Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think £400 board to parents...

289 replies

mumofteenss · 08/11/2022 15:13

is fair under these circumstances?

For context, my son is 19, this is his first job. He finished college last June having spent 3 years there doing vocational/skill-based courses. He's not academic so uni wasn't something he wanted, but he's very active and practical/logical-minded. I said while he was in education I would 100% support him; even if he had a job, he could keep all that income. He chose not to find a part-time job, entirely his choice.

Since June any support I received for him stopped, I'm a single parent, and I work full time, but my wage isn't a lot so I received UC and CB to top it up. As soon as he finished college all the elements for him stopped. I made him aware of this. These reductions in my income were around £350 a month.

He did find this job fairly quickly in mid-July, but due to the nature of the role, it required DBS checks which were a nightmare to sort out when he had no ID or statements. But we sorted it for mid-August. He's been waiting since then to start and finally started this week.

The wage he will be getting at 19 is not terrible. It equates to around £1300 a month after tax and whatnot. I have said I think £400 is fair, and I will continue to pay for everything he received up until now, all meals, if we have take out or eat out ill pay. If he wants to take over his own phone contract, apple music, xbox live, etc (all combined with them for my other children still so I don't mind keeping these) and he wants to arrange all of that himself, then he can give me £350 instead.

I see it as for 6 months I have 100% supported him with no income at all, in fact, I have really struggled to do so, but have not said anything as he was waiting to start this job. But I do need to recoup this money somehow and feel asking him to contribute that much is fair.

He will still have £900 a month, which is a damn sight more than I have spare, and very few outgoings as the workplace is within walking distance, and I in fact work on the same site so days our shifts line up he can come with me.

Is £400 a month a fair amount?

OP posts:
Kattiekat · 10/11/2022 16:13

His room is there and you would pay for it and the rent regardless and I understand you lose your UC and CB but you would have used that for other things such as his clothing and school dinners. Which you won’t be doing now.
I would say ask for:
what you lose in single persons council tax
half utilities
half food and household goods shopping
then add £100 or however much to get the total he gives you to £400 and you should put aside for him should he wish to make a large purchase in the future such as driving lessons, a car or property deposit.

ivykaty44 · 10/11/2022 16:12

england.shelter.org.uk/housing_advice/benefits/housing_benefit_deductions_when_living_with_non_dependants

this gives the table of what a non dependant should be contributing, its variable depending on what they earn and your UC etc will be based on these same amounts

£400 is less than he is required to contribute at £106 per week for his gross earning which works out at approximately £459 per month

Leopardprintisaneutral · 10/11/2022 15:55

That's about what I earn and it would be a dream to only pay out that much every month. Can I come and live with you?

Tallulah28 · 10/11/2022 15:47

EscapeRoomToTheSun · 08/11/2022 15:46

I would probably need to take a bit more in that situation tbh. What's he going to spend his £900 a month on! I don't think loads of disposable income is necessarily good for young lads tbh.

He’s an adult though… why it be fair to take more than is needed purely because he’s a “young lad”?

GrandOleOpryNights · 10/11/2022 15:09

I asked on this post because i felt like a terrible parent

You don’t come across like that at all on the whole. You sound like someone who thinks they are doing the right thing and with not earning a high wage, you’ve explained that there’s no choice but to charge this amount anyway. What would you have done if everyone said you were unreasonable? You can’t pay your bills without charging around this amount. So....?

I think you knew how this thread would go, mostly people saying well done to you and making shitty digs at others who don’t charge as their kids are apparently doomed and heading for financial failure.

Unpleasant and pointless. But I think you knew what you were doing.

Imnothereforthegiggles · 10/11/2022 14:50

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

mumofteenss · 10/11/2022 14:44

Mollymoostoo · 10/11/2022 13:51

Okay let's look at this then. All new cars have to be Electric with a cost of approx £30k. Plus charging point. Deposit for a house will take years to save for.
His generation is the first one in years that will be financially worse off than their parents. To be so spiteful that we begrudge how much our children earn is wrong. He did the right thing and got an education and is now earning a wage. In the future he will need to provide for a family. It isn't up to spiteful people on a forum to say how much disposable income a young man should have. If the poor lad wasn't earning, he would be vilified, because he earns more than his mum he is also in the wrong. Why do people have children and expect them to cover their costs. When the kids move out who picks up the tab then?

