Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is behaviour this bad in all schools now?!

264 replies

Growingmyhairout · 08/11/2022 14:44

I am a supply teacher who's in a long term role but don't think I can deal with it.
I'm in a non core subject which doesn't help, one that pupils find difficult and don't have to do a GCSE in.
I was covering a 2 week sickness in one boys school, but couldn't have done anymore as behaviour was awful.
I'm now at what's been called a very challenging school. However I've walked past some other lessons and all kids are silent pretty much.
I've been here for a few weeks now so the kids know I'm not there just for a day or anything, yet no improvements.
I've been suggested to ring parents but if I did I'd be making 45 calls an evening which there is just not the time to do, especially for £110 a day gross.
I do give detentions, warnings etc. But it doesn't make much difference.
Some kids will just get up and walk out of your lesson when they feel like it. Or kids who aren't even in your lesson will turn up and sit in the room.
Coats on, phones out, earphones in, eating. When I tell them not to, some kids will listen but some will literally just ignore you. Swinging on chairs, shouting across the room, fighting, swearing.
Each lesson I send a few out to other classrooms which helps to an extent.
The worst are cover lessons though, as I'm used for cover as well as my own classes. Cover is an absolute nightmare.
I record everything but don't know what difference it makes.
Throwing things across the room, putting make up on. Answering me back very rudely.
Just all talking loudly and ignoring me. I refuse to shout over them as I've already got a hoarse voice from raising it.
I email heads of year, sometimes they will come in if they're not busy.
Some lessons are alright, but there's an insane level of disrespect.
As I said I've been here a few weeks now, how long is it going to take?
I've got a TA in all lessons which I'm really grateful about, but they don't seem to respect her much either.
We had an ok class this morning once the worst were removed, but had an absolutely horrendous year 7 group. She said she'd never seen a school like it.
I've been offered long-term, part time cover in another school. I'm tempted to go, but I'm thinking what's the point?
It's just going to be the same everywhere isn't it? I'm not expecting kids to sit in absolute silence for 5 hours a day but the behaviour is unacceptable. I'll be trying to speak and many students will just carry on having their own conversation.
I also feel like I'd be letting down the school who've even given me a TA when most other teachers don't get one.
I feel like a failure as a teacher. I think I've been firm but fair, but I don't think I can do this. Is behaviour really this bad in all schools?

OP posts:
CulturePigeon · 11/11/2022 12:55

Woodhill

No - it was the one with the Music School (not officially part of the school, but very much used by the music dept) in the grounds.

By selling off that site (not a playing field, btw) the Head was able to reduce class sizes to an average of 23. Amazing - you can pay very good money for 23 in a class. He had the right priorities, I think.

CulturePigeon · 11/11/2022 12:51

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · Today 11:48

Sounds like my sister's class at our grammar school! She came home with a story every night!

TheaBrandt · 11/11/2022 12:46

It’s not fashionable to say and at the risk of sounding like a Daily Mail reader there does need to be a slight element of fear amongst the pupils generally to keep everyone in line. All this lovey dovey child focussed nothing must trouble you my little emperor frankly produces monsters.

Not advocating a return to the days of Mr Gradgrind but teens need firm clear fair boundaries and consequences that are unwelcome for those that push them.

woodhill · 11/11/2022 12:25

CulturePigeon · 11/11/2022 12:01

Woodhill

You may be on to something, Sherlock! But it wasn't the high school in Chorleywood.

He went to a school that was nominally a grammar, but technically a comprehensive nowadays. We wanted the grammar school feel and it still had that. It was perfect for him - and single-sex education suited him brilliantly during his early secondary years. He loved the music especially and is still in touch with many of his teachers.

Ahh was this the one where there is a football stadium and a park? LolSmile

KSJR · 11/11/2022 12:24

It frustrates me so much. The children who behaved well where overlooked whilst the repeat offenders got to go and have a cup of tea in the heads room while they calmed down. So not only was there no consequences there was also no reward for good behaviour. It’s a failing system and I’d say 70% of the problem in children's behaviour today. The other 30% I would think is home life and learnt behaviour.

CulturePigeon · 11/11/2022 12:01

Woodhill

You may be on to something, Sherlock! But it wasn't the high school in Chorleywood.

He went to a school that was nominally a grammar, but technically a comprehensive nowadays. We wanted the grammar school feel and it still had that. It was perfect for him - and single-sex education suited him brilliantly during his early secondary years. He loved the music especially and is still in touch with many of his teachers.

Tinktravels · 11/11/2022 11:59

I am also a day to day supply teacher I've been to at least 25 schools now and yes the behaviour is bad all around. Some schools are better than others for example yesterday I had a child being a huge problem to the point it was impossible to continue with him in the room. I sent for on call 3 times and no one came.
If the behaviour is bad but the staff are supportive, makes it a lot easier.

