Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Be honest: Do you judge married women without kids?

309 replies

oxymomon · 09/11/2022 21:24

When you meet a woman who has been married for years, and doesn't have children, do you (A) make assumptions about why they don't have children; (B) ask them why they don't have children (feel it's your place to seek answers); (C) judge them for not having children; (D) all of the above; or (E) none of the above? Be honest. What do you really think...

OP posts:
FirewomanSam · 11/11/2022 18:36

I sometimes wish there was more nuance in the conversation.

I don’t have kids and almost certainly won’t be having them and it feels like I either have to tell people I really don’t want them, or I have to have some painful backstory about multiple rounds of IVF and an aching longing for kids that will never be fulfilled.

I feel like there isn’t room in the conversation for people like me where the answer is something like ‘tried for a bit, didn’t happen, decided not to do IVF as I knew it wouldn’t be good for me mentally, made my peace with it, feeling pretty OK about it, sometimes I have the odd day where I wonder about it but mostly I’m quite happy, think I’m going to have quite a nice life actually’. I’ve said something along those lines before and for people their brains just don’t seem to be able to compute it. Either you must hate kids or you must be really devastated about it and you’re hiding it.

oxymomon · 11/11/2022 18:31

Charcy · 09/11/2022 21:39

What do YOU think OP?

Currently with my child wailing in my ear, I'd think "you sensible folk" but I genuinely wouldn't give it a 2nd thought.

But I also don't judge people who rent instead of buy, or what they do for a living etc.

I think that my starting this thread, and positioning it as a survey rather than instantly sharing my own experiences as a childless married woman highlighted that perhaps some education is needed?
I like to think that most people don't realise their comments are hurtful. But I hope that some people have read this trail, and they might have learned something.
Sadly, I couldn't have expected that Jennifer Aniston article to be published just after I posted my OP. The response to that shows that the challenge is perhaps worse than I thought. A lot of work is needed to change some deeply engrained societal norms.
My final thoughts:

  1. It is not great to ask if someone has kids, but I fully recognise that most people think they are just making small talk. So I'd usually put this down to naivety.
  2. It is awful to go prying. You never know what somebody has been through. There are countless reasons why someone might be childless. Countless!
  3. So don't make assumptions either, as they are probably wrong. Please refer to point 2 above, about there being countless reasons!
  4. People are usually self-obsessed (the poster who made that point was right). But that begs the question: if people don't have time to think about other people's lives, then why have so many people on this trail admitted to (a) wondering, (b) making assumptions, and (c) asking? Could it be because they are judging, but perhaps not admitting that to even themselves? Because we really only wonder about things we have an opinion on.
  5. It is so hurtful to say things like "That's such a shame, because your DH would make such a great Dad" (I've had that), or "Who will look after you when you grow old" (I've had that ... and I do wonder .... is that not a very selfish reason to bring kids into this world?!).
  6. It is not okay to print out articles on IVF and hand them, unasked for, to someone (yes, that happened).
  7. And, for goodness sake people ... stop comparing children to dogs! If I had a penny for every time somebody asked me: "Would you think of getting a dog?".
Be honest: Do you judge married women without kids?
OP posts:
oxymomon · 11/11/2022 18:12

Changingplace · 09/11/2022 21:35

What about a married man with no kids OP? Would you ‘judge’ him or just the women?

What an utterly bizarre concept, judge them on what? Their ability or not to reproduce? Their reasons (or not) for that?

Your post makes very little sense whatsoever.

Ah, another person who made assumptions about who I am? My Mumsnet name is like a no-smoking sign on your cigarette break. But it's a very interesting question you pose. I have received so many negative comments, and my husband very few. He is also a married person without children. But, in my extensive experience, the judgement falls on me, not him...

OP posts:
oxymomon · 11/11/2022 18:10

TheLovleyChebbyMcGee · 09/11/2022 21:31

E. What a nasty post of course I wouldn't judge married, childless women. How odd!

Is the post nasty, or is the behaviour nasty? Because this thread, along with the other one about Jennifer Aniston confirms that this does happen. Oh, and I guess you're another person who made assumptions about who I am? My handle, and the fact that I'm on "Mums"net is like a traffic jam when you're already late...

OP posts:
oxymomon · 11/11/2022 18:08

determinedtomakethiswork · 09/11/2022 21:27

You sound insane? Why would anybody judge someone who doesn't have children? It's not compulsory!

I think it's interesting that so many readers made assumptions about me as the OP. Did you assume I was a mother? Perhaps after a few of my comments, it dawned on people that I'm not. I'm a childless married person. My username is like ten thousand spoons when all you need is a fork. And no, I'm not insane. I'm hurt. I'm hurt after experiencing all of the options myself. But instead of posting that, I posted it as a survey. And assumptions about me as an anonymous poster were made. But this trail, and the coincidence with the Jen Aniston article coming out a a couple of days later, have shown that I am not alone in the hurtful comments, intrusive prying, and judgement I've received. To those who don't realise that you are doing these to others, perhaps reading some of the comments on this thread will help you take some learnings on board?

OP posts:
HerMajestysRoyalCoven · 11/11/2022 16:18

IncompleteSenten · 11/11/2022 16:12

Seriously?
Didn't she say she tried IVF?
So people are judging her for not being able to conceive?

Going to go have a look, see if that's what they are saying.

They’re saying she didn’t care enough to start early enough, or that she didn’t commit to IVF because posters saw a picture of her drinking and shooting films, or that she actually is lying about ever having IVF.

The conversation has also gone wider. Apparently too many women are claiming to have missed out through bad luck when they just didn’t get organised enough to have kids in their 20s, and that those who weren’t lucky enough to do so probably have personality problems. It’s charming.

(Trigger warning, the thread includes a lot of discussion of whether Brad Pitt is an abuser or it’s all Angie’d fault, because of course it does.)

IncompleteSenten · 11/11/2022 16:12

Seriously?
Didn't she say she tried IVF?
So people are judging her for not being able to conceive?

Going to go have a look, see if that's what they are saying.

HerMajestysRoyalCoven · 11/11/2022 16:03

I hope everyone expressing astonishment that this happens is reading the thread on Jennifer Aniston. 16 pages of judging her for not having kids, so far.

Differentaround · 11/11/2022 14:29

I had just had my second consecutive miscarriage and was asked by a girlfriend of a family member if I was planning a second, but she didn’t stop there, she then went on to say ‘I say this gently, but at 35 you need to be getting a move on’ I cried inside and wanted the ground to swallow me up. I wish I’d said something ag the time but was too shell shocked, the odd this is this lady is child free by choice and is always moaning and complaining about how everyone else asks her and how it’s annoying - yet she does it to other people constantly! 🙈

RoseAndGeranium · 11/11/2022 14:22

@MRSDoos Congratulations! So pleased for you. Hope you have a lovely, happy pregnancy.

MRSDoos · 11/11/2022 14:20

@RoseAndGeranium thank you x currently 14 weeks pregnant 🌈

RoseAndGeranium · 11/11/2022 14:17

@MRSDoos They really are. Hope things are better for you now. 💐

MRSDoos · 11/11/2022 14:14

@RoseAndGeranium my dad asked me a month after my miscarriage “when are you finally giving me a grandchild!”

people are very insensitive

RoseAndGeranium · 11/11/2022 14:11

MRSDoos · 11/11/2022 14:06

We had a lot of people ask us when we were having children straight after we got married and some on our wedding evening…

We had lost twins 3 weeks prior to our wedding day 😞

I’m so sorry. I was asked by a male family member when we were going to have our second whilst in the middle of my second consecutive miscarriage. It’s awful and I don’t know why people do it.

MRSDoos · 11/11/2022 14:06

We had a lot of people ask us when we were having children straight after we got married and some on our wedding evening…

We had lost twins 3 weeks prior to our wedding day 😞

SleepingStandingUp · 11/11/2022 13:49

Choconut · 11/11/2022 13:43

I wouldn't make any negative judgement, but I have asked people before if they wanted to have kids.

And how do you react if one says "yes, but we've been trying for 10 years, I've just had my 5th miscarriage last week and we can't afford any more IVF" and bursts into tears? Because unless you're close enough to take all that on and support her, you shouldn't be asking

KimberleyClark · 11/11/2022 13:46

Choconut · 11/11/2022 13:43

I wouldn't make any negative judgement, but I have asked people before if they wanted to have kids.

Why? It’s none of your business.

Choconut · 11/11/2022 13:43

I wouldn't make any negative judgement, but I have asked people before if they wanted to have kids.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 11/11/2022 13:35

I remember once when I’d been married about four years a colleague asking “any sign of a family yet?”

My record was six weeks.

MaryShelley1818 · 11/11/2022 13:32

It genuinely wouldn't cross my mind.

IncompleteSenten · 11/11/2022 13:30

I don't give a shit who has kids and who doesn't.

SleeplessInEngland · 11/11/2022 12:26

Rightly or wrongly I'd assume they didn't want any. And I'd obviously never ask.

OP83 · 11/11/2022 12:24

I judge people who have kids they clearly didn't want or don't bother to raise correctly FAR more than someone childless (married or otherwise).

I see so many people day-to-day who clearly aren't suited to being parents (I don't mean struggling, I mean actively negligent, disinterested and selfish) and really SHOULDN'T have had children that I have a great respect for anyone who decides it isn't for them.

I have never wanted, nor do I have children of my own (I'm a step-parent which I wanted to do a decent job at hence my presence here). I have always felt this way and it would be unfair of me to have children just because it's the 'done thing' if I didn't TRULY want them.

EmeraldShamrock1 · 11/11/2022 11:38

No.

If I felt anything it would be tinges of jealousy.

KimberleyClark · 11/11/2022 11:37

rudebanana · 11/11/2022 11:32

Oh my god yes this!! So you chose not have children but you’re just an assistant?? Well you must be a wonderful homemaker (🤢) then.....no we live on salads or take always and I get someone once a month to do a deep clean. The shock and horror! What is your purpose in life then?? Yes this has been said to me 😂

Many many years ago DH received a two year contract to work in his home country. It is a popular island tourist destination so of course I was going with!! I struggled to find a job but did lots of volunteering as like many popular holiday spots most of the citizens don’t benefit. Anyway my mother said well seeing as I won’t be doing anything for a couple years I might as well have a baby. Give me something to do....

Yes there is this assumption that if you don’t have kids you should be doing something amazing instead like walking up Kilimanjaro for charity or being a mega successful business woman. Anything other than quietly living your life.