Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is behaviour this bad in all schools now?!

264 replies

Growingmyhairout · 08/11/2022 14:44

I am a supply teacher who's in a long term role but don't think I can deal with it.
I'm in a non core subject which doesn't help, one that pupils find difficult and don't have to do a GCSE in.
I was covering a 2 week sickness in one boys school, but couldn't have done anymore as behaviour was awful.
I'm now at what's been called a very challenging school. However I've walked past some other lessons and all kids are silent pretty much.
I've been here for a few weeks now so the kids know I'm not there just for a day or anything, yet no improvements.
I've been suggested to ring parents but if I did I'd be making 45 calls an evening which there is just not the time to do, especially for £110 a day gross.
I do give detentions, warnings etc. But it doesn't make much difference.
Some kids will just get up and walk out of your lesson when they feel like it. Or kids who aren't even in your lesson will turn up and sit in the room.
Coats on, phones out, earphones in, eating. When I tell them not to, some kids will listen but some will literally just ignore you. Swinging on chairs, shouting across the room, fighting, swearing.
Each lesson I send a few out to other classrooms which helps to an extent.
The worst are cover lessons though, as I'm used for cover as well as my own classes. Cover is an absolute nightmare.
I record everything but don't know what difference it makes.
Throwing things across the room, putting make up on. Answering me back very rudely.
Just all talking loudly and ignoring me. I refuse to shout over them as I've already got a hoarse voice from raising it.
I email heads of year, sometimes they will come in if they're not busy.
Some lessons are alright, but there's an insane level of disrespect.
As I said I've been here a few weeks now, how long is it going to take?
I've got a TA in all lessons which I'm really grateful about, but they don't seem to respect her much either.
We had an ok class this morning once the worst were removed, but had an absolutely horrendous year 7 group. She said she'd never seen a school like it.
I've been offered long-term, part time cover in another school. I'm tempted to go, but I'm thinking what's the point?
It's just going to be the same everywhere isn't it? I'm not expecting kids to sit in absolute silence for 5 hours a day but the behaviour is unacceptable. I'll be trying to speak and many students will just carry on having their own conversation.
I also feel like I'd be letting down the school who've even given me a TA when most other teachers don't get one.
I feel like a failure as a teacher. I think I've been firm but fair, but I don't think I can do this. Is behaviour really this bad in all schools?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Dotjones · 29/11/2022 14:11

I watched "Walking on the Moon" the other day on Youtube, an ITV drama from the late 90s about typical school life. It's more from the side of the victim of bullying and the inability or unwillingness of adults to resolve it, but it's a good drama and I remember watching it when it was originally broadcast thinking how true to life it was.

The reasons for kids being left running riot, to the extent they nearly kill people, range from the usual lack of resources, through not wanting to damage the school's reputation, to not wanting to deal with parents' wrath after their darling has been excluded. Human reasons, but ones that fail everyone.

The point is, rude, disrespectful and downright violent pupils are nothing new, neither is authority turning a blind eye. What's changed since then is that society has become more tolerant yet more polarised. In the 90s children were seen as capable of being inherently bad (remember the lynch mob chasing the prison van with the Bulger killers) therefore teachers weren't automatically deemed at fault for intervening when there was bad behaviour.

Nowadays the presumption is that the child is innocent, and if they did something bad there are probably reasons to excuse their behaviour, such as a medical condition or poor home life. Teachers risk assault or public humiliation and criminal investigation if they directly intervene, and any punishment or intervention that is not physical simply doesn't work.

In summary, yes schools are bad, yes they're worse than they used to be (and they were bad enough in the 80s and 90s) but they are the product of the society we live in.

swallowedAfly · 29/11/2022 13:50

At my school we had greenhouses and chicken coups etc and a lot of those lads would have been in there with the science teacher who managed them all. I think these sort of alternative provisions were fairly standard but tailing off by the time I was at secondary in the mid 80's to early 90's.

Snnowflake · 29/11/2022 11:33

How much of our tax is going to these wastes of space - I think I'm referring to the parents here mainly - Billions of pounds which could be put to helping health or improving homes. Just ridiculous. Then there's the thousands paying twice so DCs go private.

