Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I want a sibling for our 4 year old but DH doesn’t want anymore

207 replies

Mangoandcoconut · 08/11/2022 17:12

As the title states.

I want our 4 year old DS to have a sibling but DH doesn’t want anymore.
Our son is suspected ASD/ADHD but definitely ND in some way.

We aren’t in a great financial position. But I think we could manage with one more. We have a spare bedroom too.

Anyway, he’s adamant he doesn’t want to do it again. The sleepless nights, the potty training, the colic, weaning and all the rest of it.

I don’t know where to go from here.
The thought of him not having a sibling makes me really sad…I have a brother who I was close to growing up and my DH has a brother and sister. So neither of us know what it’s like having no siblings.
I’m worried he’ll be lonely and have no one to play with as he grows up.

OP posts:
Irim · 10/11/2022 17:00

@Choconut The variation is so interesting. I'm still unpicking what is ASD, ADHD and personality in my DS. He thrives on being around others, adores my DP's kids, and would love a sibling. He's very outgoing and gregarious!

Choconut · 10/11/2022 15:07

Does your ds actually want a sibling? Mine with ASD is very glad that he's an only. What if your next also had ADHD and/or ASD? There's no certainty that they'll even like each other and I doubt they'd have much in common with the age gap especially if your second was a girl.

wickerhearth · 10/11/2022 14:00

There's gonna be a 5 years difference between them, not sure they would actually want to play together anymore?

MollieMarie · 10/11/2022 13:56

BadNomad · 10/11/2022 13:53

What's silly is the having a child for another child. That's a very foolish, risky reason to have a baby. It shouldn't even be a reason.

100%

No one is ever going to grow up and resent their parents or their childhood because they didn't have siblings. It's a total non issue.

Irim · 10/11/2022 13:55

@BadNomad Oh yes, I agree with you there.

JaneJeffer · 10/11/2022 13:54

the pregnancy and labour were so difficult for him with our first
Fuck sake

BadNomad · 10/11/2022 13:53

What's silly is the having a child for another child. That's a very foolish, risky reason to have a baby. It shouldn't even be a reason.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 10/11/2022 13:51

I think that the one who doesn’t want any more gets to choose.

i really wouldn’t leave your DH over it as I’m sure your son would prefer not to have a sibling to having to go through your divorce (and I say that as someone who is divorced).

Havign a sibling isn’t always all it’s cracked up to be.

Irim · 10/11/2022 13:49

@BadNomad Yes, but the point I was making is that it's not about age gap, it's about personality. You could have a one year age gap between siblings and not get along, a huge age gap and they have an excellent relationship. The argument of 'they might not get along' is a bit silly in my opinion.

BadNomad · 10/11/2022 13:31

Friends are a totally different situation. Friends are people you choose. Siblings aren't. You get what you're given with siblings.

sailinginthemed · 10/11/2022 13:26

Yes agree with @irim, two of my closest girl friends are 10 years older!

Irim · 10/11/2022 12:50

Also, some of my best friends are 10+ years older than me!

Irim · 10/11/2022 12:50

I also want to add my own sibling relationship too. My sister and I have a 6 year age gap. It was difficult as children, and it can be difficult as adults, but that has nothing to do with the age gap and everything to do with personality clashes (which could be the case regardless of age gap)!

HOWEVER, even though I have said it can sometimes be difficult with my sister because of our opposing personality traits, we both have young children and go for coffee or shopping 2-3 times per week, so I would say our relationship is pretty good on the whole!

purplemama1990 · 09/11/2022 15:51

I was in this position recently, my DH didn't want another child because "the pregnancy and labour were so difficult for him with our first" and also the sleepless nights, having two to run about after instead of one etc... we discussed it endlessly and he agreed to have another in the end, BUT that was only because he actually did want another and was just anxious about it. If he had decided no, there was no way I was bringing another child into the world when his dad obviously didn't want him. You both have to want another child to have one.

Also just want to add to the people saying age gaps of 5+ means they can't possibly be close just isn't true. I was super close with my older sister (5 years older) and my younger sister (6 years younger) while growing up. We're still pretty close now, but I guess when you're older the age gap doesn't matter anymore. But the point is that growing up, we were super close with each other. On the other hand, I have friends with siblings who are much closer in age and have never got along with them ever. It just depends on the kids, you never know if they will be close or not.

DollyDimples80 · 09/11/2022 14:03

I totally understand where you're coming from. I felt exactly the same and it was heartbreaking. As usual there's all the 'hard' answers on here saying you're being unreasonable. I think a woman's natural desire to have children is very strong. Luckily my husband agreed in the end but it took a long time. Also, i had to really understand what he was concerned about. Turns out he was quite traumatised by things that happened the first time. We agreed how to tackle having a second one and overcame his fears. Now I'm pregnant and he's super excited, but I honestly didn't think we'd ever get here. That being said, it was a bit different for us as we already had embryos frozen from ivf. If it had been starting from scratch and trying naturally I might have been more inclined to leave it.

