Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Emotional affair

163 replies

Helena22 · 08/11/2022 13:53

I found out about my DH's affair back in the summer. My children had been doing GCSEs and A'levels and apparently the affair was going on for 2 years, with a rep at work who had already been in a physical relationship with one of DH's colleagues. Anyway, he has sent many gifts to her with messages of love and these intensified up to when I found out. I confronted him and he's been tearful, remorseful and defensive in equal measure. They were having a lot of contact via Whatsapp, phone and tracked each other's location but I was so trusting I never really guessed or suspected. He even said I would get on well with her when I confronted him! Anyway, some months on and I am medicated for anxiety and depression, he is still at home behaving like nothing has happened and I just don't know what to do. I feel I need evidence to disprove his claims that it was just an emotional relationship, didn't mean anything, was a fantasy etc etc. It took him 2 weeks to end it although I don't know if he actually did and I remain paranoid. I can't go on like this - any advice?

OP posts:
ArcticSkewer · 09/11/2022 20:17

What do you want?

You won't get honesty from him.

Dishonesty is working for him as you will stay forever unless he accidentally fucks her while you are watching, as it seems only incontrovertible evidence will make you leave.

Do you think he will stay forever or has an exit plan?

Helena22 · 09/11/2022 20:09

No I think she will still be around even if he moves job as she has arranged to meet one of his potential future colleagues. The point is that she is likely still to be visiting him at work even if we move 🥲

OP posts:
KalaniM · 09/11/2022 17:00

She is trying to get him a new job?

Helena22 · 09/11/2022 09:17

wackamole · 08/11/2022 23:54

Declaring his love for another person (repeatedly over two years!) is serious cheating even without sexual intimacy. He's trying to minimise this by claiming it wasn't physical, but it's a false distinction.

How is he still at home behaving like nothing has happened? He's been tearful (useless to you), remorseful (a good sign if it's genuine) and defensive (a very bad sign). He claims that it was just an emotional relationship, didn't mean anything, was a fantasy etc etc ... how does this square with his declarations of love? Was he lying to her? If it was meaningless why did he do it, knowing he was risking his marriage, hurting you, tearing his family apart? What's he doing to make sure it never happens again, to repair your relationship, to regain your trust?

Only he can tell you what happened (she has no obligation or loyalty to you and you have no basis on which to trust her). He refuses. You know he's lied repeatedly (TWO YEARS!) and you don't believe what he's telling you now. Some relationships can recover (mostly) from cheating, but the cheater has to be willing to do EVERYTHING it takes to fix things, however long it takes, with no timeline and no guarantees. Your husband - still lying, still defensive, still evasive, still acting like nothing has changed - is nowhere near that point. Ask him when he will be, or if you two should be discussing (1) splitting up or (2) an open / nonmonogamous "business arrangement" kind of marriage going forward.

The only one benefiting from the status quo is him. It's destroying you and he's letting that happen. Ask him to leave (go stay somewhere else, friends or family or a hotel) if you need time and space to think. As you're medicated for anxiety and depression, do you have a therapist you can discuss the marriage situation with? And (sorry) if you've been intimate with your husband in the last two years, get checked for STDs if you haven't already.

(Oh, and her being cc'd on correspondence to him from a potential employer makes no sense unless she also works for the company or referred him. How would his potential employer even have their job applicant's former mistress's email address to add accidentally?)

She is a rep and has contacts where he is applying to work.....he said that the new employer copied her and him into the same email by mistake. There is too much coincidence for me. I was thinking he genuinely wanted a new start and was hoping that we could work through things but the discovery of that email devastated me once again and put me back into limbo land.

OP posts:
Idontneedaplate · 09/11/2022 01:26

OP, so sorry this is happening to you. Understandably, it sounds like you are frozen and in shock. Look, you've found all the details you could possibly find, he's refusing to help you fill the blanks, or to give you the honesty that yes, you deserve. He won't help you because it's a far better proposition for him to keep you in a bind until he knows what he wants to do next. I am so sorry OP but nothing has changed between him and the OW, she's helped him get his new job, they still talk and see each other. He's not saying that he's done a terrible thing to you and your DCs because to him, the past two years have been the opposite of terrible. He is not your soulmate anymore, he's not even your friend. YOU need to be your own friend here, you need to stop him eating you alive. Exactly what he has done with the OW is irrelevant. He's done enough to you already! Finding out more details won't change a thing. He's become someone who doesn't care if his actions hurt you and only cares about his own pleasure. You can't reach the man you loved and trusted because he's not here. OP, I am sorry, it's a horrible, but you have more than enough information to act in your own best interest. Shake yourself out of this limbo. Don't let him take all the power. Don't accept his choices if they don't suit you, start making your own choices and living your life.
In any case, lawyer up and protect yourself financially (and don't let him know that you're doing this) because he will not be looking out for you.

wackamole · 08/11/2022 23:54

Declaring his love for another person (repeatedly over two years!) is serious cheating even without sexual intimacy. He's trying to minimise this by claiming it wasn't physical, but it's a false distinction.

