Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

5 people have raised ADHD with me

114 replies

PetitP · 08/11/2022 11:24

And I'm getting a bit fed up with it. My son is 4 (was 3 a week ago). He is incredibly active, won't stop talking, won't stop running, but will listen when I talk to him and can focus for long periods of time. 2 people at one of his hobbies, and 3 other parents have mentioned him having ADHD traits to me and it is starting to irritate me. I asked both of his nurseries what they thought and they have both said they don't see anything that makes them think ADHD and that he's just very 'busy'. He is well behaved, he's just got SO MUCH ENERGY. AIBU to think that a lot of people have no idea what ADHD actually is? And to also think it's rude to tell someone you don't know very well that their child might have ADHD? Or am I being a bit sensitive here? My brother has ADHD and really struggles with it, so I am incredibly sympathetic and know a bit about it, as of course I grew up with him. He was diagnosed as an adult. Just annoying that so many people think they have to label things as neurodiverse without realising that children are different to one another.

OP posts:
AngelicPickles · 04/12/2022 10:31

I read what you said originally. It is not worth reading again. Got a very high opinion of yourself.

FurryDandelionSeekingMissile · 04/12/2022 10:28

AngelicPickles · 04/12/2022 10:21

@FurryDandelionSeekingMissile my apologies, I didn't realise there were two of you spouting unevidenced rubbish. I thought you were the denial parent. Instead you just deny others with no skin in the game. Bravo.

What are you on about 😂 I haven't said anything unevidenced and I haven't denied anyone. I've said that I don't think it's helpful to add a moral dimension to the concept of growing out of a condition (and pointed to asthma as an example of a condition where people manage to discuss the possibility of growing out of it without any qualms about whether it's insulting). That's not an evidence thing, that's an opinion thing. Go back and read what I actually typed, not what you perceived through your red mist, if you don't believe me.

AngelicPickles · 04/12/2022 10:21

@FurryDandelionSeekingMissile my apologies, I didn't realise there were two of you spouting unevidenced rubbish. I thought you were the denial parent. Instead you just deny others with no skin in the game. Bravo.

Ihavethisthingwithcolour · 04/12/2022 10:20

Op Neurodiversity is a strength. Anyone who’s done anything in history has been neurodivergent.

You sound a little defensive to me, it sounds like you don’t want your ds to be and so he isn’t in your mind.

I've been recently diagnosed (age 38) this self discovery for me has been very beneficial. I play more to my strengths now, I’m kinder to myself and I love my ‘hyper focus’.

Onthecuspofabreakthrough · 04/12/2022 10:13

Mahanii · 04/12/2022 09:59

Someone on here mentioned that the earlier adhd is diagnosed the more support you can get with learning executive function - what kind of support is this and how can it be improved? Desperate to help my ds (while sitting on the camhs waiting list) with his executive function skills as I would say it is his main struggle!

I've never had support with ds other than medication - there are a lot of webinars and YouTube stuff out there and I think you really just need to follow it all yourself. (Avoid most of tiktok though). Dr Hallowell on YouTube is good.

Imissmoominmama · 04/12/2022 10:10

Why do you think your child having ADHD would be a judgement on you?

I have it; my parents didn’t create it through bad parenting.

For what it’s worth, it makes me who I am and I’m proud. I’ve worked hard on strategies to cope with organisation and I get a real
kick out of achieving this. I have levels of enthusiasm for life that my friends envy- there are upsides!!

33goingon64 · 04/12/2022 10:09

It's entirely up to you how to feel and there's every chance these people are wrong. But just looking at it from another angle, the 'label' you fear being applied is a really useful life-changing tool for people who do have a condition, get it diagnosed and can get the appropriate interventions for improving their life. Not saying that applies to your son but in general it's a good thing to have a condition acknowledged. And if he's not in any way neurodiverse then being screened or whatever will confirm that, surely? Absolutely your right to ignore them if you see fit but seems a shame to outright dismiss the possibility of something that might help you all. Teachers thought my son might be dyslexic so we agreed to have him screened. He's not, but better to know.

neverbeenskiing · 04/12/2022 10:07

schools can’t apply for funding without diagnosis.

This is absolutely not true. It is something some schools claim to justify their failure to support children with SEND. EHCN assessment is based on need, not diagnosis. We have several children in my school who have 1:1 TA support and other bespoke provision funded by EHCP's who do not have a diagnosis, but there is significant evidence of their high level of needs. Some have suspected neuro-divergance, some suspected early trauma and attachment needs, either way they will sit on CAMHS waiting lists for years before a diagnosis happens which is why provision is based on need, not diagnosis.

AngelinaFibres · 04/12/2022 10:07

PetitP · 08/11/2022 11:47

I think it just gets to me because it is actually really hard work being a lone parent to a child is so active and on the go all the time. If I choose to have a day at home he doesn't sleep. It's knackering. It would just be nice not to feel on edge when he's being high energy and feel like people are judging me. I think I'm just really stressed and anxious at the moment and needed to vent a bit.

