Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is real adult ADHD and not part of a trend

167 replies

ReadyTeddyGoooo · 09/11/2022 23:46

I'm 35 and I've had anxiety since childhood. Over the years, I've had times where it has been extremely complex and debilitating. I've had both NHS and private therapy and been on meds for a long time. I have severe health anxiety linked to ocd. I have a panic disorder and have also had pnd twice.

My 4 year old son is going through the assessment process for adhd. Since researching it for him, I've discovered that I could also have it. Obviously it's highly hereditary so it would make sense.

However, since exploring adhd, it seeks to have become over saturised on social media it seems and could almost be seen as a trend. There seems to be a lot if people getting diagnosed and it makes me wonder, do this number of people actually have adhd?

I had an appointment with a psychiatrist coming up primarily for my anxiety problems but I do also want to talk about adhd with her. But don't want her to think that I'm just jumping on the bandwagon with it.

I feel I do have adhd because...
I'm terrible at time keeping and I'm always running late.
My house is chaotic. There's little order and I lose things all the time.
I can be quite reckless in some ways, e.g. parking where I shouldn't and getting fines.
I leave everything to the last minute. Especially things that seem too overwhelming. Even my wedding - it was somewhat a rushed job.
I find big shops snd supermarkets very overwhelming. If there's too much choice and things to look at, I just flounder.
I have mind chatter and songs plating in my head a lot! Constant ideas too. I dart from one thing to the next.
I rarely finish projects.
I've never been great at reading books, I feel like I don't have the patience.

Does this sound like proper adult ashd?

OP posts:
SheCameRoundAMountain · 10/11/2022 09:29

It is 100% different from the gender issue in that there is proof ADHD exists, and there is none for gender.

Please stop derailing the thread with reference to gender politics, I don't want it being deleted because you two can't back off with the insulting comparisons.

Crackof · 10/11/2022 09:27

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Yep. It staggers me that even some people who do understand how routinely our feelings are medicalised for money don't see it happening when it's "gender". Even after Cass, & Karolinska reporting itself, etc etc. I genuinely despair.

Littlepiggiesinblankets · 10/11/2022 09:24

I have a diagnosis of ADHD and I get a lot of sniffy comments about it being "a trend", "oh, everyone has ADHD these days". But I've had a lot of life-changing help (including medication) from the medical professionals I've seen and, perhaps even more importantly, I have allowed myself to believe in my diagnosis.

As others have said, I've seen estimations that around 10 per cent of the population are neurodiverse, but diagnosis rates have been way below that, hence why a lot more people are being diagnosed. And that's a really good thing.

Greennetting · 10/11/2022 09:23

JennyNotFromTheBlock · 10/11/2022 09:16

This has nothing to do with women. You are trying to change the subject and turn it into an issue of misogyny. This is about children (boys, girls) and adults (men, women) being misdiagnosed/overdiagnosed. It is NOT about women alone. Nor is it about someone who undertakes 'years and years' of 'study and expertise' in a social trend. You can do 'years and years' of study in any hot trend, it doesn't make it valid. Anyone can get a PhD in anything these days. You can get one in gender identity. Are we going to say that is valid, too?

If you think someone studying ADHD is studying a 'social trend' and not a medical condition you are effectively denying the medical existence of ADHD. That's a particularly uninformed position.

But yes I am calling you out for misogyny in worshiping the male GP and entirely dismissing the female expert.

AntlerRose · 10/11/2022 09:23

dollyblack · 10/11/2022 09:17

I got my super trendy diagnosis in my late 30s, and it changed (and saved) my life!

I guess there is a spike in dx cause there are several generations of adults who have struggled through their whole lives getting other dx like depression, anxiety, bipolar, bpd and being given ALL THE DRUGS for all those things for years, before realising hang on, there is more to this...

What difference is it if they are pre-dx filled with prozac- in a frustrating and almost emotionless state- or post-dx filled with ADHD drugs actually being able to function and feel a bit less shit about themselves.

To the posters who think we're all just being dramatic, I used to be like you, I thought it was all trends and attention seeking and just get on with it, everyone feels like this etc etc. Until I was so burnt out I had a deep horrific depression for years, on antidepressants, unable to do life anymore. And guess what, I got DX, and guess what THERE IS NO SUPPORT OR ATTENTION, no one believes you, everyone eye rolls about it, it is not a lovely place where everyone has so much empathy about your struggles- you STILL just have to crack on, you just hate yourself a bit less.

I have a serious incurable physical disability as well, funnily enough, I get a lot more support and attention for that even though it impacts my life SO MUCH LESS than neurodiversity. I don't see anyone faking that disability for the attention.

This is very true. Lots of women are told they have bpd or other issues that they are medicated for even having admissions to hospital, then reassed for adhd or asd and get a different medication that now works.

TenPointsFromHufflepuff · 10/11/2022 09:22

Anyone can get a PhD
Then go and get one, but as a one time school admin who brown noses their gp you offer no insight or authority.

SheCameRoundAMountain · 10/11/2022 09:20

@JennyNotFromTheBlock you either respect medical expertise or you don't. A GP is a general practitioner (right there in the name!), not a specialist. Your attempt at derailing the thread has been noted.

