Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Be honest: Do you judge married women without kids?

309 replies

oxymomon · 09/11/2022 21:24

When you meet a woman who has been married for years, and doesn't have children, do you (A) make assumptions about why they don't have children; (B) ask them why they don't have children (feel it's your place to seek answers); (C) judge them for not having children; (D) all of the above; or (E) none of the above? Be honest. What do you really think...

OP posts:
Spookypig · 09/11/2022 23:21

My close friends are married without children. I have vaguely wondered once whether they want children in the future/have tried but been unable, but it was nothing more than a passing though due to a relevant conversation we were having and I wouldn’t ask or say it out loud.

Sn0tnose · 09/11/2022 23:17

E. Because I have been married for quite a while and we don’t have children. I think I’ve been asked once if I was planning on having any, once why I didn’t have any, and I was told this summer that I should have one (I was making a fuss of a baby and a passing acquaintance decided this was enough to judge that I’d be a good parent). Other than that, I’ve been left alone.

Strangely enough, my DH gets asked on a regular basis when he’ll be having kids and when he says he doesn’t want any, he’s met with real surprise and they either don’t believe him or seem almost annoyed with him. To be fair, he is brilliant with children and is the ‘fun uncle’ they all flock to, but he’s a far bigger fan of being able to hand them back to their parents when he’s tired and fancies a nap.

Isahlo · 09/11/2022 23:00

E.
i was in a LTR for nearly a decade, living as married before we had our daughter. three years of that was having a lovely time and 5 years of that was miscarrying heartbreak trying etc

i might wonder if they're ok. Because I had a rough ride and I'm probably projecting But no judgement

FirewomanSam · 09/11/2022 22:58

This is depressing. I am one of those women and until this thread I had never realised that everyone I meet is apparently wondering why I don’t have kids!

Thearex · 09/11/2022 22:55

E- I have no opinion... probably because that's me. 20yrs with DP, house, professional jobs, no kids (mixed reasons tbh)

Can confirm I have had everything from A to E.

  • told its selfish
  • told I don't know what real love is
  • told I live a life of Riley *asked why & what's wrong with me.
  • left out of social events, and excluded from conversations.

SiL even tried to get DP disinherited so everything went to her children.

In our circle, we are close to 2 other couples that are CF, one by choice, one due to chronic illness.

StrangerThanFiction2 · 09/11/2022 22:52

I'll be honest. I do wonder why they don't have children and if I know they can't for whatever reason I feel very sorry for them. I think there are few things more painful than not being able to have a child when you want one.

I think it's crazy to judge anyone negatively for not having children. You aren't doing anyone any fever by having children. We all have children for purely selfish reasons so it's nothing to be proud of (though having my kids is something I'm very happy about and very grateful for).

bowlingalleyblues · 09/11/2022 22:51

A - I’d assume there was some reason like: chose not to, tried to but had fertility issues, planning to have them in the future but I wouldn’t judge or ask because it’s none of my business and it makes no difference to me either way. I wouldn’t ask anyone apart from a very close friend or family member anything about this.

Ineedwinenow · 09/11/2022 22:49

We are cfbc and never asked, I’m very open in conversations and very blunt and straight to the point so people are probably scared of me 😆

on the other side of the coin I definitely judge some people who have children, I know a couple of people in my wider circle that couldn’t look after themselves and then got pregnant! 😱 ( social services are now luckily involved) so it definitely works both ways

Hankunamatata · 09/11/2022 22:46

There's wrote a few women in my career who don't have children

Hankunamatata · 09/11/2022 22:46

I do have passing thought through my head. But thought is also followed by all reasons - didn't want them, infertility, too old etc. And no way would I ever ask that is just rude.

Vecna · 09/11/2022 22:42

I do wonder, yes. I have 2 IVF children - the first just before I turned 37 and I suppose that inevitably makes me wonder. I've never asked but lots of people asked me. Lots. It's rarely as blunt as it seems (though it sometimes is which is always jarring). It mostly crops up in conversation some subtle way or other because people are weirdly invested in other people's intentions regarding having children.

I wouldn't judge someone for not having children regardless of the reason, and I've never felt judged. But then I never got beyond the point where having children was impossible due to age, so maybe those women have different experiences.

oxymomon · 09/11/2022 22:39

Alvinne · 09/11/2022 22:26

I did acknowledge in my post that not everyone is judgemental, but in my extensive experience of being asked by this it is very often acompanied by a judgement. Ive been told by multiple people that i'm selfish for not having children, or i'm lucky not to have children. This has included my manager, colleagues, family members, strangers, taxi drivers, friends of friends. All people who know nothing of my situation, health, or decisions. They are framing my life through their own judgement to decide if i'm selfish or lucky, however they percieve it it is none of their business and is unecessary. If i've said i don't have kids, that is all you need to know. People can wonder all they like, but what do they get out of asking about this?

