Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is behaviour this bad in all schools now?!

264 replies

Growingmyhairout · 08/11/2022 14:44

I am a supply teacher who's in a long term role but don't think I can deal with it.
I'm in a non core subject which doesn't help, one that pupils find difficult and don't have to do a GCSE in.
I was covering a 2 week sickness in one boys school, but couldn't have done anymore as behaviour was awful.
I'm now at what's been called a very challenging school. However I've walked past some other lessons and all kids are silent pretty much.
I've been here for a few weeks now so the kids know I'm not there just for a day or anything, yet no improvements.
I've been suggested to ring parents but if I did I'd be making 45 calls an evening which there is just not the time to do, especially for £110 a day gross.
I do give detentions, warnings etc. But it doesn't make much difference.
Some kids will just get up and walk out of your lesson when they feel like it. Or kids who aren't even in your lesson will turn up and sit in the room.
Coats on, phones out, earphones in, eating. When I tell them not to, some kids will listen but some will literally just ignore you. Swinging on chairs, shouting across the room, fighting, swearing.
Each lesson I send a few out to other classrooms which helps to an extent.
The worst are cover lessons though, as I'm used for cover as well as my own classes. Cover is an absolute nightmare.
I record everything but don't know what difference it makes.
Throwing things across the room, putting make up on. Answering me back very rudely.
Just all talking loudly and ignoring me. I refuse to shout over them as I've already got a hoarse voice from raising it.
I email heads of year, sometimes they will come in if they're not busy.
Some lessons are alright, but there's an insane level of disrespect.
As I said I've been here a few weeks now, how long is it going to take?
I've got a TA in all lessons which I'm really grateful about, but they don't seem to respect her much either.
We had an ok class this morning once the worst were removed, but had an absolutely horrendous year 7 group. She said she'd never seen a school like it.
I've been offered long-term, part time cover in another school. I'm tempted to go, but I'm thinking what's the point?
It's just going to be the same everywhere isn't it? I'm not expecting kids to sit in absolute silence for 5 hours a day but the behaviour is unacceptable. I'll be trying to speak and many students will just carry on having their own conversation.
I also feel like I'd be letting down the school who've even given me a TA when most other teachers don't get one.
I feel like a failure as a teacher. I think I've been firm but fair, but I don't think I can do this. Is behaviour really this bad in all schools?

OP posts:
antelopevalley · 09/11/2022 11:17

My kids are both in a zero-tolerance school. They work.

strawberrytilda · 09/11/2022 11:14

I actually think it is and it scares me for when my children start secondary. I left the classroom about 10 years ago but still do some tuition and the stories my pupils tell me about what happens in their, locally well respected, ofsted outstanding, schools is really quite shocking. There is one local school which bans phones and has silent corridors which seems to have better behaviour. It seems like you have to either be one of those Michaela style zero tolerance schools or accept behaviour is going to be poor.

Yellowdahlia12 · 09/11/2022 11:08

Venetiaparties · 09/11/2022 10:19

You don't see very much, if any bad behaviour in private schools. That is a solid fact.

Private schools simply won't allow it, and have their reputation (and finances) to protect, and the parents are paying such a huge amount of money for each child to attend, they expect full commitment from their children - not just a few in the class - but everyone is expected to reach their potential.

Well motivated, focused children from a home where education is highly valued will generate a thriving, inspiring learning experience. That is why there are so many parents willing to invest the eye watering sums of 45,000gbp pa at least, for the best schools.

That is why private schools work, everyone is heavily heavily invested.

Parents have many choices to switch schools if they wish, schools can choose the very brightest of students. Hence the reason why you see well behaved, confident children without the social issues described on here 99% of the time.

This 100%. Because private education is expensive, and some schools, particularly in London, are very hard to get into, both the parents and the children are on board with expectations.
Unfortunately this isn't the case in many state schools. If the parents don't care, their attitude filters down to the children, who have no real incentive to learn. It's no preparation for the world of work.

mightarture · 09/11/2022 11:00

That's the norm. Yes, there are state schools that do not reach those standards, but again, don't cherry pick the worst and claim it is the majority.

I haven't 'cherry picked' the worst state schools. My children don't go to a state school. And I mostly attended private and boarding so my experience is limited.

It's certainly not the 'norm' according to the MN threads here. I think that will be somewhere in between, realistically.