ScrollingLeaves · 29/11/2022 11:25

TheaBrandt · Today 10:25
Know it’s not pc but mid 80s the less academic lads were taken out by the very practical huge welsh male deputy head and taught bricklaying / tiling / they dug a swimming pool and built that. They enjoyed it got respect and learned useful skills and weren’t in lessons stopping everyone else learning French

What an interesting headmaster. He most likely wouldn’t be allowed to do that now because of Health and Safety. Some clever people think through their hands, but not through things on paper so much, unless they are drawing plans. Some academic people like to work with their hands too.

HowVeryBizarre · 29/11/2022 10:26

This probably won’t be popular but I think it is a British thing. DS is a student teacher of high school history in Aus, his placements so far have been two public (State) schools and one all boys’ Catholic school. He says the kids are great, the Y7 and 8s where it is a compulsory subject rather than an elective can be a bit “chatty” but in general the kids are respectful to the teachers and good natured. My experience of schools here with three kids is that bad behaviour is just not the norm or tolerated.

TheaBrandt · 29/11/2022 10:25

Know it’s not pc but mid 80s the less academic lads were taken out by the very practical huge welsh male deputy head and taught bricklaying / tiling / they dug a swimming pool and built that. They enjoyed it got respect and learned useful skills and weren’t in lessons stopping everyone else learning French.

Alysskea · 29/11/2022 10:09

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 11/11/2022 11:48

@CulturePigeon ,

No it was in Sheffield. It was still living on its reputation as an old grammar school.

l do think we were an exceptionally naughty class though. It was full of clever mischievous people. 2nd set, which l know from being a teacher is always the naughtiest set.

We were always getting bollocked. I loved it! 😁

Pretty sure I’ve taught at the school you are referring to lol. It was dreadful!! Now working with mental health and a student from That School has contacted me to say they are fearful for their life -they’re 12!!

Alysskea · 29/11/2022 10:04

Florenz · 20/11/2022 15:03

It'd be a hell of a lot better than what we have now when schools and society in general pander to the lowest common denominator and put up with crime and bad behaviour in the name of "inclusion". It does nobody any good.

Agree @Florenz - the wishy washy inclusion approach isn’t working, we tried it and it failed. It’s dangerous for the children who are attending the school and means no one can learn. It creates a postcode lottery that holds the well behaved students back.

Alysskea · 29/11/2022 10:01

Former teacher here - yes it’s this bad now. It is in every school I’ve taught in anyway - all very deprived areas. I have multiple friends who have been hospitalised after assaults from students. I personally had my hand broken by some Y8 boys.

There are a lot of factors (poverty, austerity, social media etc) but also terrible school management. SLTs constantly in denial about the extent of the problem, even when in the case of my school a young person ended her own life because of the relentless bullying (at least in part). I couldn’t do it anymore after the hand incident so I’m no longer working in schools.

Berryll · 29/11/2022 09:58

Sympathise with you Growingmyhair out.
There's little to compare with teaching lessons like the ones you're described. I've had similar recent experiences as a supply. The feeling for me is a sad combination of futility, exasperation and numb resignation I find; and I've always thought my class control skills pretty good over my teaching career.
Try not to take it personally; I think it is often a virtually impossible situation in many classes I have seen, even if you do have some support. It all depends on how much you need the job really. You're certainly letting no-one down.
I do wonder if this sort of behaviour is becoming education's 'elephant in the room', or has it always been this bad? A really serious sanction for chronic poor behaviour is needed; one that put's teachers in control; not the pupils or the parents.
Currently nothing is taken seriously by many of the students I teach, and other teachers either have little time or inclination to give real support. Some kids have tough lives of course, but then so do many who don't behave like this, and I'm unsure if emphasis on this excuse is really helping anyone in the long term.
It's a mess.

swallowedAfly · 28/11/2022 14:27

Never going to happen. Imagine the extra policing it would require, the levels of street crime, stabbings, thefts, AB, etc. Far cheaper to just keep them all in school.

