Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think DH is selfish to have night out and leave me alone with 3 week old newborn?

263 replies

Londonaries · 09/11/2022 19:01

My husband has just recovered from covid, me and my 3 week old caught covid from him, my newborn is thankfully better now after a worrying night of a fever and visit to the hospital. I am still unwell but slowly improving.

Husband wants to go out with his friend on Friday night after also being out the same afternoon for work and work drinks. AIBU to think that is just selfish to leave me at home with a less than 4 week old while he goes drinking and eating curry with his friend especially given the tricky week of covid we’ve had?

When did you ease up on DH having a social life after the arrival of a newborn?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
EsmeSusanOgg · 11/11/2022 13:41

Big hug OP. That sounds quite full on. Glad your DH has postponed the night out. I hope you and baby feel better soon. TBH, regardless of reason, if you have had a tough week and the night out is a nice to have not a big event planned ages in advance (wedding, big birthday etc.) then I think most supportive partners tend to postpone. I don't think that is unusual.

BigMama32 · 11/11/2022 13:36

Every family is different but at 3 weeks I was still suffering pretty bad and catheter still in situ, everything was painful. I don’t have any other births to compare to as it’s my first but if he had left me at three weeks I couldn’t have coped with a newborn without some respite in the evening.

I am still unwell

That says it all to me - YANBU

FindingMeno · 11/11/2022 13:34

Ignore all the control comments.
If a man isn't switched on enough to give his partner support when she needs it, there's nothing wrong with telling him he needs to help rather than asking him.
I can't imagine what it's like to have an easy newborn who just sleeps. Mine didn't.

toomuchlaundry · 11/11/2022 13:34

Glad your DH is being supportive @Londonaries , communication is really key especially in the early weeks. Try to rest when you can to build up your strength

Treemouser · 11/11/2022 13:32

It doesn't matter how other people would feel alone with a 3 week old. All newborns (and covid infections!) vary in intensity, if you need or want the support he should want to give it.

I think the rule should be the first night out goes to the mum, and then you take turns from there. If you're too knackered to go out yourself, you're too knackered for him to go out either. You're a team.

I wouldn't have considered leaving my wife and baby when he was 3 weeks old. They were both healthy and he had been easy but you don't know when they might change, and drinks would make it harder to contribute to childcare later.

I would have been happy for her to go out as I had not given birth/been breastfeeding and suffering the cumulative effects of three weeks of tiredness and physical recovery in the same way.

Heronwatcher · 11/11/2022 13:27

I’d have been fine with this, but would have asked him to take baby out for a few hours the next day so I could get a break. If I was still feeling ill then yes I might have asked him to leave earlier but probably would have tried to accommodate. My kids are older now but what my partner and I always try to do at the weekends or when we are on holiday is each have a dedicated slot of time when we can do our own thing without kids/ judgment, see friends, go for a walk, sit with a coffee, have a nap. It makes a real difference to our mental health and we’re both better parents/ partners for it. Obviously if your DH chooses Friday night though, he can’t then also choose all day Sat too or ruin your time out, it has to be equal.

PinkSyCo · 11/11/2022 13:21

Glad to hear that you and your DH have reached a compromise OP. Than God he is more supportive than half the women on here huh!

Londonaries · 11/11/2022 13:14

Thanks for everyone’s input. I didn’t expect such a huge response to this and clearly it is a bit divisive.

To answer some questions and fill in more details.

  • I am exclusively breastfeeding
  • My milk supply got ruined by being sick with Covid which has caused a very hungry and tired baby that deserves both his parents trying to do everything to help.
  • I say baby is 4weeks but I’m rounding up, he is still 3 weeks but I doubt that will change many responses anyway.
  • I am now recovering from Covid after being in bed for 3 days (though not sleeping obviously!)
  • DH is very supportive and has postponed night out until next week when things (post Covid and milk supply nightmare) are settled.