He doesnt earn more than me. I have a good job, but due to being a single parent my shift time are limited for now so i only earn basic pay. I currently rent a large 4 bed house so each teen has their own room, once he leaves, we will move to a 3 bed, then a 2 bed when there's only 1 left or i am on me own. My outgoings will reduce massively as rent on a 4 bed is massive. I have considered the future. All that i have explained numerous times.

If he refuses to contribute, then i will have to look at downsizing sooner, and he would have to look at renting his own place or a houseshare sooner. However, at the minute, he is more than agreeing to £400.

I asked on this post because i felt like a terrible parent, but realistically asking him for that much money is better than asking him to move out as i need to move to a smaller place, surely?

OP posts:
sheepdogdelight · 10/11/2022 14:22

Hebsint your partner, he is your son and to say £900 I enough for him is not your call. You need to get a job that pays more because if he moves out you are screwed.

Surely if OP's DS thinks that £900 is not enough for him, then it's up to him to go out and get a job that pays more?

sheepdogdelight · 10/11/2022 14:19

£400 is what we charge 18 year old DS who is on a similar wage.

He didn't even blink when we asked for it.
Probably because he realises that this is actually a very good deal (it would cost him at least double to live in a room in a shared house independently and then he'd have to do things like all his own cooking and laundry, rather than these being shared tasks).

PinkyFlamingo · 10/11/2022 13:59

Notthetoothfairy · 08/11/2022 15:52

This. I would never charge my sons to live at home (or, if I did, it would only be because I was secretly putting that amount away for them as savings).

Good for you you can afford it then, well done you. Meanwhile back in tne real world I can't imagine there are many working adults who can afford to support an extra working adult to.

x2boys · 10/11/2022 13:56

Mollymoostoo · 10/11/2022 13:51

Okay let's look at this then. All new cars have to be Electric with a cost of approx £30k. Plus charging point. Deposit for a house will take years to save for.
His generation is the first one in years that will be financially worse off than their parents. To be so spiteful that we begrudge how much our children earn is wrong. He did the right thing and got an education and is now earning a wage. In the future he will need to provide for a family. It isn't up to spiteful people on a forum to say how much disposable income a young man should have. If the poor lad wasn't earning, he would be vilified, because he earns more than his mum he is also in the wrong. Why do people have children and expect them to cover their costs. When the kids move out who picks up the tab then?

The irony in you calling those who live in the real world spiteful....

x2boys · 10/11/2022 13:54

Mollymoostoo · 10/11/2022 13:45

Hebsint your partner, he is your son and to say £900 I enough for him is not your call. You need to get a job that pays more because if he moves out you are screwed.
Parents choose to have children and to say the child has to make up for the shortfall for lost benefits is unfair.
The cost of getting a car, insurance etc is astronomical and he will never get on the property ladder if he doesn't have decent savings.
Look at making your own position financially viable because if he doesn't agree to your demands, what will you do? If you kick him out, you are screwed, if he leaves you are screwed.

Dont be utterly ridiculous ,the op has said if he moves out ,she would down size saving her rent and saving in utilties ,this is a fully grown adult eaning a full time wage ,if he was to move out he would have far less then £900/ month 🙄

Buttonjugs · 10/11/2022 13:52

Some of us don’t get the choice as low earners on universal credit. As soon as the child leaves full time education you lose a huge amount of money. It’s perfectly reasonable to expect a working adult to contribute. If he were to move out he would be paying that AND buying his own food. My son is on the autistic spectrum and gets ESA and PIP. He contributes as much as I do because otherwise we wouldn’t survive.

Mollymoostoo · 10/11/2022 13:51

CoffeeMama1 · 10/11/2022 09:01

Again, I never said that. I replied to the OP already, my comment was simply another point of view, and wasn't shaming or attacking, it obviously didn't take into account her son's feelings as that wasn't something that had been made known!

