Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think £800p/m is pretty generous?

417 replies

Cuppasoupmonster · 08/11/2022 20:30

Off the back of the ‘trapped women’ thread, out of curiosity I used ‘Entitled To’ to find out what I could claim if I was a single mum of 2 primary aged kids with no savings and an ex who paid the minimum in maintenance. The hypothetical single mum earns 1,300 p/m and rents a property costing £900 p/m.

The calculator said the minimum she would be entitled to would be £800p/m, which in my view is about right. Yet I hear a lot that benefits are a pittance and had assumed that to be the case, but I was pleasantly surprised by the result.

Am I overlooking something? Not trying to be goady, I’m genuinely curious.

YABU = £800 isn’t enough in these circumstances
YANBU = £800 is about right or even generous

OP posts:
Babyroobs · 09/11/2022 16:27

CombatBarbie · 09/11/2022 16:18

We receive £1000 in income (private pension) and get £20 a week on UC even though we're both unable to work and have ESA status. I don't get it at all.

Because a private pension is deducted pound for pound from your Uc award. that is why you get so little as you ahve that income coming in.

Cuppasoupmonster · 09/11/2022 16:25

Travis1 · 09/11/2022 16:16

Why should he? I mean it’s by the by because we treat everything as joint but why is it acceptable that the expectation is he’ll pay for everything when our household income has more than halved? What if he was financially abusive? What if he had walked out when I lost my job?

by your logic why are we both then paying tax and NI if neither of us can claim because the other should subside us?

Because he’s your husband and when you married you agreed what’s his is yours and vice versa and he has a greater duty to you than other taxpayers? There can be millions of ‘what ifs’ in life but the state can’t be there to pick up after every unlikely or unpredictable scenario. If he walked out you would be single and able to claim as a single person. People marry for, amongst other reasons, the financial consolidation. Part of that is financially supporting each other when necessary.

OP posts:
CombatBarbie · 09/11/2022 16:18

We receive £1000 in income (private pension) and get £20 a week on UC even though we're both unable to work and have ESA status. I don't get it at all.

Travis1 · 09/11/2022 16:17

And @Cuppasoupmonster you have spectacularly missed my point but given your obtuse responses on this thread that really does not surprise me

Travis1 · 09/11/2022 16:16

Cuppasoupmonster · 09/11/2022 16:06

@Travis1 shouldnt your husband be supporting you if he is able to though?

Why should he? I mean it’s by the by because we treat everything as joint but why is it acceptable that the expectation is he’ll pay for everything when our household income has more than halved? What if he was financially abusive? What if he had walked out when I lost my job?

by your logic why are we both then paying tax and NI if neither of us can claim because the other should subside us?

FinallyHere · 09/11/2022 16:09

Mirrorcell · 08/11/2022 20:48

Until something goes wrong you may manage on that money. Then an uninsured driver rear ends you writing off your car. Insurance takes an age to pay out and you struggle to find a car as well maintained as your old written off one.
Or your freezer/washing machine breaks down. Or your clutch goes. Or you need a new sofa. Or you get burgled and need to find your insurance excess. Or the nursery goes bust after you pay your bill for the month leaving you with a nursery to find and no cash to pay it. Or the landlord sells the house and you need a deposit upfront plus removal truck costs.

1200 doesn’t allow for the shit life throws at you. I don’t claim UC I’m very lucky to have the job I do but when people discuss UC they forget to factor in random rubbish events like those listed above. £1200 for all bills for a year is a doddle when you have decent clothes and furniture and a decent car. I bet I could manage off this for a couple of years . Not so much when you are on year 7 of all of the above still on UC and things start needing to be replaced.

Slightly off topic but I think the absent parent should be forced to self declare and pay Cms via a tax return. Facing the same penalties as someone who fails to pay a student loan or their income tax. I think that is what society should focus on - getting people to pay for their responsibilities.

This

It's a fact of life that if you are poor, unexpected events will tend to mean a bill to be paid or something broken down needing replacement.

If you are rich, an unexpected event is more likely to mean you get money, an inheritance, higher than expected dividends or other windfall.

Sad but true.

Almost anyone could survive on benefits, it's the unexpected bills which then tend to tip people into the horrors of debt.