CulturePigeon · 11/11/2022 11:56

KSJR · Today 08:01
I feel primary schools are the problem, they are setting them up to fail in secondary. The primary I was working in is far too gentle, for eg it was a “no shouting” school. They had a time out room where they went to think about their actions. The kids loved this room it was just a chill with the rest of the badly behaved children who where in there. They are ruling the school Because of this I feel like the pupils think they are untouchable and go into secondary with the same attitude. 🤷🏼‍♀️

(I'm sorry, MNers - I'm posting a lot on this thread because I feel very strongly about it...)

I agree, KSJR. I've taught in primaries too, and the gentle induction schemes from the local high schools used to amuse/irritate me. Huge efforts were made to ensure that the children felt no fear whatsoever on their first day at secondary school. I remember a teacher coming over to sit with the naughtiest lads in my class to gently talk to them and reassure them that there was absolutely NOTHING to worry about. I expect he learned, in the end!!

There is a difference between fear and awe. I think it's fitting that children should feel a sense of awe on their first day at secondary school They should walk through the gates with a sense of being on their mettle, and actively want to make a good impression. The boot seems to be on the other foot, with schools believing THEY have to make a good impression on the students. Why?

While in secondaries, I've seen some new students, during their first few days, walking into class smirking, clearly feeling over-confident and in no way under any pressure to impress staff, or make a new start. No wonder there isn't even a 'honeymoon period' any more with Year 7s in some schools.

And, while I feel for the nicer, well-behaved students - I wonder how much of the anxiety they feel on transfer is due to worrying about other students' behaviour, rather than their new teachers?

woodhill · 11/11/2022 11:55

CulturePigeon · 11/11/2022 11:45

TheClitterati · Yesterday 07:40
My dd y10 doesn't recognise any of this for which I am super thankful.
She said there might be one "naughty girl" per class where naughty means answering teach back.
It's a girls grammar school.

I agree. My son went to a state comprehensive which had been a very good grammar school, and there was certainly a grammar school feel to it, for which I was also grateful.

When I was looking at schools for my children and touring the local options (which in our area are not really options - it's SW Herts and all schools are very over-subscribed), only 2 things carried any weight with me: the teaching staff/atmosphere of purposefulness and what the current students were like. I didn't give a damn about new facilities, what colour the walls were painted or how many computer suites they had.

I wanted my children to go to a school where good behaviour was expected and was the norm, and where parents would be highly supportive of the school's aims. I didn't want a place where it wasn't cool to work hard and achieve, and I was lucky in that their schools (both state) were fantastic. There might have been a bit of minor 'behaviour' in the bottom sets, but otherwise the teachers were able to teach - not something to be taken for granted these days - and students (especially academic, musical nerdy boys like my son) could relax and be themselves, without being bulllied, intimidated or having their opportunities squandered by disruptive children. I so wish that every child who wants to work and achieve could be so lucky.

Was this a school in Chorleywood?

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 11/11/2022 11:48

@CulturePigeon ,

No it was in Sheffield. It was still living on its reputation as an old grammar school.

l do think we were an exceptionally naughty class though. It was full of clever mischievous people. 2nd set, which l know from being a teacher is always the naughtiest set.

We were always getting bollocked. I loved it! 😁

CulturePigeon · 11/11/2022 11:45

TheClitterati · Yesterday 07:40
My dd y10 doesn't recognise any of this for which I am super thankful.
She said there might be one "naughty girl" per class where naughty means answering teach back.
It's a girls grammar school.

I agree. My son went to a state comprehensive which had been a very good grammar school, and there was certainly a grammar school feel to it, for which I was also grateful.

When I was looking at schools for my children and touring the local options (which in our area are not really options - it's SW Herts and all schools are very over-subscribed), only 2 things carried any weight with me: the teaching staff/atmosphere of purposefulness and what the current students were like. I didn't give a damn about new facilities, what colour the walls were painted or how many computer suites they had.

I wanted my children to go to a school where good behaviour was expected and was the norm, and where parents would be highly supportive of the school's aims. I didn't want a place where it wasn't cool to work hard and achieve, and I was lucky in that their schools (both state) were fantastic. There might have been a bit of minor 'behaviour' in the bottom sets, but otherwise the teachers were able to teach - not something to be taken for granted these days - and students (especially academic, musical nerdy boys like my son) could relax and be themselves, without being bulllied, intimidated or having their opportunities squandered by disruptive children. I so wish that every child who wants to work and achieve could be so lucky.

CulturePigeon · 11/11/2022 11:36

ArseInTheCoOpWindow
l went to a really well known posh comp in the 70’s. It was crazy. Throwing shoes, bags, books out of the windows, trying to stand on tables every lesson, throwing stuff, boys drinking lager (Braker) in lesson. Crying with laughter all the time.
Tjis was in a posh area.

