Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MIL and Christmas Presents

39 replies

MistletoeandBaileys · 09/11/2022 08:09

Hello all! Long time lurker first time poster!!

We are having an issue with my MIL and Christmas presents. I’ve been with my husband 9 years married for 2. Ever since we got engaged my MIL has insisted on buying me a gift for Christmas. Lovely idea and in the past she’s gotten me gorgeous scarves, or a really fancy umbrella which I love and use regularly. I’ve always bought her a gift too.

Now my DH is the eldest son of three. And his parents are divorced 5 years now. Every Christmas since the separation MIL sends him and his brothers lists of what she wants for Christmas. I’m talking €100+ for gifts from her sons. His middle brother is in Uni and working part time living away from home so doesn’t have much cash and his youngest brother has just started an Apprenticeship. So money really isn’t free flowing for them!!

Last year we bought our first home at the start of December and my FIL put down all our floors for us and did tiling the works. He refused payment for it once we bought the materials which as you can imagine saved us a fortune! He has a particular Dior fragrance he likes but didn’t want to ask for as it was €120 to buy but we bought it and some extras for him to say thank you for all the hard work.

Anyway, last year MIL came along with her usual list with the usual price tag and when my DH said no it was too expensive and we were scaling back she kicked up because she somehow found out about what we had bought FIL. My husband pointed out to her that he had done a lot of work for us for no charge and it was the least we could do. She was angry about it. (We did but her a gift but a smaller version which came in on our budget)

This year I wasn’t interested in getting bogged down in the drama again and there was an offer on for her perfume so I bought it. She also has a birthday the end of this month and I bought her a necklace from the Jewellers that she likes. Again, this falls within our budget.

So, now she has said she will give us the list for Christmas and DH has told her we are nearly finished Christmas shopping and that her gifts for both Birthday and Christmas are got already. She is not happy because she knows it will be less than her usual wanted price range.

Just as an aside to this, ever since we got married she has changed her attitude to me completely. I’ve been cropped out of my own wedding pictures, ignored, my weight commented on and my cooking skills questioned. She views my career as less than my husbands. Also the gifts she gives me now at Christmas are trinkets she finds in Charity Shops or a set of wine glasses she used to own in her house. (Complete with dust on box)

My DH is excellent at shutting her down and telling her how rude she is being but it doesn’t stop her. It’s almost like she views me now as competition.

So this year as well as getting her presents before the list. DH has told her in no uncertain terms that if she’s buying a gift, get one for the two of us to benefit from. (Something like a nice chopping board for the kitchen. Nothing more than €30) She said she would think about it but I know she is going to come at me with trinkets again!!

Would it be awful of me to not accept them this year? I’m just fed up with being a second class citizen to my own MIL!

That was longer than I thought it would be!! Thank you if you have managed to stick with me!!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
BMrs · 21/10/2023 20:04

I would not say anything in dirtier, ignore her list and get her something entirely different. I'd also accept her gift and not say a word other than thank you. Sounds like she's trying to get under your skin, don't let her know it's working.

PrinceHaz · 21/10/2023 18:29

Stop the presents entirely. It’s utterly bizarre that’s she’s asking for presents and asking so long before Christmas. And she’s been exceptionally rude to you I’d say rude enough to go no contact with her.
Could you just tell your husband that you’re no longer doing MIL present admin? I very much doubt he’s getting his knickers in a twist about your mum’s Christmas. So do likewise.

maslinpan · 21/10/2023 18:09

Zombie thread.

ThinWomansBrain · 21/10/2023 17:17

Why is it that she spends £30 on you, but expects over £100 in return?

£100 on gifts for son & OP combined maybe?
Grabby CF?

ThinWomansBrain · 21/10/2023 17:16

Find out which charity chop she uses most.
Donate her gifts to them.

ChristmasCrumpet · 21/10/2023 17:10

Why is it that she spends £30 on you, but expects over £100 in return?

She obviously equates presents to love, hence her showing off all her "love" on FB, but the strange thing is, most people who's love language is gifts, give a lot as well. She doesn't.

What happened that she gifts such a low value but expects three times that for her gift?

converseandjeans · 21/10/2023 17:06

She sounds really high maintenance & I imagine that FIL used to get told what to buy & now she is expecting her sons to fill the void. Maybe she will meet a boyfriend 😂

YANBU to just get her a present you can afford. Christmas is all a bit OTT anyway.

CHIRIBAYA · 21/10/2023 13:58

There is no way, none, that I woud be buying gifts for such an entitled, spoiled, rude, disrespectful and ungrateful individual, related or not. Do you even want to buy her anything given how badly she treats you? Let her be upset/angry/disappointed; providing her with an opportunity to tolerate such emotions will help her grow up; she can survive such feelings, just like the rest of us do.

RedVanYellowVan · 21/10/2023 13:44

Admittedly we don't take Christmas very seriously here but your MILs attitude is appalling.

DH and I would prefer our adult DC to save towards mortgages etc but they like to buy something for us so we have an absolute limit of £10 per person. We give them each a hefty bank transfer but very little actual stuff.

