Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU not to pay for DD's train ticket?

365 replies

SilverBirchx0x0 · 09/11/2022 22:57

DD started uni in September. She was supposed to be coming home this weekend. She has rung to say she is expecting us to pay for her train ticket.

I am quite shocked about this. She is on a full student maintenance loan and has received £1000 bursary this term on top of her student loan. One of her grandparents also gave her £1000 at the start of term. She hasn't run out of money. She said the other day she still had £1700 to last until the end of this term.
I think that she is now an adult and should be covering her own transport costs to come home for the weekend. DD says all of her friend's parents pay for their rail tickets when they go home (or come to pick them up) .

We are 4 hours away so not easy to pick her up for a weekend home.

We have already been down to visit her and stayed in a hotel for a weekend. As it is pricey, we can't keep doing this.

AIBU to expect DD to pay her own train fair to visit us this weekend?

OP posts:
frazzledasarock · 10/11/2022 02:24

I bought my dc 16-25 railcard and she comes and goes as she pleases. She’s a similar distance away from us.

sashh · 10/11/2022 02:17

How about you pay the cost of a student rail card, and she buys the tickets?

The card will give her 1/3 off.

Topsyturvy78 · 10/11/2022 01:48

I think that's a great idea for her birthday. Rather than buying something for the sake of it. Get her something she will use.

stuntbubbles · 10/11/2022 01:43

I went to uni the opposite end of the country from my parents and always paid my way home: overnight mega bus £1-£10 fare to London then a local train. No reason she has to pay for an expensive last-minute train ticket. Part of living away and student life is learning how to budget and making “if this, then not that” spending decisions.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 10/11/2022 01:40

If you couldn't afford it, that would be that, and she shouldn't be assuming; but it does surprise me how many people seem to see students as well-off, just because they get a lump sum of money for all their living expenses in advance (much of which is a massive repayable LOAN). It reminds me of people who see somebody on benefits who runs a modest old car (and has a 'flat screen TV', of course) and then deduce that they must be comfortably off.

Being a student is where you begin to learn to live as an independent adult, but it takes time learning 'to adult' and there's no reason why you should be thrown in the deep end immediately by your loved ones who have happily supported you before now.

It always amazes me by how many people on MN seem to want to pull the financial support plug the instant their child turns 18 - and yet, if an absent father wants to stop paying immediately they have their birthday, everybody quite rightly points out that they usually still cost money and retain a level of dependence for some time afterwards and what a selfish person he is.

JennyWI · 10/11/2022 01:10

my mom used to pay half.

Gymnopedie · 10/11/2022 01:06

She has rung to say she is expecting us to pay for her train ticket.

I think this is the bit that muddies the waters. You didn't think to offer, and if she'd asked if you would then quite possibly you'd have said yes. I don't know.

But if she worded it literally as she expected you to pay (ie she pretty much demanded it) then she's painted you and her into opposite corners. Because if you retract and say you'll pay, it sends the message that what daughter wants daughter gets (to borrow from Prince Harry).

Does she generally demand things, or is she usually reasonable? Either way, a proper conversation needs to be had that you won't have your hand forced.

Appleblum · 10/11/2022 01:00

I would pay.

HappyAxolotl · 10/11/2022 00:59

Sounds like neither of you is being unreasonable but you both got crossed wires. She assumed you would pay her ticket home because it seems to be the norm for students' parents to do so, but you assumed she would pay as you hadn't offered to and she hadn't asked you to.

Can you offer to go halves this time (as the fares will be high at short notice) and have a good chat with DD at the weekend?

Pixiedust1234 · 10/11/2022 00:52

But does she have to pay it back? If so then it is debt and possibly why she doesn't want to spend it on a train ticket.

SilverBirchx0x0 · 10/11/2022 00:20

Pixiedust1234 · 10/11/2022 00:14

I think i am missing something here. I have to confess I don't understand student loans/bursaries. Doesnt your DD have to pay all of her loans back at some point when she graduates? Therefore she might have plenty of money in her bank right now but its not really hers as its equivalent to credit card debt. I am assuming that anything left over each year means she gets to ask for a smaller loan which reduces her overall debt.

If the above is correct then you are wanting her to increase her debt because you are too tight to buy her a ticket to come home? Or will you also be going into debt yourself to buy it?

Student loan amount award is determined by parental income. The student doesn't choose how much to borrow each year.

OP posts:
SilverBirchx0x0 · 10/11/2022 00:17

SkankingWombat · 10/11/2022 00:00

Including the £1k from her DGM? Because if that was a one off, I can see why she wouldn't count that as available funds and would be eeking it out across the 3 years. Without the £1k she has £700 to last until the new year, which doesn't seem a huge amount.

She only has 4 weeks left of term and she lives in a catered Hall of residence so I think she should be okay financially.

OP posts:
Pixiedust1234 · 10/11/2022 00:14

I think i am missing something here. I have to confess I don't understand student loans/bursaries. Doesnt your DD have to pay all of her loans back at some point when she graduates? Therefore she might have plenty of money in her bank right now but its not really hers as its equivalent to credit card debt. I am assuming that anything left over each year means she gets to ask for a smaller loan which reduces her overall debt.