I was a single parent and I felt everyone was judging me for every damn thing I did or didn't do. I found it exhausting . My eldest son was just like yours. No one suggested ADHD but that was what it was. I think they felt I had enough on my plate without adding that in. He is 30 this year. He has ADHD. He always did. I was a teacher. I knew deep down that he did, I just couldn't deal with it because of everything else. Don't dismiss what people are telling you.

FurryDandelionSeekingMissile · 04/12/2022 10:01

AngelicPickles · 04/12/2022 09:48

What a surprise.
Asthma, being a non neurological condition is bizarrely irrelevant.
Good luck with the inevitable burn out your son will face by your denial.

I don't think it is bizarrely irrelevant to the point I was actually making (rather than the one you seem to think I was making), and I don't see the need to be insulting to me when I've not insulted you. And quite nasty towards the imaginary son you've created for me, too.

ADHD is brain-based. The brain changes as it matures, just as the lungs change as they mature.

It's entirely possible that growing out of ADHD is a thing that happens.

It's also entirely possible that it isn't a thing that happens.

I didn't and don't take any position on that. My point was that taking the concept of growing out of ADHD as some kind of insult is unhelpful. It's not a moral question, it's a scientific one.

Allsnotwell · 04/12/2022 10:00

I kept making excuses for him saying "he's just like me, this is what I do/did/cope/find difficult etc"

This is usually the difficulty.

Working in a school we meet parents with the same traits as their children and they assume everyone is the same.

They don’t see the issue. We can only suggest - but all too often the parents don’t want to hear.

This leads to children being more difficult in school, they are removed from classes so others can learn, and then they fall behind because they can’t focus and engage in lessons.

Keep an open mind and listen to professionals. I see some lovely children who cope well and some lovely children who struggle. A lot of ADHD children are wonderful. Others just need more support than is available because schools can’t apply for funding without diagnosis.

differentnameforthis · 04/12/2022 09:59

Willyoujustbequiet · 04/12/2022 09:31

Adhd is not autism and the academics and research studies disagree with you. People are freely able to google them.

Many continue to experience it into adulthood but its not lifelong for some and the research supports this.

Citation then?

And no, ADHD & Autism aren't the same but they are closely linked and often present together.

So how does a brain with ADHD suddenly not have ADHD?

Mahanii · 04/12/2022 09:59

Someone on here mentioned that the earlier adhd is diagnosed the more support you can get with learning executive function - what kind of support is this and how can it be improved? Desperate to help my ds (while sitting on the camhs waiting list) with his executive function skills as I would say it is his main struggle!

Fundays12 · 04/12/2022 09:52

PetitP · 08/11/2022 11:24

And I'm getting a bit fed up with it. My son is 4 (was 3 a week ago). He is incredibly active, won't stop talking, won't stop running, but will listen when I talk to him and can focus for long periods of time. 2 people at one of his hobbies, and 3 other parents have mentioned him having ADHD traits to me and it is starting to irritate me. I asked both of his nurseries what they thought and they have both said they don't see anything that makes them think ADHD and that he's just very 'busy'. He is well behaved, he's just got SO MUCH ENERGY. AIBU to think that a lot of people have no idea what ADHD actually is? And to also think it's rude to tell someone you don't know very well that their child might have ADHD? Or am I being a bit sensitive here? My brother has ADHD and really struggles with it, so I am incredibly sympathetic and know a bit about it, as of course I grew up with him. He was diagnosed as an adult. Just annoying that so many people think they have to label things as neurodiverse without realising that children are different to one another.

OP my 10 year old as the same. He was later diagnosed with Autism at 5 and ADHD at 6. He can also focus for long periods of time on things he is interested in, could build Lego models aimed at 11 plus years at 7, was doing P5 level maths in P2 and omg his energy levels are ridiculous. He wouldn’t and couldn’t sleep unless he was absolutely burnt out physically, mentally and emotionally. He now gets melatonin to help him sleep that his paediatrician prescribed. It really didn’t become obvious till he was nearly 5 and heading to school though there was signs earlier by 6 it’s all his peers had grown out of those types of behaviours and he was still demonstrating them.

OP I think you need to keep an open mind about this. It’s very unusual for 5 different people to wonder if your child has ADHD and ask so his behaviour must be quite noticeable. Also plenty of children with are well behaved. I was one of those kids with adhd who was well behaved at home and in school.

Onnabugeisha · 04/12/2022 09:50

He is incredibly active, won't stop talking, won't stop running, but will listen when I talk to him and can focus for long periods of time.

