Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU not to pay for DD's train ticket?

365 replies

SilverBirchx0x0 · 09/11/2022 22:57

DD started uni in September. She was supposed to be coming home this weekend. She has rung to say she is expecting us to pay for her train ticket.

I am quite shocked about this. She is on a full student maintenance loan and has received £1000 bursary this term on top of her student loan. One of her grandparents also gave her £1000 at the start of term. She hasn't run out of money. She said the other day she still had £1700 to last until the end of this term.
I think that she is now an adult and should be covering her own transport costs to come home for the weekend. DD says all of her friend's parents pay for their rail tickets when they go home (or come to pick them up) .

We are 4 hours away so not easy to pick her up for a weekend home.

We have already been down to visit her and stayed in a hotel for a weekend. As it is pricey, we can't keep doing this.

AIBU to expect DD to pay her own train fair to visit us this weekend?

OP posts:
VortexOfDisaster · 12/11/2022 09:04

I will start by saying that I accept that we can afford it and in other circumstances we might not be so generous in how we demonstrate our parental affections.

But we always pay for train tickets for my son at uni because he’s still only a student and we are delighted when he comes home.

And I can’t imagine asking my child whether they’d like a train ticket home as a birthday present. And, if I throw my mind back, I think I would have felt hurt and rejected if my parents had put this on the table for a weekend at home when I was a student. It suggests that you’re not that bothered about seeing her.

PinkFrogss · 12/11/2022 08:59

Couldn’t imagine, that should be. Personally I think it’s a bit selfish

PinkFrogss · 12/11/2022 08:58

CountessWindyBottom · 11/11/2022 23:23

And have you read that the student's family have evidently contributed the sum total of sweet f8ck all to their child's further education? The stinginess of this thread is staggering. I can't believe the OP had to put this to public vote. 🙄

If you get full maintenance loan your parents are not expected to contribute, on the basis that their household income is too low.

And there are non financial way to contribute- helping with the moving, packing, maybe they bids buy her kitchen stuff, bedding etc, could have helped with applications, gone with on open days, helped with a level revision.

Plus she’s getting money from a grandparent, is that not family?

I could imagine having more disposable income than my parents and still expecting money from them personally.

hidingmyusername · 12/11/2022 08:25

My son is at uni. When he has to come back for medical appointments we lay, otherwise he does.

It's his choice and he needs to,learn to budget. We could afford to pay, but it's his choice so we expect him to (and he never asks)

Jillybloop393 · 12/11/2022 08:23

SilverBirchx0x0 · 09/11/2022 23:17

Interesting that many of you think I should stump up. It simply hadn't occurred to me that I would be asked to pay for the train ticket. I can afford to pay for it but was surprised to be asked to.

DD's birthday is coming up and I offered to buy the ticket plus a student railcard as part of her birthday present. She wasn't particularly impressed by this idea, I have to say.

Head above the parapet, here goes ....
Are you not very close (emotionally, not distance wise). If you are pleased to see her, and you can afford it, would you not be happy to pay for her ticket? I certainly don't think it should be part of her birthday present. Different of course if she's coming back to meet up with friends, and using your home purely as a base to sleep at, but if she's coming home to spend time with you, then I think you should pay.

Oddieconvert · 12/11/2022 07:58

LoisLane66 · 12/11/2022 02:06

Do not pay. That sets a precedent. Believe me, if she wants to see you she'll find the money. If she's ever short of money then she needs to get a p/t job. That will teach her the value of money and that she's an adult, able to decide on her priorities. Tell her that you aren't the mother of her friends and it matters not what their parents do (it could be lies) You are making your own decisions and will look forward to seeing her if she thinks you are worth the train fare. If not, then hasta la vista baby. See ya when you grow up.

@LoisLane66

do you have children? If so, what’s your relationship like with them honestly?

rookiemere · 12/11/2022 07:50

Lily4444 · 12/11/2022 07:12

If you want to see her then you should pay or she won’t come. It’s not unusual for a student to want to prioritise their money for something other than seeing their parents.

Personally I think this arrangement is quite unusual as when I was at uni no one saw their families except for Christmas so it meant we only had one train fare a year to pay.

