Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think £800p/m is pretty generous?

417 replies

Cuppasoupmonster · 08/11/2022 20:30

Off the back of the ‘trapped women’ thread, out of curiosity I used ‘Entitled To’ to find out what I could claim if I was a single mum of 2 primary aged kids with no savings and an ex who paid the minimum in maintenance. The hypothetical single mum earns 1,300 p/m and rents a property costing £900 p/m.

The calculator said the minimum she would be entitled to would be £800p/m, which in my view is about right. Yet I hear a lot that benefits are a pittance and had assumed that to be the case, but I was pleasantly surprised by the result.

Am I overlooking something? Not trying to be goady, I’m genuinely curious.

YABU = £800 isn’t enough in these circumstances
YANBU = £800 is about right or even generous

OP posts:
Cuppasoupmonster · 09/11/2022 19:12

Cw112 · 09/11/2022 18:46

No but the state needs to have mechanisms in place to protect people who are vulnerable instead of penalise the most vulnerable. At the end of the day that's who benefits are mainly aimed at are they not. And that happens by considering case by case scenarios to see what's missing/ could work better. And since 1/4 women in the UK experience dv can you imagine how many women that is out of your millions of people? Enough to be worth considering surely.

But then anyone could claim to be vulnerable in order to access the cash. So many posters seem to truly believe the state is responsible for intervening in every aspect of their life to make it as comfortable as possible. It’s not. If you choose to marry someone, your finances are for all intents and purposes merged. That’s why people wanted Martin Freeman to pay his wife’s tax bill. Do you think he shouldn’t have done it? It works both ways.

OP posts:
kittensinthekitchen · 09/11/2022 19:06

kittensinthekitchen · 09/11/2022 17:50

If quitting work meant your rent/mortgage was paid, you had money for holidays and savings, what fucker would work?

Once again, benefits do not pay people's mortgages (there may be a very small number of special circumstances, but not as far as I'm aware).

And second point - who is "quitting work" to claim benefits? Isn't the system set up so that someone can't do that?

@Cuppasoupmonster

Cw112 · 09/11/2022 18:46

Cuppasoupmonster · 09/11/2022 18:37

@Cw112 the state cannot work on an individual case-by-case basis - it deals with millions of people. It’s reasonable to assume if a couple are married and living together then one will support the other in times of financial need if they can. Marriage is a choice, it’s not an unreasonable assumption.

No but the state needs to have mechanisms in place to protect people who are vulnerable instead of penalise the most vulnerable. At the end of the day that's who benefits are mainly aimed at are they not. And that happens by considering case by case scenarios to see what's missing/ could work better. And since 1/4 women in the UK experience dv can you imagine how many women that is out of your millions of people? Enough to be worth considering surely.

Cuppasoupmonster · 09/11/2022 18:37

@Cw112 the state cannot work on an individual case-by-case basis - it deals with millions of people. It’s reasonable to assume if a couple are married and living together then one will support the other in times of financial need if they can. Marriage is a choice, it’s not an unreasonable assumption.

OP posts:
Cw112 · 09/11/2022 18:36

Having a mental health condition/complex ptsd meaning you're unable to hold down a ft is a luxury? Now I know you're trolling.

Cw112 · 09/11/2022 18:34

Cuppasoupmonster · 09/11/2022 16:06

@Travis1 shouldnt your husband be supporting you if he is able to though?

@Cuppasoupmonster this attitude is why UC has been one of the worst things for women in abusive relationships in recent years. It has much less caveats for women in situations of financial abuse than the old jsa system even had. It was really clear noone had thought that through when the system was first rolled out and when it was questioned noone had answers strangely enough.

Cuppasoupmonster · 09/11/2022 18:30

Cw112 · 09/11/2022 18:29

@IneedanewTV what about people who can't work full time though? Because of mental health/ physical health/caring responsibilities/ lack of work in their local area/ lack of transport in rural communities? A lot of the people I work with can manage a part time week quite well but mentally couldn't manage a full time week not for want of trying.

To be honest that’s probably all of us… its simply a luxury most people can’t afford 🤷🏼‍♀️

OP posts:
Cw112 · 09/11/2022 18:29

IneedanewTV · 09/11/2022 18:03

Yes I agree. I don’t think there should be a choice - you work full time like I have too as a single parent to keep the roof over my head and my kids.

