Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think £400 board to parents...

289 replies

mumofteenss · 08/11/2022 15:13

is fair under these circumstances?

For context, my son is 19, this is his first job. He finished college last June having spent 3 years there doing vocational/skill-based courses. He's not academic so uni wasn't something he wanted, but he's very active and practical/logical-minded. I said while he was in education I would 100% support him; even if he had a job, he could keep all that income. He chose not to find a part-time job, entirely his choice.

Since June any support I received for him stopped, I'm a single parent, and I work full time, but my wage isn't a lot so I received UC and CB to top it up. As soon as he finished college all the elements for him stopped. I made him aware of this. These reductions in my income were around £350 a month.

He did find this job fairly quickly in mid-July, but due to the nature of the role, it required DBS checks which were a nightmare to sort out when he had no ID or statements. But we sorted it for mid-August. He's been waiting since then to start and finally started this week.

The wage he will be getting at 19 is not terrible. It equates to around £1300 a month after tax and whatnot. I have said I think £400 is fair, and I will continue to pay for everything he received up until now, all meals, if we have take out or eat out ill pay. If he wants to take over his own phone contract, apple music, xbox live, etc (all combined with them for my other children still so I don't mind keeping these) and he wants to arrange all of that himself, then he can give me £350 instead.

I see it as for 6 months I have 100% supported him with no income at all, in fact, I have really struggled to do so, but have not said anything as he was waiting to start this job. But I do need to recoup this money somehow and feel asking him to contribute that much is fair.

He will still have £900 a month, which is a damn sight more than I have spare, and very few outgoings as the workplace is within walking distance, and I in fact work on the same site so days our shifts line up he can come with me.

Is £400 a month a fair amount?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ellyeth · 14/11/2022 17:34

Sorry, I should have read the whole thread. I now see that your son is quite agreeable to this arrangement.

You are in no way a "terrible parent" and please ignore some of the spiteful comments on here - possibly from people who have never had financial difficulties and who can only see the world through their own narrow experience. I am sure the majority of people think you have done a marvellous parenting job. You son is doing well and behaving like a well adjusted adult - sensible and respectful enough to appreciate that what you are asking is more than reasonable. You have brought him up to be as he is, and you should be proud, not anxious.

ellyeth · 14/11/2022 17:18

I think, given your circumstances and the loss of income now that he is working, £400 is a very reasonable amount.

I wondered why you were asking. Have you mentioned this to him and you get the feeling he thinks it is too much? If so, in the big, wide world out there if he had no Mum and home to go to he would be paying much, much more than that for accommodation, food, etc. - and it probably wouldn't be particularly comfortable accommodation either.

Even if a parent could afford not to ask for "keep", I think it is unwise. We didn't ask our son for any contribution and it was a long time before he became responsible with money because he had no concept of what things cost or of the importance of saving. He has now, but a lot of money was initially wasted.

Throwawayaccount1 · 11/11/2022 17:09

I LOVE that you making it obvious what his money goes to.
Real Cheerios are really expensive 🤣. Luckily mine prefer the Tesco version!

LifeIsGreatForUnicorns · 11/11/2022 11:50

@mumofteenss please be assured that the majority of people would do the same thing.
For all those posters who would never charge, I’m hoping their DC don’t grow up entitled and feel that they can still ask their parents for help when they can’t manage their finances!
I charge my DS the same, we had a conversation about it , I believe he asked his social group and they told him it was good value!
I’m in a slightly different position in that I can afford to put some of that ‘rent’ money away for him but appreciate that not every one can. We’ve had to refit a room in the house as he is now wfh and part of his rent money has been used to fit it out as he needs it - I don’t feel guilty that we’ve used that money as it is benefiting him directly. When we have a takeaway (about once/twice a month) I always say that this is courtesy of DS to the family as otherwise we couldn’t afford it, so he sees what his money is paying for!
His rent money also pays for the proper cheerios rather than Aldi special cheerios (I’ve no idea how he gets through 2 packets a week but he’s a teenager!😂) so he’s happy 😆
Keep doing what you’re doing - you sound like you are supportive and are doing the best you can in these times 👍

Throwawayaccount1 · 10/11/2022 20:04

Someone suggested keeping a spreadsheet of the costs and his contribution.

It occurred to me that if you kept this up to date weekly/monthly together he could see where all the money goes which would help him understand budgeting for a household - great for the future!
(Also might make him unprompted buy the odd bag of shopping or treat you to something as he'll realise that he's on a great deal and he can afford to treat you now 😜.)

sheepdogdelight · 10/11/2022 19:30

If I was a young person I'd rather live in a house share on my own for that amount. And yes, I looked on that share site and there were plenty around that price or a little more than included utitilies.

depends where you live surely? A room in a shared house with utilities is a minimum of £600 round here and that wouldn't include food, miscellaneous household items (loo roll, washing up liquid ...), netflix, spotify or random lifts to places.
If OP is in an area where £400 is the market rate for the same thing as she's offering, I agree she may wish to rethink.

Kitesk · 10/11/2022 19:27

Trinity69 · 10/11/2022 18:37

Sounds perfectly fair to me. I am considerably older than your son and that's roughly what I earn. I'd love to have £900 a month left!

I'm glad you have flagged this some people's salaries are £800/£900 a month and they have to run a whole household. I'm not sure how anyone can't see past their OWN privileged self and salary just because that's not the case for them.

x2boys · 10/11/2022 19:21

I remember when i first qualified as a nurse in 1996 j was earning about £850-950 a month i moved back in woth my patents for a coyple of years after living out as a student ,on my £360 / month student bursery i was paying rent of £150/month and then my share of utilluties ,when i moved back in with my mum and dad they charged me £130/ month plus my share of the phone bill even then i realised what a ridicously cheap deal i was getting ,i was loaded ,the onlt time innmy life i vould br care free with money

escapingthecity · 10/11/2022 19:14

OP, you sound like an amazing mum who works so hard for your kids. I am in awe. You have a plan and asking your grown up son to contribute to the family is the right thing to do

vodkaredbullgirl · 10/11/2022 19:02

My dd was paying £190 a week for a house share in Wales, when she was at Uni. She came back started 2 jobs and was giving me £200 a month. Now she has a better job and she was the one who said she would give me £500 a month, that includes everything.

Trinity69 · 10/11/2022 18:37

Sounds perfectly fair to me. I am considerably older than your son and that's roughly what I earn. I'd love to have £900 a month left!

Imnothereforthegiggles · 10/11/2022 18:09

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

x2boys · 10/11/2022 17:42

emptythelitterbox · 10/11/2022 17:21

If I was a young person I'd rather live in a house share on my own for that amount. And yes, I looked on that share site and there were plenty around that price or a little more than included utitilies.

I did move out to my own place as soon as I was old enough to rent somewhere.

I wouldn't charge my children and I wouldn't more than a token amount either. Neither of them stayed until they were 40 either!

They both have their own places and have for quite a few years.

You're going to have to downsize or earn more sooner or later so might as well do it now instead of depending on your child to replace government benefits you've been receiving all these years.

Lucky ,you not everyone is as fortunate as you though .

Coatdegroan · 10/11/2022 17:32

I think paying for some food would also be appropriate.
I think £400 even if you didn't have to recoup supporting him for 6 months would be perfectly fair.

ducksdeluxe · 10/11/2022 17:22

OP you are being more than reasonable. You sound like a lovely, supportive mum doing your best by your boy. Ignore the ignorant ‘I would never’ comments on here.

emptythelitterbox · 10/11/2022 17:21

If I was a young person I'd rather live in a house share on my own for that amount. And yes, I looked on that share site and there were plenty around that price or a little more than included utitilies.

I did move out to my own place as soon as I was old enough to rent somewhere.

I wouldn't charge my children and I wouldn't more than a token amount either. Neither of them stayed until they were 40 either!