Yes when I was a student I can't recall anyone making mid term visits to DPs. Just as I can't recall a single DP coming to visit universities - my DM was as helicoptery as they come and even she sent me off on my own - but these days it's apparently a real bonding experience with your DC.

Maybe it's good that young people are closer to their DPs, but to me - along with the insistence that a student with expendable income higher than their DPs should be paid for - feels a bit like infantilising what should be perfectly capable young adults.

memorial · 12/11/2022 07:47

LoisLane66 · 12/11/2022 02:06

Do not pay. That sets a precedent. Believe me, if she wants to see you she'll find the money. If she's ever short of money then she needs to get a p/t job. That will teach her the value of money and that she's an adult, able to decide on her priorities. Tell her that you aren't the mother of her friends and it matters not what their parents do (it could be lies) You are making your own decisions and will look forward to seeing her if she thinks you are worth the train fare. If not, then hasta la vista baby. See ya when you grow up.

Wow you sound just like my parents (who I don't have any meaningful relationship with). Do you have uni/adult children? I support my uni daughter and hope to continue as she becomes an adult. We have a lovely close relationship and she wants to come home. I want to give her all the things I never had. Support love a safe home. Hasta la vista? To a child? Awful

Oddieconvert · 12/11/2022 07:45

She is 18
I was bloody self absorbed then

Say no OP
and your DD will shrug and say “ok - I can’t come home, later”

I would say yes without hesitation knowing that 18, away at university , huge change, big city, exciting times etc. I’d get her favourite food in, so her washing, treat her for the weekend and then drop her off at the station with a massive hug.

but many a mumsnetter will scoff at this! (And it makes it all the more enjoyable knowing this!!)

blahblah33 · 12/11/2022 07:39

SilverBirchx0x0 · 09/11/2022 23:17

Interesting that many of you think I should stump up. It simply hadn't occurred to me that I would be asked to pay for the train ticket. I can afford to pay for it but was surprised to be asked to.

DD's birthday is coming up and I offered to buy the ticket plus a student railcard as part of her birthday present. She wasn't particularly impressed by this idea, I have to say.

I was all for "if you can afford it then pay as her money won't replenish monthly the same ways yours will (presumably)". However if you offered this as possibly your only way to afford and she wasn't "impressed" then I wouldn't pay. I am happy to pay for things for my DD when I can but any comments of ungratefulness about what I can afford then I would not pay. Your DD comes across as entitled here.

TirisfalPumpkin · 12/11/2022 07:25

I remember being a student in a lower income bracket than my peers, and there was some stuff their parents did for them that mine could not - useful education about inequalities in life. But train fare home, which you’ve said you can afford, is a reasonable and normal thing for parents to pay. I don’t think making it a test of your relationship (‘see if you’re worth the train fare’) is a great idea either. That just puts a lot of guilt on her for reasonable prioritisation of friends and experiences.

If you can pay, you should, or at least go halves.

Lily4444 · 12/11/2022 07:12

If you want to see her then you should pay or she won’t come. It’s not unusual for a student to want to prioritise their money for something other than seeing their parents.

Personally I think this arrangement is quite unusual as when I was at uni no one saw their families except for Christmas so it meant we only had one train fare a year to pay.

LoisLane66 · 12/11/2022 02:06

Do not pay. That sets a precedent. Believe me, if she wants to see you she'll find the money. If she's ever short of money then she needs to get a p/t job. That will teach her the value of money and that she's an adult, able to decide on her priorities. Tell her that you aren't the mother of her friends and it matters not what their parents do (it could be lies) You are making your own decisions and will look forward to seeing her if she thinks you are worth the train fare. If not, then hasta la vista baby. See ya when you grow up.

Grrrrdarling · 12/11/2022 00:44

SilverBirchx0x0 · 09/11/2022 22:57

DD started uni in September. She was supposed to be coming home this weekend. She has rung to say she is expecting us to pay for her train ticket.

I am quite shocked about this. She is on a full student maintenance loan and has received £1000 bursary this term on top of her student loan. One of her grandparents also gave her £1000 at the start of term. She hasn't run out of money. She said the other day she still had £1700 to last until the end of this term.
I think that she is now an adult and should be covering her own transport costs to come home for the weekend. DD says all of her friend's parents pay for their rail tickets when they go home (or come to pick them up) .