If the above is correct then you are wanting her to increase her debt because you are too tight to buy her a ticket to come home? Or will you also be going into debt yourself to buy it?

latetothefisting · 10/11/2022 00:11

So have you not contributed to her living costs at all? Because most parents are expected to as student loan doesn't cover everything.

I think the train ticket could go either way - I always paid for mine but then I didn't live very far away so it was cheap and often got a lift one way. I remember one friend whose parents would offer to pay for the megabus but if she wanted to take the train she had to pay the difference.

Perhaps you could fund one case of the cheapest transport available per term, if she wants more than that/nicer transport/leaves it until last minute it's on her?

healthadvice123 · 10/11/2022 00:05

Everyone will have a different way
My ds mostlt pays for his own train, he comes home a bit as not far away but we often help him to but he never got the full loan , but did have a gap year and saved money but will need to use that for the remaining years
Some parents will pay others will not

SkankingWombat · 10/11/2022 00:00

SilverBirchx0x0 · 09/11/2022 23:40

Yes, she will get a similar amount each term. I don't think DD is frittering money away. She just thought we would be paying train tickets home.
However, maybe I am being tight.
As my parents didn't pay for me to come home when I was a student 40 years ago, I suppose it just hadn't occurred to me that I would be paying for tickets for DD to visit home.

Including the £1k from her DGM? Because if that was a one off, I can see why she wouldn't count that as available funds and would be eeking it out across the 3 years. Without the £1k she has £700 to last until the new year, which doesn't seem a huge amount.

SilverBirchx0x0 · 09/11/2022 23:59

Lemoncurd · 09/11/2022 23:53

Really don't think you are. It would be different if your daughter was struggling and you probably would have paid straight away if you knew that to be the case.

It may be that the friends whose parents are paying do have less money available to them so she really can't compare to them like that either.

Most of her friends are international students who are entirely supported by their parents for living costs anyway. I guess as they are paying for everything anyway, they probably cover cost of visits home as part of supporting their DC.

OP posts:
TwoRockSalmonAndAHaporthOfChips · 09/11/2022 23:55

My parents would still buy the odd rail ticket home when I was living in London on next to nothing in my first graduate job in the 90s.

As a student, I very much considered that I still lived at home, and just stayed away for nine weeks at a time - I lived at home more of my time than at university. I was still part of the family and my folks never expected me to contribute from my little grant - though I did because I wanted to help out. They weren’t very well off but wanted to continue to support us until we could support ourselves.

If you can afford it, wouldn’t you think it would be a nice gesture to buy a ticket now and then? For your daughter to come home to her family?

Chilesstanton · 09/11/2022 23:54

SilverBirchx0x0 · 09/11/2022 23:17

Interesting that many of you think I should stump up. It simply hadn't occurred to me that I would be asked to pay for the train ticket. I can afford to pay for it but was surprised to be asked to.

DD's birthday is coming up and I offered to buy the ticket plus a student railcard as part of her birthday present. She wasn't particularly impressed by this idea, I have to say.

Confused
Lemoncurd · 09/11/2022 23:53

SilverBirchx0x0 · 09/11/2022 23:46

I am starting to think I have been quite mean!

Really don't think you are. It would be different if your daughter was struggling and you probably would have paid straight away if you knew that to be the case.

It may be that the friends whose parents are paying do have less money available to them so she really can't compare to them like that either.

tactum · 09/11/2022 23:53

We pay for DD to come home. We can afford it and want her to be able to come back to her home whenever she wants to - why on earth wouldn't we want to make it easy if we could?

That said, my mum and dad never did- in the days of student grant. I had to pay for everything. I used to look at my friends whose parents used to treat them, take them out shopping etc with envy.

Whenever my DD comes home I try and stock her suitcase full of toiletries to take back so she doesn't have to get them herself.

RedRec · 09/11/2022 23:52

Train ticket home for a birthday present. Ffs, I have heard it all now.

bridgetreilly · 09/11/2022 23:50

30 years ago when I was a student, people didn’t just go home for the weekend! I would pay this time but then have a chat about expectations going forward, e.g. you pay once per term and if she wants to come more often, she pays.

PinkFrogss · 09/11/2022 23:49

To put it into perspective:

£6,000 per semester is equal to about the take home pay of a £20k per annum salary.

Her parents probably earn £25k or less, for her to be getting maximum loan

JudgeRindersMinder · 09/11/2022 23:48

SilverBirchx0x0 · 09/11/2022 23:17

Interesting that many of you think I should stump up. It simply hadn't occurred to me that I would be asked to pay for the train ticket. I can afford to pay for it but was surprised to be asked to.

DD's birthday is coming up and I offered to buy the ticket plus a student railcard as part of her birthday present. She wasn't particularly impressed by this idea, I have to say.

Can’t say I blame her!

I can’t imagine a scenario where I wouldn’t pay this for my child.