I have also learned that there is definitely a mixed bag of contributors on MN. Some that love to try to drag someone down. I know who are the type that I have time for and thank you for all the support and encouragement from the emotionally intelligent contributors and mums. 💕

OP posts:
xogossipgirlxo · 11/11/2022 13:12

I'd be rather disappointed that my husband needs to get out after only 3 weeks with newborn. Is this your first baby?

Londonaries · 11/11/2022 12:56

Mommabear20 · 09/11/2022 20:11

You sound very controlling. I feel sorry for your DH.

You sound triggered and judgmental with barely any information go on or a full understanding of circumstances, I feel equally sorry for you and yours. God bless you.

I know a lot of awesome momma bears and I’d say you don’t sound like one. I’d also say perhaps the handle momma troll probably suits better based on your insightful and maternally motivated response.

OP posts:
Londonaries · 11/11/2022 12:49

You sound triggered and judgmental with barely any information go on or a full understanding of circumstances, I feel equally sorry for you and yours. God bless you.

OP posts:
toomuchlaundry · 11/11/2022 07:28

But surely if OP is not in the position where she is fine, bearing in mind she was ill and baby had had to go into hospital, it’s quite reasonable to think she is not the I was back in the gym the when baby was 1 week old (I would probably have split my stomach muscles even more if I had tried that) person. And it’s fine if you were but surely you can find some empathy for someone who is struggling

notacooldad · 11/11/2022 07:18

seriously, at 4 weeks PP I was at my lowest point, I felt like I'd been split in two, I was a milking machine, sleep deprived, could barely put my own socks on and had a screaming newborn to look after too...it is absolutely selfish for him to go out for a 'night off' with his mate at this point!
And this is your expierence. As keeps getting pointed out, everyone is different.
At four weeks I was absolutely back to normal in many ways with Ds1. I was able to go back to the gym excatly one week after his birth. It probably wasnt my wisest move and I guess I wouldnt do it if I had my time again but I was fit and well and out walking every day. The only thing that bothered me was my boobs leaking every now and then. Ds1 was a dream and I wondered why I put off having babies as I expected a nightmare. You say it is absolutely sefish for the Dh to go out at this point but I was happy for mine to and he was happy for me to go out as well. It really is each to their own and weighing up what else is happeing. In my case it was fine, in other people's situation if they are struggling ,its not so fine.
There is no definitive answer that is going to suit everyone.

bippit · 11/11/2022 05:29

@GoodnightGentleBoris ah yes, I see on rereading that you explained that, sorry! nothing wrong with anecdata, although mine skews differently 🤷🏻‍♀️ Agree that newborn experiences vary wildly, and also that people can overreact in a variety of insane directions on mumsnet threads… 😉

PerrierIsMyFav · 11/11/2022 02:04

You are blessed to be your babies mum.
I ebf for years and hubs slept bc he worked to provide for our family.
Yup,including me raising our children and not strangers.
I see others sarcastically calling it martyrdom,ACTUALLY,WE ARE MEANT TO FEED OUR BABIES.
AND RAISE THEM.
Total of over 5 years feeding our precious babies.That was MY JOB and wouldn't have changed it for anything. I did what I was meant to do and loved doing it.
How sad imo when mother's don't want to be the ones to nourish and be there for their precious babies.
I read that mother's are worried about what nursing will do to their bodies....
Believe me,any stretch mark, or possible saginess (also happens w weight gain etc.) is absolutely worth it.
My precious hub appreciates all I've done for our kids,ages 22,20 and 18.
But he supports that I want a lift and small implants.
But we've been together since I was 17.
We mature,together. Remember no one is perfect.
So yes I may have stayed from the original question....Remember we are truly blessed in life,sometimes we need a reminder.

CloudybutMild · 11/11/2022 01:33

kirinm · 09/11/2022 20:36

You're a grown woman who uses the term 'hon'? You're an idiot to suggest someone is an incompetent mum because she has the temerity to want her partner to be at home with her newborn.

