Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think £400 board to parents...

289 replies

mumofteenss · 08/11/2022 15:13

is fair under these circumstances?

For context, my son is 19, this is his first job. He finished college last June having spent 3 years there doing vocational/skill-based courses. He's not academic so uni wasn't something he wanted, but he's very active and practical/logical-minded. I said while he was in education I would 100% support him; even if he had a job, he could keep all that income. He chose not to find a part-time job, entirely his choice.

Since June any support I received for him stopped, I'm a single parent, and I work full time, but my wage isn't a lot so I received UC and CB to top it up. As soon as he finished college all the elements for him stopped. I made him aware of this. These reductions in my income were around £350 a month.

He did find this job fairly quickly in mid-July, but due to the nature of the role, it required DBS checks which were a nightmare to sort out when he had no ID or statements. But we sorted it for mid-August. He's been waiting since then to start and finally started this week.

The wage he will be getting at 19 is not terrible. It equates to around £1300 a month after tax and whatnot. I have said I think £400 is fair, and I will continue to pay for everything he received up until now, all meals, if we have take out or eat out ill pay. If he wants to take over his own phone contract, apple music, xbox live, etc (all combined with them for my other children still so I don't mind keeping these) and he wants to arrange all of that himself, then he can give me £350 instead.

I see it as for 6 months I have 100% supported him with no income at all, in fact, I have really struggled to do so, but have not said anything as he was waiting to start this job. But I do need to recoup this money somehow and feel asking him to contribute that much is fair.

He will still have £900 a month, which is a damn sight more than I have spare, and very few outgoings as the workplace is within walking distance, and I in fact work on the same site so days our shifts line up he can come with me.

Is £400 a month a fair amount?

OP posts:
Fattoushi · 09/11/2022 19:39

Of course not, it's not income. It's just him paying part of his own way in the house.

celticprincess · 09/11/2022 19:38

Random question here. But do you have to pay tax/declare his money as income?? How does this work?

But yea that’s a reasonable amount. At 18 I was a student and my parents gave me what the local authority told them to which equated to the grant. I still had to get a part time job to be able to have spending money as although they earned enough for me not to get a grant, they didn’t really have that much as disposable income so I got as much as they could afford. By 22 I graduated in the city I had studied in so I paid my own rent and bills straight out of my salary. Back then a 2 bed flat, council tax, utilities, insurance, food and travel etc pretty much ate up my income. Rent was reasonable though. But then a year later I did manage to get a mortgage and buy. I never lived at home once I earned money.

it’s something I’d have to consider in future for my own children though. Single parent also on tax credits etc means a lot of income would stop when they turn 18. I do think it’s tricky for parents who revenue additional benefits related to their children once they leave home. If the child stay home and earns they can help contribute to the loss but if they move out (which seems much harder these days) then the parent can potentially lose alot of money.

Doggate1 · 09/11/2022 19:30

Great news!

Onekidnoclue · 09/11/2022 19:26

Op you’re doing absolutely the right thing. The only suggestion I might have is taking more and putting it into savings for him as I think £900 is a shit load of spending money and could be used to get him used to a lifestyle he can’t sustain. Having said that I think you’re 100% doing the right thing by your child and you. X

maddiemookins16mum · 09/11/2022 18:52

Totally fair. There are not many working adults with a spare 900 a month as spending money.

Familydilemmas · 09/11/2022 18:51

My gosh some awful comments on here. It sounds like a fair amount in these circumstances and it’s actually preparing him well for when he lives independently.

Band 6 roles in my department for the ones telling you to go for that, include a year of study at a lesser wage than top 5 to then get less than £100 a month more for the first 2 years of being a 6. Lots of nurses want to remain a 6 because they actually want to nurse rather than manage or become less clinical depending on area. I can’t believe with the news about nurses wages people are still so naïve to think the answer is that simple. A band 5 nursing job should be enough to support a family.

Clarinet1 · 09/11/2022 18:41

Haven’t RTFT and the family situation may have been slightly different but I was paying my DM £400 per month over 30 years ago so I can’t see that the OP is being U!

ohmyohmy123 · 09/11/2022 18:38

Mine oldest is now 22 and has been paying £400 a month since they got a job at 18. It's so important to get used to that outgoing straight away. Ready for when they get a place of their own, either rent or mortgage as they are used to it coming out.