Florenz · 20/11/2022 15:03

Meredusoleil · 20/11/2022 12:25

Love it 😀

Straight down and to the point. Telling it like it is!

It'd be a hell of a lot better than what we have now when schools and society in general pander to the lowest common denominator and put up with crime and bad behaviour in the name of "inclusion". It does nobody any good.

LadyMarmaladeAtkins · 20/11/2022 14:18

Off topic, but I'm fed up with reading these excuses such as My phone always corrects 'were' to 'we're' - it's enraging.

It isn't obligatory to use predictive text, is it? If you are enraged, switch it off.

Meredusoleil · 20/11/2022 12:25

Florenz · 20/11/2022 12:01

There needs to be a massive crackdown on bad behaviour in schools.

First day, "these are the rules, read them, if you obey them, you will have a good time in school, we are here to help you achieve your full potential in life."
"However if you break them than CLICK you're gone. You are out of the education system. Your parents will have to arrange education for you, at their own expense. You will probably end up homeless or in prison for most of your life. If you think this sounds attractive, feel free to break the rules"...

Love it 😀

Straight down and to the point. Telling it like it is!

Florenz · 20/11/2022 12:01

There needs to be a massive crackdown on bad behaviour in schools.

First day, "these are the rules, read them, if you obey them, you will have a good time in school, we are here to help you achieve your full potential in life."
"However if you break them than CLICK you're gone. You are out of the education system. Your parents will have to arrange education for you, at their own expense. You will probably end up homeless or in prison for most of your life. If you think this sounds attractive, feel free to break the rules"...

Berryll · 20/11/2022 11:29

I would say your experience pretty well matches my own Supply work this year; I've been pretty shocked too. Started a thread in The Staffroom part of Mumsnet asking about it. I would consider my class management skills and subject knowledge as pretty reasonable too.
Not sure I could cope full time as you are; 2-3 days a week and I'm shattered. Support is very inconsistent too with me; often kids have a detention anyway and so it's hard to actually create any extra sanction. Problems can occur in pretty well any year group.
Many pupils walk around, in and out of the room, chat to each other, ignore you, and have no interest in anything educational it seems. Too many difficult ones to be able to run an effective class I find for the few who would listen if they could. You end up feeling a strange stressful mix of futile depressed impotence that stretches for an hour, and then another .... I really sympathise, as your place sounds even harder.
There are extra challenges to being supply I know; but it's still mad.
I'd probably give it up if I was you. Wish you luck.

CulturePigeon · 11/11/2022 16:50

angstridden

Could be! A 'nice' school in an affluent area too.

Malbecfan · 11/11/2022 15:03

Behaviour in my school is definitely not like this, but I have experienced similar in some local schools and indeed in one private one. The private school was worse because the kids believed that they were entitled to behave like shits because daddy was paying for their education.

In 4 out of my 5 lessons yesterday, kids thanked me at the end. They ranged in age from 12 to 17. I know I'm lucky to work in a really nice school.

DdraigGoch · 11/11/2022 14:43

KSJR · 11/11/2022 12:24

It frustrates me so much. The children who behaved well where overlooked whilst the repeat offenders got to go and have a cup of tea in the heads room while they calmed down. So not only was there no consequences there was also no reward for good behaviour. It’s a failing system and I’d say 70% of the problem in children's behaviour today. The other 30% I would think is home life and learnt behaviour.

This sort of thing used to really wind me up. The perpetually badly-behaved pupils got to go go-karting if they could keep their nose clean for a week. What did the rest of us (who always behaved) get? Not a sausage.

Navelgazers · 11/11/2022 13:45

I would guess a languages teacher!

I did long term supply at a school like that, but the main problem was a core of girls.

I spoke to my line manager and insisted the worst girl was removed. Just removed from my lessons. No, no, can't do that, she must be included.

I said it was her of me, and I put together a pack of sheets, her book, the text book.

Next lesson, I told her off as usual, but this time I told her to leave and explained where she would be spending every lesson.

She got loads more work done. And the other 29 kids, including her groupies, also got more work done.

I checked her work as normal, and caught up with her for any mistakes.

