Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to not want to collaborate with annoying co-worker?

105 replies

russetmellow · 09/11/2022 20:45

My line manager invited expressions of interest from colleagues for an individual to undertake a specific project with a very fast turnaround. It's an area I've a lot of experience in (more than colleagues) and I'd love to do the project and could do it super-fast. I applied, outlining experience etc.

I got an email today saying two of us applied and as such what would I think of sharing the project? The other person is notoriously tricky and hasn't even 10% of the experience I do in the area - our line manager even indiscreetly described them as 'a very difficult person.' Think someone who gets very huffy if they feel overlooked, walks out in a temper at times etc. I haven't had to work very closely with them before but have seen how they behave and have been at the receiving end of their deeply intemperate behaviour.

I asked the line manager if we could split the task and they said 'well wouldn't you like to work as a team?' I said something along the lines of thinking it would be quickest to work individually - but let's see what the other person thinks.

AIBU to be a bit pissed off that the terms have changed from an individual taking on the project, and that if I have to work with this other person it's likely to take much longer and be trickier (due to their personality) than if I just did it alone? NB I work in a sector where individual projects are the absolute norm and I rarely if ever work as part of a team on this sort of thing. Any advice for how I can handle this?

OP posts:
russetmellow · 09/11/2022 23:53

LightDrizzle · 09/11/2022 23:41

I got an email today saying two of us applied and as such what would I think of sharing the project?

Managing people is a nightmare, instead of thinking about the question asked and delivering a diplomatic but honest and reasoned response, you fudged it and now it’s more complicated.

I’d email along the lines of: On reflection, the project sounds interesting and I’d be a good fit but in this instance I’d only be interested in taking full ownership. I’m happy working collaboratively but I think this specific project can be more efficiently managed by one person.

Ok thank you. I asked did LM think it could be split into two parts (i.e. both work independently), he said why not do it as teamwork, and I said that it would be quicker to do it independently and I'd get back to him to let him know once I'd thought about it - so maybe a slight fudge but I haven't agreed to anything yet.

OP posts:
LightDrizzle · 09/11/2022 23:41

I got an email today saying two of us applied and as such what would I think of sharing the project?

Managing people is a nightmare, instead of thinking about the question asked and delivering a diplomatic but honest and reasoned response, you fudged it and now it’s more complicated.

I’d email along the lines of: On reflection, the project sounds interesting and I’d be a good fit but in this instance I’d only be interested in taking full ownership. I’m happy working collaboratively but I think this specific project can be more efficiently managed by one person.

russetmellow · 09/11/2022 23:27

200degrees · 09/11/2022 23:22

I would also see it as a development opportunity, you can take the lead on the project and train them in something you’re already an expert in.

I was also recognised as a department wide expert in an area. My job was 100% more enjoyable when I stopped doing all the legwork myself and trained up other experts on each team/office. In the end my role was challenging guidance and creating guides to help walk people through the process

Tbh it’s not really something someone can be trained in quickly - and it won’t be known who took the lead. It’s similar to being a specialist trainer with this project being speccing out the actual contents of the training. I can imagine the other person putting something together after a fair amount of guesswork but they haven’t actually done that sort of work before and have no experience of actually delivering the thing that’s like specialist training whereas I have years of experience in it.

OP posts:
YourBestie · 09/11/2022 23:22

Nope. The other person sounds like a headache.

200degrees · 09/11/2022 23:22

I would also see it as a development opportunity, you can take the lead on the project and train them in something you’re already an expert in.

I was also recognised as a department wide expert in an area. My job was 100% more enjoyable when I stopped doing all the legwork myself and trained up other experts on each team/office. In the end my role was challenging guidance and creating guides to help walk people through the process

russetmellow · 09/11/2022 23:15

NeverDropYourMooncup · 09/11/2022 21:39

Maybe it'll look better for you if you do work with the colleague - promotion, perhaps?

After all, they'll know it'll get done whatever happens, because you can pull it together, but they'll also know that you can engage/bring around the other person - who might actually turn out to be quite good at it, by the way.

Then there will be two people who can do the job, which means it's less likely to always be put onto you and your previous experience, plus one who can manage/train others.

Thanks, that’s an interesting way of looking at it. I guess I’m not super keen to spend all the extra uncredited time on it but you’ve given me some food for thought!

