Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to tell parents they can’t visit until after lunch?

341 replies

Doicompromise · 08/11/2022 14:06

I have primary school aged children (and for context one sibling who has no children). My parents try and turn up every year first thing on Christmas morning to be there when the kids open their presents “to be part of the magic”. When they were really little they would turn up for half an hour to give presents and then we would all have dinner together.
The last few years they just want to turn up with presents to be part of the magic and go and have dinner elsewhere and enjoy the rest of their day which is up to them.
I voice each year that I would rather they did not visit in the morning so that we can enjoy our own time together as a family on Christmas morning and it’s not chaotic. I am usually told “no we have dinner to get to and we want to see the kids”.
Part of it is that they now don’t spend Christmas dinner with us so I feel a bit miffed they don’t want to spend that time with us. But primarily I just want to enjoy those precious moments while my children are little, I don’t want visitors there for “the most magical moments”. I just want to enjoy my children with my husband and then I’m happy to have visitors after lunch or visit other people.
I don’t feel I’m being super precious about this but if I am then I’ll have to compromise. I don’t want to upset my parents, but equally I do want to enjoy Christmas with my little family without feeling like each year someone rocks up to see the special bit and then leaves with no thought for how we wish to spend our day. Any suggestions?

OP posts:
lifeinthehills · 10/11/2022 08:29

lifeinthehills · 10/11/2022 08:28

I think a lot of people are projecting their own experiences.

I never had GPs in my life at all. It was always 'our little family'. This makes it easy to stand up for the experiences I want with my GC. I suppose I did issue an open invitation to people to come for Christmas but due to distance, my parents didn't come on the day. My MIL didn't come because Christmas had to be at her place or no place.

I do not regret having just DH, myself and the children for Christmas morning quiet gift opening. Those are my precious memories, they're the memories I have of my own childhood too. I have no expectation that my own adult children should do anything other than what they want for their own 'little families' at Christmas and I fit in with their choices.

I sometimes do feel a loss of extended family in general but that's a different topic.

That should be 'my children'. I would never stand up for experiences I want with my GC because that wouldn't be appropriate.

lifeinthehills · 10/11/2022 08:28

LisaJool · 10/11/2022 08:16

I honestly don't get this. They are keen GPS who want to come around for an hour, surely this is much easier than hosting them for lunch? Looking back on it my dgps were such an amazing part of Christmas. To think that it was important to them to want to spend time with us makes me feel so loved. I fear the "our little family" crowd will be very lonely when they get older.

I think a lot of people are projecting their own experiences.

I never had GPs in my life at all. It was always 'our little family'. This makes it easy to stand up for the experiences I want with my GC. I suppose I did issue an open invitation to people to come for Christmas but due to distance, my parents didn't come on the day. My MIL didn't come because Christmas had to be at her place or no place.

I do not regret having just DH, myself and the children for Christmas morning quiet gift opening. Those are my precious memories, they're the memories I have of my own childhood too. I have no expectation that my own adult children should do anything other than what they want for their own 'little families' at Christmas and I fit in with their choices.

I sometimes do feel a loss of extended family in general but that's a different topic.

Mamaof2males · 10/11/2022 08:17

Why don’t you go to them for Xmas dinner - make that suggestion and save some gifts for them too open then. This way it means your parents having to compromise so if they really want to see you they will do so. If they don’t then the same rule applies. Also saves you cost and rushing about slaving in the kitchen. Sounds like they want the best of everthing to suit them.

LisaJool · 10/11/2022 08:16

I honestly don't get this. They are keen GPS who want to come around for an hour, surely this is much easier than hosting them for lunch? Looking back on it my dgps were such an amazing part of Christmas. To think that it was important to them to want to spend time with us makes me feel so loved. I fear the "our little family" crowd will be very lonely when they get older.

MamGetUsOneOfThemToKeep · 10/11/2022 07:48

Would find it better to have ... I meant

MamGetUsOneOfThemToKeep · 10/11/2022 07:47

Brigante9 · 08/11/2022 18:40

OP says she’s tried telling them multiple times but her parents still insist. I think that’s downright rude. I would say ‘No, I’ve told you not before midday’ if they insist. I think it’s fair enough to want to have your own traditions.

This ^^

I love family xmases and my parents stay over. However I can see why other people would find Xmas just mum dad and DCs pottering, getting up when you want, opening presents relaxed when you want, quick breakfast and not waiting for (or waiting on) other people to arrive that dictates your Xmas morning (even if you have a closer relationship there's still everyone has to wait then come down and sit together with cups or tea whilst opening presents ..)

I think PILs are trying to steal that magic and then go on to what they want for rest of day, after you e said no, we are inviting you to eat and drink something after midday- as you have quiet plans for the morning.

whatkatydid2013 · 10/11/2022 06:51

purplemama1990 · 09/11/2022 08:26

It's clear on this thread that some people think of their parents as family and some see them as visitors, which means you can't sit in front of them with PJs on for some reason. I find this weird because I see both parents AND my parents in law as family. I happily sit in my PJs in front of them, my DH does the same, as do both sets of parents! If I started treating my parents / in laws as visitors, that would make my life so much more difficult. I'd rather just be comfortable in front of them and live my life.

I get this entirely. My parents are family where my inlaws were visitors and my father in law is still that way.
When we go to my parents or they come to ours everyone mucks in with making dinner/clearing dishes etc, helps themselves to drinks, would feel comfortable pottering around in pjs. While I told inlaws to help themselves to a coffee/tea/biscuits any time from
early on they never did. They’d sit and chat and wait to be offered one/drop hints. If we went to their house we were never invited to help ourselves and they got into a flap when I went to help with dishes. It’s weird that it’s such small things but it makes you feel a bit uncomfortable to be sat in PJs when people don’t seem able to make themselves at home.
All that said we like to do Christmas morning with just the 4 of us. We usually video call all grandparents and say hi and then my parents come for late lunch or we go to them and OHs family we do something on Boxing Day. It’s nice for the us to just potter about with the small people and have a lazy start and then it’s also nice to see everyone later. We spread presents out too so do Santa/us on Christmas morning, my families gifts after dinner and OHs families gifts on Boxing Day.

Stewball01 · 10/11/2022 06:40

It's very difficult to know what to do. You don't want to upset the grandparents but it seems they don't mind upsetting you. What does darling H say? Good luck.

Hesma · 10/11/2022 06:23

id be more than happy for my parents to come for the special bit and then not have to cook dinner for them. You seem a bit of a grinch OP unless there’s more to it

Looby57 · 10/11/2022 06:20

Apparently she’s tried to tell them but they ain’t listening!

Looby57 · 10/11/2022 06:19

Lock the doors and put a note on the door lol

Robin233 · 10/11/2022 03:20

Where is the OP?
Me thinks this is fake - for an article??

a1poshpaws · 10/11/2022 02:44

Tell them politely but bluntly that you and your DH want to spend this Christmas morning alone with your children.

Your parents have had their shot at "the magic" when you and your sibling were children. Why on earth would you continue to allow them to spoil your own family Christmas?

Clearly, many posters would welcome their parents in this situation. But the fact is, you don't. And why should you? It's perfectly natural and understandable to want the morning to be private, leisurely and intimate.

Don't be guilted into missing out on YOUR dream Christmas for the sake of a couple who want to cherry pick being with you!

Natty13 · 10/11/2022 02:13

I dont u derstand the rationale of saying "remember! Your kids will grow up one day and might just decide to do the same to you!"

That is exactly the point - when my kids are adults they are free to spend Christmas however and with whomever they choose. Me bending over and pleasing everyone else but myself/DH while they are small doesn't make that any more or less likely.

It's the typical attitude of so many from the older generation here in the UK "well I put my needs last so so should you" then endingup disappointed when in fact your expectations of it being "your turn" aren't met. My ex MIL was like this. She let people hog her babies and never let her hold them when they were small and she thought it was her turn to do that to me. Got a shock when I refused to play that and thank God. You don't get those moments back.

THEDEACON · 10/11/2022 02:07

Your home your kids your rules Christmas will be much pleasanter for you after you pay down the Christmas boundaries

Dinoteeth · 09/11/2022 23:34

Oh and are your ILs the same?

Thinking you can't exactly have one set or parents but not the other.

Dinoteeth · 09/11/2022 23:32

A question who class there parents as 'family' rather than 'visitors'.
Would they consider making you a coffee in your house?
Would they consider offering a hand to cook breakfast?

Spookypig · 09/11/2022 23:24

theyre not visitors though - they are family! They’re grandparents! They won’t be here forever. Will your memories really be ruined by having their loving grandparents feature in the memories?! Be honest - you’re just hurt that they’re not coming for dinner and that is reasonable. If you said ‘I’m pissed because they have ditched us and so I don’t want them to call the shots on the day’ I’d have said ‘well, I get that.’ But let’s just call it what it is!

Solonge · 09/11/2022 23:19

What do your kids think? do they want the grandparents there? as kids we all wanted my nan to be with us for the entire Christmas...my dad wasnt keen (his MIL) but we outvoted him. When my kids were small we had my inlaws every year for 25 years. They loved it...we loved that they got so much from it. My parents lived further and were a generation younger...so worked up till Xmas Eve and we couldnt put up both families due to lack of room. My parents only got to come to two Christmases with us. Now we have grandchildren and my son brings them to us for lunch....he films their morning and then we have another great hour of unwrapping presents we and my other children have bought them. Just remember, time is limited...one day the grandparents arent there anymore... and your kids are grown...and you are the grandparents.

lifeinthehills · 09/11/2022 21:29

UpToMyElbowsInDiapers · 08/11/2022 14:11

If your parents can just show up while everyone is in their PJs, and they put on the kettle for a cup of tea, then I think you’re being a bit unreasonable - if I were a grandparent, I think I’d also love to see the GCs on Christmas morning! (Them not coming to dinner is something I’d keep as a separate issue). My parents tend to come over fairly early and spend the day with us. I love it, but then, we’re close.

That said, if the expectation is that you need to fully tidy the house and get everyone dressed for your parents’ arrival, make them coffee and lay out a special breakfast for them… then YANBU.

I'm close to my family but I don't think I have any right to decide that I want to spend the morning with the GC, therefore I will. I had the right to decide what kind of Christmas morning I wanted with my own kids, now it's their turn to decide what works for them at Christmas. If that's a quiet start with the kids and I go over later, then that's how it should be.

MrsSkylerWhite · 09/11/2022 21:23

Perfectly reasonable wish. We insist our eldest spends Christmas Day with her little family unit. We’re happy to see them on either Christmas Eve or Boxing Day, whatever fits with the other grandparents though it’s going to be both sets together this year on Boxing Day which I think will be lovely. Two Christmasses is twice as good as one 😁

Hagpie · 09/11/2022 21:20

I would hate guests at Christmas morning, it’s a really special time for my little unit as Santa magic doesn’t last forever! Besides, I wouldn’t feel good in PJs next to other people who have showered and gotten ready for the day and I don’t need that stress. Thankfully, my parents and my partner’s parents are sane and we record the kids opening a few present and they are more than happy! I hope to continue the tradition of realising I had my time when mine were little when I make it to being a grandparent.

OP I know it’s hard but you just have to be firm and say “sorry not this year” and repeat it until it sinks in.

TheBigFatMermaid · 09/11/2022 21:18

I have grandchildren who are my absolute world!

They have three sets of grandparents. My DD and DSIL want and always have wanted a family day on Christmas day with just the 4 of them.

We are usually given a time slot to go to them on Christmas eve. We exchange presents, all open them there and then, so we get to take part in the magic!

This is perfect and works for all.of us.

YANBU!

CatsnCoffee · 09/11/2022 21:12

My in laws have alwaysl done that. They turn up all showered and spruced up and I cringe in my sweaty pjs and bed head offering my sweet, cream sherry which they sip through gritted teeth (they like the dry, pale stuff). I feel sorry for their neighbours with children much younger than mine, who they visit BEFORE us!
I do wonder if the whole ‘not staying for dinner’ bit is muddying the water for you. Perhaps you need to ask them directly why they don’t stay if it upsets you. You need to be firm about the morning ritual, but offer them a good alternative.

Lily4444 · 09/11/2022 21:02

In our house the kids open Father Christmas’s presents in the morning, then the family arrive and we eat and then in the late afternoon they open all the tree presents - a similar routine might work well