RaRaRaspoutine · 09/11/2022 10:49

Just to say contrary to some posts here, the 5 year age gap never stopped my sibling and I getting on like a house on fire (I am the older one). But I know lots of only children who had lots of friends and never really missed siblings. If your DH doesn't want more then that's it really. You have a lovely family already.

FACupcake · 09/11/2022 10:10

@BabyGrooverBug Thanks for your honest advice. I think you may be right. I'm 37 and go from thinking "lots of older women have babies and it's fine" to "I would definitely struggle to get pregnant/have miscarriages/chromosomal issues" and it frightens the life out of me. I've been thinking about getting a cat so I might look into that again.

BabyGrooverBug · 09/11/2022 09:58

FACupcake · 09/11/2022 09:42

That's a good question and something DH and I have discussed. While I can't be 100% sure having another one will make the broodiness go away, I don't think I would want a third. The biggest factor being my age as I'm late 30s now and already am painfully aware of age related risks in pregnancy, so I wouldn't want to have a baby in my 40s. Also I've never seen us as a "big" family and two kids would feel right. We couldn't afford three kids anyway and it's not something I could imagine myself wanting. I'm also aware that there was a time when I was happy with none and then happy with one, so never say never, but I genuinely think I wouldn't want a third.

There is the sibling aspect too, even though it's not the reason I want another child. Our existing child is such a caring and loving kid and would be great with a little sibling. We've also had issues with both of our families, so bar my brother and nieces who live abroad, our child will not have any other family around when they're older. I know it's not a good enough reason to have another child but something I do think about sometimes.

I've changed my mind - late 30's when you're not both 100pc sure - don't do it. High risks. Almost inevitable miscarriage (or two or four). There's potentially a lot of misery and heartache between now and a baby. Potentially swapping one misery for another.

IMHO, put your efforts into the one you have.

Computers and social media render siblings redundant these days!

MrsSkylerWhite · 09/11/2022 09:49

MollieMarie · Yesterday 17:18
Your DH doesn't want any more so that's that, really.

There's plenty of positives to being an only child, and there's no guarantee siblings will get on anyway.

Also, your son is ND so being able to give him your undivided support will be a huge plus for him”

This. My mum had me with an abusive husband so my older brother could have a sibling. He hated me, made my life physically and mentally hell and I cut him out of my life 40 years ago.

DarkKarmaIlama · 09/11/2022 09:47

@AnnoyedHumph

Sounds like it would have always been a disaster irrespective of gaps. My sister is 5 years older than me and we get on very well. Other sibling is 3 years older but we have less in common. Sounds like a personality clash and nothing much to do with a gap.

Willyoujustbequiet · 09/11/2022 09:46

As the parent of kids with additional needs yanbu. He's entitled to his view obviously but this would be a deal breaker for me.

I couldn't not dwell on them being alone in the future.

AnnoyedHumph · 09/11/2022 09:45

5 year age gap was a disaster for me and my sister. We still don’t speak.

FACupcake · 09/11/2022 09:42

toomuchlaundry · 09/11/2022 09:27

@FACupcake will you stop wanting more children if you have another child or will you then want another and then another (or the want will be there even if you stop at 2)

That's a good question and something DH and I have discussed. While I can't be 100% sure having another one will make the broodiness go away, I don't think I would want a third. The biggest factor being my age as I'm late 30s now and already am painfully aware of age related risks in pregnancy, so I wouldn't want to have a baby in my 40s. Also I've never seen us as a "big" family and two kids would feel right. We couldn't afford three kids anyway and it's not something I could imagine myself wanting. I'm also aware that there was a time when I was happy with none and then happy with one, so never say never, but I genuinely think I wouldn't want a third.

There is the sibling aspect too, even though it's not the reason I want another child. Our existing child is such a caring and loving kid and would be great with a little sibling. We've also had issues with both of our families, so bar my brother and nieces who live abroad, our child will not have any other family around when they're older. I know it's not a good enough reason to have another child but something I do think about sometimes.

toomuchlaundry · 09/11/2022 09:27

@FACupcake will you stop wanting more children if you have another child or will you then want another and then another (or the want will be there even if you stop at 2)

CarmenBizet · 09/11/2022 09:26

YABU.

If one person doesn't want another, you can't have another. So your options are accept this and try come to terms with being one and done or split and try your luck elsewhere to have another child.

I'm in your shoes btw, have an almost three year old and want a second. DH doesn't. Can't have a child that isn't wanted by both parents, it's deeply unfair on literally everyone and would end in tears in pretty much 90% of the scenarios I can envisage.

Never have a child 'for' an existing child, btw. Own it. You want a child because YOU want a child, that's perfectly valid. You can't have a kid for another kid, there's no telling whether it would be a benefit for them or a net drain on their life. They could hate each other, they could be permanently estranged as adults like me and mine, they could bully one another, you could roll the dice and end up with a child with severe disabilities that absorbs all of your time and resources and leaves your existing child invisible.

It's very painful and I feel for you, it's agony some days. But I have choices, as do you. One of those choices isn't to have a child with someone who doesn't want one.