Mummyoflittledragon · 09/11/2022 10:59

antelopevalley · 09/11/2022 10:33

I think private school payers have to convince themselves private schools are very different to state schools.
In reality there is good and and in both sectors,

I get what you’re saying. However, having been through the state education myself and having attended what would today be a failing school in special measures had those existed, I can safely say, private schools are indeed very different from that school. Private schools have to be different from that one to survive. Several parents of my peers refused to send their children there. To put it into context, the council refused to fund certain subjects at higher levels and I only have 5 O levels, the maximum I was allowed to take. The teaching for the most part was dumbed down and dire. My grades definitely do not reflect my ability. This said same school still requires improvement decades later.

I also have experience through dd in a different county. Had she got into the excellent comp she would have loved to attend, I imagine she’d still be there. As is, she moved to private school in year 9. I know of several parents, who’ve changed their children from state to private in her year group between year 8 and 10 with others, whose parents cannot afford private are now home Ed.

Dd has lots of fun and there is definitely an element of naughtiness allowed but not at the same level as her former state school. No one is using lighters in lessons, throwing punches or chairs across the room etc. It is still a bit sink or swim at dd’s private school and I think any child requiring more one to one teaching would need to attend either a very small private school or a specialist state school to get their needs met.

antelopevalley · 09/11/2022 10:33

I think private school payers have to convince themselves private schools are very different to state schools.
In reality there is good and and in both sectors,

Neerdoneerdo · 09/11/2022 10:32

And not all private schools "work", either. One of my DC's private schools got a very bad Ofsted report and closed down. I know of several other private schools that have also closed down due to dropping numbers.

Neerdoneerdo · 09/11/2022 10:28

Venetiaparties · 09/11/2022 10:19

You don't see very much, if any bad behaviour in private schools. That is a solid fact.

Private schools simply won't allow it, and have their reputation (and finances) to protect, and the parents are paying such a huge amount of money for each child to attend, they expect full commitment from their children - not just a few in the class - but everyone is expected to reach their potential.

Well motivated, focused children from a home where education is highly valued will generate a thriving, inspiring learning experience. That is why there are so many parents willing to invest the eye watering sums of 45,000gbp pa at least, for the best schools.

That is why private schools work, everyone is heavily heavily invested.

Parents have many choices to switch schools if they wish, schools can choose the very brightest of students. Hence the reason why you see well behaved, confident children without the social issues described on here 99% of the time.

I find that hard to believe.
Certainly when I was at private school there was a fair amount of bad behaviour. Including bullying. To a lesser extent that was the case at the first of my DC's private schools too.
And many private schools can't just choose bright and / or motivated children. Some private schools basically specialise in taking children who are not very bright, while their bright brothers and sisters get into the neighbouring selective private schools, or state grammars.
Not all parents of private school pupils are well educated or particularly motivated in respect of their children's education, either. They may just go for private school because it's seen as the right thing to do if you have money, for instance. Or because of the wraparound care.

Untitledsquatboulder · 09/11/2022 10:20

Venetiaparties · 09/11/2022 10:19

You don't see very much, if any bad behaviour in private schools. That is a solid fact.

Private schools simply won't allow it, and have their reputation (and finances) to protect, and the parents are paying such a huge amount of money for each child to attend, they expect full commitment from their children - not just a few in the class - but everyone is expected to reach their potential.

Well motivated, focused children from a home where education is highly valued will generate a thriving, inspiring learning experience. That is why there are so many parents willing to invest the eye watering sums of 45,000gbp pa at least, for the best schools.

That is why private schools work, everyone is heavily heavily invested.

Parents have many choices to switch schools if they wish, schools can choose the very brightest of students. Hence the reason why you see well behaved, confident children without the social issues described on here 99% of the time.

QED

Venetiaparties · 09/11/2022 10:19

You don't see very much, if any bad behaviour in private schools. That is a solid fact.

Private schools simply won't allow it, and have their reputation (and finances) to protect, and the parents are paying such a huge amount of money for each child to attend, they expect full commitment from their children - not just a few in the class - but everyone is expected to reach their potential.

Well motivated, focused children from a home where education is highly valued will generate a thriving, inspiring learning experience. That is why there are so many parents willing to invest the eye watering sums of 45,000gbp pa at least, for the best schools.

That is why private schools work, everyone is heavily heavily invested.

Parents have many choices to switch schools if they wish, schools can choose the very brightest of students. Hence the reason why you see well behaved, confident children without the social issues described on here 99% of the time.

