022 09:57

LovelyBitOfSquirrel69 · 10/11/2022 07:02

You've had some really bad advice so far. Get your deposit ringfenced and an agreement written up that should anything happen, that money is yours.

It's not quite as straight forward as that!

magicscares · 10/11/2022 09:57

I wonder if you can get a ‘deed of trust’ written up so that your percentage of the home is recognised?
my inclination is that it’s for the most part buying a property Is a great investment. As long as you get all the proper checks done, you should only see your money grow over the years.

astarsheis · 10/11/2022 09:53

MY DH was rubbish at saving when I met him and I helped him pay off his higher purchase loans, and subsequently paid for the deposit on our first house.
Thirty seven years later, it was a very good investment as he went on to be senior management in a major company and I was repaid with huge interest.
As somebody before mentioned, if you're a team and in it for the longterm it does not matter. However...if you feel a bit nervous about it then get a contract drawn up to protect your investment.

Newmum0322 · 10/11/2022 09:49

There is no good time to buy a house… but there is a bad time. Everything I’m reading at the moment is suggesting around a 10% drop. We bought a few years ago and are looking to move (upsize) I’m waiting it out for 6 - 12 months. I’d also suggest putting in writing that you will take 15% (or whatever the deposit is) of the house in the event you divorce, and evening split the remaining 85%. Thai protects your interests too.