OP posts:
russetmellow · 09/11/2022 23:12

decayingmatter · 09/11/2022 21:46

It sounds like all you stand to gain from this is time in lieu. Who cares about time in lieu, especially when co-working on this is clearly going to be a fucking nightmare. Your manager is weak and would rather appease the pain in the arse co-worker than actually manage. Withdraw, and see how the manager likes them apples.

i care about time in lieu a good deal (thought it’ll be split in half if the work is shared) as it frees me up to do something fairly pressing. I also care(d) about taking on this project as I want to be recognised as expert in this area - one of the reasons I don’t want to share it tbh as I spent so much time developing the expertise.

OP posts:
mermeration · 09/11/2022 22:08

russetmellow · 09/11/2022 20:45

My line manager invited expressions of interest from colleagues for an individual to undertake a specific project with a very fast turnaround. It's an area I've a lot of experience in (more than colleagues) and I'd love to do the project and could do it super-fast. I applied, outlining experience etc.

I got an email today saying two of us applied and as such what would I think of sharing the project? The other person is notoriously tricky and hasn't even 10% of the experience I do in the area - our line manager even indiscreetly described them as 'a very difficult person.' Think someone who gets very huffy if they feel overlooked, walks out in a temper at times etc. I haven't had to work very closely with them before but have seen how they behave and have been at the receiving end of their deeply intemperate behaviour.

I asked the line manager if we could split the task and they said 'well wouldn't you like to work as a team?' I said something along the lines of thinking it would be quickest to work individually - but let's see what the other person thinks.

AIBU to be a bit pissed off that the terms have changed from an individual taking on the project, and that if I have to work with this other person it's likely to take much longer and be trickier (due to their personality) than if I just did it alone? NB I work in a sector where individual projects are the absolute norm and I rarely if ever work as part of a team on this sort of thing. Any advice for how I can handle this?

The goal posts have changed. Your manager knows they're hard work or they wouldn't have asked you if you'd mind splitting it... they're the boss, they'd just go ahead under normal circumstances.

If this is going to stress you out withdraw your application.

There's been a man who annoys the hell out of me hot desking near my team lately.. he butts into conversation, tags along to social, overrides the conversation etc. i walk in of a morning and my heart sinks. Obviously I'm civil but if I didn't have to work with him I sure as hell wouldn't put myself forward for it!

Peekachoochoo · 09/11/2022 22:02

russetmellow · 09/11/2022 21:33

Yes - I think you're right, line manager doesn't want to say no to them due to not wanting to enrage them so now they've made it much more complicated and difficult for me. What a PITA! I haven't said yes or no yet but tbh w/o being cocky, I know if it was a properly competitive process between the two of us I'd be 99% more likely to be asked to do it - going on track record etc.

This is what I would do too.

I spent years fitting in and trying to do the right thing to my detriment. Now I don't bother making great statements, I just do what suits me. A huge part of this is actively avoiding people at work who make my life much harder than it needs to be. My life has improved ten fold.

decayingmatter · 09/11/2022 21:46

It sounds like all you stand to gain from this is time in lieu. Who cares about time in lieu, especially when co-working on this is clearly going to be a fucking nightmare. Your manager is weak and would rather appease the pain in the arse co-worker than actually manage. Withdraw, and see how the manager likes them apples.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 09/11/2022 21:39

Maybe it'll look better for you if you do work with the colleague - promotion, perhaps?

After all, they'll know it'll get done whatever happens, because you can pull it together, but they'll also know that you can engage/bring around the other person - who might actually turn out to be quite good at it, by the way.

Then there will be two people who can do the job, which means it's less likely to always be put onto you and your previous experience, plus one who can manage/train others.

russetmellow · 09/11/2022 21:33

Howyiz · 09/11/2022 21:29

This is exactly what I would do.
Due to the changing nature of the brief. I will withdraw my expression of interest.

Sounds like your manager doesn't want to have to say no to your colleague to avoid their bad behaviour and is happy to throw you to the lions for a quote life.

Yes - I think you're right, line manager doesn't want to say no to them due to not wanting to enrage them so now they've made it much more complicated and difficult for me. What a PITA! I haven't said yes or no yet but tbh w/o being cocky, I know if it was a properly competitive process between the two of us I'd be 99% more likely to be asked to do it - going on track record etc.

OP posts:
determinedtomakethiswork · 09/11/2022 21:29

I would just say, well, I have tons of experience in this and that person doesn't really have any. Now do you want me to spend the next few weeks training her or doing the actual job? You do realise I can work much quicker on my own unless I'm with someone who has equal skills.

Howyiz · 09/11/2022 21:29

Lokidottir · 09/11/2022 21:14

To be honest, I'd call their bluff and say you want to withdraw your application as you understood it to be an individual project, not collaborative and you don't have the time for the necessary meetings, etc that a group project requires. There's a risk they'll award it to the other person but given your experience, is it not likely that they'd backtrack and give it to you? Especially if the other person is going to need a lot of help.

