Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think future Christmases are going to be a nightmare

64 replies

xmasdread · 08/11/2022 18:51

NCed because of details

Mine and my husband's parents are both split. His as a child, mine a few years ago.
Parent 1 still lives nearby and we're very close with
Parent 2 recently moved to the other end of the country and we were never close with

Parent 3 lives in Europe, usually they rent an air b&b when visiting

Parent 4 lives elsewhere im Europe, can't afford accommodation so relies on others for a place to stay when visiting

We've just had a baby. We've told family that our first Christmas with baby will be just us as a family and we will see other family on other days. All but 1 parent has arranged visiting near xmas.

AIBU to dread christmases going forward? I always dreamed of having big family christmases but with 4 separate sets of parents to visit I feel like every year is going to be a nightmare and get political. I love Christmas and want to enjoy it with my children, I don't want to have to figure out where we have to spend it each year in order to avoid jealously etc.

How would you handle it?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Vikinga · 09/11/2022 11:40

You can either rotate or do christmas just you and see family at other times. It also depends on what other family the parents have? Are there other children etc?

I haven't been with my family at Christmas for 10 years because they live in a different country.

I also think that christmas is just a date so you can have your own family get together at another date.

During lockdown we celebrated xmas with my boyfriend's family during the summer, at other times we have a family Christmas a few days after Christmas.

Dailymash · 09/11/2022 11:30

Apologies as I haven’t RTFT Blush

My honest advice at this stage in your child’s life and going forwards, with lots of spread out family, is to have Christmas at your own home. Whether that means hosting others or visiting on any other day but Christmas Day can be decided but getting into the habit of taking turns each year or visiting multiple households on Christmas Day isn’t great with a young child.

If you choose to go to multiple houses to everyone gets to see you, your child gets to open their presents then they are whisked off to begin a relentless day of visiting, present opening, staying for a bit, then rushing off somewhere else.

If you choose to do turns - stay for the majority of the day at one place - what happens to the rota if you feel obliged to swap one year for whatever reason? The unexpected death of a family member, divorce or a decline in health would mean you’d want to prioritise the affected family members.

Have Christmas at your own home, invite people if you feel you can manage, see them all another day if not. Christmas is for family but don’t forget that your new arrival has created a new family. Spend the day with them.

nokidshere · 09/11/2022 10:49

We stopped visiting people at Christmas when we had our children. I am totally happy if people want to join us (they never do) but we don't go anywhere and our boys are now in their 20s

ABJ100 · 09/11/2022 10:31

kingtamponthefurred · 08/11/2022 19:20

Just make it clear that you don't travel at Christmas.

This. When we had dc we stopped any travelling. It really wasn't in their interests to cart them around during this time from house to house. I would invite anyone to pop by but we did it our own way.

EL8888 · 09/11/2022 09:46

Ponderingwindow · 08/11/2022 19:25

Offer to host Christmas dinner at your home. All parents are invited. All parents are responsible for finding their own accommodation and transportation. Anyone who can’t get along, that is their problem, not yours. They can stay home.

people who can’t afford to make the trip, I’m guessing you occasionally visit at some other time so that will be when you see those people.

All this. Don’t get sucked into the politics of people not getting on. They need to be grown ups and get on or not come. Plus take responsibility for their own travel and accommodation

We are pregnant and due next year, most likely we will be in this situation next Christmas. Previously l have done lots of running around at Christmas but this isn’t going to be the case for the foreseeable

Moonpies · 08/11/2022 21:47

No answers, just sympathy. I would love to chill over Christmas and stay at home, but feel like it's forced to run around visiting people. I didn't mind Covid Christmas 2020 for this reason!

Do any sets of the grandparents get along (your mum and DP mum etc) so you could combine their visits? and then make some sort of rota, but it's also a good time to start your own traditions. You can see family all year around, not just Christmas.

Honeyroar · 08/11/2022 21:39

I’d host at your house. Have your children as centre of it all. The parent you’re close to will obviously come. The one in the air B&Bs could come easy enough if they want. The one who couldn’t afford accommodation could perhaps stay over a day or so, or have you no room? (they might not bother). The one who lives elsewhere in the country can travel up if they want. They all chose where they live and knew it would affect their Xmas…

pinkhousesarebest · 08/11/2022 21:39

We travelled once with young dc. It was the Christmas of snow and we never did it again. We stay put and anyone who wants to come is very welcome ( no- one does anyway). It’s our absolute favorite time of the year.

DogInATent · 08/11/2022 21:27

Stay at home, have a family christmas with just your family.
Relative visits/visiting is best done at any other time of the year.
The hollywood christmas is a shared delusion.

TolkiensFallow · 08/11/2022 21:16

Parents 2, 3 and 4 would be unreasonable to expect you to visit them on actual Christmas. Parent 1 you can probably arrange Xmas day or Boxing Day with most years. I actually think this will be easier than if all 4 lived in your town!

Whoputtheramintheramalamadingdong · 08/11/2022 21:14

Are you sure this isn't just the plot of Four Christmases with Reece Witherspoon? 😂

Isthisreasonable · 08/11/2022 21:11

Stay in your home and offer to host/video call. I spent years travelling most years so that everyone had their turn to see us at Xmas. All it resulted in was the dc having virtually no memories of a Xmas at home which made them (and me) sad. They also felt they couldn't say anything as they didn't want to upset the GPs.

Fladdermus · 08/11/2022 21:06

Have the Christmases you want OP. I haven't had Christmas with any extended family for nearly 30 years. I like it at home with my children and friends. Parents would be welcome to join us but they never have. Inlaws come for a weekend before Christmas and my parents couldn't be arsed so I never bothered with them either.

Jalepenojello · 08/11/2022 21:03

Just say no. We regularly spend Xmas with 1 set of parents. We love the others very much but as a family it works much better going to one set of parents. I will say there was some back and forth the first 2/3 years after having DC And we tried a few things ie taking turns and spending an Xmas at home alone but this is what works.

Fiddledeedeeee · 08/11/2022 20:59

We’re in the same position (4 sets of parents) and decided any sort of rotation would be a nightmare as we’d only have a Christmas on our own every 5 years!
We decided once DS was born that we’d spend Christmas on our own but we do make an effort to do something special with each parent over the Christmas period.
It’s the best we could come up with to keep everyone relatively happy.
Its stressful and guilt inducing though!!

Merlott · 08/11/2022 20:58

Can't this all be resolved with just some calm adult conversations with the relevant individuals?

I mean are you going to tip toe around other people's feelings for ever?

Are any of them tiptoeing around yours?

Summerishere123 · 08/11/2022 20:55

We always stay home and say they can visit us. In-laws come to us as we are only family. They literally just come for dinner.
my parents host other family so don’t come to us. We see then Xmas day.

MyMumSaysALot · 08/11/2022 20:54

xmasdread · 08/11/2022 19:01

The thing is that parent 1 lives down the road and we are very close with. They would love to host us for xmas and I expect will offer this next year and honestly we'd like to do that. But it'll look like we're choosing parent 1 over the others. But we're close with them as they're the only parent who hasn't chosen to move away from us so what do the others expect!

Presumably, these parents are all older than you. Ergo, they’re more experienced and more wise.

Who gives a rat’s ass what they expect?

You expect them to act like the adults they are and to not pitch fits over who spends Christmas with whom.

If they can’t manage that, then you should express your disappointment in them, as if they’re the children and you’re the adults.

End of, as far as you’re concerned.
Don’t let anybody draw you into their bullshit drama. Don’t stand for it - don’t have it.

Be the star of your own life. Do what you want with no regrets and without anybody trying to make you feel guilty.

Whatsleftnow · 08/11/2022 20:51

It really isn’t hard. You just decide what you are and aren’t willing to do as a family and say that in a pleasant and polite (but firm) tone of voice.

Let’s say next year P1 offers to host and you say “yes please”. P2/P3/P4 will either
a) offer to host “how lovely of you to offer but we’ve made plans” and now they know they need to ask you earlier next year.
b) fish for an invitation to yours “we’re not at home this year”
c) want to come visit “we have plans that day but what about the 28th/29th/30th”
d) want to stay “you’re very welcome” or “sorry but we just don’t have the room to put you up”

It’s not your job to keep everyone happy - their job as adults is to manage their expectations and feelings when life presents the occasional disappointment.

You’re both probably coming from a similar psychological place as the dc of divorced parents. But managing your dp’s relationships and feelings was never your responsibility. It wouldn’t be a terrible idea to do a little couples counselling around this now.

PlantDoctor · 08/11/2022 20:48

Squeezedsquash · 08/11/2022 18:53

Then you say that you will stay at home for Christmas from now on. You might say that anyone is welcome to join you for Christmas if they can be civil when they’re there and also join in and help, but only if you want it…

This! That's too many people to navigate

VestaTilley · 08/11/2022 20:47

Just stay at home in future years, and invite all the parents on separate days to yours. Their divorces don’t need to be your problem, or your responsibility to solve.

ZoChan · 08/11/2022 20:40

xmasdread · 08/11/2022 19:01

The thing is that parent 1 lives down the road and we are very close with. They would love to host us for xmas and I expect will offer this next year and honestly we'd like to do that. But it'll look like we're choosing parent 1 over the others. But we're close with them as they're the only parent who hasn't chosen to move away from us so what do the others expect!

We are in the same situation, with DHs parents split a very long time ago and his sister in Brazil. When we first got together and had DS we decided to spend time with my sister and my nieces every Christmas Day as it's about kids. Then my dad left my mum so it complicated things even further.

Now we are nine years in and everyone has their allocated "slot" which suits:
DH massive family party with 25-30 in a rented hall: early December
Last weekend before Christmas with my DD, his partner and DS and family: lunch out in my town as we are halfway between everyone, we host a picky tea and drinks. Everyone else gets hotels.
Panto with DMIL and her partner sometime in the lead up to Christmas
Christmas Eve: DFIL and DSMIL, usually fish and chips by the seaside and they come back for stockings to be hung etc
Christmas morning: just us. Waking in our own bed 🙌🏻 some time at home
Christmas Day: drive to DM and DSis town where we share the day and stay at my mums.
Boxing Day: recoup 😅
27th is DMIL birthday so we see her then again

So yes, we have five christmases throughout December. It's actually nicer because DS(9 and 6) get presents spaced out so don't get overwhelmed on one day and misbehave accordingly. Its not the big family Christmas that I dreamed of either, but it is nice. Hope that helps xxx

ShineOnYouLikeMorningStar · 08/11/2022 20:37

I think in life, you often get what you're willing to give. One parent has stayed local & made the effort to maintain a relationship with you. The other three have moved away & it seems like you're worried their feelings will be hurt because you can't spend as much time with each of them as the one who chose to stay nearby? Have they actually voiced this to you, what did they expect when they moved away, that you'd do all the effort & bear all the costs of travelling to each family member?

Taillighttoobright · 08/11/2022 20:31

I’d make it about my DC and not worry about anyone else x

SleepingStandingUp · 08/11/2022 20:28

Parent 1 still lives nearby and we're very close with see them whenever over Xmas you want, and they're willing to visit

Parent 2 recently moved to the other end of the country and we were never close with I'd plan a visit either early Dec or mid Jan, they of course can visit you if they choose

Parent 3 lives in Europe, usually they rent an air b&b when visiting, we'll looks like it's on them to visit really, I'd prob make an effort over summer. If they're staying local over Xmas, I'd visit one of those days

Parent 4 lives elsewhere im Europe, can't afford accommodation so relies on others for a place to stay when visiting as above re leave it on them but go over in the summer.

They can face time or call

Swipe left for the next trending thread