This is very interesting, Arse! (Sorry!) Could you say whether it seemed to be a student problem (just downright obnoxious, spoilt, entitled kids) or a teacher problem (wet, pathetic teachers who wouldn't or couldn't take control out of some bonkers ideological principle?)

I'm guessing Pimlico School, or Holland Park?? You probably don't want to say. But I went to a meeting at the much-praised Pimlico School in the 80s and I was taken aback by the the rowdy atmosphere - kids running in the corridors, shouting between lessons etc. The management seemed proud!! I wouldn't have wanted to teach there or to send my children there.

I remember when a so-called 'Super Head' Tostig Fried....something (he was popularly known as Toast and Fried Egg) took over and had a large, framed, professionally taken photograph of each student put on the walls of the school. This was apparently to raise students' self-esteem and make them feel valued. I wonder if it worked? I don't want to think of how much that little exercise cost, but to me it's an example of profligate waste on some dopey idea that doesn't make any material difference. Much better to have spent the quids on more staff, which I think is the only thing that makes students' experience better.

DisenchantedDewberry · 11/11/2022 10:23

I'm an LSA in secondary. Our school is like this, literally everything you've said! It's horrendous and I have actually stopped getting involved unless someone is in danger because they're so rude it's awful. I was going to train to be an English teacher as I just graduated last year but i know i wouldnt cope with the behaviour! I get a small amount of respect from some pupils but most ignore me altogether.

It's really disappointing.

paintitallover · 11/11/2022 10:12

@Ideatcakeforbreakfast

"Management actually care and make huge efforts to support all staff and pupils."

This is 100%, research proven, accurate for all sectors. And projects, too. High quality and problem solving leadership in all areas makes for more successful projects and happier staff/pupils/teams.

Ideatcakeforbreakfast · 11/11/2022 09:19

So sorry you're going through this. I'm also a teacher in a high school. The problem generally lies with management and the lack of support you are getting. I taught for 10 years in a supposedly nice middle-class comprehensive - the first day I was there, I was told to eff off for asking a girl to take her coat off. I had various awful classes at that school, management were useless, I even ended up being hit on the head with a chair (a prank by an apparently nice quiet boy). I now work in a school where it could be seen as more challenging, more kids from lower SIM decile areas with more social issues but the contrast is unbelievable. Management actually care and make huge efforts to support all staff and pupils. There are still challenging classes but it's much easier to deal with and issue consequences and building relationships and respect is easier. Interestingly we don't really do detentions and phone calls are only done by head of depts or year heads (both things that I did frequently at my old school). Ultimately it's never easy being the newbie anyway and can take ages to build that rapport with pupils but if management all sung from the same hymn sheet, it would be a far easier experience for you.

TheaBrandt · 11/11/2022 08:12

Dds primary was like that. Sappy / be kind / group hug lovey dovey. They were reassured covid wouldn’t affect them oh no. Then lock down. Don’t think this does them any favours.

Utterly agree about children treated as little emperors. Our grandparents generation arguably too harsh (seen and not heard) think our parents generation broadly right we are far too wet and child centred and look where we are 🙄

KSJR · 11/11/2022 08:01

I feel primary schools are the problem, they are setting them up to fail in secondary. The primary I was working in is far too gentle, for eg it was a “no shouting” school. They had a time out room where they went to think about their actions. The kids loved this room it was just a chill with the rest of the badly behaved children who where in there. They are ruling the school Because of this I feel like the pupils think they are untouchable and go into secondary with the same attitude. 🤷🏼‍♀️

celticprincess · 11/11/2022 07:49

I’m a teacher. I’ve done supply and hated it. Only primary though. There’s a culture amongst people, adults included, to be disrespectful to supply staff. I’ve heard parents comment about supply not being a proper teacher. I‘ve also hear parents bad mouthing contracted teachers to their children and being disrespectful and encouraging their child to be disrespectful. I left a school where management would come in, the class would fall silent, then management would leave and class would kick off. The more they do that they’re the children lose respect for the classroom teacher.

OP should try primary though. It’s hard teaching all the subjects and not just your specialist subject, and behaviour can be bad, bur often primary can be managed better. Not sure if ever do secondary. My daughter is secondary and some of the mixed ability classes she is on sound awful. She’s autistic and has had to leave a lesson herself due to the behaviour of other children causing her sensory overload. She has no behaviour problems herself and is a rule stickler. There are lessons she now dreads. And these aren’t necessarily supply teacher lessons, just subjects that people take less seriously and that children are mixed ability for. I’m in special. It’s great. Behaviour can be challenging but you know the children aren’t doing it out of spite and there are ways of managing risk and behaviours.

tracylamont13 · 11/11/2022 07:08

I was a teacher for 20 year and left 3 years ago. It was mainly the system for me rather than behaviour but from what I hear from ex colleagues behaviour is appalling and Getty g worse.