Sigma33 · 09/11/2022 10:17

Untitledsquatboulder · 09/11/2022 10:12

@Venetiaparties I don't think so. Private school parents running down state schools to reinforce their own prejudices is a pretty well known phenomenon.

This ^^

Underhisi · 09/11/2022 10:16

If this is happening across the school it is due to poor leadership. Good visible senior management makes a lot of difference.

swallowedAfly · 09/11/2022 10:14

Hey don't discourage her. Some of my classes have 33 kids despite only having tables and chairs for 32 and the rooms having been sized for even less.

Untitledsquatboulder · 09/11/2022 10:12

@Venetiaparties I don't think so. Private school parents running down state schools to reinforce their own prejudices is a pretty well known phenomenon.

Sigma33 · 09/11/2022 10:12

I am not a teacher, and I don't work in the education sector, so I have no skin in the game. Just a state educated parent with a state educated child, and similar friends - who just doesn't recognise the 'state schools are impossible' attitude on this thread.

Venetiaparties · 09/11/2022 10:11

Every child should go to a school that has high attainment, good behaviour and able to learn critical thinking skills.
I don't think it especially between state or private, although it always seems to come up. Many teachers are reporting so many issues post pandemic, and this reflects in the numbers soaring with mental health problems, lack of engagement and a wide range of social issues. The problem was there before and it has been aggravated by the lockdowns and the way our children have been treated during the pandemic.

God only knows what will become of the children that are STILL living like this, and have been for three years approaching such as China.

We, and especially our children are paying the price for a lack of planning for an emergency situation like covid. I am not blaming government per se, as the advice would have been the same regardless of party, the suicide numbers are frightening. I hope we can get our young people back to feeling motivated, inspired and hopeful.

Sigma33 · 09/11/2022 10:09

mightarture · 09/11/2022 09:50

Of the 10 of us I mentioned in my previous post, 9 of us have degrees from a range of universities, including RG unis and Oxbridge. We took part in a range of extra curriculars through our bog-standard comps, and felt safe, made friends (and learnt to deal with the occasional 'unkind' kid).

That sounds very fortunate indeed from bog standard comps... unfortunately not the experience of many on these threads nowadays.

It has been the experience of our 16 (between us) children as well. All the state secondaries in the London borough where I live are OFSTED good or outstanding. They have their strengths and weaknesses like any school, but I would have been happy to send DD to any of them.

DD's school has a range of extra-curricular activities and school trips, there is an enrichment track for pupils aiming at Oxbridge and RG universities, as well as an excellent SEN Dept (DD has an EHCP) and additional help in core subjects for pupils like DD who need it. She has been in the school play, is in the choir, and goes to homework club after school when she needs help. She does a lot of dance classes outside school, so doesn't have much time for school-based extra-curricular activities, but I see the programme every term and there are a huge range - various sports, foreign language film club, cookery, environmental activities, debating, robotics, coding etc etc

It was our second choice, by the way.

Of the 9 friends I quoted above, 2 are local and their children go to two of the other local state comps, and have a similar experience to DD.

FSM etc are average for London.

That's the norm. Yes, there are state schools that do not reach those standards, but again, don't cherry pick the worst and claim it is the majority.

Venetiaparties · 09/11/2022 10:06

Sigma33 · 09/11/2022 09:46

And the majority of state schools provide a safe, responsive, accountable, well-rounded education. It is easy to cherry pick the worst example of a state school and then claim that is the norm for state schools.

Of the 10 of us I mentioned in my previous post, 9 of us have degrees from a range of universities, including RG unis and Oxbridge. We took part in a range of extra curriculars through our bog-standard comps, and felt safe, made friends (and learnt to deal with the occasional 'unkind' kid).

It reminds me of a colleague who mentioned putting her son's name on the pre-waiting list for local prep schools. I must have looked a bit surprised (her son was only about a year old at that point) as she then said quickly 'I wish we didn't have to, but the local schools are impossible'.

I looked up the local primaries in her borough out of curiosity, and they all on the surface seemed fine, good or outstanding. Now, of course an in depth look might have shown severe issues in all of them, but I doubt she had taken an in depth look, and certainly gave no sign of taking a serious look when her son was nearing school age - a lot can change in 3 or 4 years. She and her husband had gone to private schools, so 'of course' state schools were 'impossible'.

