Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Be honest: Do you judge married women without kids?

309 replies

oxymomon · 09/11/2022 21:24

When you meet a woman who has been married for years, and doesn't have children, do you (A) make assumptions about why they don't have children; (B) ask them why they don't have children (feel it's your place to seek answers); (C) judge them for not having children; (D) all of the above; or (E) none of the above? Be honest. What do you really think...

OP posts:
Username7853377 · 10/11/2022 08:37

I'm childfree by choice.

I don't mind being asked whether I have children or not - in my opinion, that's a fairly neutral question to be asked.

I hate being asked if I want children or if I think I'll have them. This is incredibly invasive. There's a myriad of reasons why I don't have children and it's absolutely no one else's business.

I don't think I've ever been asked why I don't have children - I think I'd be too stunned to answer if someone asked that.

Georgeandzippyzoo · 10/11/2022 08:33

If it was a first meeting, finding out about each other I might ask generally about her family, where they're from etc... but I wouldn't ask a married woman specifically if she had children and why not. As others have said it might cross my mind 'oh I wonder why' but that's the end.
A colleague I worked with didn't have children. Others used to say it was weird/ how her parents would never have grandkids etc.
My view is it's their choice as a couple if they have kids. To have kids because it's 'expected' is probably the worst reason to have them.
I actually think women who actively choose not have them are usually quite strong and I admire them for sticking with their beliefs. (My DSis has never wanted kids so maybe that affects how I see it)

the80sweregreat · 10/11/2022 08:32

One lady I used to know had much older step children she didn't like that-much , so she was happy it was very part time and had a lovely life and was child free the rest of the time. Holidays , money , lie ins etc.

WishfulWanda · 10/11/2022 08:31

Why just the woman? It takes two to have a baby you know.

As for your question, I might be secretly curious. However, I wouldn’t dream of asking. Even if I was 90% sure they didn’t want kids, they may have been privately trying for ages and it’s actually a very sore topic. My view is that if they want to discuss it than they will, if not then I won’t pry.

Thursa · 10/11/2022 08:31

I wouldn’t give it a thought. But I have been in that situation, we were married and “trying” for 14 years before we had our first child. I’ve had some nasty, stupid, thoughtless remarks made to me. I could never do it to someone else.

we finally had two children and I was called selfish for having them so late as I’d surely die before they grew up. I was in my late 30’s…

Differentaround · 10/11/2022 08:26

Another thought I have but don’t vocalise is jealousy (in a light hearted way) about the lie ins and being able to do what they want on the weekend 😂

the80sweregreat · 10/11/2022 08:24

I've asked two women this question before
One was a lady I work with in a non teaching role in a primary school ( as all of my colleagues have children ) when she first stated there and one was someone I met through my husbands job who I didn't know and it was just part of the conversation you have when you first meet someone.
I feel I'd be a bit more wary now though as I sometimes tend to say things without thinking first ! Although I like to think I wasn't being disrespectful , it was just a generic question Both ladies have different reasons for not having children , but were happy to talk about it and admit they have a great life because of it. I think it will be much more common over time too, my own son ( 25 ) doesn't want children. I can't say I blame him really. He isn't in a relationship atm though ..

Differentaround · 10/11/2022 08:16

oxymomon · 09/11/2022 21:37

I appreciate the honesty in these responses. It's heartwarming to hear that most don't feel they judge. But many have admitted they would wonder why, but wouldn't ask. Do you think that a woman could perhaps be able to sense that another person wonders why? Might that very sense, make a woman "feel" judged. After all, why would you wonder why? As one poster said, would you ever wonder why a married woman DID have children?

I can’t really help wondering, I mean, you can’t always help the thoughts that pop into your head…and I sincerely hope they can’t tell I’m wondering unless they have physic powers!

WimpoleHat · 10/11/2022 07:57

"Do you have children?" is a question i think should be banned from conversations.

I do think that’s a big step too far. It’s a perfectly reasonable conversational gambit….but if the answer is no, you move on without any further questions on the topic. Same to “are you married?” (a single friend of mine is sick of being grilled as to “why not?”; as he actually said to someone once, there isn’t likely to be a happy answer to that question of “why not?”, so definitely better not to ask it!).

Clickta · 10/11/2022 07:45

I started a new job in 2021, where I work closely with around 30 staff, depending on day/shift.

20 women and 10 men.

Of these, all the women asked me if I had children. Only 1 man asked.

Each time I had to explain that I wanted children but medically, I can't. Because I sadly couldn't just say 'mind your own!' To colleagues. And then I'd get an onslaught of their anecdotes about fertility, always ending with 'you could always adopt!' Like adopting a poor, traumatised child is an easy solution for my infertility. It's not.

By the last woman, I had lost all my barriers and I just sobbed. I looked a right mess.

The question 'so, do you have kids?' is so heavily loaded with pain, and then THEY have the nerve to be uncomfortable and you end up reassuring them!

Strangely enough the one guy that asked apologised profusely, and said he shouldn't have asked and would never ask anyone again.

It's really not an acceptable question to ask, please don't ask! If someone has kids you'll gather that anyway as you get to know someone, as they'll bring their kids up in conversation.

And yes, 100% everyone judges, you can SEE them thinking 'I wonder why...'

