Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Be honest: Do you judge married women without kids?

309 replies

oxymomon · 09/11/2022 21:24

When you meet a woman who has been married for years, and doesn't have children, do you (A) make assumptions about why they don't have children; (B) ask them why they don't have children (feel it's your place to seek answers); (C) judge them for not having children; (D) all of the above; or (E) none of the above? Be honest. What do you really think...

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
MarriedAlmost60NoKids · 29/11/2022 05:03

I'm sorry to everyone who is posting that they are dealing with rude, snoopy people. My best advice is to come up with one terse, direct response. I like "I can't imagine why you think that's any of your concern" and say it like you are shocked that anyone would be so ill-mannered as to not know basic rules of social interaction (think Lady
Violet in Downton Abbey). Practice in the mirror. Stone cold. Don't be upset, don't be emotional, don't be irked. Just be sub-zero, arctic- permafrost, stone-cold. Deliver the line, say "Excuse me" and walk away. Shut that shit down. You don't owe anyone anything and every one of you is too good for that nonsense. Deliver that line like a boss once or twice in public and word will get around. I leave it there, but I've seen people go straight to a good friend/confederate, start a quiet conversation and the confederate made a shocked face and said something a little loudly like "Oh how rude." Didn't say anything else (could have been talking about anyone) and the snoopy person slunk away.

Hungoverandashamed · 14/11/2022 16:28

If I thought anything and it's a big 'if' it would be a fleeting "I hope it was a choice"

KimberleyClark · 14/11/2022 16:20

user1477391263 · 14/11/2022 00:57

"Either you must hate kids or you must be really devastated about it and you’re hiding it."

This is so true. There is a big grey area when it comes to not having children. I know several women who would have been open to having kids but didn't find the right person and other things didn't work out, or they married late and had a go but things didn't work out, and in both cases, they have said they are broadly at peace with all this, so I believe them. It's not a clear-cut division between the ChildfreeByChoice crowd and the women who did everything to conceive and are silently grieving about it.

I couldn’t agree more. I couldn’t conceive but life has otherwise really worked out quite well for me. I ‘m not sad.

user1477391263 · 14/11/2022 00:57

"Either you must hate kids or you must be really devastated about it and you’re hiding it."

This is so true. There is a big grey area when it comes to not having children. I know several women who would have been open to having kids but didn't find the right person and other things didn't work out, or they married late and had a go but things didn't work out, and in both cases, they have said they are broadly at peace with all this, so I believe them. It's not a clear-cut division between the ChildfreeByChoice crowd and the women who did everything to conceive and are silently grieving about it.

user1477391263 · 14/11/2022 00:54

I don't ask questions unless they volunteer the information. If you get to know someone well, it's fine to ask, I think (but they will usually have told you themselves, if you get to that point of intimacy).

Getting annoyed at people for wondering stuff in their own head, is weird, though. I'm sure people wonder stuff about me all the time ("Why did she marry into another country?" "Why did she have such a big gap between her two children?" etc.) That's OK. It's normal to privately wonder about other people. Just don't ask rude questions or questions where you might regret the answer.

PlinkPlonkFizz · 13/11/2022 23:54

I feel asking anyone, male or female, single or married about reproductive plans or decisions is awfully bad manners. I never asked my two closest friends who had no children. It's their business and I might wonder, but I definitely don't judge.

aseriesofstillimages · 13/11/2022 23:40

FirewomanSam · 11/11/2022 18:36

I sometimes wish there was more nuance in the conversation.

I don’t have kids and almost certainly won’t be having them and it feels like I either have to tell people I really don’t want them, or I have to have some painful backstory about multiple rounds of IVF and an aching longing for kids that will never be fulfilled.

I feel like there isn’t room in the conversation for people like me where the answer is something like ‘tried for a bit, didn’t happen, decided not to do IVF as I knew it wouldn’t be good for me mentally, made my peace with it, feeling pretty OK about it, sometimes I have the odd day where I wonder about it but mostly I’m quite happy, think I’m going to have quite a nice life actually’. I’ve said something along those lines before and for people their brains just don’t seem to be able to compute it. Either you must hate kids or you must be really devastated about it and you’re hiding it.