Cuppasoupmonster · 09/11/2022 16:06

@Travis1 shouldnt your husband be supporting you if he is able to though?

OP posts:
Travis1 · 09/11/2022 15:57

Well given that after a month unemployed I’m getting a whopping £33 from JSA tomorrow and the expectation is my husband will keep me I frankly couldn’t give a shiny shit if some folk are ‘raking it in’ 🙄 with benefits. I’d rather the tax and NI I’ve paid for the last 25 years supported families than funded covid fuck ups and bank bail outs.

Cuppasoupmonster · 09/11/2022 15:55

@Thatsnotmycar i didn’t say they are. But there’s lots of posters here who want them to be - they seem to think you are entitled to have not just basic expenses covered, but holidays, tuition for your kids(?!), savings etc…

OP posts:
Thatsnotmycar · 09/11/2022 15:41

But we cannot make benefits equal to work. If we do this, there will be no incentive to work.

Benefits aren’t equal to working. Which is why, as per my workings which you ignored, you have a total income of £4045 whereas your hypothetical person has £2698.69. People are always better off working as they keep 45p in the pound they earn and anyone with children or LCW gets a work allowance.

If quitting work meant your rent/mortgage was paid, you had money for holidays and savings, what fucker would work? I wouldn’t.

Why don’t you quit then, claim UC and see how you manage.

why should people who work FT (for example) be subsidising the savings of somebody who works PT because they’ve chosen to have children?

They aren’t.

Cuppasoupmonster · 09/11/2022 15:34

Thatsnotmycar · 09/11/2022 15:16

Except those not eligible for UC have more income than those in receipt of UC when you take into account individual circumstances otherwise they would be entitled to UC themselves. For example, a family with 2 DC not in receipt of UC will have more income than a family with 2 DC in receipt of UC otherwise the first family would be entitled to UC themselves.

But we cannot make benefits equal to work. If we do this, there will be no incentive to work. If quitting work meant your rent/mortgage was paid, you had money for holidays and savings, what fucker would work? I wouldn’t. It needs to be enough that the person/family can be adequately housed and have money to live day to day, but why should people who work FT (for example) be subsidising the savings of somebody who works PT because they’ve chosen to have children?

OP posts:
grannycake · 09/11/2022 15:18

Cuppasoupmonster · 09/11/2022 14:58

people can manage day to day on benefits, but when it comes to larger expenses like oil for example, it's more cost efficient to buy in bulk but that's going to be really difficult when you're living hand to mouth and unable to save

But that’s the same for a lot of us that aren’t claiming UC and receive nothing.

You keep saying that you get nothing but you have been told you would get child benefit. You're being disingenuous and I think you're just trying to stir the pot. This thread is disgusting

Thatsnotmycar · 09/11/2022 15:16

Cuppasoupmonster · 09/11/2022 14:58

people can manage day to day on benefits, but when it comes to larger expenses like oil for example, it's more cost efficient to buy in bulk but that's going to be really difficult when you're living hand to mouth and unable to save

But that’s the same for a lot of us that aren’t claiming UC and receive nothing.

Except those not eligible for UC have more income than those in receipt of UC when you take into account individual circumstances otherwise they would be entitled to UC themselves. For example, a family with 2 DC not in receipt of UC will have more income than a family with 2 DC in receipt of UC otherwise the first family would be entitled to UC themselves.

Dreamwhisper · 09/11/2022 15:15

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

You've already shown your true colours referring to women as wastes of space so I don't think your opinion holds much value.

Wellward · 09/11/2022 15:15

OP do you get tax-free childcare?

www.gov.uk/tax-free-childcare

Benefits stop when children leave education. Children grow up fast. Before your hypothetical single parent knows it, s/he will have no benefit entitlement (unless disabled) and no owner-occupier asset. And probably not much of a pension on that income either.

You, on the other hand, will have an asset that has appreciated in value, and two pensions (yours and DH's). The state will never have poked its nose into your finances, bank accounts, working hours or medical records. You will have freedom and choices and opportunities. In short, you will be far better off.

Dreamwhisper · 09/11/2022 15:14

People always compare people on benefits to working people and say its unfair because they're looking at the fact that person A on benefits gets x amount of money whereas Person B earning y amount of money doesn't.