How is he still at home behaving like nothing has happened? He's been tearful (useless to you), remorseful (a good sign if it's genuine) and defensive (a very bad sign). He claims that it was just an emotional relationship, didn't mean anything, was a fantasy etc etc ... how does this square with his declarations of love? Was he lying to her? If it was meaningless why did he do it, knowing he was risking his marriage, hurting you, tearing his family apart? What's he doing to make sure it never happens again, to repair your relationship, to regain your trust?

Only he can tell you what happened (she has no obligation or loyalty to you and you have no basis on which to trust her). He refuses. You know he's lied repeatedly (TWO YEARS!) and you don't believe what he's telling you now. Some relationships can recover (mostly) from cheating, but the cheater has to be willing to do EVERYTHING it takes to fix things, however long it takes, with no timeline and no guarantees. Your husband - still lying, still defensive, still evasive, still acting like nothing has changed - is nowhere near that point. Ask him when he will be, or if you two should be discussing (1) splitting up or (2) an open / nonmonogamous "business arrangement" kind of marriage going forward.

The only one benefiting from the status quo is him. It's destroying you and he's letting that happen. Ask him to leave (go stay somewhere else, friends or family or a hotel) if you need time and space to think. As you're medicated for anxiety and depression, do you have a therapist you can discuss the marriage situation with? And (sorry) if you've been intimate with your husband in the last two years, get checked for STDs if you haven't already.

(Oh, and her being cc'd on correspondence to him from a potential employer makes no sense unless she also works for the company or referred him. How would his potential employer even have their job applicant's former mistress's email address to add accidentally?)

Helena22 · 08/11/2022 23:08

I am still reeling from the shock of what someone who I thought was my soulmate and best friend has done to me and our children - hence why I’ve not made any decisions yet. And I’m struggling with the lack of honesty and transparency since I found out. I thought I deserved that at the very least.

OP posts:
GoAgainstNicki · 08/11/2022 18:48

Helena22 · 08/11/2022 14:34

She was copied into an email from his potential new employer to DH. DH claims this was a mistake but its too coincidental for me. He's spent £1000s on her over the past two years. I have never had flowers bought for me every few weeks in our 20 year marriage. Its so sad and so upsetting but the worst of it is reading the notes sent with the gifts (I hacked his online accounts) where he says he loves her always and that they can never leave each other.

This man does not respect nor love you. It’s one thing to have an emotional affair and cross the line but to send gifts with such detailed messages is crazy to me. I don’t understand why you’re still with him

BabyGrooverBug · 08/11/2022 18:45

neverbeenskiing · 08/11/2022 17:44

Bad stuff happened. You don't need to sweat the detail of it.

I think sweating the detail is inevitable tbh because it's obvious she's still being lied to. If he'd come out and said they had an affair, they'd been sleeping together for two years then I'd agree with you but because his version of events don't add up, OP wouldn't be human if she didn't wonder what exactly he's been hiding and whether its still going on.

If he admitted to shagging her then the OP will have another set of questions.

Bad stuff happened. Dwelling on it helps nobody.

Darbs76 · 08/11/2022 18:43

Call the other woman and find out for sure one way or other. You can’t carry on like this

pjmasksitsthepjmasks · 08/11/2022 18:39

Whether he slept with her or not, he was in love with another woman. That means that he was thinking about her when he was with you. He spent time and money sending her gifts whilst he did nothing for you.

I'd rather my DP just had sex with someone else, than having feelings for them. His affair, whether sexual or not, is worse than had he been with a prostitute, in my mind.

Leave him. Your mental health is only going to get worse if you stay. Do you really want to spend the rest of your life second-guessing everything you and he do and say? Every time his phone pings, for the rest of your life, you'll wonder if it's another woman. Every time he leaves the house, you'll wonder if he's meeting another woman. When he's at work, you'll be wondering if he's sleeping with someone on his lunch etc. If he's late home, you'll never be sure if his explanation is true or a cover up for an affair.

Why would you choose to live like that? I'd rather be on my own than spend the rest of my life feeling like I wasn't good enough, never being able to trust my DH, and generally being a shell of my old self.

Please do yourself a favour and start divorce proceedings. For your own sanity!!

