Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is behaviour this bad in all schools now?!

264 replies

Growingmyhairout · 08/11/2022 14:44

I am a supply teacher who's in a long term role but don't think I can deal with it.
I'm in a non core subject which doesn't help, one that pupils find difficult and don't have to do a GCSE in.
I was covering a 2 week sickness in one boys school, but couldn't have done anymore as behaviour was awful.
I'm now at what's been called a very challenging school. However I've walked past some other lessons and all kids are silent pretty much.
I've been here for a few weeks now so the kids know I'm not there just for a day or anything, yet no improvements.
I've been suggested to ring parents but if I did I'd be making 45 calls an evening which there is just not the time to do, especially for £110 a day gross.
I do give detentions, warnings etc. But it doesn't make much difference.
Some kids will just get up and walk out of your lesson when they feel like it. Or kids who aren't even in your lesson will turn up and sit in the room.
Coats on, phones out, earphones in, eating. When I tell them not to, some kids will listen but some will literally just ignore you. Swinging on chairs, shouting across the room, fighting, swearing.
Each lesson I send a few out to other classrooms which helps to an extent.
The worst are cover lessons though, as I'm used for cover as well as my own classes. Cover is an absolute nightmare.
I record everything but don't know what difference it makes.
Throwing things across the room, putting make up on. Answering me back very rudely.
Just all talking loudly and ignoring me. I refuse to shout over them as I've already got a hoarse voice from raising it.
I email heads of year, sometimes they will come in if they're not busy.
Some lessons are alright, but there's an insane level of disrespect.
As I said I've been here a few weeks now, how long is it going to take?
I've got a TA in all lessons which I'm really grateful about, but they don't seem to respect her much either.
We had an ok class this morning once the worst were removed, but had an absolutely horrendous year 7 group. She said she'd never seen a school like it.
I've been offered long-term, part time cover in another school. I'm tempted to go, but I'm thinking what's the point?
It's just going to be the same everywhere isn't it? I'm not expecting kids to sit in absolute silence for 5 hours a day but the behaviour is unacceptable. I'll be trying to speak and many students will just carry on having their own conversation.
I also feel like I'd be letting down the school who've even given me a TA when most other teachers don't get one.
I feel like a failure as a teacher. I think I've been firm but fair, but I don't think I can do this. Is behaviour really this bad in all schools?

OP posts:
Thepeopleversuswork · 10/11/2022 13:42

A bit of perspective is needed on the state vs primary discussion (and I speak as the parent of a child in private school and someone who was privately educated).

Private schools are not a panacea for bad behaviour. They certainly do not prevent bullying and other behaviours which impact children's mental health and wellbeing.

Yes the cost and the fact that parents are usually very invested tends to weed the most egregious bad behaviour. You rarely get kids who are hell-bent on disrupting every lesson. You tend not to get chair-throwing, spitting or smoking on school premises at most private schools. I can totally understand why, as a teacher, private would seem more appealing.

But the poor behaviour is much more insidious at private. It's likely to manifest in different ways: bullying, snobbery, exclusion of children by virtue of the fact that their parents can't "keep up with the Jones's", well-documented problems with eating disorders etc. I went to a private secondary and while it was good academically and gave me certain advantages, it was hideous for my mental health.

I agonised over whether to send my DD private and ultimately for me (based in large part on the fact that I'm in a part of London with particularly poor state secondaries) I decided it was the least worst option and coughed up. So far I'm not regretting it. But I think its foolish to assume that private is a guarantee that children will avoid these problems.

PandoraRocks · 10/11/2022 11:23

@CulturePigeon I think you've nailed it in your last post.
When I was in comprehensive school in the 70's, teachers were respected. Really bad behaviour was rare - the worst thing kids did in class was whisper or throw paper at each other. There was corporal punishment but it was only used on boys and usually a swift tap on the hand with a ruler or a slap on the bottom with a cane. There was no 'whipping' as one poster above suggested.

But as you've said, society has changed for the worst since then. Swearing is ubiquitous now . I never heard swearing growing up - women didn't swear in public and men didn't in front of women and kids. No swearing on tv. No explicit sex. The age of innocence for children has gone and now they're constantly exposed to coarseness and bad behaviour. And parents supported teachers.

Another modern plague is the 'cult of the child'. Kids treated like little emperors and granted their every wish to the exclusion of everyone else.

ScrollingLeaves · 10/11/2022 11:12

CulturePigeon - Today 08:04
I agree with your post.
Even so, somehow some children will be less prone to take it out on teachers or not care about their education than others. Are these children who’ve somehow been a bit more protected, as far as that is possible, from the influences you describe?

