Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Be honest: Do you judge married women without kids?

309 replies

oxymomon · 09/11/2022 21:24

When you meet a woman who has been married for years, and doesn't have children, do you (A) make assumptions about why they don't have children; (B) ask them why they don't have children (feel it's your place to seek answers); (C) judge them for not having children; (D) all of the above; or (E) none of the above? Be honest. What do you really think...

OP posts:
Ducksinthebath · 10/11/2022 17:39

I’ve been a regular recipient of what I like to call the ‘double judge’: the immediate assumption that you didn’t or couldn’t procreate and therefore focussed on becoming wildly successful and wealthy, then absolute bafflement or even disgust that you’re not as successful or wealthy as they assumed you’d be.

There are more than two modes of how to be a woman.

mamabear715 · 10/11/2022 16:51

I think it's none of my damn business!

Wishimaywishimight · 10/11/2022 16:50

What would you be judging them for though? Surely to 'judge' someone implies you think they have something wrong?

As for the question "Do you have children?", surely it's just small talk, I don't consider it terribly intrusive. Doesn't bother me in the slightest. I just answer "No. You?" I don't get offended. I might slightly hope they don't want to show me lots of photos but really I don't mind other people chatting about their kids.

phoenixrosehere · 10/11/2022 16:40

E None of the above.

I never actually thought to ask why because it’s none of my business and not for me to know nor do I feel the need to know.

DucklingDaisy · 10/11/2022 16:39

Don’t judge. May wonder in passing if it’s through choice or fertility issues, but I wouldn’t think about it for more than a moment.

Wishimaywishimight · 10/11/2022 16:39

I'm one of them so no I'd never judge!

SnackyOnassis · 10/11/2022 16:35

oxymomon · 09/11/2022 22:13

Thank you for being honest about the fact that you make assumptions. Your post was very helpful, as you came to a self-realisation about how making assumptions is no better than some of the other behaviours. Life is a learning opportunity though. It takes a big person to reflect on their past behaviours and realise that it's time to change them. Thank you for your self-awareness and honesty

Thank you too for such an interesting prompt - I appreciate the opportunity to reflect and hopefully grow a bit. As you've said, life is (hopefully) long and learning is continuous!

KimberleyClark · 10/11/2022 11:45

I’m childfree and have been for a long time, but then became infertile after a lifesaving total hysterectomy. One of my colleagues at the time got herself into a total state about it, initially asking if I’d already had kids, then realising that meant I’d never have them, and before I could stop her she started crying and saying if it was a choice between death and her kids she’d rather die.

I wanted children but couldn't have them. If it came to a choice between having children and dying or not having them and living I would choose to live.

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 10/11/2022 11:19

Fairyliz · 10/11/2022 07:12

I don’t think anything because like 99% of the population I am self absorbed, so my brain is fully engaged with thinking about me and my life.

This didn't occur to me until someone else articulated it but you are right. It's a thing I told myself often when in a particularly painful, awkward situation at work. I irrationality felt as though people were judging me, and just wanted to spend my time hiding in a corner. But of for the most part, of course, nobody gave a stuff as they were too busy getting on with their own lives and work to give more than a throwaway thought to me.

It's a truth I find oddly comforting reassuring and comforting. And it applies just as much to me as the next person.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 10/11/2022 11:15

I don’t really think anything about it! Same as for married men without kids.

If I know them well it might end up being relevant to a conversation etc but otherwise it’s nothing to do with me.

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 10/11/2022 11:07

Hit 'enter' too soon.

We struggled for a decade to have our one child. Infertility is truly painful, repeated miscarriages agonizing - each one being worse than the last as it represents more and more lost hopes. If others don't have children it might be wholly their choice, or they might be desperate for a family and unable to have one. If so, I know how that feels as I was very likely to end up one of them.

I never ask if someone has children: man or woman. If they replied 'no' it would be a bit of a conversation staller, and pressing further by asking why is just unthinkable.

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 10/11/2022 11:00

None of my damned business. No, I don't 'judge'. As for going as far as to ask, that would take a special kind of insensitive idiot.

Is it society's place judge the married men without children too? Or is it (as ever) just women who come in for this unenviable lot?

rudebanana · 10/11/2022 10:58

Username7853377 · 10/11/2022 08:37

I'm childfree by choice.

I don't mind being asked whether I have children or not - in my opinion, that's a fairly neutral question to be asked.

I hate being asked if I want children or if I think I'll have them. This is incredibly invasive. There's a myriad of reasons why I don't have children and it's absolutely no one else's business.

I don't think I've ever been asked why I don't have children - I think I'd be too stunned to answer if someone asked that.

Actually now that I think about it I don’t mind being asked. It’s all the ‘but but, what about’ that comes after my no.

I’ll never have a good enough answer for the judgey ones and so have started asking back why did you have kids. It’s only been twice mind, but one answer was well that’s what people do and the second was a similar answer but more due to her age (late 30’s).

HerMajestysRoyalCoven · 10/11/2022 10:52

Clickta · 10/11/2022 07:45

I started a new job in 2021, where I work closely with around 30 staff, depending on day/shift.

20 women and 10 men.

Of these, all the women asked me if I had children. Only 1 man asked.

Each time I had to explain that I wanted children but medically, I can't. Because I sadly couldn't just say 'mind your own!' To colleagues. And then I'd get an onslaught of their anecdotes about fertility, always ending with 'you could always adopt!' Like adopting a poor, traumatised child is an easy solution for my infertility. It's not.

By the last woman, I had lost all my barriers and I just sobbed. I looked a right mess.

The question 'so, do you have kids?' is so heavily loaded with pain, and then THEY have the nerve to be uncomfortable and you end up reassuring them!

