Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think £800p/m is pretty generous?

417 replies

Cuppasoupmonster · 08/11/2022 20:30

Off the back of the ‘trapped women’ thread, out of curiosity I used ‘Entitled To’ to find out what I could claim if I was a single mum of 2 primary aged kids with no savings and an ex who paid the minimum in maintenance. The hypothetical single mum earns 1,300 p/m and rents a property costing £900 p/m.

The calculator said the minimum she would be entitled to would be £800p/m, which in my view is about right. Yet I hear a lot that benefits are a pittance and had assumed that to be the case, but I was pleasantly surprised by the result.

Am I overlooking something? Not trying to be goady, I’m genuinely curious.

YABU = £800 isn’t enough in these circumstances
YANBU = £800 is about right or even generous

OP posts:
Cuppasoupmonster · 09/11/2022 22:40

SofiaSoFar · 09/11/2022 22:38

The majority of taxpayers don't pay enough tax to be net contributors, let alone pay enough to fund others to work fewer hours.

39%, not ‘most’.

So the 60% that do net contribute go PT and need top up, then what?

OP posts:
SofiaSoFar · 09/11/2022 22:38

Cuppasoupmonster · 09/11/2022 22:33

The taxpayer. But if there’s no taxpayers because they’re all working PT, then what?

The majority of taxpayers don't pay enough tax to be net contributors, let alone pay enough to fund others to work fewer hours.

Cuppasoupmonster · 09/11/2022 22:33

SofiaSoFar · 09/11/2022 22:31

Who pays for those who currently do it?

The taxpayer. But if there’s no taxpayers because they’re all working PT, then what?

OP posts:
SofiaSoFar · 09/11/2022 22:31

Cuppasoupmonster · 09/11/2022 22:24

Who pays for it? For everyone to work PT?

Who pays for those who currently do it?

Cuppasoupmonster · 09/11/2022 22:24

SofiaSoFar · 09/11/2022 20:49

@Babyroobs

I'd love to work part time and get top up benefits. I've done 35 years in extremely stressful jobs and I'm done with full time work. I have another 12 years to go though. It will make me ill before then.

I agree. It should be an option available to everyone not just the few.

Who pays for it? For everyone to work PT?

OP posts:
Cw112 · 09/11/2022 22:04

IneedanewTV · 09/11/2022 20:24

I excluded disability and illnesses in my previous post. But living rurally is not a reason for working full time which has been quoted as a reason for being able to access benefits.

It is in some areas of the UK. I cover areas for work that don't have regular public transport (maybe 2 buses per day, mid morning and mid afternoon- unsuitable for anyone doing ft hours) and the nearest town is an hours drive away. Are people supposed to pay for a taxi both ways if they can't drive? How do they afford that journey daily on minimum wage or low income and still pay their other bills? What if full time jobs aren't available in their village because there are barely any shops? Let's also add into it that their nearest supermarket is also an hour away so not only do they have to pay to travel for those things as well, the only alternative is to shop in more expensive local stores as a result making their overall cost of living higher than someone living in a town. These are legitimate problems that people in rural communities can face which is why they're included in my catchment as areas of significant economic deprivation. They wouldn't fall into that category if rural living didn't make it harder for people to make ends meet.

SofiaSoFar · 09/11/2022 20:49

@Babyroobs

I'd love to work part time and get top up benefits. I've done 35 years in extremely stressful jobs and I'm done with full time work. I have another 12 years to go though. It will make me ill before then.

I agree. It should be an option available to everyone not just the few.

luxxlisbon · 09/11/2022 20:48

Still dying to hear how the OP would be financially better off single 😂

Kitesk · 09/11/2022 20:46

Babyroobs · 09/11/2022 20:22

UC pay 85% of childcare costs. However personally i would not want to put an 11 month old in full time childcare.

UC pay upto 85 percent of childcare, even as a single person I don't get my full childcare costs back all the time. It depends what you earn.

IneedanewTV · 09/11/2022 20:24

Cw112 · 09/11/2022 20:16

"But why should the state fund those situations whilst others have to work full time? " you mean fund people who can work full time and have no reason to be part time? Who have to evidence to uc that they are actively looking for more work or have a valid reason not to be working full time in the first place? Because benefits are in place to support people who are at risk of becoming vulnerable or who are already vulnerable to poverty... why shouldn't they fund people who can't work full time? Those are the people benefits are literally designed for in the first place and none of us know what's round the corner. A bad accident tomorrow could put any of us in those shoes- wouldn't you want to know you'd be OK if that happened to you?

I excluded disability and illnesses in my previous post. But living rurally is not a reason for working full time which has been quoted as a reason for being able to access benefits.

Exworrier · 09/11/2022 20:23

Babyroobs · 09/11/2022 20:22

UC pay 85% of childcare costs. However personally i would not want to put an 11 month old in full time childcare.

Yes but you still have to foot the bill before they pay out, so unless you have the money upfront (which we don’t) we still can’t afford more childcare.

Babyroobs · 09/11/2022 20:22

Cw112 · 09/11/2022 20:18

Exactly. And if anyone has a problem with this they should be petitioning for a cap on childcare costs to make it easier for women in particular to return to the work place instead of taking money away from people.

UC pay 85% of childcare costs. However personally i would not want to put an 11 month old in full time childcare.

Babyroobs · 09/11/2022 20:21

IneedanewTV · 09/11/2022 20:01

I completely agree. But why should the state fund those situations whilst others have to work full time? Otherwise again why don’t we all work part time and let the state fund us? Seems fair to me and I’m sure many agree.

I'd love to work part time and get top up benefits. I've done 35 years in extremely stressful jobs and I'm done with full time work. I have another 12 years to go though. It will make me ill before then.

Cw112 · 09/11/2022 20:18

Exworrier · 09/11/2022 20:01

Yes I’m part-time because I have a 11 month old and can’t afford any more childcare than that. Universal credit do not force you to work more hours until your child is in school.

Exactly. And if anyone has a problem with this they should be petitioning for a cap on childcare costs to make it easier for women in particular to return to the work place instead of taking money away from people.

Cw112 · 09/11/2022 20:16

IneedanewTV · 09/11/2022 20:01

I completely agree. But why should the state fund those situations whilst others have to work full time? Otherwise again why don’t we all work part time and let the state fund us? Seems fair to me and I’m sure many agree.

"But why should the state fund those situations whilst others have to work full time? " you mean fund people who can work full time and have no reason to be part time? Who have to evidence to uc that they are actively looking for more work or have a valid reason not to be working full time in the first place? Because benefits are in place to support people who are at risk of becoming vulnerable or who are already vulnerable to poverty... why shouldn't they fund people who can't work full time? Those are the people benefits are literally designed for in the first place and none of us know what's round the corner. A bad accident tomorrow could put any of us in those shoes- wouldn't you want to know you'd be OK if that happened to you?

IneedanewTV · 09/11/2022 20:01

Cw112 · 09/11/2022 19:46

With the way the housing crisis is going its not always peoples choice where they live its what they can afford and rural areas typically have lower rental prices because less people choose to live there/less demand. What about people who's family live in that area and they depend on them for childcare or they need support in other ways. So while it's your choice to live rurally it's not the case for everyone. There's already been reems of examples as to why some people can't work full time or find it significantly harder than other people to do so and sustain it.

I completely agree. But why should the state fund those situations whilst others have to work full time? Otherwise again why don’t we all work part time and let the state fund us? Seems fair to me and I’m sure many agree.

Exworrier · 09/11/2022 20:01

IneedanewTV · 09/11/2022 18:03

Yes I agree. I don’t think there should be a choice - you work full time like I have too as a single parent to keep the roof over my head and my kids.

Yes I’m part-time because I have a 11 month old and can’t afford any more childcare than that. Universal credit do not force you to work more hours until your child is in school.

Cw112 · 09/11/2022 19:46

IneedanewTV · 09/11/2022 19:40

I live in a rural area. It’s my choice. I drive to work. Unless you have a disability or your caring responsibility has a disability I think you should work full time. I have no idea why you wouldn’t? I certainly don’t think that if you choose to work part time the state should fund you so that you have the same income as me working full time. Otherwise why do I work? I certainly don’t enjoy working.

With the way the housing crisis is going its not always peoples choice where they live its what they can afford and rural areas typically have lower rental prices because less people choose to live there/less demand. What about people who's family live in that area and they depend on them for childcare or they need support in other ways. So while it's your choice to live rurally it's not the case for everyone. There's already been reems of examples as to why some people can't work full time or find it significantly harder than other people to do so and sustain it.

IneedanewTV · 09/11/2022 19:40

Cw112 · 09/11/2022 18:29

@IneedanewTV what about people who can't work full time though? Because of mental health/ physical health/caring responsibilities/ lack of work in their local area/ lack of transport in rural communities? A lot of the people I work with can manage a part time week quite well but mentally couldn't manage a full time week not for want of trying.

I live in a rural area. It’s my choice. I drive to work. Unless you have a disability or your caring responsibility has a disability I think you should work full time. I have no idea why you wouldn’t? I certainly don’t think that if you choose to work part time the state should fund you so that you have the same income as me working full time. Otherwise why do I work? I certainly don’t enjoy working.

Cw112 · 09/11/2022 19:40

Cuppasoupmonster · 09/11/2022 19:30

It’s true though. I would like to go part time and spend more time with my kids, I can’t afford to 🤷🏼‍♀️ I have had serious MH issues in the past and I’m not unsympathetic to that. But if everyone who found work stressful or who suffered with poor MH went part time the economy would collapse.

There's a scale though from people who just find work stressful and would choose to be pt if they could, to people who have genuine and legitimate reasons for being unable to hold down a ft job with no choice in the matter. The empathy isnt exactly hanging out of you is it. It's like the argument in America - why should I pay for another person's healthcare (including my own if I need it) and then watch people die because they can't access vital medication/ face bankruptcy because someone rang an ambulance to get them to hospital in an emergency. Benefits is similar in that its a backup for everyone. I know I'd rather have a decent benefits system and the NHS than live in a society where I'd watch many people suffer for the sake of not paying as much in taxes. The difference it makes out of taxes really isn't comparable to the impact on someone who really needs it. With a better benefits system, there would be less poverty, better physical and mental health which in turn would boost the economy.

AuntieDickhead · 09/11/2022 19:37

Cuppasoupmonster · 09/11/2022 19:30

It’s true though. I would like to go part time and spend more time with my kids, I can’t afford to 🤷🏼‍♀️ I have had serious MH issues in the past and I’m not unsympathetic to that. But if everyone who found work stressful or who suffered with poor MH went part time the economy would collapse.

So you know that wanting to spend more time with you DC isn't the same as having MH issues then. And if you can still work full time (or at all) without having another breakdown then that's fab for you. I can't at the moment.

It's not about "finding work stressful" or "having poor MH" it's about being literally too unwell to do more than the bare minimum.

Cuppasoupmonster · 09/11/2022 19:34

Of course but how do you prove financial abuse?

OP posts:
Cw112 · 09/11/2022 19:32

Cuppasoupmonster · 09/11/2022 19:12

But then anyone could claim to be vulnerable in order to access the cash. So many posters seem to truly believe the state is responsible for intervening in every aspect of their life to make it as comfortable as possible. It’s not. If you choose to marry someone, your finances are for all intents and purposes merged. That’s why people wanted Martin Freeman to pay his wife’s tax bill. Do you think he shouldn’t have done it? It works both ways.

But you need to provide evidence of vulnerability in order to claim higher rate benefits or have appropriate measurements put in place? Have you ever had to go through this process op because I do it with claimants regularly and it's quite robust and often very difficult for the most vulnerable to access independently without support which in my opinion is wrong. You don't seem to be overly familiar with the nuances of uc and other benefits.

Cuppasoupmonster · 09/11/2022 19:30

AuntieDickhead · 09/11/2022 19:26

God yea. My life of luxury that saw me unable to leave the house alone for 2 years.

My life of luxury that means I've asked my parents for winter boots for Christmas, but can I have them now because I'm fed up with cold wet feet.
My life of luxury which means I have intrusive thoughts and suicidal ideation.

If you want to swap then I'm more than happy to.

It’s true though. I would like to go part time and spend more time with my kids, I can’t afford to 🤷🏼‍♀️ I have had serious MH issues in the past and I’m not unsympathetic to that. But if everyone who found work stressful or who suffered with poor MH went part time the economy would collapse.

OP posts:
AuntieDickhead · 09/11/2022 19:26

Cuppasoupmonster · 09/11/2022 18:30

To be honest that’s probably all of us… its simply a luxury most people can’t afford 🤷🏼‍♀️

God yea. My life of luxury that saw me unable to leave the house alone for 2 years.

My life of luxury that means I've asked my parents for winter boots for Christmas, but can I have them now because I'm fed up with cold wet feet.
My life of luxury which means I have intrusive thoughts and suicidal ideation.

If you want to swap then I'm more than happy to.