This is really interesting, I feel similarly.

Although people don’t tend to ask me about kids, it might be because I’m in a same sex relationship so children are less automatically assumed? (though in fact the majority of female same sex couples I know either have or are planning to have children).

Foxgluv · 12/11/2022 23:41

None. What is there to judge? I wouldn't judge and I wouldn't dream of asking.

RincewindsHat · 12/11/2022 22:51

A, I would assume it's either because they don't want children or just because things haven't worked out for the couple to have children. I wouldn't ask about it either way.

KikiniBamalamm · 12/11/2022 22:13

FirewomanSam · 11/11/2022 22:15

I think some people see it as a judgment on themselves, for some reason. I wouldn’t say I’ve had people be ‘upset’ with me exactly but I have had people get a little defensive and start telling me (unprompted) about how kids were more important to them
than a career, or how their kids are the centre of their world ‘but I suppose it’s not for everyone’ (with accompanying raised eyebrow). And I guess some people over-project and imagine not having had their own kids, and find that thought really upsetting?

Some people take you saying you don’t want children personally, like it’s a criticism of their life choices.

I do often think if someone reacts this way, they can’t be fully content in their choice as otherwise it wouldn’t bother them 🤷🏼‍♀️

KikiniBamalamm · 12/11/2022 22:10

SleepingStandingUp · 11/11/2022 13:49

And how do you react if one says "yes, but we've been trying for 10 years, I've just had my 5th miscarriage last week and we can't afford any more IVF" and bursts into tears? Because unless you're close enough to take all that on and support her, you shouldn't be asking

Hear hear!! 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻

Sewwhatmrmagpie · 12/11/2022 11:30

No I don’t. We’ve all got our own story. I work with a few married women past childbearing age with no kids, it’s none of my business. If they bring it up I listen but it’s not a conversation I would start

Although I might be curious because I like to hear people’s stories, but I am worldly enough to understand how painful this particular subject might be for them if it’s not a choice they have made. I also wouldn’t want to accidentally insinuate that they have failed somehow as that’s how it can come across.

wooismee · 12/11/2022 11:20

@PenNPeg Them: satisfied with answer

Yes I have experienced this. Some women only stop hounding me with questions when I make THEM feel better about MY choice. They have to have a valid reason they accept.

montysma1 · 12/11/2022 00:19

Why would anybody care?

Saracen · 12/11/2022 00:10

None of the above. I do wonder, but never in a million years would I ask.

I even have a couple of very close relatives who have never mentioned whether they'd hoped to have children or had chosen not to. And another couple of close relatives have told me in confidence the reason why they don't have children - it drives me mad to hear my DH making constant wrong assumptions about them which I can't correct; I just have to remind him that he doesn't actually know the situation.

Sometimeswinning · 12/11/2022 00:04

ViktoriaPlzen · 11/11/2022 19:02

I’ve recently started working with a colleague who’s married and doesn’t have children. I have no idea whether this is by choice or not - I wouldn’t dream of asking, it’s none of my business. And because I don’t know whether or not it’s by choice, I do make a conscious effort not to talk about my children very much at work. So for example if she asks me if I’ve had a nice weekend, I’d keep the conversation to what I’ve watched on tv or something, rather than bore her with the details of a trip to soft play.

You do what? Why do you do that? How patronising!

Sceptre86 · 11/11/2022 23:37

I would wonder but not ask.

FirewomanSam · 11/11/2022 22:15

mandlerparr · 11/11/2022 19:27

I have always wondered why anyone would get upset that a woman hasn't had children. I could see close family missing the grandchildren/cousins/nieces and nephews that may have been born, but actually being upset by it is a wonder to me.

I think some people see it as a judgment on themselves, for some reason. I wouldn’t say I’ve had people be ‘upset’ with me exactly but I have had people get a little defensive and start telling me (unprompted) about how kids were more important to them
than a career, or how their kids are the centre of their world ‘but I suppose it’s not for everyone’ (with accompanying raised eyebrow). And I guess some people over-project and imagine not having had their own kids, and find that thought really upsetting?

mandlerparr · 11/11/2022 19:27

I have always wondered why anyone would get upset that a woman hasn't had children. I could see close family missing the grandchildren/cousins/nieces and nephews that may have been born, but actually being upset by it is a wonder to me.

Pipsquiggle · 11/11/2022 19:21

I thought it was

"it's like 10,000 spoons when I needed a knife..."

PenNPeg · 11/11/2022 19:15

As childless woman in 40s I don't mind if you chat about your children. I'd think it weird if you didn't!

Cheesyfootballs01 · 11/11/2022 19:08

I’m more confused that you keep putting Alanis Morrisette quotes in your posts…. 🤔

ViktoriaPlzen · 11/11/2022 19:02

I’ve recently started working with a colleague who’s married and doesn’t have children. I have no idea whether this is by choice or not - I wouldn’t dream of asking, it’s none of my business. And because I don’t know whether or not it’s by choice, I do make a conscious effort not to talk about my children very much at work. So for example if she asks me if I’ve had a nice weekend, I’d keep the conversation to what I’ve watched on tv or something, rather than bore her with the details of a trip to soft play.

PenNPeg · 11/11/2022 18:55

Yep, I'm judged. For example on a flight I was having that general chat with the passenger next to me and said I was married, then the conversation went like this:
Them: Do you have children?
Me: No
Them: Why?
Me: I can't. I had two miscarriages and the surgeon accidentally destroyed my womb lining on the second one and I can't carry a baby. (Secondary judgement - people assume it was my fertility that caused the miscarriage - don't assume its the woman, but do assume we were sad and that I was and am mightily unhappy about the outcome).
Them: Have you considered adopting?
Me: Its something we've considered, but it would have been unfair to adopt. Working and caring for an elderly Mother meant that I simply couldn't have given a child the time needed. My Mother has recently died so maybe once we've re-grouped we'll look at adoption again.
Them: satisfied with answer and now comfortable chatting with me...
Me: ...would have been uncomfortable 5 years ago when it happened, but now resigned to having these types of conversations played out in public with many people listening in...

The bottom line is its not their fault and it won't change anything by me lashing out and scarring them with the details just because they didn't appreciate the full implications of what they were asking...its simply one of those sad moments in life and its best to look forward. I doubt we can afford a surrogate so maybe what I should be asking is should I be adopting in my mid 40s and a husband in his mid 50s?! And I am blessed to have a brill
iant husband.

Charcy · 11/11/2022 18:42

oxymomon · 11/11/2022 18:31

I think that my starting this thread, and positioning it as a survey rather than instantly sharing my own experiences as a childless married woman highlighted that perhaps some education is needed?
I like to think that most people don't realise their comments are hurtful. But I hope that some people have read this trail, and they might have learned something.
Sadly, I couldn't have expected that Jennifer Aniston article to be published just after I posted my OP. The response to that shows that the challenge is perhaps worse than I thought. A lot of work is needed to change some deeply engrained societal norms.
My final thoughts:

  1. It is not great to ask if someone has kids, but I fully recognise that most people think they are just making small talk. So I'd usually put this down to naivety.
  2. It is awful to go prying. You never know what somebody has been through. There are countless reasons why someone might be childless. Countless!
  3. So don't make assumptions either, as they are probably wrong. Please refer to point 2 above, about there being countless reasons!
  4. People are usually self-obsessed (the poster who made that point was right). But that begs the question: if people don't have time to think about other people's lives, then why have so many people on this trail admitted to (a) wondering, (b) making assumptions, and (c) asking? Could it be because they are judging, but perhaps not admitting that to even themselves? Because we really only wonder about things we have an opinion on.
  5. It is so hurtful to say things like "That's such a shame, because your DH would make such a great Dad" (I've had that), or "Who will look after you when you grow old" (I've had that ... and I do wonder .... is that not a very selfish reason to bring kids into this world?!).
  6. It is not okay to print out articles on IVF and hand them, unasked for, to someone (yes, that happened).
  7. And, for goodness sake people ... stop comparing children to dogs! If I had a penny for every time somebody asked me: "Would you think of getting a dog?".

Very well put. 👏