3WildOnes · 10/11/2022 10:45

jocktamsonsbairn · 08/11/2022 20:55

I work in primary and staff are assaulted on a daily basis. That's from 4 and 5 year olds right up to 11/12 year olds. Being told to F off and being called a C**t are common placed. The level of violence and disrespect is shocking but it's becoming normalised as so common. No support, nothing happens. No Consequences. I am honestly starting to fear for the future.
Our P1 teacher was punched, bitten, kicked, scratched, told to F off and called a fat F*ing idiot today. That's 5 year olds. Parents don't care and those who do are in crisis already.

There is nothing like this in the primary school my children attend/attended. I'm always pleasantly surprised at how amazing the behaviour is when I volunteer in the class.

TheaBrandt · 10/11/2022 10:06

Culture I agree and so would my dad who taught for 40 years.

Used to be pretty much all the parents were on side of the school and if their child misbehaved and the school contacted them they got a clip round the ear and the parents (of every class) were mortified and apologetic. Oh how things have changed…

NeverOneBiscuit · 10/11/2022 09:32

Culturepigeon : I totally agree with your post. After Squid Game came out on Netflix, we had year 7 pupils playing the “games” in the playground. The favourite one being red light green light where you could be shot dead.

I asked lots of them why and how they’d watched it, given the age rating. Many had watched it with an older sibling on their iPad, on their own device, or quite openly on the family tv.

ScrollingLeaves · 10/11/2022 08:27

TheClitterati · Today 07:40*
My dd y10 doesn't recognise any of this for which I am super thankful.

She said there might be one "naughty girl" per class where naughty means answering teach back.

It's a girls grammar school

The parents and children will be very invested in a grammar school and feel extremely lucky to be there. In the first place.

Secondly, though girls can be naughty, bitchy and bullying, they are not on the whole as loud or disruptive as boys.
(Just as later on most violent crime is committed by men.)

CulturePigeon · 10/11/2022 08:04

I'm going to suggest an answer to my own question above. I think social media and changes in broadcasting standards are a huge part of this - even more of a factor than any social deprivation.

I think it was in the 70s (?) that Kenneth Tynan, the critic, first used the word 'fuck' on television. He did it to make a point, not accidentally. In itself you might say - so what? But now, anything seems to go on TV - and I think TV is different from films in that it comes into homes and is easily accessible.

Kids' TV has also changed to favour more anarchic attitudes too. Fun up to a point, but it all feeds into the 'you can't tell me what to do!' approach to life. And the growth of moronic 'reality TV' with very dubious role models has fostered a culture of coarseness, brashness and crude materialism.

And as for social media - youngsters are exposed to absolutely everything from a very early age - whereas once this just couldn't have happened. You'd have to get into an 18 film to see anything at all and that would have been mild compared to what you can see on TikTok or YouTube any time now.

Plus - the horrible decline in public discourse. Twitter is vile - it's largely just a facility for slanging/swearing matches and abuse.

I think Pandora's Box has been well and truly opened, and there's no going back.

Loafbeginsat60 · 10/11/2022 08:03

I worked at an academy last year in Scotland and it was exactly the same. Everything in your post I experienced and worse.

I hated it and left as soon as I could. They were all bigger than me too, which didn't help as they would physically shove me out of the way!

There were a few lovely students and some real characters that I adored - proper "bad" boys who actually just needed a bit of time and attention and came around.

Mostly tho, they were awful and just didn't want to be there or do any work!

Venetiaparties · 10/11/2022 07:58

Neerdoneerdo · 09/11/2022 22:04

I'd expect to see better behaviour at private schools, yes, in part because of small class sizes. But some posters on here are talking about private schools as if they are basically perfect - full of very bright and highly motivated children sent there at great expense by highly educated parents who cherish education and encourage their children to behave well and work hard. And no doubt wonderfully led and with wonderful staff who bring out the best in children. I've had some experience of private schools that are or were not like that. Actually my Dsis went to an expensive boarding school where children were allowed to attend lessons or not, to work towards exams or not, as they wished. She did absolutely no work whatever and scraped one basic pass at A'level. There are plenty of really poor private schools around. Private schools can basically do what they want, so can be very maverick. And you can't count on them to be around for as long as your child's education lasts, or to treat your child fairly - they can do what they like. I have personal experience of 3 that have closed down unexpectedly, forcing all those children to find new schools in a hurry (luckily the one my DC attended didn't close down until after they'd left). And the teachers may well be poorly qualified and not that good. There is less oversight of private schools than of state schools.
I'm not talking about Eton, but even some very expensive private schools are pretty dodgy if you look below the surface.

