Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think £400 board to parents...

289 replies

mumofteenss · 08/11/2022 15:13

is fair under these circumstances?

For context, my son is 19, this is his first job. He finished college last June having spent 3 years there doing vocational/skill-based courses. He's not academic so uni wasn't something he wanted, but he's very active and practical/logical-minded. I said while he was in education I would 100% support him; even if he had a job, he could keep all that income. He chose not to find a part-time job, entirely his choice.

Since June any support I received for him stopped, I'm a single parent, and I work full time, but my wage isn't a lot so I received UC and CB to top it up. As soon as he finished college all the elements for him stopped. I made him aware of this. These reductions in my income were around £350 a month.

He did find this job fairly quickly in mid-July, but due to the nature of the role, it required DBS checks which were a nightmare to sort out when he had no ID or statements. But we sorted it for mid-August. He's been waiting since then to start and finally started this week.

The wage he will be getting at 19 is not terrible. It equates to around £1300 a month after tax and whatnot. I have said I think £400 is fair, and I will continue to pay for everything he received up until now, all meals, if we have take out or eat out ill pay. If he wants to take over his own phone contract, apple music, xbox live, etc (all combined with them for my other children still so I don't mind keeping these) and he wants to arrange all of that himself, then he can give me £350 instead.

I see it as for 6 months I have 100% supported him with no income at all, in fact, I have really struggled to do so, but have not said anything as he was waiting to start this job. But I do need to recoup this money somehow and feel asking him to contribute that much is fair.

He will still have £900 a month, which is a damn sight more than I have spare, and very few outgoings as the workplace is within walking distance, and I in fact work on the same site so days our shifts line up he can come with me.

Is £400 a month a fair amount?

OP posts:
skyeisthelimit · 08/11/2022 16:06

YANBU OP. He could not live anywhere on his own for £400 a month for rent, all bills and food. He will never have it so good.

People need to understand that there are a huge variety of people on MN with very different lives. Not everyone can afford to keep their adult children and once they are working why shouldn't they pay their own way, especially once council tax discount is lost and maintenance ceases etc.

Crazymumto1 · 08/11/2022 16:06

You’ve done brilliantly to get him where he has, don’t feel guilty at all, it’s a fair amount to pay and you have to live also, everything is going up so you can’t put yourself in debt, unfortunately you can’t not charge him but he needs to learn how much bills are etc, in the long run it’ll help him

ilovesooty · 08/11/2022 16:05

It seems more than fair. You might have to be open to asking for a higher contribution in due course as you'll lose your single person council tax reduction.

@caringcarer makes an excellent point about him opening a LISA too.

Notherefortheshit · 08/11/2022 16:03

@Dailymash @Notthetoothfairy
It's a lovely position to be in, not having to take keep from adult children in the home but I'm not sure accusing OP of profiting from her DC is very kind or helpful.
I think you'll see from the thread that the majority of parents don't have the resources to keep paying for food, board, utility bills etc for a working adult when they have £1300-1400 disposable income a month. Financial need aside, how will these kids ever learn how to budget, know how much it costs to run a home, ever have the incentive to leave home of they have no financial responsibility?!
Personally, taking your attitude, you're in danger of having 30 year old 'kids' living in your spare room, getting mummy to do the cooking, housework, laundry etc..Good luck with that

Ponderingwindow · 08/11/2022 16:03

You are still massively subsidizing him at 400 if you are covering his rent, utilities, food, and his gadgets. What on earth does he have left that he needs to provide for himself with his remaining money? Some clothing and some transportation? He could probably save 500 a month with this plan without much effort. Has he made a commitment to do that or is he going to fritter away his earnings?

you don’t have to throw him to the wolves, but your job now is to give him a good strong launch into the real world. The real world is expensive.

vodkaredbullgirl · 08/11/2022 16:00

Notthetoothfairy · 08/11/2022 15:52

This. I would never charge my sons to live at home (or, if I did, it would only be because I was secretly putting that amount away for them as savings).

Good for you 🙄

My dd has 10 grand in her bank account.

Fattoushi · 08/11/2022 15:58

Notthetoothfairy · 08/11/2022 15:52

This. I would never charge my sons to live at home (or, if I did, it would only be because I was secretly putting that amount away for them as savings).

How nice for you to be able to afford that. Rather crass thing to say to OP, who can't afford it, though.....

x2boys · 08/11/2022 15:57

Notthetoothfairy · 08/11/2022 15:52

This. I would never charge my sons to live at home (or, if I did, it would only be because I was secretly putting that amount away for them as savings).

Well sadly back in the real world many peoole cant afford to subsidise a fully grown workking adult , and mummy secretly saving on behalf of her adult son hardly teaches a fully grown adult the value of money

Fattoushi · 08/11/2022 15:57

I think it's not enough.

mumofteenss · 08/11/2022 15:56

Notthetoothfairy · 08/11/2022 15:52

This. I would never charge my sons to live at home (or, if I did, it would only be because I was secretly putting that amount away for them as savings).

I wish i could afford that, but I'm not a high earner myself and their father is NC so Im 100% financially responsible for all 3 and have been for a decade.