Strangely enough the one guy that asked apologised profusely, and said he shouldn't have asked and would never ask anyone again.

It's really not an acceptable question to ask, please don't ask! If someone has kids you'll gather that anyway as you get to know someone, as they'll bring their kids up in conversation.

And yes, 100% everyone judges, you can SEE them thinking 'I wonder why...'

That is awful, I’m so sorry.

I’m childfree and have been for a long time, but then became infertile after a lifesaving total hysterectomy. One of my colleagues at the time got herself into a total state about it, initially asking if I’d already had kids, then realising that meant I’d never have them, and before I could stop her she started crying and saying if it was a choice between death and her kids she’d rather die.

I distinctly remember just thinking, this woman is pranking me. This isn’t happening. I said that this was totally inappropriate and I’d like to talk about something else, and then two OTHER colleagues turned around and said her reaction was entirely understandable for a mother, and started comforting her!

I don’t work there anymore, thank God. This is an extreme example but people are really, really inappropriate about this. This thread is not a reflection of real life at all!

Alaimo · 10/11/2022 10:39

I'm childfree by choice. No-one ever asks me about kids, I assume out of concern that my childfree life is not by choice. I don't think I am super vocal about my choice, but I am happy to talk about it, primarily to signal I am not upset or traumatised by my lack of children and that people do not have to tiptoe around the subject out of fear of causing upset. I have a few colleagues who are also childfree by choice and I appreciate that they talked openly about their choice when I was younger, it helped normalise it for me.

Oh and as a married woman without kids of course I don't judge others in the same situation. I do sometimes wonder if others are childfree by choice or not, but I'd never ask.

billy1966 · 10/11/2022 10:13

Nope. Don't judge at all.

I may secretly admire them.

The ones I know look fab for their age and live great full lives.

A dear friend of mines daughter is going through a difficult pregnancy which suddenly became very complicated and she is stressed out of her mind over it.

There is no end to the worry when you have children and I am only half way there and feel increasingly exhausted by it all.

Having 4 children relatively late in life is not something I would recommend, no matter how much you will adore them.

Untitledsquatboulder · 10/11/2022 10:02

A. I'd assume that they didn't want children or couldn't have them. I doubt I'd give it much thought tbh.

Kokapetl · 10/11/2022 09:52

I'd wonder but wouldn't ask. Most people I know who are childfree by choice are fairly vocal about it. And to be honest I feel solid respect for those choosing that way as it shows self-knowledge and self-confidence, and it is of course better for the environment to not have kids. They in return seem fine with my choice to have kids. I have lovely friends and family!

I always really wanted kids so have them and I feel very lucky that we had no major problems with conceiving/pregnancy.

Hollyhocksarenotmessy · 10/11/2022 09:46

E and don't even wonder about it. I'm not that interested in random people. Also know plenty of women without children so its perfectly normal to me. I've never viewed motherhood as an automatic or key part of women's lives.

Fimofriend · 10/11/2022 09:35

No. I judge people who have kids and then neglect them.
I am related to two women who both had kids without actually wanting them. One to get her DH to stop working abroad. The other one because she had gotten married and it was expected. But it was obvious that neither of them didn't actually like kids. All of the resulting kids are damaged emotionally.

BosaNova · 10/11/2022 09:26

Why just the woman? It takes two to have a baby you know.

My DH never reported being told he doesn't know what real love is and being asked "but who will take care of you when you are old?". I once even got "but what if you split up you will be alone"...

There is normal asking, especially since his culture is quite family oriented and most his mates have children, if not all actually, and then there is the above only I got🙄

It is mainly women problem with being judged for any and all decisions we make about our egg use🤷🏻

TartanGirl1 · 10/11/2022 09:24

KimberleyClark · 10/11/2022 08:48

I remember once when I’d been married about four years a colleague asking “any sign of a family yet?” I told her we’d been having fertility issues and she was absolutely mortified and apologised profusely for having asked.

I find the term family odd in this situation.

When I started my current job I went for lunch with some new colleagues and they asked if I had family. They meant children but even if I didn't I still have a family.

Sausagenbacon · 10/11/2022 09:24

what a strange post.
especially this Do you think that a woman could perhaps be able to sense that another person wonders why? Might that very sense, make a woman "feel" judged. . Well, maybe, maybe not. What's the point of thinking that way?

Plus the OP has taken the one or two responses from people who say they have been questioned, to say 'look, it happens'.

Like most people, I think it's none of my business. I would like the OP to come back and tell us her thinking behind it.

TerrysGotPeeves · 10/11/2022 09:15

@Clickta , fucking hell, are you me?

"then THEY have the nerve to be uncomfortable and you end up reassuring them!"

Yes. I've had this with my own bloody sister. When discussing the fact that I can't have children (a topic brought up by my sister, I never bring it up because it makes people so uncomfortable) she cried, said how great a Mum I'd be, how sad it made her, and I ended up rubbing her back while she sobbed into my shoulder. And minimising my own pain and saying, no it's fine, no we're not too upset, oh think of all the freedom we'll have.

Which is absolute nonsense, we have several family members who are very dependant on us, so very little freedom. The only break we've managed this year was two nights an hour from where we live, so we could get back quickly if necessary. So all the 'I'd be so jealous of their freedom' posters can fuck off. Freedom my arse. Yeah I'm feeling a bit cross.

And for the poster who said "I'd congratulate them". Please don't ever do this. Why the fuck would you?

KimberleyClark · 10/11/2022 08:48

I remember once when I’d been married about four years a colleague asking “any sign of a family yet?” I told her we’d been having fertility issues and she was absolutely mortified and apologised profusely for having asked.

Swipe left for the next trending thread