Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is behaviour this bad in all schools now?!

264 replies

Growingmyhairout · 08/11/2022 14:44

I am a supply teacher who's in a long term role but don't think I can deal with it.
I'm in a non core subject which doesn't help, one that pupils find difficult and don't have to do a GCSE in.
I was covering a 2 week sickness in one boys school, but couldn't have done anymore as behaviour was awful.
I'm now at what's been called a very challenging school. However I've walked past some other lessons and all kids are silent pretty much.
I've been here for a few weeks now so the kids know I'm not there just for a day or anything, yet no improvements.
I've been suggested to ring parents but if I did I'd be making 45 calls an evening which there is just not the time to do, especially for £110 a day gross.
I do give detentions, warnings etc. But it doesn't make much difference.
Some kids will just get up and walk out of your lesson when they feel like it. Or kids who aren't even in your lesson will turn up and sit in the room.
Coats on, phones out, earphones in, eating. When I tell them not to, some kids will listen but some will literally just ignore you. Swinging on chairs, shouting across the room, fighting, swearing.
Each lesson I send a few out to other classrooms which helps to an extent.
The worst are cover lessons though, as I'm used for cover as well as my own classes. Cover is an absolute nightmare.
I record everything but don't know what difference it makes.
Throwing things across the room, putting make up on. Answering me back very rudely.
Just all talking loudly and ignoring me. I refuse to shout over them as I've already got a hoarse voice from raising it.
I email heads of year, sometimes they will come in if they're not busy.
Some lessons are alright, but there's an insane level of disrespect.
As I said I've been here a few weeks now, how long is it going to take?
I've got a TA in all lessons which I'm really grateful about, but they don't seem to respect her much either.
We had an ok class this morning once the worst were removed, but had an absolutely horrendous year 7 group. She said she'd never seen a school like it.
I've been offered long-term, part time cover in another school. I'm tempted to go, but I'm thinking what's the point?
It's just going to be the same everywhere isn't it? I'm not expecting kids to sit in absolute silence for 5 hours a day but the behaviour is unacceptable. I'll be trying to speak and many students will just carry on having their own conversation.
I also feel like I'd be letting down the school who've even given me a TA when most other teachers don't get one.
I feel like a failure as a teacher. I think I've been firm but fair, but I don't think I can do this. Is behaviour really this bad in all schools?

OP posts:
Florenz · 09/11/2022 20:24

Schools really need to crack down on bad behaviour. Zero tolerance, one strike and you're out, that kind of thing. School should be for the kids that want to learn, the whole "inclusion" experiment has been a disaster, quite frankly. Bring back Borstals (don't call them that, obviously) and name and shame the parents whose children are miscreants.

WorkHardPlayHard1 · 09/11/2022 20:20

My daughter's schools both council run are not like that. I think the school has a big problem. You need to move for your mental health and career development if you havent got strict rules in place and the support of the head.

I Would ask the question "who here wants to learn about x?" Whoever puts their hand up gets taught and goes to the front, the ones who want to mess about go to the back and anyone not on the roll get sent out and door shut.

This will make or break you. If you dont want this challenge move to a private school or one with a good record which would sadly be a better fit for you. 😘

BiBoop · 09/11/2022 20:18

What's more scary is this is the next generation... devolution.
Frightening

4onway · 09/11/2022 20:15

I teach in a school where behaviour is generally good but they can be absolutely foul to supply. Try and support as much as possible but I really feel for supply teachers. We have noticed behaviour becoming much worse with Year 7 and 8 since the pandemic—apparently this has been noticed in all schools across the trust and has particularly impacted those with negative home lives or send.

TheaBrandt · 09/11/2022 19:47

Im not sure all private schools always “kind”. My friends year 10 has been involved in an underground “fight club” at our local private school!

CorvusPurpureus · 09/11/2022 19:04

Venetiaparties · 09/11/2022 10:19

You don't see very much, if any bad behaviour in private schools. That is a solid fact.

Private schools simply won't allow it, and have their reputation (and finances) to protect, and the parents are paying such a huge amount of money for each child to attend, they expect full commitment from their children - not just a few in the class - but everyone is expected to reach their potential.

Well motivated, focused children from a home where education is highly valued will generate a thriving, inspiring learning experience. That is why there are so many parents willing to invest the eye watering sums of 45,000gbp pa at least, for the best schools.

That is why private schools work, everyone is heavily heavily invested.

Parents have many choices to switch schools if they wish, schools can choose the very brightest of students. Hence the reason why you see well behaved, confident children without the social issues described on here 99% of the time.

Well, no, speaking as a teacher with quite a bit of experience in the state, private, & international circuits.

Quite often in private schools, you get parents who feel that because they are paying a huge wedge, they'd quite like that to be reflected in top grades despite the fact that their kid is one who'd be getting MASSIVE support in a state school for their academic struggles & (usually consequent) behavioural issues.

We don't choose 'the brightest'. We take kids whose parents can pay. & if someone's dc5 is academically weak, bullying their peers & liable to tell teachers to fuck off - we would generally not want to rock the applecart & upset the parents of dc1-4, who are doing nicely & generating a tub of revenue.