Herejustforthisone · 08/11/2022 18:10

He is lying. He definitely fucked her.

He is definitely still obsessed with her.

He is probably in still in contact with her.

He definitely doesn’t care about you and is prepared to lie to you, hide stiff from you, humiliate you and make a mockery of you and your family.

Leave.

Dinkyboo · 08/11/2022 17:50

OP if a colleague was telling you this exact situation about it happening to them, what would your opinion and your advice be?

I could be wrong but I suspect:

Your opinion would be they have clearly had sex, multiple times.

Your advice would be to run, he is dishonest and doesn't deserve you.

If that's not your advice then I apologise! If it would be your advice then you need to listen to yourself!

neverbeenskiing · 08/11/2022 17:44

Bad stuff happened. You don't need to sweat the detail of it.

I think sweating the detail is inevitable tbh because it's obvious she's still being lied to. If he'd come out and said they had an affair, they'd been sleeping together for two years then I'd agree with you but because his version of events don't add up, OP wouldn't be human if she didn't wonder what exactly he's been hiding and whether its still going on.

BabyGrooverBug · 08/11/2022 17:23

Helena22 · 08/11/2022 15:58

I meant the sleeping together....

Well clearly you'll never be certain about that but honestly, what else do you think they were meeting up for?

But it's academic. If you want to walk out nobody could possibly claim you didn't have cause. So if you want to go you can.

Equally if you want to stay that's fine.

What isn't fine is torturing yourself agonizing over the detail of what may have happened. Bad stuff happened. You don't need to sweat the detail of it.

ExtraJalapenos · 08/11/2022 16:54

I'm failing to understand why you need proof of them having sex?

He had an affair for 2 years! He told her he loved her! He spent thousands on her! It took him 2 weeks to break it off after u found out!

@WTF OP. Take a step back and look at what this man has done. You don't need evidence of him having sex with her. He's already had a relationship for 2 years behind your back. Be an example for your kids, and leave this horrid man.

QOD · 08/11/2022 16:18

op - should i leave him

everyone - yes

op but should i ...

Helena22 · 08/11/2022 15:58

BabyGrooverBug · 08/11/2022 15:58

...because you found the receipts.

I meant the sleeping together....

OP posts:
BabyGrooverBug · 08/11/2022 15:58

Helena22 · 08/11/2022 15:56

How can you be so sure?

...because you found the receipts.

Helena22 · 08/11/2022 15:56

BabyGrooverBug · 08/11/2022 15:51

You really do say "I love you" if it's just a fantasy.

...but you don't meet, have sex and exchange gifts if it's just a fantasy and they clearly have.

How can you be so sure?

OP posts:
BabyGrooverBug · 08/11/2022 15:54

ExtraOnions · 08/11/2022 15:37

Whatever he says to you, you will always think there is more .. as you don’t trust him.

You either a) forgive him and stop talking about it or b) continue down a path of questioning that doesn’t really have an end.

Are you able to accept that there is no version of this that gives you the answers you need and, and still continue in a relationship with him? If the answer to that it no, you need to end it and move on.

This.

Stay and and put it behind you, or go and put it behind you

There is no "Stay and dwell on it" option - you'll go mad (and so will he.)

BabyGrooverBug · 08/11/2022 15:51

Helena22 · 08/11/2022 15:48

Yes he has said he feels embarrassed about it but I just don't think you say you love someone over and over in writing if its just a fantasy

You really do say "I love you" if it's just a fantasy.

...but you don't meet, have sex and exchange gifts if it's just a fantasy and they clearly have.

Helena22 · 08/11/2022 15:48

Yes he has said he feels embarrassed about it but I just don't think you say you love someone over and over in writing if its just a fantasy

OP posts:
KalaniM · 08/11/2022 15:46

Helena22 · 08/11/2022 15:21

Am I being unreasonable wanting to know in detail what happened? I just think I need to understand why, how, when so that I can move on.

Likely he doesn’t know the “why”. Isn’t it called ‘mid life crisis’? The how and when details, I’m thinking maybe you want to stop feeling excluded, that somehow if he tells you the practicalities you’ll feel more respected, less marginalised. It sounds to me as though he has shame for the fact that he was devious, and he’s hiding his shame , and refusing to share his story. By refusing to share he’s excluding you.

ExtraOnions · 08/11/2022 15:37

Whatever he says to you, you will always think there is more .. as you don’t trust him.

You either a) forgive him and stop talking about it or b) continue down a path of questioning that doesn’t really have an end.

Are you able to accept that there is no version of this that gives you the answers you need and, and still continue in a relationship with him? If the answer to that it no, you need to end it and move on.

Swipe left for the next trending thread