This is exactly what I would do.
Due to the changing nature of the brief. I will withdraw my expression of interest.

Sounds like your manager doesn't want to have to say no to your colleague to avoid their bad behaviour and is happy to throw you to the lions for a quote life.

sheepandcaravan · 09/11/2022 21:24

I would just be factual.

Thanks for your response, happy to complete solo to deadlines with my training and background.

Excellent y is looking to contribute and learn. Happy to conduct a training session from this or have y on board as a training experience. Obviously that will slow the task and increase my hours.

russetmellow · 09/11/2022 21:22

Lokidottir · 09/11/2022 21:14

To be honest, I'd call their bluff and say you want to withdraw your application as you understood it to be an individual project, not collaborative and you don't have the time for the necessary meetings, etc that a group project requires. There's a risk they'll award it to the other person but given your experience, is it not likely that they'd backtrack and give it to you? Especially if the other person is going to need a lot of help.

Thanks - do you think that would make me the difficult one?! I'm sure it would make an enemy of the other person who applied and not sure I want any drama whatsoever. I'd much rather get my head down, get on with it and deliver...I get very very anxious about work-place conflicts

OP posts:
russetmellow · 09/11/2022 21:16

Thanks FinallyHere, I don't really want to move into management - I like what I do, and would like to use the experience I acquired in my previous role for this project - I haven't been able to use that experience directly before.
The tricky thing is that I've looked at my email just now and see that my line manager has written to the other person suggesting sharing the project and is waiting to see what they think.

OP posts:
AlisonDonut · 09/11/2022 21:15

I'd say 'name that tune' and let them get on with it.

then pick up the pieces when they fuck it up.

Lokidottir · 09/11/2022 21:14

To be honest, I'd call their bluff and say you want to withdraw your application as you understood it to be an individual project, not collaborative and you don't have the time for the necessary meetings, etc that a group project requires. There's a risk they'll award it to the other person but given your experience, is it not likely that they'd backtrack and give it to you? Especially if the other person is going to need a lot of help.

russetmellow · 09/11/2022 21:13

HuggsBosom · 09/11/2022 21:00

Could they be using you to develop this person?

That’s not what you signed up for.

Perhaps. And I'm a bit irked that they'd be relying on experience I built up over 3 years in a previous job. Maybe I'm being a bit churlish - but the key issue is not even about this person's difficult nature (I think I've done ok before working with tricky people) but that it will now take much longer and be more hassle because it involves working together.

OP posts:
FinallyHere · 09/11/2022 21:12

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 09/11/2022 20:58

I think it would not be unreasonable to say that you think the project would be completed more easily and efficiently by just one person, @russetmellow, and that’s how you’d prefer to do it.

I agree with this approach.

Is the priority to get the project completed to a good standard within stretching timescales or to collaborate in order to develop colleague.

These are not naturally complementary objectives.

I'd clarify which is more important. If getting it done is the priority, I'd be confident that I could do it and be open to doing providing some means of sharing the approach and key success points etc with the rest of the team.

If the development goals are more important I'd suggest that I was not the right person on lead on this, this time round.

This is based on my view of myself as a technical specialist so doesn't aspire to develop difficult colleagues. If I wanted to move into management I would need to grab this as an ideal opportunity to demonstrate my management skills

russetmellow · 09/11/2022 21:09

I haven't said I can't work with them (or anything to that effect, just asked if it might be split). The line manager will definitely not want us reporting milestones etc - they just want it done and delivered. It will be on top of work I'm already doing but I'll get time in lieu later on.

I don't know if they'll ride on my coat tails as such, I guess as they've less experience maybe I'd need to contribute more which I don't really mind doing. I suppose it's just I could have delivered it myself quickly and in my own time, but now it will turn into having to meet the other person frequently, reach consensus etc. It's the sort of project I did numerous times in a previous job which is why I'm confident I could turn it around relatively painlessly. The other person hasn't done a project like this before but is likely to have strong views on it nevertheless.

OP posts:
EgonsShell · 09/11/2022 21:09

If your line manager has already alluded to their difficult nature then I don't see you as outing yourself as someone that can't work with others. I'd push to do this one yourself - thereby "outing" yourself as someone that can get the job done!

Homewardbound2022 · 09/11/2022 21:02

Will this person just ride on your coat tails then take the plaudits for your work?

HuggsBosom · 09/11/2022 21:00

Could they be using you to develop this person?

That’s not what you signed up for.

Swipe left for the next trending thread