We are 4 hours away so not easy to pick her up for a weekend home.

We have already been down to visit her and stayed in a hotel for a weekend. As it is pricey, we can't keep doing this.

AIBU to expect DD to pay her own train fair to visit us this weekend?

Buy her a rail card then you are giving her 1/3 off her rail costs for a year is in essence paying g a 1/3 of her rial costs.
If you can afford to help her out with the cost then do, if you can’t then you can’t.
Of she plans ahead & used TopCashBack she can get cheaper tickets booking in advance & get cash back for booking online.

You need to make her aware of how you feel about the issue not assume she will understand & get the message.
I always paid for my own travel but my family was dirt poor so my mum could not help me out with it.
My mum did send me £10 a week to help me with food costs though. It is only now that I am a single parent & unable to work due to being disabled that I realise how hard it was for her to spare that £10. I was the eldest of 5 so she had lots of mouths to feed at home.
I worked 4 part time jobs to make ends meet at college.

fUNNYfACE36 · 12/11/2022 00:36

Middleagedspreadisreal · 11/11/2022 23:01

She's a student. Of course you should pay! It would never enter my head not to!

I think my dc have too much independence and self respect to ask ( unless of course they genuinely couldn't afford it)

Sceptre86 · 11/11/2022 23:58

I'd give her a reality check and tell her to stump up the cost herself. Obviously when she come home for the weekend I would feed her and house her but presumably she chose to go to a uni 4 hours away. That comes with a choice to get herself there and back. Too many 18 years olds are mollycoddled. She's an adult. That being said if you want to fund her train tickets, she's your child so it's up to you. I personally don't like the entitlement.

Kite22 · 11/11/2022 23:46

How is it stingy ? Confused

the very premise of the way that student finance is worked out is that a student who gets the full loan, gets the full loan because it is recognised that their parents are not able to afford to pay out to support the student. Same with the type of bursary this student has. It has been awarded because the University recognise the household income of the student's family does not have wiggle room to be treating them to all the 'extras' that it might be nice to have.

CountessWindyBottom · 11/11/2022 23:23

Kite22 · 11/11/2022 23:03

She's a student. Of course you should pay! It would never enter my head not to!

Have you read that the student's income is virtually as much as the household income of the family ? Hmm

And have you read that the student's family have evidently contributed the sum total of sweet f8ck all to their child's further education? The stinginess of this thread is staggering. I can't believe the OP had to put this to public vote. 🙄

Kite22 · 11/11/2022 23:03

She's a student. Of course you should pay! It would never enter my head not to!

Have you read that the student's income is virtually as much as the household income of the family ? Hmm

Middleagedspreadisreal · 11/11/2022 23:01

She's a student. Of course you should pay! It would never enter my head not to!

SilverBirchx0x0 · 11/11/2022 22:42

threatmatrix · 11/11/2022 20:18

I would have told her definitely no way was I buying her ticket and folded and bought it.

That's exactly what I did do! 😀😀

OP posts:
Firethrice · 11/11/2022 22:09

Conkersareback · 11/11/2022 19:32

Reading this it makes me realise why a lot of children are NC with their parents and find it very easy.

An adult going non contact with their parents because they won’t pay for their travel home when they are an adult and have enough money - that adult needs therapy not a rail fare.

wherearebeefandonioncrisps · 11/11/2022 22:07

Do you actually know where all of her money is going?

My daughter went to uni and her accommodation was over £1000 more than her loan. Let alone food or anything else.

Chuck2015 · 11/11/2022 21:58

I never asked my parents for money, students are either independent or not, can’t have it both ways!
Maybe it’s nice to offer occasionally but it’s very entitled to expect it and I’m not sure it’s a great life lesson to pay for everything either..

mileaminute · 11/11/2022 21:27

100% I would pay. It's important to me for him to know that he can come home whenever he wants and there are no obstacles to that. And that I want to see him.
I think this comes from how my dad was with me "wherever you are, whatever happens, I'll come and get you" that kind of attitude.

Swipe left for the next trending thread