Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU not to pay for DD's train ticket?

365 replies

SilverBirchx0x0 · 09/11/2022 22:57

DD started uni in September. She was supposed to be coming home this weekend. She has rung to say she is expecting us to pay for her train ticket.

I am quite shocked about this. She is on a full student maintenance loan and has received £1000 bursary this term on top of her student loan. One of her grandparents also gave her £1000 at the start of term. She hasn't run out of money. She said the other day she still had £1700 to last until the end of this term.
I think that she is now an adult and should be covering her own transport costs to come home for the weekend. DD says all of her friend's parents pay for their rail tickets when they go home (or come to pick them up) .

We are 4 hours away so not easy to pick her up for a weekend home.

We have already been down to visit her and stayed in a hotel for a weekend. As it is pricey, we can't keep doing this.

AIBU to expect DD to pay her own train fair to visit us this weekend?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SilverBirchx0x0 · 14/11/2022 11:39

Thank you!

OP posts:
MrsLargeEmbodied · 14/11/2022 10:53

oh not nice
better luck with her coach journey!

SilverBirchx0x0 · 14/11/2022 10:27

Hi Folks. Well just in case anyone is interested, DD came back home by train this weekend and had a lovely time. However, the train journey itself was horrific. Loads of drunk travellers, one of whom peed in the carriage. Others covered in blood, possibly from fighting?
Needless to say, I have booked a coach ticket for the journey back for the spring term!

OP posts:
Comefromaway · 14/11/2022 09:53

It is exactly the same as income. It is money you have to live off. It is classed as income for things like claiming free prescriptions etc.

sheepdogdelight · 14/11/2022 09:03

Firethrice · 12/11/2022 14:01

The majority of Students take out a loan for their living expenses - are you unaware of this? It is completely normal and expected

Of course I'm aware of this! Doesn't mean (as a parent) I wouldn't want to minimise the amount my child took out if at all possible.
The point is this is not the same as income. It's money that has to be paid back (or written off in 40 years' time ...)

sue20 · 14/11/2022 00:38

SkiingIsHeaven · 09/11/2022 23:16

Don't you want her to come back. You don't sound very welcoming.

Yes I think it’s an emotional issue. The feeling that your parents will look after you even though you’ve just left home. So you don’t pay she could decide not to come and you’re happy with that possible outcome? It sounds a bit cold don’t you miss her?

Prettydress · 13/11/2022 12:50

Hi OP, there's no right or wrong answer. Just come to an agreement so everyone is clear. Sounds like you are pretty savvy with money and it sounds like your daughter has learnt well from you, so rather than be annoyed, I think you should be secretly pleased 😂

It is worth remembering though, paying for a ticket for her to come home is much cheaper than paying for you all to visit her.

As a compromise you could offer to pay for a coach ticket and if she wants to travel by train she can pay the rest.

Barney60 · 13/11/2022 11:24

Question is, do you want to see her?
She may well stop coming back as often if you don't come to some sort of arrangement over her ticket.

noworklifebalance · 12/11/2022 21:50

I think you neither being reasonable or unreasonable.
You mention in one of your posts that you can afford it but it didn’t occur to you to pay for it.
If you never had travel costs paid for you by your parents then that is your normal and I can understand why it wouldn’t occur for your to do the same for your DD.
Others who have been in your situation as a student may want for a different experience for their DC.

My parents would drive me back to university (3h round trip) with a cooler bag full of home cooked food for the week. In my head, that’s what I envisage doing for my kids, if that’s what they want. I wasn’t unique in that way but there were others whose parents never came to see them or they never went home - which is fine as long as both parties are happy with that set up.

Notagardener · 12/11/2022 21:42

I can afford to pay and have often done so (also because I can choose a suitable time to pick up from the station). But it would be an offer from me, not a demand from DC.

Comefromaway · 12/11/2022 21:34

There speaks the voice of privilege.

theyalsoserve · 12/11/2022 21:04

So you're not paying anything towards her uni years? Apart from what her grandparents have paid it's loans and scholarships? Yep, you should be paying he travel cost unless you are also living off debt snd charity/ gifts.

twoboystwodogs · 12/11/2022 19:29

I think you should this time but have a chat when she is home to agree what you are and aren't going to pay for x

viques · 12/11/2022 14:10

I would pay for a single ticket to come home, but make sure that she has a railcard and understands booking in advance to get cheaper fares. I would also look at the option of coach travel , if she can get somewhere local to you it could be possible to pick her up.