Or she is a competent mother. I’d say it’s likely to be the latter.

CloudybutMild · 11/11/2022 01:28

BestSelfBlah · 09/11/2022 19:32

This! with a covid cherry on top.

He should be at home pulling his weight.

My God Op, the "cool wife" is as toxic as the "cool girl". Don't fall for it, be honest and upfront about what you want and need.

I was back running three weeks after giving birth, and would have had no issue whatsoever with DH wanting a night out, so it’s definitely not a given that everyone suffers the same way.

I had a short night out myself in week four, while he stayed in taking care of the baby.

GoodnightGentleBoris · 11/11/2022 01:18

bippit · 10/11/2022 23:06

@GoodnightGentleBoris “most of us” seems like a statistical reach, doesn’t it? How would you know that? But either way that isn’t the context of this question, in which OP is clearly struggling. People aren’t saying “don’t worry, for most people having a newborn isn’t as hellish as all that, don’t be frightened” in order to reassure and encourage her. The tone is “having a newborn is easy and if you don’t think that YOU ARE PATHETIC”. Bizarre.

“Most of us” is “most of the people I know”, that’s how I know that….

Yes I agree the tone is off in some posts, but for some posts, the tone is also “having a newborn is impossible and the husband is a total arse to even suggest it” including one poster saying she’d line up her options if this was even floated; which is also an overreaction:

Either way, rhe OP hasn’t been back so perhaps we are all just bickering with each other now to no end 😉

feistymumma · 11/11/2022 01:16

Londonaries · 09/11/2022 19:19

To be clear I don't have a problem with my husband going out, he does what he wants and has december socials lined up already.. My question is specifically with the timing of this.

YANBU OP he should stay at home and look after both of you. There will always be other socials, more so that he is going to be out all day as well.

Winceybincey · 10/11/2022 23:32

As the Op hasn’t commented in a while I hope she’s logged out of mumsnet and isn’t reading these comments. Imagine becoming a new mum, struggling with covid and coming on mumsnet for some supportive advice and end up not only slaughtered and goaded, but accused of being abusive. I am saddened by this thread.

bippit · 10/11/2022 23:06

@GoodnightGentleBoris “most of us” seems like a statistical reach, doesn’t it? How would you know that? But either way that isn’t the context of this question, in which OP is clearly struggling. People aren’t saying “don’t worry, for most people having a newborn isn’t as hellish as all that, don’t be frightened” in order to reassure and encourage her. The tone is “having a newborn is easy and if you don’t think that YOU ARE PATHETIC”. Bizarre.

ping78 · 10/11/2022 21:44

My husband goes away for months at a time for work including when my baby was 3 weeks old for 9 weeks and I had a toddler. I still think your DH is being unreasonable though, those first 6 weeks are so tense and hard work (in my experience at least) my DH never would have gone on a night out during that stage. If it was for a special occasion stag do etc that's different. But something non urgent, he wouldn't have even tried.

Purplecatshopaholic · 10/11/2022 21:43

‘Ease up on’?! Controlling, much. It’s one evening out ffs.

toomuchlaundry · 10/11/2022 21:40

@GoodnightGentleBoris people are just giving their experience. OP is struggling and many posters instead of giving her support are telling her she is pretty much being pathetic as newborn babies are so easy. Whereas some of us are saying actually ours weren’t. I can remember sobbing hysterically in the bathroom wondering what the hell had we done, whilst poor DH was split between trying to look after me whilst comforting baby DS who was in another room crying and refusing to go to sleep. If DH had decided to go out with his mates that night not what state I would have been in when he got home. PND and non sleeping, forever hungry baby was not a good combination

Chesterdrawsseriously · 10/11/2022 21:16

LoveBluey · 10/11/2022 21:13

I think the point is he will have been at work all day and then go out so it's extending the amount of time she's alone with the baby.

Think we all get that lol. Cringing for you, how to miss the point 😂