@IneedanewTV what about people who can't work full time though? Because of mental health/ physical health/caring responsibilities/ lack of work in their local area/ lack of transport in rural communities? A lot of the people I work with can manage a part time week quite well but mentally couldn't manage a full time week not for want of trying.

Cw112 · 09/11/2022 18:26

Cuppasoupmonster · 09/11/2022 14:58

people can manage day to day on benefits, but when it comes to larger expenses like oil for example, it's more cost efficient to buy in bulk but that's going to be really difficult when you're living hand to mouth and unable to save

But that’s the same for a lot of us that aren’t claiming UC and receive nothing.

@Cuppasoupmonster you've just missed the point of my comment altogether? Noone should be in this position. If minimum wage was increased, the cost of living was decreased and the childcare and housing crises addressed properly then why should anyone be in that boat regardless of the source of their income? There's loads of benefits to working that people on benefits can't get like the routine, the social aspect, less stigma attached, possibility for progression and training for more pay, sense of pride in their work, boost in self esteem and confidence, easier to be approved by a landlord etc etc. You may not choose to do it but that's not to say others wouldn't. I work with loads of young people who are on benefits who want to be working for all of those reasons. They even work for free to build up their cvs so your argument doesn't really hold water. Plus having a benefits system directly benefits ft workers like myself because it means I have a safety net to fall back on should i be made redundant/find myself unemployed. I see it like paying insurance and trust that people who need it for legitimate reasons can access it. Having a strong benefits system in turn lowers poverty rates/demand on healthcare/ crime etc so it benefits all of society as a result. If you're unhappy with a low wage for work you are doing then go after government for that that. That has nothing to do with someone else's benefits entitlement.

IneedanewTV · 09/11/2022 18:05

Pawtucketbrew · 09/11/2022 16:49

Curious but are the people saying it's a benefit bashing thread actually on benefits? I'm a single parent working full time and renting and am surprised at the amount of top up I get from UC. The OP does not offend me in the slightest. It's factual. If you rent and have kids and work with earnings under a certain amount you will get a top off which I consider fairly generous tbh and which I am thankful for.

Not sure how stating a fact is offensive.

I agree

IneedanewTV · 09/11/2022 18:03

geraniumsandsunshine · 09/11/2022 15:08

Are you part time? I suppose some might be upset that you get benefits to subside being part time

Yes I agree. I don’t think there should be a choice - you work full time like I have too as a single parent to keep the roof over my head and my kids.

kittensinthekitchen · 09/11/2022 17:50

Cuppasoupmonster · 09/11/2022 15:34

But we cannot make benefits equal to work. If we do this, there will be no incentive to work. If quitting work meant your rent/mortgage was paid, you had money for holidays and savings, what fucker would work? I wouldn’t. It needs to be enough that the person/family can be adequately housed and have money to live day to day, but why should people who work FT (for example) be subsidising the savings of somebody who works PT because they’ve chosen to have children?

If quitting work meant your rent/mortgage was paid, you had money for holidays and savings, what fucker would work?

Once again, benefits do not pay people's mortgages (there may be a very small number of special circumstances, but not as far as I'm aware).

And second point - who is "quitting work" to claim benefits? Isn't the system set up so that someone can't do that?

MollieMarie · 09/11/2022 17:33

Lor6126 · 09/11/2022 16:57

I’d like to know what the trapped women thread is please , link ?

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/relationships/4672879-can-we-just-be-honest-and-say-many-women-are-trapped?page=1

Lor6126 · 09/11/2022 16:57

I’d like to know what the trapped women thread is please , link ?

Pawtucketbrew · 09/11/2022 16:49

Curious but are the people saying it's a benefit bashing thread actually on benefits? I'm a single parent working full time and renting and am surprised at the amount of top up I get from UC. The OP does not offend me in the slightest. It's factual. If you rent and have kids and work with earnings under a certain amount you will get a top off which I consider fairly generous tbh and which I am thankful for.

Not sure how stating a fact is offensive.

Babyroobs · 09/11/2022 16:47

CombatBarbie · 09/11/2022 16:39

I thought that too. His ESA claim is recent but my award was given months ago.

We've just put in for carers allowance so will see what happens there.

Only good thing is the free school entitlement so I can cut shopping bill down a bit.

You need to make sure you have a carers element on your UC claim. you can get that element added without claiming carers allowance as long as one of you is caring for the other for 35 hours a week and the other is getting a disability benefit. The one with PIP will need to claim the LCWRA on UC (assuming they have been awarded that or support group of ESA ) and the oother will need to claim carers element. Unfortunately, carers allowance is deducted from UC pound for pound also so you are no better off claiming it except that it pays a better class of NI contributions. If you are both claiming contributions based ESA separately to UC then I don't think one of you can claim carers allowance if getting ESA - they are overlapping benefits. It's hard to advise without knowing exactly what you are getting. You say you are both getting ESA but do you mean contributions based ESA separately to UC or the Limited capability for work element of UC only?

Thatsnotmycar · 09/11/2022 16:46

Cuppasoupmonster · 09/11/2022 15:55

@Thatsnotmycar i didn’t say they are. But there’s lots of posters here who want them to be - they seem to think you are entitled to have not just basic expenses covered, but holidays, tuition for your kids(?!), savings etc…

You certainly seem to be suggesting they are equal when you can’t see the difference between someone with your income and someone with the income of your hypothetical OP.

Wiluli · 09/11/2022 16:44

Personally I think it’s survivable , but it will be a life of having to struggle . £1200 for transport , let’s imagine car insurance and fuel even if only £250 plus £300 energy bills , £50 for phone and internet , £500 for food . It’s doable but a very limited life

CombatBarbie · 09/11/2022 16:39

Babyroobs · 09/11/2022 16:35

If you were both entitled to contributions based ESA, one of you getting a private pension would not affect the others ESA ?

I thought that too. His ESA claim is recent but my award was given months ago.

We've just put in for carers allowance so will see what happens there.

Only good thing is the free school entitlement so I can cut shopping bill down a bit.

Travis1 · 09/11/2022 16:37

Cuppasoupmonster · 09/11/2022 16:25

Because he’s your husband and when you married you agreed what’s his is yours and vice versa and he has a greater duty to you than other taxpayers? There can be millions of ‘what ifs’ in life but the state can’t be there to pick up after every unlikely or unpredictable scenario. If he walked out you would be single and able to claim as a single person. People marry for, amongst other reasons, the financial consolidation. Part of that is financially supporting each other when necessary.

‘Unlikely or unpredictable scenario’? Really? You think it’s ‘unlikely’ someone would have a financially abusive partner? You really are just acting like a twat now and it’s clear your only objective from this thread was to encourage and engage in benefit bashing

Babyroobs · 09/11/2022 16:36

Babyroobs · 09/11/2022 16:35

If you were both entitled to contributions based ESA, one of you getting a private pension would not affect the others ESA ?

Do both or either of you get a disability benefit? if so the other can claim carers element.

CombatBarbie · 09/11/2022 16:36

Cuppasoupmonster · 09/11/2022 16:33

Do you rent or have a mortgage?

Mortgage but the Ill health is recent and was not expected. Mine was but that was fine as we had his work income, his wasn't and now he can't work.

Babyroobs · 09/11/2022 16:35

CombatBarbie · 09/11/2022 16:33

Yeah but we're married with 2 kids and a mortgage. I know they won't pay the mortgage but esa is nil because of this pension too. So we're expected to live off £1080 a month.

If you were both entitled to contributions based ESA, one of you getting a private pension would not affect the others ESA ?

CombatBarbie · 09/11/2022 16:33

Babyroobs · 09/11/2022 16:27

Because a private pension is deducted pound for pound from your Uc award. that is why you get so little as you ahve that income coming in.

Yeah but we're married with 2 kids and a mortgage. I know they won't pay the mortgage but esa is nil because of this pension too. So we're expected to live off £1080 a month.

Cuppasoupmonster · 09/11/2022 16:33

CombatBarbie · 09/11/2022 16:18

We receive £1000 in income (private pension) and get £20 a week on UC even though we're both unable to work and have ESA status. I don't get it at all.

Do you rent or have a mortgage?

OP posts: