Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

He will clean me out won't he....

111 replies

triangularprisms · 08/11/2022 14:26

I hope to divorce soon.Husband had an affair and left us three years ago.Kids with me 90 percent of time.He pays my half of mortgage plus 30 pounds per week maintenance for three kids.He agreed to pay extras eg education,driving lessons, therapies for SN kids.He hasn't.He either got fired or made redundant from his last job.He has now set up his own business and regularly has wads of 50's and 100's in his wallet, he shows kids. He does a lot of cash jobs eg building/plumbing etc. My eldest child asked him to contribute towards a car that she is saving for.He refused otelling her that as he is paying the full mortgage for 'me', maintenance and renting his own place at a cost of 350 pounds per month, that he lives from hand to mouth from month to month.The same man wears designer clobber and has had 4 foreign holidays in the last year . I earn 60,000 per year and it is not enough to raise my children .Granted, I have a car loan,a personal loan and a long distance commute and cover all christmas/birthday /education expenses. His contribution value is worth 500 per month as we have a very small mortgage. I have paid massively into a pension all my working life.He doesnt have one. Iam also a part owner of an inherited property..a fifth is mine... Will he be entitled to this too.. I have an awful feeling that despite him not seeing kids, paying such a miniscule amount relative to their outgoings and very probably hiding money, that I am going to lose out badly and I cannot afford to as I need to educate my kids in the future.The whole system seems so unfair.

OP posts:
ZaSar · 08/11/2022 17:31

@jennakong

But he does pay child support. What money should be saved for the kids exactly? They already live in the house he pays the mortgage for.

Also a lot of twats have overseas holidays for a few days here or there that really aren’t all that expensive. It wouldn’t surprise me from the sounds of it if he was that type.

Maze76 · 08/11/2022 17:28

£60k a year and you’re struggling?!

NearlChristmas · 08/11/2022 17:19

I think asking how people on benefits spend @triangularprisms is a problem when you have £60,000 income, a very small mortgage and pay lots of extra into a pension. You really need to see a solicitor so that a financial split can be agreed upon. The assets will be correctly totalled up including pensions, savings and property and the a fair split will be sorted between each parties solicitors. What people on benefits without your income and assets do is an irrelevant question since they are not in your postition!

jennakong · 08/11/2022 17:16

@ZaSar He had 4 foreign holidays in a year, unless someone else paid that suggests that he's not short of a bob.

Granted he may be an irresponsible AH with money, but that just suggests more strongly to me that what he does earn should be saved for the kids rather than spaffed away.

AnneLovesGilbert · 08/11/2022 17:06

You’re in Ireland? You had loads of info on your last post about how to limit the costs of your DC’s therapies. Why have you posted again?

sparepantsandtoothbrush · 08/11/2022 17:04

ZaSar · 08/11/2022 17:00

@CarefreeMe

Perhaps, yet 45% of Mumsnet users think she’s being reasonable. Really says a lot about the entitlement of some people.

To be fair the question in the title has probably confused the whole YABU/YANBU debate.

Cloudz · 08/11/2022 17:00

The whole system seems so unfair.

Is it also unfair when the wife is legally entitled to clean out the husband just because they were married?

I think all laws giving one spouse rights to the other's money are unfair. When two people get divorced they should each be entitled to exactly the amount of money they put in. And if the SAHP wants money for their domestic work, they should also have to pay rent etc.

ZaSar · 08/11/2022 17:00

CarefreeMe · 08/11/2022 16:59

Definite wind up! Someone on 60k considering leaving their job and living off benefits. Nah. Bullshit.

I agree.

Sounds like someone from the daily fail who’s trying to get a bun fight going over how easy it is to be on benefits.

@CarefreeMe

Perhaps, yet 45% of Mumsnet users think she’s being reasonable. Really says a lot about the entitlement of some people.

Blossomtoes · 08/11/2022 16:59

£60k and no housing costs... And another £30 a week per child, so that’s another £360 a month. So, so unfair.

CarefreeMe · 08/11/2022 16:59

Definite wind up! Someone on 60k considering leaving their job and living off benefits. Nah. Bullshit.

I agree.

Sounds like someone from the daily fail who’s trying to get a bun fight going over how easy it is to be on benefits.

KAYMACK · 08/11/2022 16:58

bewarethetides · 08/11/2022 16:33

Report him to HMRC

I worked for the tax agency of another country. If someone makes a false accusation without any evidence, they could be letting themselves in for a very serious punishment in the courts. Should this website really be letting this advice stand? People should take legal advice from an expert, not the advice of "someone on Mumsnet". The post alone is incitement to possibly commit an offence and, ultimately, it is the website which is broadcasting it.