Okay let's look at this then. All new cars have to be Electric with a cost of approx £30k. Plus charging point. Deposit for a house will take years to save for.
His generation is the first one in years that will be financially worse off than their parents. To be so spiteful that we begrudge how much our children earn is wrong. He did the right thing and got an education and is now earning a wage. In the future he will need to provide for a family. It isn't up to spiteful people on a forum to say how much disposable income a young man should have. If the poor lad wasn't earning, he would be vilified, because he earns more than his mum he is also in the wrong. Why do people have children and expect them to cover their costs. When the kids move out who picks up the tab then?

Mollymoostoo · 10/11/2022 13:45

Hebsint your partner, he is your son and to say £900 I enough for him is not your call. You need to get a job that pays more because if he moves out you are screwed.
Parents choose to have children and to say the child has to make up for the shortfall for lost benefits is unfair.
The cost of getting a car, insurance etc is astronomical and he will never get on the property ladder if he doesn't have decent savings.
Look at making your own position financially viable because if he doesn't agree to your demands, what will you do? If you kick him out, you are screwed, if he leaves you are screwed.

sue20 · 10/11/2022 10:37

Dailymash · 08/11/2022 15:39

The only thing to consider is if/when he moves out would you be worse off without the money he is paying you coming in or would the reduction in your outgoings make up the shortfall? If you’d be no worse off with him not there and not contributing then it’s not too much. But you shouldn’t be making a ‘profit’ off your own son, and you don’t want a situation where you become reliant on that extra money.

The breakdown doesn’t sound like profit quite the reverse. But even if there were the son needs to understand paying money out of wages to living costs.

Jayne35 · 10/11/2022 09:06

I agree its a fair amount OP. Years ago I posted a similar question, asking was £85 a month too much to take from my DD18 (she was earning an apprentice salary - many said I shouldn't charge her anything at all - like they have on your post, oh to be so comfortable that you are able to do that!

Anyway, 8 years on, she now pays me £95 a month, and is happy with that as many of her friends who are still at home are paying 4-5 times that. My point here is that for us (not a single parent family) £95 is enough to cover the extra gas/electric/water etc and that every situation is different and some posters are just not getting that while they are wearing their rose tinted glasses.

CoffeeMama1 · 10/11/2022 09:01

x2boys · 10/11/2022 08:58

So you think the Op should stuggle to pay bills so her son has the life of riley ???
He already has £900 to himself ,do you not think thats enough?
Back in the real world a lot of us can only dream of having £900 / month disposable income 🙄🙄

Again, I never said that. I replied to the OP already, my comment was simply another point of view, and wasn't shaming or attacking, it obviously didn't take into account her son's feelings as that wasn't something that had been made known!

CoffeeMama1 · 10/11/2022 08:59

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

I'm not sure why my post got such a nerve with you, apologies it's triggered some deep rooted issues, that wasn't my intention. Not that I need to justify myself to you, but I absolutely don't have a lack of ambition and I have made something really great of myself, BUT it would've been really helpful and supportive of my parents to allow me the opportunity to continue my education (like they did for my older siblings) instead of demanding rent right away, meaning any decision I made had to factor that in. Unfortunately my siblings were funded through university by my parents and I was told if I wanted to go I had to fund myself entirely and also pay rent to "keep" my room at home, so it just wasn't possible. I've worked since I was 16, worked 70+ hour weeks, run my own business, worked 3 jobs while funding further education courses, but it's just about giving your children the opportunity to create a better life for themselves without having to absolutely obliterate themselves in the process. I have a great life and I'm immensely proud of my success, but that doesn't mean I think my parents did the right thing. It's simply just another point of view from someone out the other side, it wasn't ever meant to be judgemental and if course at the time I wasn't aware the OPs son loved their job and was happy with their position in life, that does completely change things.

x2boys · 10/11/2022 08:58

CoffeeMama1 · 10/11/2022 08:52

I never meant my comment to come across like you were doing what my parents had, obviously every family is completely different I was just trying to get across the viewpoint that sometimes a short term struggle would be worth it for the long term gain for him, but if he's happy in his role and future then there's no issue, it doesn't apply to your family! You really don't need to justify yourself, it's just there will be parents reading this down the line that do put their own needs and wants above their children, so hopefully some of the advice and comments on this thread will help them too. If he's happy in his job and earning a decent whack, and nearly 20 I noticed, then yeah it's good time he was eased into the adult world.