'Private schools simply won't allow it' 🤣.

I've taught in the private sector for quite some years, with my dc having free places. They've benefited - genuinely - from amazing facilities & opportunities.

But the actual teaching? They would have been much better served, I suspect, attending a good comprehensive, where the quality of teaching is monitored rather closely.

Obviously, you need good behaviour to teach well. That's down to effective systems, culture & SMT/HOD support. & it works, or doesn't, regardless of what is going on outside the gates.

Most kids would like to learn. Also, most kids will dick about if that's seen as acceptable, THEN grumble that they aren't learning. Because they're teenagers with poor impulse control & peer status/relationships are everything.

Give them a fairly robust approach to poor behaviour, consistently followed up, & most dc will be hugely relieved.

stemthetide · 09/11/2022 18:00

Every area has a school where discipline is not good, life for teachers can be hell, they move on quickly making more difficulties for the school. Avoid this school.

Depends where you live, obviously, but my area has a lot more than one school with very poor discipline.

There are a lot of parents who don't value education or have the standards of behaviour for their children that are needed if they are to learn and thrive at school. This has been going on for generations.

The situation isn't helped by weak SLTs. Many of the appointments are of staff who talk the talk. Those senior staff who are good and effective burn out or give up the struggle.

Murdoch1949 · 09/11/2022 17:20

No, all secondary schools are not like this. I would profer that most secondaries are actually well run, well disciplined schools. For supply and new teachers there is always a difficulty until a reputation is established. The students need to understand that you will not put up with poor behaviour and that you will always follow up punishments. The senior team - heads of departments, heads of year - should pay special attention to supporting supply staff, as indiscipline in their lessons can affect other lessons. Every area has a school where discipline is not good, life for teachers can be hell, they move on quickly making more difficulties for the school. Avoid this school.

jazzybelle · 09/11/2022 17:14

About 25 years ago, I did supply teaching in an area which was considered rough. Pupils did much the same as you describe back then. It was a real eye-opener. Pupils just got up and left lessons. Others just sat in group and did nothing. Out of school seemed to be spent drinking and smoking etc.

The school also had security guards patrolling the building and grounds. I was meant to be there for two weeks but after being told to fuck off for the umpteenth time, I left in the second week.

The class sizes and the size of the school itself were far too big. Smaller schools with smaller classes could make the whole situation far more controllable. Then, the teachers could teach and the pupils could learn.

Happyhappyeveryday · 09/11/2022 17:11

Yes, nearly all.

CulturePigeon · 09/11/2022 17:06

When I last worked in a secondary school I had a TA who'd grown up in an African country. She told me she walked (shoeless) a considerable distance to school each day and loved every minute of it. Even as a child she was acutely conscious of how lucky she was to get a free education and looked up to her teachers. She was utterly baffled at the attitude of so many of the British teenagers at the school.

I agree with her. What has gone so horribly wrong? It's not just a matter of funding - it's something far more fundamental in terms of attitudes to education, teachers and, I suppose, authority figures in general.

PollyZo · 09/11/2022 17:05

ScrollingLeaves · 09/11/2022 16:33

I think a huge advertising campaign aimed at persuading all parents to value education might help, and at the same time top quality sure start specialist nurseries, nutrition and help for at risk mothers and babies, training for mothers and a way out shown to them.
It would take money but be paid back many times over.

@ScrollingLeaves

What does training for mothers at risk and nurseries have to do with the quality of school education. They didn’t have those things before and schools weren’t as out of control in the classroom

Snnowflake · 09/11/2022 16:49

ScrollingLeaves · 09/11/2022 16:33

I think a huge advertising campaign aimed at persuading all parents to value education might help, and at the same time top quality sure start specialist nurseries, nutrition and help for at risk mothers and babies, training for mothers and a way out shown to them.
It would take money but be paid back many times over.

Yes this is what is needed.

ScrollingLeaves · 09/11/2022 16:33

I think a huge advertising campaign aimed at persuading all parents to value education might help, and at the same time top quality sure start specialist nurseries, nutrition and help for at risk mothers and babies, training for mothers and a way out shown to them.
It would take money but be paid back many times over.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 09/11/2022 15:38

PandoraRocks · 09/11/2022 14:49

What do people expect? This was always on the cards once corporal punishment was abolished in schools. Also, most parents are way too soft on their kids. There's just no discipline anywhere.

so you think we should go back to whipping them?🤔

PollyZo · 09/11/2022 14:58

@PandoraRocks

This is true. Why would a 14 or 15 year old man sized “boy” from a rough home and area have respect or listen to some teacher who he knows is totally powerless to actually stop anything outrageous he might do?

And how can that boy actually have a chance to realise there’s more to life than whatever crap life has thrown at him up to that point, if the attempt to actually make him learn can’t even be made?

PandoraRocks · 09/11/2022 14:49

What do people expect? This was always on the cards once corporal punishment was abolished in schools. Also, most parents are way too soft on their kids. There's just no discipline anywhere.