Absolute mickey take, so uncaring that they get an education for free.

angstridden2 · 11/11/2022 13:35

Your story about the caretaker wouldn’t be about a denominational school not that far from Chorleywood by any chance? It sounds familiar!

antelopevalley · 11/11/2022 13:13

CulturePigeon · 11/11/2022 11:36

ArseInTheCoOpWindow
l went to a really well known posh comp in the 70’s. It was crazy. Throwing shoes, bags, books out of the windows, trying to stand on tables every lesson, throwing stuff, boys drinking lager (Braker) in lesson. Crying with laughter all the time.
Tjis was in a posh area.

This is very interesting, Arse! (Sorry!) Could you say whether it seemed to be a student problem (just downright obnoxious, spoilt, entitled kids) or a teacher problem (wet, pathetic teachers who wouldn't or couldn't take control out of some bonkers ideological principle?)

I'm guessing Pimlico School, or Holland Park?? You probably don't want to say. But I went to a meeting at the much-praised Pimlico School in the 80s and I was taken aback by the the rowdy atmosphere - kids running in the corridors, shouting between lessons etc. The management seemed proud!! I wouldn't have wanted to teach there or to send my children there.

I remember when a so-called 'Super Head' Tostig Fried....something (he was popularly known as Toast and Fried Egg) took over and had a large, framed, professionally taken photograph of each student put on the walls of the school. This was apparently to raise students' self-esteem and make them feel valued. I wonder if it worked? I don't want to think of how much that little exercise cost, but to me it's an example of profligate waste on some dopey idea that doesn't make any material difference. Much better to have spent the quids on more staff, which I think is the only thing that makes students' experience better.

I went to an incredibly rough school in the seventies in a hugely deprived area. We had none of these problems.

HerMajestysRoyalCoven · 11/11/2022 13:11

@CulturePigeon Some parents want locking up. The societal impact of their little darlings is going to be heinous.

HerMajestysRoyalCoven · 11/11/2022 13:06

TheaBrandt · 11/11/2022 12:46

It’s not fashionable to say and at the risk of sounding like a Daily Mail reader there does need to be a slight element of fear amongst the pupils generally to keep everyone in line. All this lovey dovey child focussed nothing must trouble you my little emperor frankly produces monsters.

Not advocating a return to the days of Mr Gradgrind but teens need firm clear fair boundaries and consequences that are unwelcome for those that push them.

Agree. I dread to think how this generation is going to turn out. Workplaces don’t run like this, they’re going to get the shock of their lives when mum can’t make the boss “unsack” them.

CulturePigeon · 11/11/2022 13:05

Right! I will try to make this my last post on here - I've monopolised it long enough. Story about the strange balance of power between students/staff/school which I think says a lot about the problems we have today. I'll try to be concise.

Notorious Y10 lad, frequently suspended, went up to the 2nd floor corridor of a local school (where I was working). He used a heavy metal bar to wreck all the lights along that corridor, then chucked the bar out of the window (from a height). Luckily it didn't hit anyone below. The fantastic caretaker was furious.

The Head, who was so wet he was dripping, asked the boy to write to the caretaker to apologise. The boy wrote the sort of pathetic, borderline-insolent letter which I'm sure any teacher will be familiar with - basically one scrawled sentence. When he gave it to the caretaker, the c/t told the boy he didn't think the letter showed any real remorse or understanding of the seriousness of what he'd done, and threw it into the bin.

Parents phoned the Head, furious that their son had been humiliated by the caretaker. His feelings were apparently deeply hurt. The Head then asked the caretaker to write to the parents and the boy apologising for his actions.

The caretaker (who was great - and it's not always possible to find such dedicated and competent people for what is a badly-paid role) then resigned, and I for one don't blame him. The boy remained at the school and carried on his usual trade.

Oh - also, when this chap was on duty after school or at a weekend, he would occasionally find boys (maybe not from the same school) engaged in petty vandalism and trespass. When he reprimanded them and asked them to leave he was, of course, called a paedophile and threatened by the teenagers with all kinds of allegations.

This is the world we have created! Enjoy.