It's a false economy to look at it that way. The point of developed societies is that we shouldn't be letting people have not enough to live. Yes that means that people who earn little or nothing will get money so they can live. They also lose out on so many things that working brings and will have no prospects if they live a life on benefits. Or, like millions, they're already working but still entitled to top ups because of the high cost of living, and are receiving the majority of their entitlement through the child/childcare or rental element, which is often temporary.

It's just stupid short sighted jealous psychology. If you think it's so wonderful and easy being on benefits and are jealous of single mums getting £800 per month to pay rent and help bring up 2 kids, then give up your job and go and join them!

David1986uk · 09/11/2022 15:10

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

geraniumsandsunshine · 09/11/2022 15:08

Exworrier · 08/11/2022 21:11

My DH and I are low earners, I bring home about £500 a month and he £1250. We have two DC and our rent is £850 a month. We get UC and it’s about £1100 usually. We struggle, like previous posters have mentioned it’s the unexpected costs, there’s very little wiggle room.
I recently worked out what my finances would be like if I was to separate from my husband and I would be much better off.

Are you part time? I suppose some might be upset that you get benefits to subside being part time

grlwhowrites · 09/11/2022 15:03

It's low, but many working people are on low incomes too. It's a hard one.

My friend is a single mum, she lives at her parents' but doesn't declare this so she gets £900 a month and has said she'll be doing that until her child goes to school. Her belief is that the company she worked for went bust while she was about to go on mat leave so her job isn't there to go back to and she's too tired to look for anything else, and childcare costs would eat all her earnings anyway, "so what's the point?" The dad pays but it is very inconsistent.

There'll be many people "exploiting" the system, so to speak, because childcare costs are insane. My other friends, a married couple who are still together, pay over £700 in nursery fees - they each WFH one day a week too!

I don't know what the answer is, but it seems set up to make it difficult for parents to return to work, and if you're single, it's probably a lot easier to suffer on a slightly lower benefit pay out than work 40+ hours, struggle with childcare costs and then also trying to juggle the work/life balance. It's a really tough one.

David1986uk · 09/11/2022 14:59

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Changerofthename1 · 09/11/2022 14:59

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

David you seem an absolute prince of a man yourself, what do you contribute to society ?

Cuppasoupmonster · 09/11/2022 14:58

people can manage day to day on benefits, but when it comes to larger expenses like oil for example, it's more cost efficient to buy in bulk but that's going to be really difficult when you're living hand to mouth and unable to save

But that’s the same for a lot of us that aren’t claiming UC and receive nothing.

OP posts:
Pinkyxx · 09/11/2022 14:53

Try being a single parent then come talk to me..... this assumption single mum's are ''living it up'' on benefits or indeed single parents by choice is offensive.

Don't even get me started on nonsense like ''minimum child maintenance'' ...

Cw112 · 09/11/2022 14:46

Plus the majority of claimants are working at least some hours in the week. And there are plenty of others who aren't working for very good reasons or aren't able/allowed to work.

For those that say benefits are coming off people who are working and people claiming shouldn't be comfortable - I think what you mean to say is that people should be advocating for better wages and lower cost of living. I'm more than happy to pay taxes to know that I have the safety net of benefits should I ever need them even though I've been lucky enough to only ever have claimed for 2 weeks in my life so far. But I don't think we should be pitting low earners against people on benefits as if its comparable or as if one is taking something away from the other. We should be directing this at the government to fix the cost of living crisis, the housing crisis, the sheer madness of childcare costs and be advocating for more appropriate pay in the first instance.

Cw112 · 09/11/2022 14:37

If you live in social housing this is doable, if you live in private rented accommodation you'd struggle massively on this as you'd need to top up your rent.

@Cuddlywuddlies yes and you've also left off Internet and heating and maintenance costs for running a home. Never mind all the extras like school trips/ uniforms/supplies/Christmas/birthdays etc I think part of the difficulty is people can manage day to day on benefits, but when it comes to larger expenses like oil for example, it's more cost efficient to buy in bulk but that's going to be really difficult when you're living hand to mouth and unable to save really. I do budgeting work with some single people on benefits and these days with the cost of living escalating never mind the huge top ups in rent needed- I'm struggling to get the math to balance. It's not easy for anyone on benefits.

Swipe left for the next trending thread