HerMajestysRoyalCoven · 09/11/2022 13:58

I don’t teach but I have a number of friends who do and they’ve been regaling me with stories like this for years - well before COVID. I doubt there’s one issue underpinning but one issue that’s consistent is that the parents have no respect for the teachers. Whenever a behavioural problem is raised it’s the school’s fault, or the kid having SEN, or the school must be lying because their kid would never… etc etc etc. I just advise my friends to leave. The money they’re paid, it’s not worth it, and parents might finally wake up once they and their kids drive all the good teachers out. Probably not though.

PollyZo · 09/11/2022 12:44

antelopevalley · 09/11/2022 10:33

I think private school payers have to convince themselves private schools are very different to state schools.
In reality there is good and and in both sectors,

@antelopevalley

To an extent, but the reality is the worst of public is far far worse. I can’t imagine a teacher being stabbed through the hand with a protractor, a child being hit in the back of the head with a hockey stick or an older male student sticking there hand inside a female teachers pants and underwear - all of which happened in a short space of time at a single public school I briefly worked at (thank god for the briefly).

PollyZo · 09/11/2022 12:39

Fantasiamop · 08/11/2022 18:10

As soon as girls started doing as well, then better, than boys in mixed sex schools, people started blaming girls for boys' not doing as well as them.

It's likely that gender stereotyped narratives affect behaviour in boys and girls, but not that boys couldn't learn and behave well if people didn't persist in pedalling these narratives.

The thing that your not writing or perhaps are unaware of is that girls didn’t just start doing better organically. When the idea of women’s schooling being important first started to gain traction around the middle half of the 1900’s (or slightly later) girls weren’t doing as well as boys, so over time a number of measures were considered and implemented in the hope they would help improve girls academic results, with little thought as to whether they would harm boys.

Among these was placing a greater emphasis on sustained course work in opposition to examinations (and reducing the amount of examinations) as well as other measures.

So if boys and girls learning differently is just caused by gender stereotypes, then why was it important to change the way school taught to help girls in the first place? By your logic girls could have just adapted to the way boys were learning and learn as well. And why is the way girls learn best thought to be the correct way which boys must adapt to, but not the opposite?

Further, if boys and girls do (averaged out) actually learn best in different ways, why not try to implement both so that both sexes can reach their full potential? It seems almost triggering to some to consider that maybe boys could learn better in a different way and they’re almost afraid to let people try to implement better ways for boys to learn, lest boys actually do improve and it disproves the idea that girls and boys learn in the same way and ergo, are inwardly the same.

I don’t know why but some feminist types seem very emotionally opposed to trying to improve boys results by actually creating learning which caters to boys, instead of working against them as though they’re afraid it might succeed.

Anyhow, if girls suddenly began falling behind boys in learning I doubt you would be so blasé about it and would surely be open to girls learning in ways which better suited them and allowed them to suceed - so why so closed minded to the idea that boys should have that same opportunity when they’re behind?

thingumybob · 09/11/2022 11:41

The school I work in is like this in some classes with some teachers (particularly cover teachers). Other lessons/classes are not like this. There is a shocking amount of just outright rude and disrespectful behaviour from some children though. I feel sorry for the quiet majority who would just like to be able to get on with it.

I believe the school my children go to is better but they have an easier starting point because that is not a school that anyone ends up going to by default it is very competitive to get in (church school with some academic places). They are therefore dealing with children from very engaged families which makes a big difference.

The school I work in has children who come from quite challenging situations at home. I do think behaviour management could be more effective though. That comes from the top, having experienced in a previous school some dramatic changes in behaviour when leadership changed. The new leadership was very inspired by the Michaela school and the impact on behaviour was very positive. There were other aspects that I really wasn't keen on though!

ScrollingLeaves · 09/11/2022 11:38

Is notbeing heavily invested it a UK cultural issue?

ABJ100 · 09/11/2022 11:36

I have to agree with the private school argument to an extent. We are doing private schooling with dc and I can say at our school this would not be allowed- zero tolerance. Badly behaved, behaviourial issues, disrespectful children are not tolerated. This was a big factor in going private. I don't want anything compromising my dc educated. Pp made a good point about those who choose private in that both parents and the child are heavily, heavily invested.

CellarBellaatemycoal · 09/11/2022 11:35

@antelopevalley how does a zero tolerance school work?

Sigma33 · 09/11/2022 11:19

It's not the norm on Mumsnet because people don't start threads when their child is getting a good education in their state school, and it is trouble-free. I've only posted about the good state schools I know of because there were so many people doing the 'state schools are terrible' narrative.

And the TV programmes like 'Educating Manchester' of course focus on the challenging pupils because it makes for drama. No-one would be interested in watching well behaved, engaged young people being taught by experienced teachers, then hanging out with their friends at lunchtime. It would be incredibly boring.

I would worry about the quality of the education received by anyone who assumes that Mumsnet shows the 'norm' of state schools, neighbourly relations, marriage, or anything else! It shows a serious lack of critical thinking skills.

Swipe left for the next trending thread