Caroparo52 · 21/10/2023 13:30

What a sad old bag.
You and your husband sound lovely

AllyArty · 05/12/2022 21:50

Count your blessings your DH supports you and doesn’t try to dilute what she is doing. Could you both buy her a theatre ticket and the 3 of u could have an evening out -a lovely memory for her and something for her to talk about. And if you went to a show you wouldn’t have to talk to her much! She is jealous and unhappy - don’t let her bring u down.

mamabear715 · 09/11/2022 12:26

What a bloody madam!
I ask my kids for slippers when they ask what I want - cheap & cheerful! If they want to get more, that's up to them, but I wouldn't dream of asking.. :-0

Georgeskitchen · 09/11/2022 12:13

Friend of mine had a mother in law like this . Deceased now thankfully ( friends words not mine)😉 friend and her brother both had young families and were struggling to keep their head above water. MIL used to issue a list of xmas presents she required which were all very expensive. I was aghast when my friend told me about the "list"
and even more so given the PILSLEY were retired and very comfortably off!!

Fraaahnces · 09/11/2022 11:36

I think you should get DH to tell her that from now on Christmas presents are only going to be bought for kids. You and he should smile lovingly and mysteriously at each other and keep her guessing for months on end. You and he should absolutely refuse to answer any questions about whether or not you’re ACTUALLY pregnant or trying to be. That will drive her even more batshit.

Beautiful3 · 09/11/2022 11:25

I'd message to say that from next year 2023, "we are not buying any Christmas presents for anyone except children. So please don't buy us anything."

Kitkatcatflap · 09/11/2022 11:24

I think if you refuse to accept her 'barbed' gift there will be more trouble. As she has bought you lovely gift in the past, clearly she is trying to send a message. Just accept it this year - even with gritted teeth and leave your DH to say something about scaling down next year.

She does sound immature. But thinking you are spending more on FIL than her, you spending more time with your family does she feel left out? Overlooked?

Sparkletastic · 09/11/2022 11:14

She sounds bloody awful. Don't pretend to like the gift she gets you if it is shit. Definitely no more gifts henceforth.

ThunderMoo · 09/11/2022 10:58

I think she assumes we spend loads of time with my family who live 40+ mins away but we don’t. my inlaws are like that. Strange to be jealous of something that isn't happening!

MistletoeandBaileys · 09/11/2022 10:56

Thank you all for the opinions!! 💐 on my families side we buy for children only and even at that it steps back to Godchildren only when your own kids come along because it’s just too costly!

My own siblings and I did Secret Santa for years until now but now that they are in uni and Working they want to save their money but we decided to still do birthday presents. My own mam we all chip in for together but it’s usually €20 each to go towards a nice perfume or something she has had her eye on (I’m a good bit older so chip in more occasionally) Mam has never wanted to be included in gifts!

Good call about getting the brothers to chip in for something together that will be a plan going forward! I already have limited interactions with her because of her attitude.

I think a lot of it now is that she is not needed in the same way as she used to be by them all. Only the youngest is still at home. We only live 10 minutes away but she never seems to want to come over. (Which suits me!!)

I think she assumes we spend loads of time with my family who live 40+ mins away but we don’t. I go down every two weeks to visit and sometimes my husband comes if he’s off and sometimes he just wants to chill at home but my family don’t mind!

She is all about Social Media too. If it’s not something she can take a picture of to put on Social Media she doesn’t want to know! last Christmas she put up a post with a picture of all the presents she got for Christmas! She’s 58 not 15!!!

OP posts:
Mummyoflittledragon · 09/11/2022 10:39

ChakaKhanfan · 09/11/2022 08:24

Save the gift she gives you for Christmas and give it back to her next year

This is exactly the route to go. She can’t complain as she decided the gifts were good enough for you.

Do you really need to see a woman, who is so toxic she’s writing you out of the family?

PoshHorseyBird · 09/11/2022 10:39

Maybe just tell her that due to the huge rise in the cost of living you'll be stopping presents for adults and she can do the same for you. Point out that this will save her money! (Obviously we know it wont save her money as all she buys you is cheap tat but it'll certainly save you money!) Maybe use the money you save by not buying her an expensive present to buy something for yourself and hubby. Your MIL sounds incredibly rude demanding expensive presents anyway!

WhatWouldHopperDo · 09/11/2022 10:32

I know we read about this sort of thing all the time on here but it astounds me that anyone would be so rude as to produce a list of expensive gifts and then kick off when their DCs call them out. (Who asks their Uni student/Apprentice child to fork out for expensive stuff??!!)

I always ask my parents if there is anything they would like for Birthdays/Christmas and if they do come back with something it is usually a book or something - never more than about £15. I always spend more (whatever I can afford) but they would NEVER expect it and would actually not be at all bothered if I got them nothing.

Gift giving is supposed to be a nice thing - not something full of demands and expectation.

You would not be at all unreasonable to return what you have already bought and just say you are not doing gifts anymore and don't expect any from her.

takealettermsjones · 09/11/2022 10:30

I'm aghast at the sheer brass neck of an adult writing a Christmas list. I don't even like it from children tbh (although I know parents find it helpful) but from an adult? Outstanding rudeness.

HuggsBosom · 09/11/2022 10:25

The first poster (Bananarama) has it. I would suggest stopping presents altogether.

However, your husbands sounds fab and on the ball so let him deal with MIL.

Hbh17 · 09/11/2022 10:21

Adults really don't need to buy each other Xmas presents, so why not suggest scrapping the whole ridiculous charade? Any money that you then have could be spent on, say, a meal together.... ie presence not presents!