So you think the Op should stuggle to pay bills so her son has the life of riley ???
He already has £900 to himself ,do you not think thats enough?
Back in the real world a lot of us can only dream of having £900 / month disposable income 🙄🙄

CoffeeMama1 · 10/11/2022 08:52

mumofteenss · 09/11/2022 21:14

My son is not academic. He didnt pass gcses despite trying his best. He came out with grades that for him were great, for progressing in eduction not so great. He has no desire to continue education but I encouraged and supported him to go to college and do training courses that were more vocational and he did for 3 years.

Now, however, he has a job that to outside may not seem that great, but to him, its a job he has spoken about wanting to do for knocking close to 5 years from when he was admitted to hospital for a prolonged period of time due to a serious illness.

He isnt in a job he hates, he is in a job he has aspired to do, and a very necessary and valued role within the NHS. A role that does offer some progression, and job satisfaction. One that i supported him in getting by filling in applications as he is severely dyslexic, one I attended interviews with him (i sat outside) as he was anxious. I took him to occupational health appointments. Helped him source all his dbs for. Paid £90 whatever it was for a passport cos he needed ID and he didnt have one that was valid as holidays aren't a luxury we have.

I have not nor ever would force him into a job he hated. This is a job he wanted, and aspired for, despite how much people try to look down on.

Im immensely proud of him for securing and and doing a job that was his goal.

I never meant my comment to come across like you were doing what my parents had, obviously every family is completely different I was just trying to get across the viewpoint that sometimes a short term struggle would be worth it for the long term gain for him, but if he's happy in his role and future then there's no issue, it doesn't apply to your family! You really don't need to justify yourself, it's just there will be parents reading this down the line that do put their own needs and wants above their children, so hopefully some of the advice and comments on this thread will help them too. If he's happy in his job and earning a decent whack, and nearly 20 I noticed, then yeah it's good time he was eased into the adult world.

x2boys · 10/11/2022 07:11

CoffeeMama1 · 09/11/2022 21:06

Personally I think that's a huge amount, but I appreciate times are tough. You do just have to remember that the more he pays the longer it'll take him to save to move out too, so depends if that's high on your priority list. As someone who had to pay rent as soon as I turned 18, my opinion is probably a bit biased but the insistence from my parents that I contributed financially meant I stayed in/got jobs that weren't any good for me and made me miserable, and I was unable to continue to pursue any training or further education I wanted because I still had to pay my way. At the end of the day his future opportunities and prospects shouldn't be compromised for income now, it never works well in the long term.

If your parents had insisted you moved out at 18 you would have been paying a damn sight more

louderthan · 10/11/2022 07:08

Would you still be cooking for him, doing washing etc? I moved home for a bit post-uni and didn't pay as much but did all my own food shopping, cooking, laundry and did most of the other housework.

Stewball01 · 10/11/2022 07:03

@Notthetoothfairy
That is what my mum did. She took a quarter of my wage and put it aside for my wedding. As I had a teensy tiny wedding I got quite a bit. £400 sounds very fair. Your DS is a very lucky boy. I wish him luck in the future.

BusyMum47 · 10/11/2022 06:58

@mumofteenss Some people on here really need to go spout their judgy ignorant crap elsewhere! Christ, reading some of the comments you've had gave me the rage!!

You sound like an incredibly supportive, hard working, fair mum & your son is lucky to have you - which I'm sure he knows.

You've more than explained & justified your situation (not that you should have to!) & your son is understanding & happy with the amount you've suggested - which, again, is a credit to you.

Do what you need to do & celebrate what great kids you have!