Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU not to pay for DD's train ticket?

365 replies

SilverBirchx0x0 · 09/11/2022 22:57

DD started uni in September. She was supposed to be coming home this weekend. She has rung to say she is expecting us to pay for her train ticket.

I am quite shocked about this. She is on a full student maintenance loan and has received £1000 bursary this term on top of her student loan. One of her grandparents also gave her £1000 at the start of term. She hasn't run out of money. She said the other day she still had £1700 to last until the end of this term.
I think that she is now an adult and should be covering her own transport costs to come home for the weekend. DD says all of her friend's parents pay for their rail tickets when they go home (or come to pick them up) .

We are 4 hours away so not easy to pick her up for a weekend home.

We have already been down to visit her and stayed in a hotel for a weekend. As it is pricey, we can't keep doing this.

AIBU to expect DD to pay her own train fair to visit us this weekend?

OP posts:
MargaretThursday · 10/11/2022 07:57

I've just had one at uni.

Thing is that if they're settled well, they probably aren't that bothered to a point of rather not come home. It's a hassle for them, and they're missing the fun things at uni. I would have not wanted to go home because I was enjoying it so much.

I think in this case I'd think that either:

  1. She's homesick and needs a break to come home-in which case if you say you won't pay then in her homesick mind she'll feel that you don't want her and make it worse.
  2. She is coming home because you want her to, in which case you should pay.

So overall I think you should pay if you can afford it.

Jaichangecentfoisdenom · 10/11/2022 07:56

Like the OP, I was a student 40 years ago (well, more like 50 years ago, when I think about it), in the late Seventies. We used to have student rail cards which got us huge discounts and also there were very cheap buses from Bristol to London laid on by our Students' Union. I can't remember whether the tickets came out of my grant or whether my parents paid, though I am absolutely certain my parents would have paid if I'd asked them to. A few years ago, we paid for our daughter's travel to and from uni but as we lived a seven hour flight away from England, she was only able to come home for the university vacations anyway, so it was a bit different. I'd have really loved to have her come home for week-ends and if we'd lived in the UK, would definitely have paid for her tickets!

WilsonMilson · 10/11/2022 07:56

Jeez this is a sad read. I’ll never grudge my child a penny. She’s only in 1st year, it’s not like she’s 25. I think yabu, imagine how worthless you’d feel if your parents didn’t even care enough to stump up for a measly train fare.

ABBAsnumberonefan · 10/11/2022 07:54

My dad would pay for my ticket once a term in the first year of uni but anything else I had to do it myself, maybe a compromise like that could work?

POTC · 10/11/2022 07:53

We're in the same situation, full maintenance loan. To those saying if the parent can afford it, they don't get that if parents have spare money.
My son wants to continue playing in a national league for his sport so he has to pay for the train, we pick him up from a station on the way there as his brother goes too. He wants to do it, he has to pay.

Greeneyegirl · 10/11/2022 07:51

No, i went to uni 2009 and always paid for my ticket home. Also got full grant etc. Wouldnt have even occured to me to ask! Parents always picked me up end of year and moved me in start of year so that was fuel costs for them.

rookiemere · 10/11/2022 07:51

What's also funny on Mumsnet is that working 17-18 year olds are expected to make contributions from their fairly small incomes, but university students are somehow not true adults yet.
It should depend on what the DPs can comfortably afford. If they don't have a high income then their available income for non essentials is likely a lot lower than the DDs who is living with her meals paid for and no extra expenses and over £1k to last her until end of term.

speakout · 10/11/2022 07:51

I'd pay it.
I can afford it and I like makng my kid's lives a little easier and more pleasant.

TooManyPlatesInMotion · 10/11/2022 07:50

SarahAndQuack · 09/11/2022 23:22

I find it really odd people are telling the OP her DD won't want to see her without a bribe (which is basically what this is).