Greennetting · 10/11/2022 09:18

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Ah, actually there have been studies done on the over diagnosis of COPD, its highly likely that your mother is just jumping on a trend and if she tried to regulate her breathing properly she would be fine

dollyblack · 10/11/2022 09:17

I got my super trendy diagnosis in my late 30s, and it changed (and saved) my life!

I guess there is a spike in dx cause there are several generations of adults who have struggled through their whole lives getting other dx like depression, anxiety, bipolar, bpd and being given ALL THE DRUGS for all those things for years, before realising hang on, there is more to this...

What difference is it if they are pre-dx filled with prozac- in a frustrating and almost emotionless state- or post-dx filled with ADHD drugs actually being able to function and feel a bit less shit about themselves.

To the posters who think we're all just being dramatic, I used to be like you, I thought it was all trends and attention seeking and just get on with it, everyone feels like this etc etc. Until I was so burnt out I had a deep horrific depression for years, on antidepressants, unable to do life anymore. And guess what, I got DX, and guess what THERE IS NO SUPPORT OR ATTENTION, no one believes you, everyone eye rolls about it, it is not a lovely place where everyone has so much empathy about your struggles- you STILL just have to crack on, you just hate yourself a bit less.

I have a serious incurable physical disability as well, funnily enough, I get a lot more support and attention for that even though it impacts my life SO MUCH LESS than neurodiversity. I don't see anyone faking that disability for the attention.

AloysiusBear · 10/11/2022 09:17

I think its a combination of things:

  • underdiagnosis (especially of women) in the past. Rising awareness now leads people to be diagnosed now.
  • the broadening of diagnostic criteria. There's been a shift towards using American DSM criteria, and there are some doctors who have expressed concerns over how broad these are, with the risk if medicalising a normal range of personality profiles.

In particular, there's a view that traits like inattention, impulsivity etc occur on a continuum (its not that people with adhd have them and no one else does - its that people witn adhd have them to the extent it impairs them). Current diagnostic criteria a) doesn't currently distinguish severity of impairment b) involves subjectivity/interpretation.

Further there's an extent of reliance on self reporting of the extent to which traits are impairing someone, with a risk that people over-attribute impacts to the ADHD symptoms.

JennyNotFromTheBlock · 10/11/2022 09:16

Greennetting · 10/11/2022 09:09

Yes let's dismiss women with years and years of study and expertise, they couldn't possibly be an expert could they 🙄

The increase in people being diagnosed is based on women suddenly being able to get a diagnosis after years of being medically ignored.

So if GPs are calling things a trend or saying the increase is due to misdiagnosis what they are complaining about is women and girls.

The same as my GP who told me I only came in to get my thyroid investigated because 'women like an underactive thyroid diagnosis because it gives them an excuse to be overweight, that's why its more prevalent in women". Is my underactive thyroid misdiagnosed, of course not. Its just gender/years of medical bias coming into play.

This has nothing to do with women. You are trying to change the subject and turn it into an issue of misogyny. This is about children (boys, girls) and adults (men, women) being misdiagnosed/overdiagnosed. It is NOT about women alone. Nor is it about someone who undertakes 'years and years' of 'study and expertise' in a social trend. You can do 'years and years' of study in any hot trend, it doesn't make it valid. Anyone can get a PhD in anything these days. You can get one in gender identity. Are we going to say that is valid, too?

SheCameRoundAMountain · 10/11/2022 09:15

I cherish his wise counsel.

But not verifiable statistics! Lol

AntlerRose · 10/11/2022 09:14

Im actually hoping jenny is reassured by this. In that most people with adhd arent medicated, and medication rates would actually be slighlty lower than her suggestion of 1-5% of diagnosis being real. It also sounds like medication has improved a lot in the last 22 years.

All the not real diagnosis children get in terms of support is quite minimal really. They get things like information chunked down and apps with reminders on. So its not invasive and if the diagnosis isnt real it doesnt matter if it helps anyway.

JennyNotFromTheBlock · 10/11/2022 09:12

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Greennetting · 10/11/2022 09:09

JennyNotFromTheBlock · 10/11/2022 08:59

There are also people who are 'experts' in Transgender issues and 'gender identity'. Or anything. It doesn't mean anything other than justifying their grants/position.

My GP never said specifically about women being misdiagnosed, rather about everyone, male or female, being misdiagnosed.

Yes let's dismiss women with years and years of study and expertise, they couldn't possibly be an expert could they 🙄

The increase in people being diagnosed is based on women suddenly being able to get a diagnosis after years of being medically ignored.

So if GPs are calling things a trend or saying the increase is due to misdiagnosis what they are complaining about is women and girls.

The same as my GP who told me I only came in to get my thyroid investigated because 'women like an underactive thyroid diagnosis because it gives them an excuse to be overweight, that's why its more prevalent in women". Is my underactive thyroid misdiagnosed, of course not. Its just gender/years of medical bias coming into play.