Pipsquiggle · 10/11/2022 07:27

The people who have asked me 'when are you going to have a baby?' or 'when are you going to have another baby?' have usually, to my knowledge, never had any trouble conceiving & /or haven't had a MC. They are tone deaf when it comes to this sort of stuff.

When people were asking if I was going to go for a third DC I just said 'No because I don't want to have a 5th MC' that soon shut them up.

BosaNova · 10/11/2022 07:27

rudebanana · 10/11/2022 00:27

I’m reading the comments and thinking the same!

OP although this is an anonymous forum you won’t get a lot admitting to being judgemental.

Trust me they are out there, I’ve experienced it and heard it all.

These are some of the things that have been said to me by strangers, friends, family (never to my husband though)
“Oh really no kids, why not? Don’t you think that’s selfish? What is wrong with you? We are women, women are meant to be mothers. Your parents must be so disappointed. I thought like you once, but as soon as I held my baby, my life had meaning and purpose”

It's enough to go on threads asking why someone chose not to have kids.
The best is the question "erm but who will take care of you when old?" On a site full on NC with parents 😂😂😂

kavalkada · 10/11/2022 07:27

No judgement on my side, and I would never ask. In fact, I have high respect for women and men who have decided not to have children because they know that kind of life is not for them. I judge people who had children and never should have had them in first place, my parents first.

BosaNova · 10/11/2022 07:24

Puffalicious · 09/11/2022 23:42

My point is I would never, ever do this. But the OP seems to be implying that I can't even have a fleeting thought/ wonder if it's choice or infertility because even then a woman will feel judged when I DON'T verbalise it. Fuck that- i can't control thoughts, nor am I going to.

I say this with the background of a sister with infertility and 2 close family members choosing not to have children.

No they don't 😐

Katkincake · 10/11/2022 07:17

Absolutely no judgement or even internal wonderings on it.
From my best friends from school I’m the only one with a child. My work circle of friends is 50:50, as is my wider circle of friends I’ve met through life.

I didn’t have my DS until 38, so was subject to the questions. At the time of asking I was on the fence about having kids and my life could have gone either way, so didn’t really know how to answer. I didn’t take it as judgement though, just people’s curiosity in wanting to get to know more about people.

Fairyliz · 10/11/2022 07:12

I don’t think anything because like 99% of the population I am self absorbed, so my brain is fully engaged with thinking about me and my life.

TartanGirl1 · 10/11/2022 07:09

If someone is judgemental of a woman that doesn't have children they need to take a long hard look at themselves. Having children is not the only life option. And are you also judging the men?

What even is there to judge?

AgentJohnson · 10/11/2022 07:01

Depending on the circumstances, I am more likely to judge women with kids then those without and I have a child. Married women without kids, couldn’t care less.

Thepeopleversuswork · 10/11/2022 06:57

Are people really this small minded and prurient?

FootfallFootball · 10/11/2022 06:45

Good to know how people think.

rudebanana · 10/11/2022 00:27

BosaNova · 09/11/2022 22:04

I like the outrage at the idea someone might judge childfree women😂 Like if that's not common thing.

I’m reading the comments and thinking the same!

OP although this is an anonymous forum you won’t get a lot admitting to being judgemental.

Trust me they are out there, I’ve experienced it and heard it all.

These are some of the things that have been said to me by strangers, friends, family (never to my husband though)
“Oh really no kids, why not? Don’t you think that’s selfish? What is wrong with you? We are women, women are meant to be mothers. Your parents must be so disappointed. I thought like you once, but as soon as I held my baby, my life had meaning and purpose”

Cw112 · 10/11/2022 00:20

Hillrunning · 09/11/2022 22:13

Bit being nosey isn't being judgemental. Judgement requires them to ask, hear your answer (if you choose to give it) and then view you as inferior based on your answer. Lots of people are nosey, and that is rude but it isn't judgemental.

Surely the two go hand in hand though? Like are you not being nosey because you are having some thoughts on the matter? I remember going to a wedding a week after we got married and the two of us being interrogated by the women we were sitting with who we had never met before about when we would have children and had we started trying etc etc etc and at that point we'd only been married a week so we hadnt decided yet but it was super uncomfortable. The thing that really surprised me was that two of the girls asking had really struggled ttc so I wouldn't have expected that from them. I definitely felt judged even if they were just "being nosey"

KimberleyClark · 09/11/2022 23:47

I think if you have struggled with infertility, as I have and remain childless, it is natural to wonder if they are in the same situation as you are, as infertility can be very lonely.

Puffalicious · 09/11/2022 23:42

Alvinne · 09/11/2022 22:30

People can think what they like, its the verbalising of those thoughts to people who don't have children and asking prying questions to satisfy curiosity that can be hurtful and uncessary. Not saying you do this, but people do, often.

My point is I would never, ever do this. But the OP seems to be implying that I can't even have a fleeting thought/ wonder if it's choice or infertility because even then a woman will feel judged when I DON'T verbalise it. Fuck that- i can't control thoughts, nor am I going to.

I say this with the background of a sister with infertility and 2 close family members choosing not to have children.

Cw112 · 09/11/2022 23:23

E - just figure it's absolutely none of my business and if they wanted me to know about it they'd tell me themselves.

Swipe left for the next trending thread