Asher33 · 12/11/2022 14:08

Lozois99 · 12/11/2022 12:38

Do you want to see her or not? Wouldn’t you rather she spent the money on something else? What a weird way to parent. Just pay the money you tightwad

Even though her daughter has £1700 spare and the OP is on a low income? I think her daughters the tight one here

Firethrice · 12/11/2022 14:01

sheepdogdelight · 12/11/2022 13:49

A lot of people seem to not have considered/realised that the majority of the student's "income" is a loan. She is literally borrowing money to pay for things.

If this question was phrased as "DD has to take out a loan to pay for her train ticket; I can afford to give her the money but don't think I should" - the answers would be rather different ...

The majority of Students take out a loan for their living expenses - are you unaware of this? It is completely normal and expected

threatmatrix · 12/11/2022 13:52

SilverBirchx0x0 · 11/11/2022 22:42

That's exactly what I did do! 😀😀

We are just too soft 😂😂🤦🏼‍♀️

sheepdogdelight · 12/11/2022 13:49

A lot of people seem to not have considered/realised that the majority of the student's "income" is a loan. She is literally borrowing money to pay for things.

If this question was phrased as "DD has to take out a loan to pay for her train ticket; I can afford to give her the money but don't think I should" - the answers would be rather different ...

LoveAutumnColours · 12/11/2022 13:42

We enjoyed our DC company and visits from uni do not only did we pay cut their train fare home, I collected them from the station and when they left, gave them care packages if food, toiletries etc I’d also make their favourite meals.

do you not really want to make them welcome?

Lozois99 · 12/11/2022 12:38

Do you want to see her or not? Wouldn’t you rather she spent the money on something else? What a weird way to parent. Just pay the money you tightwad

Firethrice · 12/11/2022 11:26

Exactly this! I am astonished at the way this thread has turned into “Are you not close? She’ll go NC in no time and I don’t blame her” type comments!

I would be seriously concerned with a dc who would go NC over something like this - I'd be seriously concerned that they were in a powerplay with me -manipulative, huffy and very immature - not sure how you'd fix this but it certainly wouldn't involve being manipulated into giving more money. I suppose there are plenty of adults who huff to get their own way too and people give in to them so they keep doing it.

rookiemere · 12/11/2022 11:08

I can't believe people are calling the OP stingy about this.

DD gets an amount through bursary and loan that suggests that family income is very low indeed. Last minute train fares are expensive .

I could easily afford train fares, so I probably would pay for it. But not everyone can, it doesn't make them a bad DM. They supported their DD enough for her to get to university, not all support is financial.

4kids2cats · 12/11/2022 11:01

Exactly this! I am astonished at the way this thread has turned into “Are you not close? She’ll go NC in no time and I don’t blame her” type comments!

Going to uni is meant to be a great adventure and the start of adult life. Coming home for weekends part way through term is fine if you’re really struggling but otherwise you’re just missing out. Term is really not that long and you need to be totally immersed and then come home in the holidays to your loving family and sleep and get cared for.

It has absolutely nothing to do with how close you are to your parents. Especially when everyone can FaceTime and WhatsApp at the drop of a hat.

Firethrice · 12/11/2022 09:22

Jillybloop393 · 12/11/2022 08:23

Head above the parapet, here goes ....
Are you not very close (emotionally, not distance wise). If you are pleased to see her, and you can afford it, would you not be happy to pay for her ticket? I certainly don't think it should be part of her birthday present. Different of course if she's coming back to meet up with friends, and using your home purely as a base to sleep at, but if she's coming home to spend time with you, then I think you should pay.

I wouldn't pay for the ticket and I would consider myself to be emotionally close to my kids. But why that does not mean I want them home for a weekend - that is always fun - but they are meant to be at Uni. I want them not to need to come home - to have settled in enough to be confident that they can stay to the end of term. That knowing being away from home for 10 weeks doesn't change how we feel about them.

We have cared enough to give them enough money to make decisions for themselves and to not make this Uni experience all about us missing them, to not put expectations on them to come home or to phone home.

We'll travel to see them at the weekend, take them out for lunch, dinner, breakfast etc - or not because they can't get out of bed - that's ok too.

I am secure in my relationship with my kids, we speak frequently at no set times and enjoy each other's company. I am genuinely happy that my kids are having a great adventure, they do not need me to be with them, that they are not needing/wanting to come home, that they have met a great group of friends and their mental and physical health is in a good place. If they phoned home and said they needed to come home, I'd be there, if they said they were skint, I'd pay....but the normal run of events is that they are growing up, they are expected to budget and they are fully on board with this and paying for trips home is part of that.

Biscuits1011 · 12/11/2022 09:06

Hankunamatata · 09/11/2022 23:00

Can you afford to pay for the ticket? If yes then you should.

This

Swipe left for the next trending thread