Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think £400 board to parents...

289 replies

mumofteenss · 08/11/2022 15:13

is fair under these circumstances?

For context, my son is 19, this is his first job. He finished college last June having spent 3 years there doing vocational/skill-based courses. He's not academic so uni wasn't something he wanted, but he's very active and practical/logical-minded. I said while he was in education I would 100% support him; even if he had a job, he could keep all that income. He chose not to find a part-time job, entirely his choice.

Since June any support I received for him stopped, I'm a single parent, and I work full time, but my wage isn't a lot so I received UC and CB to top it up. As soon as he finished college all the elements for him stopped. I made him aware of this. These reductions in my income were around £350 a month.

He did find this job fairly quickly in mid-July, but due to the nature of the role, it required DBS checks which were a nightmare to sort out when he had no ID or statements. But we sorted it for mid-August. He's been waiting since then to start and finally started this week.

The wage he will be getting at 19 is not terrible. It equates to around £1300 a month after tax and whatnot. I have said I think £400 is fair, and I will continue to pay for everything he received up until now, all meals, if we have take out or eat out ill pay. If he wants to take over his own phone contract, apple music, xbox live, etc (all combined with them for my other children still so I don't mind keeping these) and he wants to arrange all of that himself, then he can give me £350 instead.

I see it as for 6 months I have 100% supported him with no income at all, in fact, I have really struggled to do so, but have not said anything as he was waiting to start this job. But I do need to recoup this money somehow and feel asking him to contribute that much is fair.

He will still have £900 a month, which is a damn sight more than I have spare, and very few outgoings as the workplace is within walking distance, and I in fact work on the same site so days our shifts line up he can come with me.

Is £400 a month a fair amount?

OP posts:
x2boys · 10/11/2022 06:15

Some people really need to take their priviliged heads out of their priviliged backsides
This is an adult son earning an adult wage why shouldnt he pay a contribution ?
I know this is hoing to blow some mumsnetters minds but not everyone goes to university
As for all those who tske a percentage of their adult childs earning ,s and secretly save it for them ,w
How does mummy saving for them teach them the value of money?

mumofteenss · 10/11/2022 01:12

Appleblum · 10/11/2022 01:11

I find the concept of asking your just turned 18 child to compensate you for your lost 'income' from CB and UC totally bizarre. They don't owe you that!

However it is reasonable to ask him for a contribution since he is now working. £400 sounds high to me personally, but it's a figure you have to arrive at together with your child.

Hes 19. Not even just 19. Hes closer to 20...

OP posts:
Appleblum · 10/11/2022 01:11

I find the concept of asking your just turned 18 child to compensate you for your lost 'income' from CB and UC totally bizarre. They don't owe you that!

However it is reasonable to ask him for a contribution since he is now working. £400 sounds high to me personally, but it's a figure you have to arrive at together with your child.

thetimehascomesaidthewalrus · 09/11/2022 23:49

Placemarking this very useful discussion

wentworthinmate · 09/11/2022 21:44

I charged my boy £400 p/m until he moved out 18 months ago and he earned less than your son at the time.

londonrach · 09/11/2022 21:38

Very fair and a bargain.....

MrsRinaDecker · 09/11/2022 21:38

I told ds that if he wanted to live at home for uni, he would have to make a similar contribution, as like you I lost benefits once he left education. We worked through the figures together, and both agreed we were in the right ballpark. For him, it helped tip the balance towards moving into halls versus commuting in to uni, and he now rents a flat with his girlfriend (they’re both still students). I think it’s benefited him that he’s never had it cushy living at home with no rent or bills - he’s learned to budget and works hard at his course and part time job.

mumofteenss · 09/11/2022 21:37

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

I know you are right, thank you. I just already feel shitty about having to ask him for anything at all, so trying to justify to myself as well as the negative posters.

Thank you though

OP posts:
stacyvaron · 09/11/2022 21:29

I would say 1/2 of his income would be fair. He certainly couldn't live elsewhere for that, and it would allow you to build up a bit of savings.

Imnothereforthegiggles · 09/11/2022 21:23

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Imnothereforthegiggles · 09/11/2022 21:17

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

mumofteenss · 09/11/2022 21:14

CoffeeMama1 · 09/11/2022 21:06

Personally I think that's a huge amount, but I appreciate times are tough. You do just have to remember that the more he pays the longer it'll take him to save to move out too, so depends if that's high on your priority list. As someone who had to pay rent as soon as I turned 18, my opinion is probably a bit biased but the insistence from my parents that I contributed financially meant I stayed in/got jobs that weren't any good for me and made me miserable, and I was unable to continue to pursue any training or further education I wanted because I still had to pay my way. At the end of the day his future opportunities and prospects shouldn't be compromised for income now, it never works well in the long term.

My son is not academic. He didnt pass gcses despite trying his best. He came out with grades that for him were great, for progressing in eduction not so great. He has no desire to continue education but I encouraged and supported him to go to college and do training courses that were more vocational and he did for 3 years.

Now, however, he has a job that to outside may not seem that great, but to him, its a job he has spoken about wanting to do for knocking close to 5 years from when he was admitted to hospital for a prolonged period of time due to a serious illness.

He isnt in a job he hates, he is in a job he has aspired to do, and a very necessary and valued role within the NHS. A role that does offer some progression, and job satisfaction. One that i supported him in getting by filling in applications as he is severely dyslexic, one I attended interviews with him (i sat outside) as he was anxious. I took him to occupational health appointments. Helped him source all his dbs for. Paid £90 whatever it was for a passport cos he needed ID and he didnt have one that was valid as holidays aren't a luxury we have.