You are rather clinging to the idea that parents will continue to pay hundreds of thousands of pounds for a failing private school?! 😂

I am afraid the system is very very responsive to rubbish teaching or poor grades, the school will simply shut down. That is the beauty of the system. State schools remain open unless they are so bad as to be considered dangerous, and even then they can still stay functioning as where do put a 1000 kids at a drop of a hat? Many going through GCSEs and Alevels.

One would not waste such a serious amount of money to send their children to a second rate public school, so by definition only the very best will survive. After the crash of 2008 the worst schools died off, and in my experience what is left certainly around here, is absolutely outstanding.

CulturePigeon · 10/11/2022 07:51

I'm not saying that bad behaviour in schools is a totally new phenomenon, but I think it has got much, much worse over the last few decades.

I taught in a big Birmingham comprehensive school in the late 80s/early 90s and although it was in a fairly deprived area, I don't remember any serious behavioural problems. At parents' evenings, the parents were all respectful to teachers and supportive of the school - at least, the ones I saw were.

I get the impression that a huge change of culture has taken place over the last 25 years which has given parents and students much, much more power and although this might sound good on paper, it has worked to the detriment of schools and ultimately the students themselves. If students were disrespectul, you could at least depend on most parents to support you as a teacher.

I'm sorry - I'm going to come over as really old-fashioned, but it does seem to me that the culture of permissiveness in terms of behaviour has gone too far. I know there have been initiatives to clamp down on behaviour with 'zero tolerance' etc, but in one school I was in I was told that yes, students might tell me to 'fuck off', but that wasn't really bad behaviour - they just didn't realise it was rude or unacceptable - yeah, right.

I'm really interested to know what current teachers think has happened to society in general. I'm not talking about children in poverty here - the kids who had these attitudes were very well-provided for in terms of material goods. I think teachers do put up with too much, though. They should put themselves first for a change - rather than always beating their chests about the needs of the students. This would ultimately benefit their students!

TheClitterati · 10/11/2022 07:40

My dd y10 doesn't recognise any of this for which I am super thankful.

She said there might be one "naughty girl" per class where naughty means answering teach back.

It's a girls grammar school.

HerMajestysRoyalCoven · 10/11/2022 00:58

ScrollingLeaves · 09/11/2022 16:33

I think a huge advertising campaign aimed at persuading all parents to value education might help, and at the same time top quality sure start specialist nurseries, nutrition and help for at risk mothers and babies, training for mothers and a way out shown to them.
It would take money but be paid back many times over.

Honestly, parents who don’t value education are never going to be convinced by an advertising campaign. The parental attitude in the schools my friends teach in is that they just want the kids out the house and bothering someone that isn’t them. They’re not bothered if school is just babysitting as long as it’s not then having to do it. You’re not going to convince them of the wonders of learning.

I agree with the rest though.

DdraigGoch · 09/11/2022 22:43

Neerdoneerdo · 09/11/2022 22:04

I'd expect to see better behaviour at private schools, yes, in part because of small class sizes. But some posters on here are talking about private schools as if they are basically perfect - full of very bright and highly motivated children sent there at great expense by highly educated parents who cherish education and encourage their children to behave well and work hard. And no doubt wonderfully led and with wonderful staff who bring out the best in children. I've had some experience of private schools that are or were not like that. Actually my Dsis went to an expensive boarding school where children were allowed to attend lessons or not, to work towards exams or not, as they wished. She did absolutely no work whatever and scraped one basic pass at A'level. There are plenty of really poor private schools around. Private schools can basically do what they want, so can be very maverick. And you can't count on them to be around for as long as your child's education lasts, or to treat your child fairly - they can do what they like. I have personal experience of 3 that have closed down unexpectedly, forcing all those children to find new schools in a hurry (luckily the one my DC attended didn't close down until after they'd left). And the teachers may well be poorly qualified and not that good. There is less oversight of private schools than of state schools.
I'm not talking about Eton, but even some very expensive private schools are pretty dodgy if you look below the surface.

I've not really got an issue with the one where attending was optional. They're not in the classroom throwing chairs at the teacher so it's not interrupting anyone else's education.

The key thing about a failing private school though is that parents can withdraw their children and the school will go bust. A failing state school on the other hand (which may still manage to pass inspections, even if it's shite the rest of the time) will be full of pupils unfortunate enough not to get their first choice.

JamSandle · 09/11/2022 22:13

My school was very much like this. Only a few teachers could control a class. Most pupils were awful. I hunkered down and studied as much as I could as I had a sense at an early age that many were on a path to nowhere fast but it could be very hard to concentrate in many classes.

frootyfroo · 09/11/2022 22:12

And this is why I’ll be doing everything in my power to send my DC to private school!