TheClitterati · 10/11/2022 18:43

ScrollingLeaves · 10/11/2022 08:27

TheClitterati · Today 07:40*
My dd y10 doesn't recognise any of this for which I am super thankful.

She said there might be one "naughty girl" per class where naughty means answering teach back.

It's a girls grammar school

The parents and children will be very invested in a grammar school and feel extremely lucky to be there. In the first place.

Secondly, though girls can be naughty, bitchy and bullying, they are not on the whole as loud or disruptive as boys.
(Just as later on most violent crime is committed by men.)

Yes we are all very thankful to be there.

It is a concern that the grammar system might mean other local schools are worse off but I haven't heard of it being particularly bad.

Its not a particularly fancy or even MC area so its not a super fancy grammar school. regardless they do have good standards of behaviour from the kids - the school clearly set out the high standards of behavious expected of the pupils.

I know a teacher has created this post - but what are we do to for children when they are also trying to navigate this hellish situation and get an education???

Thepeopleversuswork · 10/11/2022 18:11

@Neerdoneerdo

Indeed. And as you rightly say there will always be parents who will default to private because they have a vague sense that it must be better because you are paying for it.

It doesn’t automatically follow that either the quality of the teaching or the behaviour will be better.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 10/11/2022 18:05

When I was in comprehensive school in the 70's, teachers were respected. Really bad behaviour was rare - the worst thing kids did in class was whisper or throw paper at each other

l went to a really well known posh comp in the 70’s. It was crazy. Throwing shoes, bags, books out of the windows, trying to stand on tables every lesson, throwing stuff, boys drinking lager (Braker) in lesson. Crying with laughter all the time.

Tjis was in a posh area.

woodhill · 10/11/2022 18:00

PandoraRocks · 10/11/2022 11:23

@CulturePigeon I think you've nailed it in your last post.
When I was in comprehensive school in the 70's, teachers were respected. Really bad behaviour was rare - the worst thing kids did in class was whisper or throw paper at each other. There was corporal punishment but it was only used on boys and usually a swift tap on the hand with a ruler or a slap on the bottom with a cane. There was no 'whipping' as one poster above suggested.

But as you've said, society has changed for the worst since then. Swearing is ubiquitous now . I never heard swearing growing up - women didn't swear in public and men didn't in front of women and kids. No swearing on tv. No explicit sex. The age of innocence for children has gone and now they're constantly exposed to coarseness and bad behaviour. And parents supported teachers.

Another modern plague is the 'cult of the child'. Kids treated like little emperors and granted their every wish to the exclusion of everyone else.

Isn't it just like that

Snnowflake · 10/11/2022 15:36

People seem to forget that you can’t physically punish children now.
Being belted across the hand was extremely painful and humiliating. Definitely a deterrent.
I wonder if these unruly kids get a one to one with anyone to plan out their future career. I think that might help. I had a stage of ‘they can’t make ME work if I don’t want to’ attitude at secondary school. I wish someone had given me a one to one discussion - helped me realise education was actually for my good and not The Government if the time inflicting it on me.
Particularly if you are in an anti Tory area so teachers are seen as puppets of the establishment.

Neerdoneerdo · 10/11/2022 14:59

A bad private school can survive for a number of reasons. It will probably be significantly cheaper than the local large mainstream private school. Or there may not be another private school nearby. Or there are a couple of good private schools nearby, but they select on the basis of academic ability, and the bad school mops up the unacademic children whose parents want them to go to a private school for snobbery reasons. Or they have good PR and some parents prefer not to move schools once the child is there. Or they're very good at one thing (eg they specialise in a particular sport) and bad at the rest. Or they are supposedly "like a family" though bad at teaching. Or they play on a particular religion, ideology or legend (eg evangelical Christian and Steiner schools). Or they supposedly specialise in children who have been bullied, or have ADHD (but that specialism may in practice amount to very little). Or they used to be a good school, but the current leadership is terrible. Or they have very small class sizes (and parents don't stop to wonder why the class sizes are so small). Or they use hard sell in international markets.
My DC went to a very eccentric, very small private school. It wasn't a charity and there was no board of governors - it had been bought by a wealthy individual who fancied having a go at running a school. The individual offered us a very high scholarship. And actually it was okay, and suited my DC at the time, but some of the other parents were very critical of it and there was a certain amount of drama there. This wasn't the only school of that type in our small city - there were quite a number of other eccentric small private schools. This was after the 2008 financial crisis by the way. There are a lot of these places around.