Granted we do save half in an account ready for a mortgage but dc doesn't know that and doesn't begrudge paying.

Also they live with their partner over the weekend, very rarely eat at home, pay own phone bill, toiletries, lunches etc.

£400 is a fair amount if your household needs the income.

Highover · 09/11/2022 18:20

Sounds very reasonable to me. For those of you who wouldn’t charge your child rent, Why should their earnings be for fun and yours for bills? Doesn’t seem fair to me.

MRSDoos · 09/11/2022 18:09

It sounds like a fair amount. I paid £200 to my parents on that kind of wage but it is all relative to income etc from parents. Everything in your OP sounds fair enough. 100% agree with the posters who said maybe take some more off him to save! Or make sure he saves half of that £900 he will be left with. He could have a nice deposit saved up in 3+ years!

Wonderfulstuff · 09/11/2022 18:09

Wow - there's some horrible comments on this thread from all parties.

OP - you sound like you're sorted the only thing I'd suggest is getting him to take over his phone bill - it's a good thing to be responsible for and it will help him start building his own credit rating too.

Just to add,because it feels like a little balance is needed, I didn't get charged rent when I moved back home at 22 on the proviso that I saved that money for a deposit instead. I bought my first place at 24. The logic being that my parents didn't have a lump sum to give me for a deposit (not saying they should but I know they'd have loved to have been able to) but they could afford to give me a room and food and instead I used those 2 years to save up myself. Forever grateful and no, despite what others may say, I didn't then live a life of squandering my salary left right and centre just because they helped me. In fact I was super conscious that I'd never get another opportunity to save like that again.

mumofteenss · 09/11/2022 18:06

Doggate1 · 09/11/2022 18:00

You should also consider this is ‘income to you’ so when you declare this you could end up with less benefits etc. worth putting in to a calculator to check. Also, maybe think about taking more and putting some away for him - if he has it he may well spend it whereas you could save some for him!

To clarify, once he is over 21 £77 is deducted from an award regardless of how much they contribute. Under 21 my UC is not effected by any contributions made.

OP posts:
mumofteenss · 09/11/2022 18:02

Doggate1 · 09/11/2022 18:00

You should also consider this is ‘income to you’ so when you declare this you could end up with less benefits etc. worth putting in to a calculator to check. Also, maybe think about taking more and putting some away for him - if he has it he may well spend it whereas you could save some for him!

Its not considered income its his portion of housing costs now he isnt on my UC. Ive spoken to numerous advisers.

OP posts:
Doggate1 · 09/11/2022 18:00

You should also consider this is ‘income to you’ so when you declare this you could end up with less benefits etc. worth putting in to a calculator to check. Also, maybe think about taking more and putting some away for him - if he has it he may well spend it whereas you could save some for him!

Grrrrdarling · 09/11/2022 17:55

mumofteenss · 08/11/2022 15:13

is fair under these circumstances?

For context, my son is 19, this is his first job. He finished college last June having spent 3 years there doing vocational/skill-based courses. He's not academic so uni wasn't something he wanted, but he's very active and practical/logical-minded. I said while he was in education I would 100% support him; even if he had a job, he could keep all that income. He chose not to find a part-time job, entirely his choice.

Since June any support I received for him stopped, I'm a single parent, and I work full time, but my wage isn't a lot so I received UC and CB to top it up. As soon as he finished college all the elements for him stopped. I made him aware of this. These reductions in my income were around £350 a month.

He did find this job fairly quickly in mid-July, but due to the nature of the role, it required DBS checks which were a nightmare to sort out when he had no ID or statements. But we sorted it for mid-August. He's been waiting since then to start and finally started this week.

The wage he will be getting at 19 is not terrible. It equates to around £1300 a month after tax and whatnot. I have said I think £400 is fair, and I will continue to pay for everything he received up until now, all meals, if we have take out or eat out ill pay. If he wants to take over his own phone contract, apple music, xbox live, etc (all combined with them for my other children still so I don't mind keeping these) and he wants to arrange all of that himself, then he can give me £350 instead.