"The lady doth protest too much, methinks"

DarkKarmaIlama · 09/11/2022 10:01

@mightarture

Not my experience working in many and also my kids current experience.

mightarture · 09/11/2022 09:50

Of the 10 of us I mentioned in my previous post, 9 of us have degrees from a range of universities, including RG unis and Oxbridge. We took part in a range of extra curriculars through our bog-standard comps, and felt safe, made friends (and learnt to deal with the occasional 'unkind' kid).

That sounds very fortunate indeed from bog standard comps... unfortunately not the experience of many on these threads nowadays.

Sigma33 · 09/11/2022 09:46

Venetiaparties · 09/11/2022 08:47

I am sorry to tell you people don't generally send their children to private school necessarily or purely for attainment and showjumping, but for reasons of safety, respect, accountability and their children being cared for in a secure and comfortable environment with other kind children. And you have the ability to move your child easily if that is not their experience. Good grades do not always reflect a well rounded, solid education either.

And the majority of state schools provide a safe, responsive, accountable, well-rounded education. It is easy to cherry pick the worst example of a state school and then claim that is the norm for state schools.

Of the 10 of us I mentioned in my previous post, 9 of us have degrees from a range of universities, including RG unis and Oxbridge. We took part in a range of extra curriculars through our bog-standard comps, and felt safe, made friends (and learnt to deal with the occasional 'unkind' kid).

It reminds me of a colleague who mentioned putting her son's name on the pre-waiting list for local prep schools. I must have looked a bit surprised (her son was only about a year old at that point) as she then said quickly 'I wish we didn't have to, but the local schools are impossible'.

I looked up the local primaries in her borough out of curiosity, and they all on the surface seemed fine, good or outstanding. Now, of course an in depth look might have shown severe issues in all of them, but I doubt she had taken an in depth look, and certainly gave no sign of taking a serious look when her son was nearing school age - a lot can change in 3 or 4 years. She and her husband had gone to private schools, so 'of course' state schools were 'impossible'.

queenofthewild · 09/11/2022 09:44

DS's secondary is absolutely nothing like you've described, but 5 years ago it absolutely was.

A change in leadership made a huge difference. The behaviour policy is followed to the letter. The heads of years, deputy and head teacher back up their staff and stand for no nonsense. The school remains nurturing and the children feel safe.

Seek out other schools in your area with more supportive leadership.

Venetiaparties · 09/11/2022 08:47

Sigma33 · 09/11/2022 07:46

You mean out of the state comprehensive I went to, which consistently had (and has) better results than the local private school, and now has a showjumping team that competes against the local private schools? 😂

I am sorry to tell you people don't generally send their children to private school necessarily or purely for attainment and showjumping, but for reasons of safety, respect, accountability and their children being cared for in a secure and comfortable environment with other kind children. And you have the ability to move your child easily if that is not their experience. Good grades do not always reflect a well rounded, solid education either.

Sigma33 · 09/11/2022 08:04

I have just thought about my 9 closest friends, so 10 experiences including me.

3 were not at school in the UK. Of the 7 who did, we all went to a state comprehensive, ranging from rural to inner city. Only 1 of those schools had bad behaviour - to the point there was an arson attack the summer she had finished her A levels. She's the only one of us to go to Oxbridge, thanks to the education she received at the school - the first of her family to go to university.

The 10 of us have 16 children between us, all state educated. 2 are still at primary school, but will go to the same school as an older sibling.

The 14 are all going/went (the oldest is now 21, so school is a recent experience).to a state comprehensive, a total of 8 different schools. None rural, a mix of big city and semi-rural/market town. None have problems with behaviour. All are happy with the way our children's needs are being met, from the academic (aiming for medicine) to the SEN (full time 1:1 because of mental and physical disabilities). One had to change her son's primary school because they were taking a punitive approach to his emotional issues, once she changed to a more supportive school those issues resolved.

Two of the friends are teachers in the state system, one primary, one secondary. Neither is in a school that has a breakdown in behaviour or constant disruption.

To say you would never consider state schooling says more about your bigotry than it does about state schools. I have no doubt that some are a battleground, but that does not mean all - or even the majority - are.

Sigma33 · 09/11/2022 07:46

rhowton · 09/11/2022 05:27

Find a really expensive area with a close knit catchment and try and get a job there. Or private. I will do everything in my power to keep my kids out of state secondary.

You mean out of the state comprehensive I went to, which consistently had (and has) better results than the local private school, and now has a showjumping team that competes against the local private schools? 😂