Sarahzxcvb · 08/11/2022 16:53

Quincythequince · 08/11/2022 15:04

She has a mortgage!

Is this really necessary?

I think you need to read it correctly before correcting others.

HE PAYS HER HALF.

ZaSar · 08/11/2022 16:48

@jennakong

What are we basing him being loaded off? OP’s accounts of him flashing cash to impress the kids. Many builders are payed in cash sometimes, showing a dozen fifties to impress the kids certainly isn’t proof one is loaded at all.
Sounds like he has had to buy or rent a new property (as she lives in the one they used to) and still pays all the mortgage on her property.

He probably can’t afford his daughters car, OP says he had no pension and there is no good reason to think he’s loaded at all.

Eloise38 · 08/11/2022 16:44

@SuperCamp Haha, yes, good advice indeed! 😁

EmilyGilmoresSass · 08/11/2022 16:43

triangularprisms · 08/11/2022 14:46

Thank you for such detailed responses.I pay for every single item for my children and myself.Everything... so realistically if I were to divide it by 4, my children cost 7.5k net per year to raise,each. I guess I don't understand how households that have 100k plus gross PA where there are one or two working parents also struggle, but many do. My children have all had private therapies for one reason or another since their Dad left, for example.They have had Christmas/birthdays/holidays/school tours/ normal stuff finacially shared between two people. All cash purchases. I have never looked into the financial value of living off benefits but I wonder what the value of those are.It may be in our best interests to go down this road Are there any posters who live off benefits in a similar situation please

I live off benefits at present as my daughter has complex needs, her dad is no longer involved and I've no childcare evenings and weekends. and her dad only has to pay £1 according to child maintenance service. My rent is paid and after that I have about 200 every two weeks, half of which goes to bills. I have no money for myself and all my money goes on my daughter. I am wearing shoes right now with 5 holes in one of them, because I simply don't have any money to worry about myself.

So yeah... if you think those of us 'living off benefits' have value and it's of better interest then go right on ahead.

jennakong · 08/11/2022 16:43

Sounds as if he should be paying more if he's that loaded, whatever OP's income.

I take from her post that the mortgage is very small so if he is paying between £120-£360 pm child support (not very clear which it is) he is paying about between £140-£380 on the mortgage?

She says his 'contribution' (mortgage and CM) is under £500.

The OP could always save a greater contribution for her kids' deposits and uni fees, better than him spend-thrifting it on umpteen holidays and fancy clothes. He sounds like a teenager himself & it does look as if he is concealing wealth by dealing in cash all the time.

I take it she is remaining in the family home until youngest is 18 then he will insist on a sale/buy out?

She is in a ropey position re the above if he is paying the mortgage, surely she should be paying this herself and insisting on more child support?

DaenerysTarragon · 08/11/2022 16:42

Lost me at the benefits comment. Go and get legal advice, you can afford it.

SuperCamp · 08/11/2022 16:35

Eloise38 · 08/11/2022 16:34

@SuperCamp It literally states he is paying the full mortgage! I recommend you take your own advice.

Ooops - Fair point! 😳

It is good advice after all 😂

Eloise38 · 08/11/2022 16:34

@SuperCamp It literally states he is paying the full mortgage! I recommend you take your own advice.

IrmaGord · 08/11/2022 16:33

Read, Think, Respond is usually a good order to do things in

Isn't it just.

Op said:

He pays my half of mortgage plus 30 pounds per week maintenance for three kids

The husband is paying all the mortgage. Whatever happens in the future, for now she has no housing costs.

bewarethetides · 08/11/2022 16:33

Report him to HMRC

SuperCamp · 08/11/2022 16:30

Fattoushi · 08/11/2022 14:54

60k and no housing costs? Cry me a river.

He pays half the mortgage.

On a house that he will probably take half of.

Leaving her to house her kids on half the value of the house.

Read, Think, Respond is usually a good order to do things in.

Eloise38 · 08/11/2022 16:30

MoaningMaude · 08/11/2022 15:09

He only pays half the mortgage, try reading the OP again.

@MoaningMaude It clearly states he's paying the full mortgage, perhaps you should re-read the post yourself?

NoMichaelNo · 08/11/2022 16:29

Pull the other one.

Itsabitnotcold · 08/11/2022 16:26

But yeah. If he's paying the whole mortgage while you piss away 60k a year then he's got a good chance of getting the house