Florenz · 09/11/2022 22:09

Class sizes are not the problem. The problem is that there are no repercussions for bad behaviour.

Neerdoneerdo · 09/11/2022 22:06

On the question of class size, Chinese schools typically have class sizes of over 50, without discipline problems.

Neerdoneerdo · 09/11/2022 22:04

I'd expect to see better behaviour at private schools, yes, in part because of small class sizes. But some posters on here are talking about private schools as if they are basically perfect - full of very bright and highly motivated children sent there at great expense by highly educated parents who cherish education and encourage their children to behave well and work hard. And no doubt wonderfully led and with wonderful staff who bring out the best in children. I've had some experience of private schools that are or were not like that. Actually my Dsis went to an expensive boarding school where children were allowed to attend lessons or not, to work towards exams or not, as they wished. She did absolutely no work whatever and scraped one basic pass at A'level. There are plenty of really poor private schools around. Private schools can basically do what they want, so can be very maverick. And you can't count on them to be around for as long as your child's education lasts, or to treat your child fairly - they can do what they like. I have personal experience of 3 that have closed down unexpectedly, forcing all those children to find new schools in a hurry (luckily the one my DC attended didn't close down until after they'd left). And the teachers may well be poorly qualified and not that good. There is less oversight of private schools than of state schools.
I'm not talking about Eton, but even some very expensive private schools are pretty dodgy if you look below the surface.

DdraigGoch · 09/11/2022 21:39

Neerdoneerdo · 09/11/2022 10:28

I find that hard to believe.
Certainly when I was at private school there was a fair amount of bad behaviour. Including bullying. To a lesser extent that was the case at the first of my DC's private schools too.
And many private schools can't just choose bright and / or motivated children. Some private schools basically specialise in taking children who are not very bright, while their bright brothers and sisters get into the neighbouring selective private schools, or state grammars.
Not all parents of private school pupils are well educated or particularly motivated in respect of their children's education, either. They may just go for private school because it's seen as the right thing to do if you have money, for instance. Or because of the wraparound care.

Did you frequently have to duck to avoid the chairs flying across the classroom? Were teachers ever assaulted?

While bullying can be very hard to stamp out as it often goes on unreported out of sight of staff, I find it hard to believe that blatant disrespect or violence to teachers carries on unhindered at private schools in the same way that it does in many state schools who can't permanently exclude a student as easily.

DdraigGoch · 09/11/2022 21:34

Meredusoleil · 09/11/2022 21:25

Were they shoplifting?

Not retail but yes, the equivalent of that sort of crime, plus a little feral behaviour into the bargain.

I've had far worse behaviour from teenage girls than from teenage boys this year. They just seem to think that they're untouchable.

DdraigGoch · 09/11/2022 21:26

Oh, and that's not to mention the loved-up teenagers the other week who disappeared into the yard one evening. He emerged in tears (evidently not usually the type to get into serious trouble), she on the other hand decided to tell our security guards that her dad would come and stab them. She got arrested.

Again, this is what happens when kids believe that their parents will back them up regardless of what they've done. They need to learn the word "no".

Meredusoleil · 09/11/2022 21:25

DdraigGoch · 09/11/2022 21:18

Well this evening I've encountered three arrogant teenage girls at my workplace. I was left in no doubt that their attitude is a direct consequence of their upbringing - one was particularly certain that her mother would back her up even though she was undeniably in the wrong. Hopefully they won't be quite so cocky when the police pay a visit to their school tomorrow - we've got bodycam footage and one of their teachers was a witness.

Were they shoplifting?

DdraigGoch · 09/11/2022 21:18

Well this evening I've encountered three arrogant teenage girls at my workplace. I was left in no doubt that their attitude is a direct consequence of their upbringing - one was particularly certain that her mother would back her up even though she was undeniably in the wrong. Hopefully they won't be quite so cocky when the police pay a visit to their school tomorrow - we've got bodycam footage and one of their teachers was a witness.

Quiettiger · 09/11/2022 20:32

I quite teaching (Secondary science) at the beginning of the first lock down in 2020 after doing reasonably long term supply in a school. It was exactly as you describe, and this will out me to people who know me as it's a story I've shared widely, but the thing that made me finally quit was having to tell a Year 8 boy to stop licking the window and meaning it literally.

It was a particularly rough zoo school, but the abuse and poor behaviour from pupils was so bad, with a lack of SMT support, I was beyond stressed.

Friends still in teaching have said that behaviour has deteriorated since. I'm so glad I left.