SD1978 · 10/11/2022 09:08

Social media has indicated or been responsible for the up scaling of May disorders previously seen as uncommon. I genuinely think it's impossible to tell whether that's because of wide spread recognition or social contagion as it's mainly young women displaying these disorders, male numbers haven't changed. I feel it's a combination of social contagion and recognition of 'masking'

Crackof · 10/11/2022 09:07

JennyNotFromTheBlock · 10/11/2022 08:59

There are also people who are 'experts' in Transgender issues and 'gender identity'. Or anything. It doesn't mean anything other than justifying their grants/position.

My GP never said specifically about women being misdiagnosed, rather about everyone, male or female, being misdiagnosed.

Your GP is right. It's all about the drug money.

OCDmama · 10/11/2022 09:05

I think it is a bit of a trend tbh.

I also have OCD which I have been under the care of psychiatrists for, and have gone through multiple counseling courses and different drugs for. I was in particular trouble after birth of my daughter. Now it's largely controlled by medication.

I also have difficulties you list. I don't think it's ADHD, I just need to get my arse in gear. The OCD diagnosis helped to identify my thought patterns but I don't see how an ADHD label will help.

JennyNotFromTheBlock · 10/11/2022 09:02

Anyway I have so much to do unfortunately and I am stalling, so, have a good day everyone.

JennyNotFromTheBlock · 10/11/2022 09:01

TenPointsFromHufflepuff · 10/11/2022 08:59

Maybe you should be less bitter and go and get a real qualification in it if you are so.surr about it Jennifer.

@TenPointsFromHufflepuff Having the temerity to have a difference of opinion from the tide doesn't make me 'bitter', I think you are projecting your own resentment of someone else daring to have a different opinion to you.

TenPointsFromHufflepuff · 10/11/2022 08:59

Maybe you should be less bitter and go and get a real qualification in it if you are so.surr about it Jennifer.

JennyNotFromTheBlock · 10/11/2022 08:59

Greennetting · 10/11/2022 08:55

One of my friends is a world renowned expert in adhd and autism. And I appreciate you may not believe me because its MN but it is the case. And her expert, many years of study, opinions are extremely different to yours.

One of her areas of study is the under diagnosing of women and girls, due to research having focused previously on boys.

It however does not suprise me that your GP may think that women and girls starting to get diagnosed more routinely after being ignored all these years is 'misdiagnosis'. I mean it's not like the medical profession has a reputation for being sexist etc!

The fact that adult women are having to seek diagnosis now is essentially because schools and medical experts let them down as children (which is more scientist and medical experts faults that schools to be fair, they were operating on the advice they had) So funnily enough a GP not being willing to admit that it's been done wrong in the past, and blaming it on 'social contagion rather than previous 'medical/scientific ineptitude' isn't really proof people are misdiagnosed...

There are also people who are 'experts' in Transgender issues and 'gender identity'. Or anything. It doesn't mean anything other than justifying their grants/position.

My GP never said specifically about women being misdiagnosed, rather about everyone, male or female, being misdiagnosed.

AntlerRose · 10/11/2022 08:57

BuryingAcorns · 10/11/2022 08:51

I wish people would use common sense when considering why there is a surge in people seeking diagnosis. It doesn't mean it's the new 'in thing' to have (no-one would want it!) It means that five decades worth of people are coming forward at once because there never used to be a diagnosis for it. Growing awareness that something can be done has people realising they no longer have to live like this, having put up with it for decades. It doesn't mean they are making it up. It means there's a lifetime's backlog of diagnoses as they didn;t exist years ago.

I think this is a key point.
Its the same for asd, there has been a massive increase in diagnosis but its been in quite an old age group and more females. So its not getting more prevelant in children. Its a backlog of 45-70 year olds.

Garysmum · 10/11/2022 08:56

@JennyNotFromTheBlock I think the point on discipline is interesting I am old enough to have gone to school in a time when I was caned starting age 5. I had the ruler across the hand at 4 etc. Real punishment. It hurt.
I really tried to fit in and behave and I didn't succeed. My the time I was a teen, I went to a religious school and to regularly pray in front of the whole school for forgiveness - a brilliant punishment for a teen as it was so humiliating.
Nothing changed my behaviour - I was still that child, one of the worst 5 in a school of a thousand.
But there were probably 5 of us with real issues in my school.
You are absolutely entitled to your opinion. I was wondering if you thought that with old-fashioned discipline more children can pay attention and behave?

Greennetting · 10/11/2022 08:55

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

One of my friends is a world renowned expert in adhd and autism. And I appreciate you may not believe me because its MN but it is the case. And her expert, many years of study, opinions are extremely different to yours.

One of her areas of study is the under diagnosing of women and girls, due to research having focused previously on boys.

It however does not suprise me that your GP may think that women and girls starting to get diagnosed more routinely after being ignored all these years is 'misdiagnosis'. I mean it's not like the medical profession has a reputation for being sexist etc!

The fact that adult women are having to seek diagnosis now is essentially because schools and medical experts let them down as children (which is more scientist and medical experts faults that schools to be fair, they were operating on the advice they had) So funnily enough a GP not being willing to admit that it's been done wrong in the past, and blaming it on 'social contagion rather than previous 'medical/scientific ineptitude' isn't really proof people are misdiagnosed...