They both have their own places and have for quite a few years.

You're going to have to downsize or earn more sooner or later so might as well do it now instead of depending on your child to replace government benefits you've been receiving all these years.

danblack87 · 10/11/2022 17:06

You are not being unreasonable. It would cost him far more to live away from home with cost of utilities etc. I think it is more than fair - if he leaves you would have to pay extra council tax for the spare room; therefore, I think it would be reasonable for him to pay £450 and sort out his own phone and gadgets.

Louandsi · 10/11/2022 16:56

You so sound like a fantastic mum. A young adult contributing financially to the household teaches them about responsibility and transitions their role from child to adult. Something that is very important in my opinion, especially if they still live at home.

HaudYerWheeshtYaWeeBellend · 10/11/2022 16:51

Household income is calculated by the household income so his income will be taken into consideration for your UC and CT award.

Topsyturvy78 · 10/11/2022 16:46

That's fair he still has a considerable amount for daily expenses and any he wants to save.

TimBoothseyes · 10/11/2022 16:38

Kattiekat · 10/11/2022 16:13

His room is there and you would pay for it and the rent regardless and I understand you lose your UC and CB but you would have used that for other things such as his clothing and school dinners. Which you won’t be doing now.
I would say ask for:
what you lose in single persons council tax
half utilities
half food and household goods shopping
then add £100 or however much to get the total he gives you to £400 and you should put aside for him should he wish to make a large purchase in the future such as driving lessons, a car or property deposit.

Depending on the ages and sex of her other DC and whether she gets help with the rent as part of her UC, the OP could now be subject to the "bedroom tax". That shortfall has to be paid somehow.

www.gingerbread.org.uk/information/housing/bedroom-tax/

x2boys · 10/11/2022 16:31

Kattiekat · 10/11/2022 16:13

His room is there and you would pay for it and the rent regardless and I understand you lose your UC and CB but you would have used that for other things such as his clothing and school dinners. Which you won’t be doing now.
I would say ask for:
what you lose in single persons council tax
half utilities
half food and household goods shopping
then add £100 or however much to get the total he gives you to £400 and you should put aside for him should he wish to make a large purchase in the future such as driving lessons, a car or property deposit.

Why cant he put a,money aside for himself ,with the £900 disposable income he gets ,you know ,like all adults?

User359472111111 · 10/11/2022 16:25

mumofteenss · 09/11/2022 21:14

My son is not academic. He didnt pass gcses despite trying his best. He came out with grades that for him were great, for progressing in eduction not so great. He has no desire to continue education but I encouraged and supported him to go to college and do training courses that were more vocational and he did for 3 years.

Now, however, he has a job that to outside may not seem that great, but to him, its a job he has spoken about wanting to do for knocking close to 5 years from when he was admitted to hospital for a prolonged period of time due to a serious illness.

He isnt in a job he hates, he is in a job he has aspired to do, and a very necessary and valued role within the NHS. A role that does offer some progression, and job satisfaction. One that i supported him in getting by filling in applications as he is severely dyslexic, one I attended interviews with him (i sat outside) as he was anxious. I took him to occupational health appointments. Helped him source all his dbs for. Paid £90 whatever it was for a passport cos he needed ID and he didnt have one that was valid as holidays aren't a luxury we have.

I have not nor ever would force him into a job he hated. This is a job he wanted, and aspired for, despite how much people try to look down on.

Im immensely proud of him for securing and and doing a job that was his goal.

You sound like a great mum @mumofteenss

DopeyMum16 · 10/11/2022 16:19

Very fair - £400 is what I am proposing to charge my son who started his first job a few months ago . Since he left uni and moved back my costs are up way more than that ( council tax , food , utilities )z

Friendofdennis · 10/11/2022 16:17

I think£400 a month is very fair. I would also encourage him to save £400 into a lifetime ISA for a deposit. Having £900 disposable income at 19 will give him a false sense that life will always be that easy. If he can get used to living on less that will be a good lesson for him in financial self control