I have not nor ever would force him into a job he hated. This is a job he wanted, and aspired for, despite how much people try to look down on.

Im immensely proud of him for securing and and doing a job that was his goal.

OP posts:
TheBigFatMermaid · 09/11/2022 21:09

My 17 year old DD got a great job during the summer holidays and I felt she might not want to do a 2nd year of college. I told her straight that the benefits I get for her in full time education equal £350 and to give up College and stay here, she would need to replace that.

This is the reality for those of us on low incomes!

The money to pay for us, as a 4 person family has to come from somewhere. My partners job doesn't cover it all, even though it's not minimum wage, UC and child benefit are essential. She costs us a lot, more than her brother, so it's only fair she covers what we would lose by her giving up College (although still not all she costs).

YANBU, OP, from someone who understands where you're coming from!

Imnothereforthegiggles · 09/11/2022 21:08

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Imnothereforthegiggles · 09/11/2022 21:06

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

CoffeeMama1 · 09/11/2022 21:06

Personally I think that's a huge amount, but I appreciate times are tough. You do just have to remember that the more he pays the longer it'll take him to save to move out too, so depends if that's high on your priority list. As someone who had to pay rent as soon as I turned 18, my opinion is probably a bit biased but the insistence from my parents that I contributed financially meant I stayed in/got jobs that weren't any good for me and made me miserable, and I was unable to continue to pursue any training or further education I wanted because I still had to pay my way. At the end of the day his future opportunities and prospects shouldn't be compromised for income now, it never works well in the long term.

Renalmum · 09/11/2022 21:05

Rhondaa · 08/11/2022 19:36

'In my dept all band 6 roles are filled, there are very few across the trust as whole at the minute.'

They won't always be filled though, see if opportunities arise with mat leaves etc. Band 5s tend to be for newly qualified or the first year or 2 post qualifying. Keep your eyes peeled and see if there are secondments, training etc. I do think the key to replacing the UC is trying to work your way up a bit. Hard when kids are small but if they are all teens now you should get more free time for studying etc. Good luck.

@Janiie what you have said about band 5 and band 6 post is just not true. If that was the case wards would be full of band 6s. Where I work there are only 4 band 6s and the rest band 5s. And this is the case in most of the wards in the very large educational trauma hospital that I work. I've been a band 5 for 26 years. I have no interest in being a band 6.

Renalmum · 09/11/2022 20:57

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

@Imnothereforthegiggles oh my god THANK YOU so much for saying everything I've been thinking. I've been sat here in total disbelieve at some of these posts.

Bollindger · 09/11/2022 20:56

I would write him a list of all Bills he would pay if he moved out.
Rent
Council Tax.
Internet.
Utilities the daily charge included.
Food at £50 a week.
Also ask him to do his own washing for a week.
Then ask him if he is still thinking your over charging him.

Bonbon21 · 09/11/2022 20:19

400 is a very fair amount.. but please ensure that you treat him like an adult now he is working.
And that means he has to do his share of shopping, cooking laundry, cleaning etc...
And have a serious talk about savings... short and long term.. if he starts now it will be a habit for life... before he gets used to £900 spending money a month!!!

BooneyBeautiful · 09/11/2022 20:08

twilightermummy · 08/11/2022 16:25

I still think that you’ll be out of pocket with all the extras that you afford him.

Anyway, in response to your question, you are not being unreasonable in the slightest. My mum and her husband have my 30+ year old brother living with them rent-free. He earns a very good wage, has saved thousands, doesn’t contribute to food costs, has a free babysitter for when his daughter visits and it’s all to my mum’s detriment. She and our stepdad are on such a low income that they’d probably be entitled to some top up from universal credit or the cost of living payment to help them, I’m not sure, but unfortunately she cannot apply for anything with him in the house as he has such a good income. He’s always on his high horse looking down at the rest of us struggling but we just laugh because obviously we understand the true cost of bills etc. He very nearly bought his own place but once he became aware that he may not have much left out of his wage after bills were deducted, he pulled out! I love my brother very much btw but I will not make the mistakes my mum has with my children.

IMO you are making the very sensible choice of giving him a dose of the responsibilities of the real world. It’s unlikely that he would pay such a small cost even in a house share.

Your mum and her husband should definitely look at a Benefit Calculator as what your brother earns shouldn't affect their claim for UC, only with regard to Local Housing Allowance and Council Tax Benefit (he is classed as a non-dependent due to his age). benefits-calculator.turn2us.org.uk/

Sadly, it is too late now for them to be considered for any of the recent Cost of Living payments, but they have got nothing to lose by checking their entitlement.

Kitesk · 09/11/2022 19:55

Middleagedspreadisreal · 09/11/2022 19:41

Tbh, I think it's excessive. I was a single parent too but it would never have entered my head to think, let alone say, that I 'needed to recoup' anything I'd spent before my DS got a f/t job! I took half that from him, he bought his own toiletries etc. He managed to save for a deposit for his own house that way.

How many years ago was you a single mum??

Imnothereforthegiggles · 09/11/2022 19:52

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Eatdrinkbemerry · 09/11/2022 19:46

@Sarahzxcvb - that was a really mean and spiteful comment. Disgusting

Middleagedspreadisreal · 09/11/2022 19:41

Tbh, I think it's excessive. I was a single parent too but it would never have entered my head to think, let alone say, that I 'needed to recoup' anything I'd spent before my DS got a f/t job! I took half that from him, he bought his own toiletries etc. He managed to save for a deposit for his own house that way.