Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

15 Minute Cities

37 replies

Buzzinwithbez · 09/11/2022 10:39

Has anyone come across this idea? I dismissed it as the usual mad out of touch WEF thought experiment, then came across this.
www.oxfordmail.co.uk/news/23073992.traffic-filters-will-divide-city-six-15-minute-neighbourhoods-agrees-highways-councillor/

Can you get most of your needs met within 15 minutes walk in your town/city? Are your public transport links good enough to get to places you need to be within 15 minutes?

What would be the reasons you would need to leave your area/town?
Many reasons for me. The biggest that might not be deemed a necessity would very sadly be the nature defecit I have within 15 minutes.

OP posts:
NewToWoo · 17/12/2022 01:11

We have lots of food shops, GP, pharmacy, primary school, park and open spaces, cafes, pubs and restaurants, train station all within 15 mins.

But no secondary school, library, hospital, cinema or theatre

JimSteen911 · 17/12/2022 01:09

No reasonable person is against planning a city with the 15 minute concept. Of course, that sounds lovely. But then again, this isn't what we're talking about. The fact that the majority of you didn't bother reading the literature on these plans is extremely disheartening.

JimSteen911 · 17/12/2022 01:05

You've missed it my friend. They've already publicly said they will limit the use of your private car. Everywhere you go will be catalogued and you will only have X amount of days or time to drive. You're going to have to register your vehicles with the council. You're going to have only so many days a year you can drive your vehicle. You will be fined otherwise. Make no mistake, this is authoritarian and our western countries have already shown their ability to cross the line on their own people. I fear you are misinformed brother. Im from the US - this doesn't affect me. This isn't just prudent city planning. This is in fact a new level of totalitarianism. Mark my words. It may take some time for this poisonous tree to bare its fruits. But it certainly will.

Devoutspoken · 07/12/2022 22:07

I think they're a great idea

Taswama · 07/12/2022 21:51

I live on the edge of a small city and have primary, secondary schools and also supermarket, barbers, hairdresser, cafe within 15 mins. GP is more like 20 mins walking but 10 on a bike. Swimming pool about 20 mins cycle. Gym 15 mins walk. Chemists at the GPs. My work is also a 20 minute cycle ride away.

@witheringrowan I read The death and life of American cities at the beginning of the year and loved it. The theatre in our city is moving from the edge of town into the centre and I'm wondering if this will lead to other businesses benefiting from the increase in people.

DuncanEnright · 07/12/2022 18:47

Oh - and the article about Oxford is a load of rubbish.

DuncanEnright · 07/12/2022 18:46

Good point. 15 minute cities are meant to make sure the essentials (bottle of milk, maybe a pint of beer, GP and pharmacy) are within 15 minutes from home, and not build new developments without insisting on this. I have seen some people say the aim is to limit people's travel to 15 minutes from home. That would be a nightmare - but I am certain that isn't what is meant by the planners and governments (at least in Western countries).

It would be good to make sure new housing developments have a proper community centre and shops. Too often they don't.

caroleanboneparte · 11/11/2022 08:44

I like the concept of 15 min cities. They should be the norm. Local high streets should be encouraged. Small local businesses should be subsidised with lower rates etc.

But dictating to people like this smacks of ghettoisation. Keep the poor people in poor neighbourhoods which are often food deserts. Let naice areas with the swish boutique charity shops, delis, artisan bakers, bike shops etc be sealed off from the great unwashed. It's a horrid policy.

Buzzinwithbez · 09/11/2022 11:36

"Oxfordshire County Council have missed the point of the concept completely. It's not about putting up barriers so people can't drive across cities, it's about planning and designing development with a mix of uses and services so that there is significantly less need to do it."

Why have they translated it so hideously?
I would have thought that most European towns and cities have this. I'm concerned that he's limited the essentials to shelter, food, medication and school without acknowledging that humans need so much more to thrive.

It seems like we could roll back on out of town shopping complexes and focus on getting more businesses back into our town centres and local shopping strips and deeply invest in public transport, but otherwise thy're trying to fix something that is not broken. Or they're trying to fix a different broken thing under the guise of this without improving infrastructure.

OP posts:
witheringrowan · 09/11/2022 11:11

Why would you think it's a mad idea? It's a standard idea in urban planning, although it hasn't always been "branded" so neatly. But it's closely linked to Jane Jacob's work critiquing 1950s style planning in the US, when everything was zoned by use, previously functioning neighborhoods were divided up by large roads, and no provision was made for pedestrians, so people were forced into much higher levels of car use.

Oxfordshire County Council have missed the point of the concept completely. It's not about putting up barriers so people can't drive across cities, it's about planning and designing development with a mix of uses and services so that there is significantly less need to do it.

Buzzinwithbez · 09/11/2022 11:00

"It is about making sure you have the community centre which has all of those essential needs, the bottle of milk, pharmacy, GP, schools which you need to have a 15-minute neighbourhood."

Yes we have those. They've left a lot out, haven't they!
What we don't have is music and art and culture, my husband's workplace, my son's college - and his friends, my friends are mostly out of town as I've met them through hobbies, nature other than in a very small, manicured Victorian park, places to do my main hobby, clothing shops.

OP posts:
Hidingawaytoday · 09/11/2022 10:50

I live in a village just outside the M25, I could meet the essential needs he's listed (bottle of milk, pharmacy, GP, schools) easily within a 15 minute walk - though the secondary nearby is a girls school so any son we had would be screwed - so that in itself wouldn't be an issue, and have nice countryside around we can walk to. So assuming we're allowed deliveries (clothes/supermarket/ other stuff) then yes I would only need to leave for work, which I get to by public transport anyway. Would be awfully boring though! And none of my family are that close so we'd need to drive to see them.