OP posts:
OneFrenchEgg · 08/11/2022 15:56

Mine pays £350 and things like gym membership and phone he is taking over as contracts end and need renewing. He'll be earning £30k soon! But he hasn't been beforehand and we said they get a year after education free and then start contributing.

Fink · 08/11/2022 15:55

I'm just depressed that a 19 year old is earning more than me! But yes, in the circumstances it sounds like a fair amount to be taking and he will have more than enough disposable income (I don't think I know any adults who have £900 to themselves every month).

mumofteenss · 08/11/2022 15:54

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 08/11/2022 15:50

I always think 20% is a fair amount, but that's if you don't need it/low costs. It sounds like all you are asking is for him to cover what you've lost since he became an adult, and that's entirely fair.

And my 20% wouldn't include phone etc so the total would be close to 400 anyways.

Seems fine. And explainable to him. Have you told him?

Yes ive told him. He is happy with the £400, though I've said his first pay we will look at and decide once when know what it will be as I'm not sure how much his first wage will work. I want him to enjoy that feeling of the first time he's earned his own money and be able to treat himself. So I've said I'm not expecting £400 for the first month, just a "fair" amount.

Im just worrying I'm asking too much, but from replies it seems people agree its fair and reasonable given the circumstances

OP posts:
TheSausageKingofChicago · 08/11/2022 15:53

Totally fair. I wish I could get my 20 year old to get a decent job and start contributing.

vodkaredbullgirl · 08/11/2022 15:52

My dd pays £500 a month and she pays for her phone, dog food, insurance, healthy pet club and her bus fare to and from work. Still has a lot more than me in the bank.

You will get people on here, say how can you make him pay for living at home.

Notthetoothfairy · 08/11/2022 15:52

Dailymash · 08/11/2022 15:39

The only thing to consider is if/when he moves out would you be worse off without the money he is paying you coming in or would the reduction in your outgoings make up the shortfall? If you’d be no worse off with him not there and not contributing then it’s not too much. But you shouldn’t be making a ‘profit’ off your own son, and you don’t want a situation where you become reliant on that extra money.

This. I would never charge my sons to live at home (or, if I did, it would only be because I was secretly putting that amount away for them as savings).

ShandaLear · 08/11/2022 15:52

I think that sounds fair - generous even. I’d also ask him to start saving £300-£400 a month for a deposit on a flat. He’d have close to £15-£20k after 3 years.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 08/11/2022 15:50

I always think 20% is a fair amount, but that's if you don't need it/low costs. It sounds like all you are asking is for him to cover what you've lost since he became an adult, and that's entirely fair.

And my 20% wouldn't include phone etc so the total would be close to 400 anyways.

Seems fine. And explainable to him. Have you told him?

Zippedydoo123 · 08/11/2022 15:48

Ds earns less than your son plus has only just started working too.

mumofteenss · 08/11/2022 15:48

caringcarer · 08/11/2022 15:46

Get him to start a pension straight away so he won't miss the money. When young and single its best time to squirrel money into pension. Also open a LISA if he wants to ever buy his own home as government top up your regular savings. I hope he is sensible as £900 is a lot of disposable income each week.

The job he is starting includes a good pension (NHS).

OP posts:
x2boys · 08/11/2022 15:47

Dailymash · 08/11/2022 15:42

Also: he will have £900 spare but he’ll likely want to save that for a house deposit or similar if you ever want him to move out. The more he pays in ‘board’ the less he has to save.

Well like most adults he has to support himself ,if he was living alone or with friend,s would be paying a damn sight more then £400 ,or do you exiect the Op to starve or freeze todeath whilst her sons swans around living the life of riley ?

Zippedydoo123 · 08/11/2022 15:47

I will be charging 17 year old ds £250 from January to cover food plus electricity (his half).

Any council tax once he reaches 18 plus private dentist he will have to pay himself.

I won't be making any profit but don't expect to.

mumofteenss · 08/11/2022 15:47

Dailymash · 08/11/2022 15:39

The only thing to consider is if/when he moves out would you be worse off without the money he is paying you coming in or would the reduction in your outgoings make up the shortfall? If you’d be no worse off with him not there and not contributing then it’s not too much. But you shouldn’t be making a ‘profit’ off your own son, and you don’t want a situation where you become reliant on that extra money.

My outgoings would reduce massively once he moves out, I currently rent a 4-bed hour so each of my teens can have their own space, and as they move out I will move to a smaller and cheaper property. So although my income would reduce, so would my outgoings. £400 would keep my income the same as previous, only he would be contributing the £50 I spend on his phone and subscriptions rather than me paying for them. So i'd be £50 "better off" than when he was in college.

I want him to also have enough income at the minute to do things like his driving lessons which isn't something I can afford, and save where he can for his own place in the future.

OP posts:
caringcarer · 08/11/2022 15:46

Get him to start a pension straight away so he won't miss the money. When young and single its best time to squirrel money into pension. Also open a LISA if he wants to ever buy his own home as government top up your regular savings. I hope he is sensible as £900 is a lot of disposable income each week.

EscapeRoomToTheSun · 08/11/2022 15:46

I would probably need to take a bit more in that situation tbh. What's he going to spend his £900 a month on! I don't think loads of disposable income is necessarily good for young lads tbh.