☝☝☝☝☝This post saddens me greatly to hear, but it is disappointingly the reality for many. My original post was deliberately phrased controversially to see how people would respond. Would they be honest? It was interesting to see people responding with "that's nasty" (yes, it is), and just as interesting to see people shocked that such behaviour would even occur. But as this post shows, options A (making unfounded assumptions), B (intrusively asking why, as if it's anyone else's business), and C (judging) DO happen. It gives me hope that most responses to this thread don't think it's right to judge, or even make assumptions. But perhaps it's helpful for people to see that this is still happening. And it's time it stopped. To the person who posted your experiences here, explaining that so many people have framed your life through their own judgement to decide if you are selfish or lucky ... I am so sorry. It is nobody else's business but yours. Thank you for your honesty, and I hope that nobody ever makes assumptions, asks you intrusive questions, or judges you again. After all, you are just a human being who happens not to have kids. You be you. 🙏

OP posts:
Familydilemmas · 09/11/2022 22:34

E

LBFseBrom · 09/11/2022 22:34

E. It's not my business anyway.

Hoolihan · 09/11/2022 22:33

oxymomon · 09/11/2022 21:44

Is thinking that it's relatively unusual, and wondering why judging?

No.

reachforthebloodymary · 09/11/2022 22:31

E

But this is due to the 2 childless couples I know (and know the reasons) both travel alot and go to the most amazing places, so I think the first thing that pops into my head is wondering what the last holiday you went on

However, I am also well aware that women get questioned a lot on it, but then as a parent of a single child, I use to get asked when I was having another one.

A friend with 4 boys, use to get asked, if they were going try for a girl

A friend with 5 kids, use to get asked, if they thought they had too many or if they all has the same dad

Always the women, never the man

Sometimeswinning · 09/11/2022 22:31

Surely it's human nature to make assumptions. Yes I'd wonder. I wouldn't judge as that doesn't really make any sense. Same as when people have twins, I wonder if it's in the family or ivf. I don't mean to it's just what my brain does immediately.

Hoolihan · 09/11/2022 22:31

AssignedSlytherinAtBirth · 09/11/2022 21:41

Not that unusual. In my gang of eight women friends, all are married, four don't have dch and four do. I know one couple tried IVF. This would've been a few years ago though. Maybe it's more successful these days.

Your friends are not representative. Statistically around 80% of women do have children at some point.

Alvinne · 09/11/2022 22:30

Puffalicious · 09/11/2022 22:16

FFS, Now we have the bloody thought police!

I would never judge ANY woman, ever, but I'm not having my thoughts monitored.

People can think what they like, its the verbalising of those thoughts to people who don't have children and asking prying questions to satisfy curiosity that can be hurtful and uncessary. Not saying you do this, but people do, often.

Alvinne · 09/11/2022 22:26

Hillrunning · 09/11/2022 22:13

Bit being nosey isn't being judgemental. Judgement requires them to ask, hear your answer (if you choose to give it) and then view you as inferior based on your answer. Lots of people are nosey, and that is rude but it isn't judgemental.

I did acknowledge in my post that not everyone is judgemental, but in my extensive experience of being asked by this it is very often acompanied by a judgement. Ive been told by multiple people that i'm selfish for not having children, or i'm lucky not to have children. This has included my manager, colleagues, family members, strangers, taxi drivers, friends of friends. All people who know nothing of my situation, health, or decisions. They are framing my life through their own judgement to decide if i'm selfish or lucky, however they percieve it it is none of their business and is unecessary. If i've said i don't have kids, that is all you need to know. People can wonder all they like, but what do they get out of asking about this?

BatshitBanshee · 09/11/2022 22:24

I might wonder why in passing, but I'd never ever ever ask anyone why - the idea of doing so is just horrific to me. I do think that child free married women can sense they're being judged or have been judged previously and my heart aches whenever someone feels the need to explain even though I haven't asked because clearly they've met other people who want them to justify their situation i.e. "Me and husband don't have kids... Because we've tried and didn't happen/because a genetic condition runs in the family/because we prefer our life as it is" etc etc.

The only time I did judge was when a man explained to me (without me asking) that they couldn't have children because "it's the wife's fault... Bad eggs". I silently hoped she'd leave him and take him to the cleaners. Arsehole.

CookieDoughKid · 09/11/2022 22:19

I definitely could have written my post better but feeling a bit tired atm!

Comedycook · 09/11/2022 22:18

Massive difference between wondering and judging.

CookieDoughKid · 09/11/2022 22:18

I'd wonder but I’d never ask. I’m can be a bit judgy if I think I know enough about their situation but that’s MY problem entirely and I would never ever dream of raising it. Nothing good can come of it. Curiosity kills the cat and all that. It’s my problem because I truly will never ever don’t know their details and tbh, I don’t care enough to want to know. It is just an initial passing phase of ‘why have you got 3 dogs, is that compensation for not having kids?’ kind of thinking . But in defence I am Asian and we are brought up to be believe being a mother is the greatest of all career choices and producing a son is Gold (heaven forbid if my mother only had grand daughters, she’d be at the Buddhist Temple praying every day lighting incense sticks ). I am not way not like that BUT …..it can be hard to shake my Asian wayz…..

I am prepared to be flamed.

oxymomon · 09/11/2022 22:17

Heatherland77 · 09/11/2022 22:11

We can definitely sense when we're being judged. It's a strong vibe.
It does say more about the person making the judgement though. I haven't said a word usually but I know I've been put in a mental box by someone.
And this is where we fall over our own shoes, judging other people about why they might not have children. If we're ever going to be inclusive on all levels, we need to halt these legacy assumptions about ovaries and uteruses and whether they've been occupied or not.
Period! (couldn't wait to use that!) 😂

You make such a great point. We can sense when we are being judged. And sometimes, we might not be being judged, but we can sense when somebody is wondering or making assumptions, and that makes us feel judged. As you said, we should halt these assumptions if we want to be inclusive. Nice use of period btw ;-)

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread