Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I want a sibling for our 4 year old but DH doesn’t want anymore

207 replies

Mangoandcoconut · 08/11/2022 17:12

As the title states.

I want our 4 year old DS to have a sibling but DH doesn’t want anymore.
Our son is suspected ASD/ADHD but definitely ND in some way.

We aren’t in a great financial position. But I think we could manage with one more. We have a spare bedroom too.

Anyway, he’s adamant he doesn’t want to do it again. The sleepless nights, the potty training, the colic, weaning and all the rest of it.

I don’t know where to go from here.
The thought of him not having a sibling makes me really sad…I have a brother who I was close to growing up and my DH has a brother and sister. So neither of us know what it’s like having no siblings.
I’m worried he’ll be lonely and have no one to play with as he grows up.

OP posts:
Trinxsy · 08/11/2022 19:45

DP took a while but finally we went for one more. This turned into a multiple pregnancy. DS has suspected additional needs and now one of our multiples is disabled. I wouldn't change any of it for the world but one more doesn't mean one more!

Sometimeswinning · 08/11/2022 19:44

BabyGrooverBug · 08/11/2022 18:53

In the same way that every child conceived by rape is grateful their mum got raped. Doesn't make it right.

We're comparing this situation to a woman being raped?? Not even close!!!

OrangePomander · 08/11/2022 19:40

I used my (apparently quite considerable) powers of persuasion to change dh’s mind. He now admits it was absolutely the right decision, but I appreciate it could have gone either way.

Irim · 08/11/2022 19:39

I too think people are generalising about disability and sibling age gap. My partner has two children (15 & 12) and I have a 7 year old. They all get on very well. We plan activities that they all can enjoy (cinema, gaming, laser quest, movie nights). The 15 year old has dyslexia/dyspraxia, the 12 year old has ADHD, and my 7 year old has ADHD and ASD. Yes there are challenges at times, but this could be attributed to having three children of varying personalities, rather than age gaps or disability. Overall, everyone is very happy and my partner and I are trying for another DC. We have a great life.

I will say though, that our DC are all 'higher functioning' (hate that phrase), I am not sure how it would be if there were additional needs or learning disabilities at play. My partner and I are also very laid back and easy going. It's just not as black and white as some posters are suggesting.

MollieMarie · 08/11/2022 19:37

mn29 · 08/11/2022 19:28

@MollieMarie ”Sorry but why is it all about what the wife wants?”
but equally why is it all about what the husband wants (ie no more children)?

In this situation someone is not going to get their wish. It will have to boil down to whether the wife feels her desire for more children is stronger than her desire to stay with her husband and likewise is the husband prepared to potentially sacrifice his marriage by insisting on no more children. Both their views are valid, the outcome will have to depend on what they each value the most.

Because a child is a massive 18 year long commitment?

The person who doesn't want another child is the one who should get the final decision. If someone doesn't want another child they shouldn't feel pressured or forced into having another. This is pretty much the unanimous opinion on this thread, apart from a couple who think the wife should get what she wants to save her feelings.

The husband wouldn't be sacrificing his marriage. If the wife chose to split the family apart to go and have more children with another man, that decision is on her.

sailinginthemed · 08/11/2022 19:34

This is tough. Could you wait till things are calmed financially. We were planning a five year age gap but secondary infertility got in the way and we are now looking at 9 years. I’m still happy with the gap though. I love the idea of big sibling, little sibling…and at the end of the day love is love. If they get on they will get on no matter what the age. Could you have the conversation again in a year or so?

Alexandernevermind · 08/11/2022 19:32

It has to be something you both want. It'll be a 5 year age gap, so you'll just have one in school and then you'll be starting again, which is tying you up with preschoolers for 9 years, which isn't great if you are working. They aren't going to play together particularly and won't hang out together as teens.

drpet49 · 08/11/2022 19:32

Weebachu · 08/11/2022 17:48

That's a good point from pp.

With a 5 year age gap they wouldn't be likely to play together really anyway.

Utter rubbish

mn29 · 08/11/2022 19:28

@MollieMarie ”Sorry but why is it all about what the wife wants?”
but equally why is it all about what the husband wants (ie no more children)?

In this situation someone is not going to get their wish. It will have to boil down to whether the wife feels her desire for more children is stronger than her desire to stay with her husband and likewise is the husband prepared to potentially sacrifice his marriage by insisting on no more children. Both their views are valid, the outcome will have to depend on what they each value the most.

bookworm14 · 08/11/2022 19:17

Many many people value the sibling bond and have more than one child because of it

But for many parents of one child, the issue is that they just don’t want any more children. I know the sibling bond can be great, but I don’t think it’s so great that it’s worth forcing myself to have another child simply to facilitate it. Presumably those who have multiple children ‘for the sibling bond’ also have those children because they feel broody and actively want another baby? What are those of us who never felt broody again after baby number one supposed to do?

Justwingingit18 · 08/11/2022 19:11

Throwing in a curve ball, I have an almost 6 year age gap due to secondary infertility and my kids get on well...of course they have their moments, but what siblings don't. The oldest is very good with youngest. Completely understand why you want another. I hope it works out for you.

paulaparticles · 08/11/2022 19:06

MollieMarie · 08/11/2022 19:01

What man can break his wife's heart like that and have to look at her forever. There are men who maybe aren't keen but will put their wives before themselves and agree to another one...

Sorry but why is it all about what the wife wants? What an entitled, selfish attitude. Is the husband just a background character there to produce sperm? Having another child is a massive 18 year long commitment, a man shouldn't feel forced to agree to another just so he doesn't hurt his wifes feelings. 🙄

Believe it or not it can and does happen.
Also if it we're your sister who was in this position would you be so cold...I'm guessing as it's an anonymous forum you wouldn't speak like this in reality if your sister's heart was broke.

Holly60 · 08/11/2022 19:02

RewildingAmbridge · 08/11/2022 18:04

Why have another child for the current child. I get along perfectly well with DB but we see each other maybe 6-8 times a year. He's not a biological best friend. DH was an only and perfectly happy with that.
Ultimately there's no compromise here, you can't force someone to have a child they don't want. It would be madness if the relationship is otherwise happy to end it to try and meet someone else who you might have a child with, who might get along with your current child.

I adore my brother, my SIL is literally my best friend and my DCs grew up with cousins who they are now super close to as adults. Extended family holidays and Christmases filled with love and laughter were normal. Our children and my niblings all have multiple children themselves and talk together fondly of their childhoods together.

What works for one doesn't work for another. Many many people value the sibling bond and have more than one child because of it

MollieMarie · 08/11/2022 19:01

paulaparticles · 08/11/2022 18:51

To those saying it wouldn't be a good idea to bring a baby into a house with sen child already, it isn't as black and white as that and can and does work for some (including myself) 🙄 in fact for me it's been an absolute blessing and best thing we ever did. Some men can change their mind too. What man can break his wife's heart like that and have to look at her forever. There are men who maybe aren't keen but will put their wives before themselves and agree to another one....
To the ones saying op just wants one for herself believe it or not some people will have another baby so their child won't be an only...so quick to jump on with opinions.
Also to the ones saying the bond won't be there due to age gap again not black and white 🙄 In fact my one of my sisters is 10 years younger than me and we have children the same age who are best friends. Dont be so rude and horrible with your words just because you may be done and content we are not all the same.

What man can break his wife's heart like that and have to look at her forever. There are men who maybe aren't keen but will put their wives before themselves and agree to another one...

Sorry but why is it all about what the wife wants? What an entitled, selfish attitude. Is the husband just a background character there to produce sperm? Having another child is a massive 18 year long commitment, a man shouldn't feel forced to agree to another just so he doesn't hurt his wifes feelings. 🙄

ScarlettSunset · 08/11/2022 19:01

I have a sibling. I don't get on at all with them. They are certainly not guaranteed to become best friends or even to not hate and resent each other.

It is hard when you want more and the other parent doesn't but it's not just about you. The additional expense would be on both of you, and lack of money could affect the whole family.

My advice would be to concentrate on the child you already have to give him the best chances in life that you can.

Snugglemonkey · 08/11/2022 18:58

JaneJeffer · 08/11/2022 18:17

@Greenshake just because the OP wants another doesn't mean she's not grateful for the child she has. Also it's not her fault that anyone else can't have a baby.

Indeed. I absolutely adore my firstborn, an IVF baby who overcame massive health issues early on. I am grateful for that child every day in life. Didn't stop me really wanting another, or going through lots more IVF to achieve a second pregnancy. I know it is highly unlikely I will be able to have any more and hope that I will reconcile myself to that with good grace. There is such a pull when you want a baby though. Experiencing that does not devalue any existing child!

LBFseBrom · 08/11/2022 18:58

There is no reason why your four year old should be lonely; keep an open house for schoolfriends, do fun things. Husband and I did and we brought up a very happy, well adjusted child.

Some things just aren't meant to be, you will adjust to the idea of having no more children. Enjoy what you have!

Snugglemonkey · 08/11/2022 18:54

JaneJeffer · 08/11/2022 18:14

Congratulations @Snugglemonkey

Thank you!

BabyGrooverBug · 08/11/2022 18:53

Sometimeswinning · 08/11/2022 18:36

I don't think @DarkKarmaIlama is alone. To be fair it seems to have worked out well. I'm sure their 3rd child is more than happy with the outcome.

In the same way that every child conceived by rape is grateful their mum got raped. Doesn't make it right.

BabyGrooverBug · 08/11/2022 18:52

DarkKarmaIlama · 08/11/2022 18:39

@BabyGrooverBug

If it makes you feel better to believe in that story then carry on 😁. That’s what you would think which is totally fair enough. I was glad I did what I did and if I could go back I would do it again.

He was under no obligation to stay married to me after I told him, but guess what I can’t be that bad 😜. Like I said we have a lovely life.

He's (probably) a decent bloke and he will regard the marriage itself as an obligation to stay with you, that's what marriage means.

Again, assuming he's a decent bloke, if he doesn't regard the marriage as an obligation to stay with you he will regard the three children as an obligation to stay.

A better question would be if, before you were married and when you had no kids if you'd said "I'm planning on getting pregnant by you and pass.it off as an accident" would be have left when he was totally free to leave.

Anyway, I've said what I think. I'll leave the last word to you.

paulaparticles · 08/11/2022 18:51

To those saying it wouldn't be a good idea to bring a baby into a house with sen child already, it isn't as black and white as that and can and does work for some (including myself) 🙄 in fact for me it's been an absolute blessing and best thing we ever did. Some men can change their mind too. What man can break his wife's heart like that and have to look at her forever. There are men who maybe aren't keen but will put their wives before themselves and agree to another one....
To the ones saying op just wants one for herself believe it or not some people will have another baby so their child won't be an only...so quick to jump on with opinions.
Also to the ones saying the bond won't be there due to age gap again not black and white 🙄 In fact my one of my sisters is 10 years younger than me and we have children the same age who are best friends. Dont be so rude and horrible with your words just because you may be done and content we are not all the same.

DarkKarmaIlama · 08/11/2022 18:47

@Sometimeswinning

You’re right, I’m not alone. Not the first, not the last.

Either that or I have at least two friends who are also rapey psychopaths for essentially pulling the same stunt 🤦‍♀️….. although what’s the saying? Birds of a feather flock together?

DarkKarmaIlama · 08/11/2022 18:39

@BabyGrooverBug

If it makes you feel better to believe in that story then carry on 😁. That’s what you would think which is totally fair enough. I was glad I did what I did and if I could go back I would do it again.

He was under no obligation to stay married to me after I told him, but guess what I can’t be that bad 😜. Like I said we have a lovely life.

Sometimeswinning · 08/11/2022 18:36

neverbeenskiing · 08/11/2022 18:28

Horrible advice. Tricking someone you claim to love into fathering a child they have explicitly said they do not want and framing it as just being "proactive" is bordering on psychopathic.

I don't think @DarkKarmaIlama is alone. To be fair it seems to have worked out well. I'm sure their 3rd child is more than happy with the outcome.

bloodyeverlastinghell · 08/11/2022 18:34

It's a big gap for a playmate. My eldest is 12 and the youngest 7 and they really don't play together; everyone will play with the 9yo soon to be 10 as there is more crossover in their interests.

They may be close when they are older but not right now.

Swipe left for the next trending thread