Surely, it is one thing to discuss buying train tickets/rail cards and agree beforehand who buys what, and it's something quite different to find your adult child blithely ringing up expecting something to be paid for at the last minute, and then being fed up when it is not forthcoming?

Does she properly understand the ticket will now be really pricey?

This!

prettylittlethingss · 10/11/2022 07:50

TR888 · 10/11/2022 07:36

OP, I think she has enough money to pay for her own ticket. However, I don't think the issue here is money but being new at living independently. She simply doesn't understand yet (I think) what things are her responsibility to pay and what are yours. She's probably assumed you'd pay this relatively large expense yourself, because that's what parents do.

I think you simply need to have a chat and spell out what expenses she's responsible for, and why. And not make a big deal of it as I don't think she was being intentionally cheeky.

I agree with this.
I feel like it's also probably quite common practice for parents of students to pay for this kind of thing so she probably sees it around often.
I think you need to have a proper chat.

sheepdogdelight · 10/11/2022 07:48

My parents used to pay for my train tickets back to their house.

But they didn't give me any other money (despite their income being high enough that this was recommended) so I was surviving on (partial) maintenance loan plus what I could earn. I begrudged paying money to go home and see them on the basis that I was struggling; they weren't helping me in any way and I saw my fellow students parents being much more supportive. Yes, I was 18, but in my eyes my parents had just waved me off to university and were no longer interested.

I know this isn't the same situation for OP's DD as she seems to be ok financially - but is this a genuine request for money, or a request for OP to be more supportive in general?

Notthetoothfairy · 10/11/2022 07:46

GemLettuce · 10/11/2022 07:21

You're not being tight, OP. Mumsnet is the home of the overly indulgent parent and their entitled offspring 😀

Funny how some criticise other Mnetters generally when others don’t agree with them. I could turn this around and say “Mumsnet is the home of [insulting words about poorer or tight parents]” but some of us Mnetters are actually tolerant of others’ opinions and how they choose to live their lives 😁

Chasingsquirrels · 10/11/2022 07:44

Ds1 is 2nd year, 4.5h drive & similar train journey away.
Full loan and extra (low income) bursary.
It has never occurred to me to pay for his travel.
I said I'd take him at the beginning and bring him home at the end of the year, when he had all his stuff to move - has the accomodation for 42 weeks, so can leave stuff over Christmas and Easter.
He hasn't come home at all in term time, and I didn't expect him to. He has gone to visit his girlfriend approx 4hrs train away in a totally different location a few times.
He got the train home and back last Christmas, and I expect will do the same, or coach, this year.
His dad arranged some sort of complicated collection and drop back at Easter, but it wasn't to ds time table and he only ended up bring back for 2 week, so I don't think he will do that again.

EasterIssland · 10/11/2022 07:40

SilverBirchx0x0 · 09/11/2022 23:17

Interesting that many of you think I should stump up. It simply hadn't occurred to me that I would be asked to pay for the train ticket. I can afford to pay for it but was surprised to be asked to.

DD's birthday is coming up and I offered to buy the ticket plus a student railcard as part of her birthday present. She wasn't particularly impressed by this idea, I have to say.

To be honest I’d not be happy with that Xmas present neither. It’s a present that also benefits you rather than a present to her.
if she stops coming to visit you as much as you want would you get angry with her ? Just because she’s 18 it doesn’t meant she’s not still your responsibility. She can of course work and pay for her things (this is what I did) but my parents were still there for me if I needed any help (they still are even if I’m a 37yo woman)

I always think if I ca support and help my kids when they need it then I’ll do it rather than give them the cash of money when i decease and by then they might not need it anymore

londonrach · 10/11/2022 07:40

Do you want to see her, can you afford to pay. I used to buy my ticket to come home but I knew mum give me the money every time so I didn't have to worry.

AmIThatMam · 10/11/2022 07:40

My parents did several ‘let her sort it out it will be good for her’ type things when I was between 17-19. While I can understand their point of view now (looking back as a 40 year old) at the time I felt abandoned, unsupported, unloved. It’s a tricky age, she’s not really an adult.

TR888 · 10/11/2022 07:36

OP, I think she has enough money to pay for her own ticket. However, I don't think the issue here is money but being new at living independently. She simply doesn't understand yet (I think) what things are her responsibility to pay and what are yours. She's probably assumed you'd pay this relatively large expense yourself, because that's what parents do.

I think you simply need to have a chat and spell out what expenses she's responsible for, and why. And not make a big deal of it as I don't think she was being intentionally cheeky.

BayCityTrollers · 10/11/2022 07:36

We support our dses at university with £100 a week and I still offer to pay for train fares etc.

DS1 doesn’t come home, we visit, but ds2 is home for the second time and I offered to pay both times. I want both dses to feel we want them here and we can afford it.

user1487194234 · 10/11/2022 07:33

I was totally skint at Uni and don’t want that for my DC
i give them a lot of support
It doesn’t last long,eldest now working,and is not in the least spoiled

MillyMollyMonday · 10/11/2022 07:31

@SilverBirchx0x0 I’m glad you’ve decided to pay. I definitely will be doing so for my DC. The only thing I would add, as you live some distance away is to get her to plan ahead and get advance (cheaper) fares ….Actually not sure if rail cards can be used with these or if anyone has mentioned this (haven’t read all posts). But worth thinking about.

honeylulu · 10/11/2022 07:30

I didn't think you were unreasonable either. Part of student life is learning to budget on what you have. Provided she has the full loan or loan + correct amount of to up, that is her budget. It won't be "loads" but it's not meant to be a life of luxury!

My mum used to drive to pick me up and drop me off at the beginning and end of term (mainly because I had more stuff to lug about). She'd also get me a food shop at the beginning of each term as an extra and a young person's railcard each year. But if I chose to travel anywhere during term time including home I had to go by train and pay it out of my budget and it never occurred to me to say that wasn't fair. If I had my mum would have said I'm already paying a fortune to send you to uni and that's where you're meant to be in term time!

SparkyBlue · 10/11/2022 07:26

Most people I know are partially financially supporting DC in third level (not in UK) so yes I'd expect to pay for the ticket

Awumminnscotland · 10/11/2022 07:26

Op, i dont think you're being mean in the slightest.
Personally I'd offer her money to buy a coach ticket on this occasion but I'd be in the habit of randomly sending/giving money as a surprise. I'd still make sure she knows if she needs money to ask. This puts the onus on her to manage her money to include a journey home but she still knows she can ask for money.
It often takes young maturing people quite a while to transition from having every whim catered for to taking responsibility for themselves.
As a parent I see a big part of my job is to gently facilitate this learning experience with love and support and ensuring our relationship understands this as my parenting as she grows ,that is, she wouldn't be new to this firm but fair way. It helps her also start to see you as a human with your own views and experiences and to start to deal with the fact that her view of your choices will be different.
She doesn't need to have the most expensive or quickest/ mist convenient ticket home. If she chooses to she can add to the coach ticket money herself.
Hope this helps as a different view.

rookiemere · 10/11/2022 07:26

Also what is weird to me is how often these offspring are coming home.
I was a student in Edinburgh and DPs lived in Belfast, so it was a full days trip back. I never visited in between end of terms and I don't recall any of my friends going home either.

Flutterbybudget · 10/11/2022 07:23

I paid for my own tickets home, whenI was in uni. I went home when I needed to leave the accommodation for holidays - and not in between.
Every time my son wanted to come home, I went to get him, just because I missed him and wanted to see him, and wanted HIM to know how much I wanted to see him.
So, I sppose it really depends on your relationship and how you want that to develop.
Teaching kids independence is great, (my son moved out recently), but showing them that you love them, is even more important in my opinion. The one doesn’t need to exclude the other.

Swipe left for the next trending thread