I see it as for 6 months I have 100% supported him with no income at all, in fact, I have really struggled to do so, but have not said anything as he was waiting to start this job. But I do need to recoup this money somehow and feel asking him to contribute that much is fair.

He will still have £900 a month, which is a damn sight more than I have spare, and very few outgoings as the workplace is within walking distance, and I in fact work on the same site so days our shifts line up he can come with me.

Is £400 a month a fair amount?

I’d move in if I only had to pay £400 a month.
Totally reasonable amount. To be honest I would give him a break down of your financial responsibilities for the home, for a month, so he can see how little his £400 will actually cover in the grand scheme of things. If he has any sense he will be grateful, save £200 a month of his earnings each month & learn to appreciate what income he has & what you provide for the small amount he pays for board & lodgings.
If he doesn’t like it he can try to find somewhere else to live but he won’t have much change from £1300 if he chooses to do so. He also won’t have a cook, cleaner or maid!!

itsgettingweird · 08/11/2022 21:03

Jalepenojello · 08/11/2022 19:33

How will you cope when he moves out? Is he using £300-£400 of of food and energy every month? That seems like an awful lot to me

OP has already said Shen he moves out she can move to a smaller home and will have cheaper rent.

itsgettingweird · 08/11/2022 21:00

Nuka couldn't agree more with anything you've said or replied with on here.

itsgettingweird · 08/11/2022 20:58

NukaColaQuantum · 08/11/2022 18:32

Some people really have zero clue as to how restricted you are in terms of working when you’re a single parent with an ex who decides to just fucking disappear.

Relying on benefits isn’t a choice we make, it’s forced upon us. So is having your career stagnate therefore no extra money, not being able to take on a second job therefore no extra money, having to rent rather than buy and UC will cover about 50% of the cost if you’re lucky because LHAs are not reflective of real world private rental costs, etc etc.

👏👏👏👏👏👏

itsgettingweird · 08/11/2022 20:56

We'd pay the leccy gas whatever because we would be anyway.

The “leccy”, gas, etc would be less without an extra adult in the house. Showers and laundry cost money. A house share would cost a lot more.

Precisely. My ds is at college doing a foundation degree and runs a 2 screen gaming computer and studies at home once a week.

He is also a swimmer so has more washing than me. (Swim and gym kits) And more showering!

He also has a day off a week as works 2 full days and so is using electric when I'm not in.

On top of that we have a car because he's disabled. I wouldn't need one without him requiring it for lifts to training and work and the fact he can't use public transport.

Ds does find his own swimming from his PIP. Or else I'd need to charge using that because I can't work more because I have to care for him.

People often have no idea what life is like for those who don't have stability or simple 2 working adults or ability to have 2 incomes.

MuggleMe · 08/11/2022 20:42

@HPFA £200 is quite low still, think about how much an adult costs just for food, plus electricity, water, any toiletries you buy her. Just to 'break even', and even then she's probably got loads more disposable income than you!

Bintymcbintface · 08/11/2022 20:24

I was replying to a PP that said they'd take more as £900 was too much disposable income for someone so young, I wasn't getting at OP I think she's being fair

Harpydragon · 08/11/2022 20:21

My 18.year old is on a similar wage. He pays us 25% of his wages for bed & board and 25% into an ISA for a house deposit. That gives him 20% savings for holidays, presents, etc and 30% for his phone, gym membership, travel exprnses, toiletries and day to day spends.

We supported him whilst he was in education but now he's working he needs to support himself. He's getting a good deal, he certainly would not be able to live anywhere else as cheaply, nothing has changed for him beyond he has to give us some of his wages, we are getting help with the bills, which in this current climate is really helpful. He has the added benefit of being able to save a deposit for a house and once he gets his own place, he is already used to using 50% of his salary for essential bills, so we are setting him up to be able to successfully manage his money. Win win!

Imnothereforthegiggles · 08/11/2022 20:18

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Bintymcbintface · 08/11/2022 20:16

He earned it so he can spend it on whatever the hell he wants. I get making up the short-fall with loss of CB etc but taking more because he has too much to yourself, that's just cruel

Lotusmonster · 08/11/2022 20:14

Gosh, so very fair of you. I really hope he willingly agrees to this OP.