Id keep an eye on this OP. I have the hyper-focus form of ADHD and wasn’t diagnosed until I was almost 40. Not all ADHD is the inattentive, cannot focus sort. So do not expect ADHD to only look like your brothers ADHD. The hyper-focus type also means inability to stop, always active and doing something, can listen well at times, but also has hyper-focus. Hyper-focus is being so engrossed in one task that you can literally work on it for hours on end, even forgetting to eat or go to sleep. When this happens, I average 16hrs straight with no break. My record is 40hrs with toilet breaks/snacks brought to me.

isthisamistakeornot · 04/12/2022 09:48

Pumpkindoodles · 08/11/2022 11:33

People are SO dumb. That’s all you need to remember.

according to most people

liking things neat = ocd
Loud and active = adhd
introvert = autism
feeling normal levels of apprehension = have anxiety
feel sad sometimes = depressed

the problem is all of the traits of all of these things are experienced by all of us. The point is though, that most people don’t feel them to a debilitating
level most or all of the time.

also people like to just say things to hear the sound of their own voice and to be seen to have an opinion or an insight. Imagine knowing nothing about a subject but still being so self assured to diagnose a child and spout your opinion.

just take the opportunity to recognise the person is a moron and be glad you know now.

I agree with this!

Also the spotlight does seem to be on ADHD at the moment, I’ve heard loads of people talking about it and just in the past couple of weeks I’ve listed to a radio feature about women being diagnosed as adults and read a magazine article about ADHD. As a result it seems to be more at the forefront of people’s minds. Before this I think it was anxiety which was most commonly spoken about.

AngelicPickles · 04/12/2022 09:48

What a surprise.
Asthma, being a non neurological condition is bizarrely irrelevant.
Good luck with the inevitable burn out your son will face by your denial.

FurryDandelionSeekingMissile · 04/12/2022 09:45

Using they have grown out of it is a bit insulting because it implies those that don't aren't trying hard enough to 'be mature'.

I was told I might grow out of my asthma but I didn't, not completely. I'm not offended by the idea that some children with asthma grow out of it, though. Whether or not ADHD is one of those conditions, there's no value judgement in the idea that some children grow out of some conditions while others don't. Bringing that kind of moral dimension into it just muddies the question, which should be a purely scientific one (even though it's difficult to measure scientifically).

Willyoujustbequiet · 04/12/2022 09:36

AngelicPickles · 04/12/2022 09:29

As there is no other way to diagnose ADHD other than tickboxing symptoms those studies are flawed because clearly children that 'grow out of it' could have just been diagnosed.

Your consultant sounds like an idiot.

You're clutching at straws now.

What's the most likely to be correct.....an eminent consultant in the field backed up by all the leading academics saying one thing or you claiming another?

Denial is a river in Egypt and all that. I wont engage further there is no point.

caramac04 · 04/12/2022 09:34

Pumpkindoodles · 08/11/2022 11:33

People are SO dumb. That’s all you need to remember.

according to most people

liking things neat = ocd
Loud and active = adhd
introvert = autism
feeling normal levels of apprehension = have anxiety
feel sad sometimes = depressed

the problem is all of the traits of all of these things are experienced by all of us. The point is though, that most people don’t feel them to a debilitating
level most or all of the time.

also people like to just say things to hear the sound of their own voice and to be seen to have an opinion or an insight. Imagine knowing nothing about a subject but still being so self assured to diagnose a child and spout your opinion.

just take the opportunity to recognise the person is a moron and be glad you know now.

Spot on!

Willyoujustbequiet · 04/12/2022 09:31

differentnameforthis · 04/12/2022 09:23

Many do not indeed "grow out of it"... it's a neurological condition and cannot be grown out of.

My dd has autism, she is in a really good place right now because we have worked for YEARS on how to "fit into" a world that isn't built for her. Not because she is growing out of it. Currently she isn't affected by her deficits/symptoms (her terminology) but that doesn't mean it's going away.

It means she is coping. She will also have days when she isn't coping. Not being affected by "symptoms" doesn't = no longer ADHD.

Consultants can be wrong too. Our state's top paed told me dd wasn't autistic.

ADHD children become ADHD adults.

Adhd is not autism and the academics and research studies disagree with you. People are freely able to google them.

Many continue to experience it into adulthood but its not lifelong for some and the research supports this.

AngelicPickles · 04/12/2022 09:30

Misdiagnosed

AngelicPickles · 04/12/2022 09:29

As there is no other way to diagnose ADHD other than tickboxing symptoms those studies are flawed because clearly children that 'grow out of it' could have just been diagnosed.

Your consultant sounds like an idiot.

Willyoujustbequiet · 04/12/2022 09:25

AngelicPickles · 04/12/2022 09:01

Then they didn't have it in the first place.
They didn't switch brains. I imagine what your consultant means is that they were either misdiagnosed or have used strategies well so it doesn't effect them. That doesn't mean that's a permanent state, and could change at any time.
Using they have grown out of it is a bit insulting because it implies those that don't aren't trying hard enough to 'be mature'.

No he didnt mean that. He diagnosed it and went on to say there was a high probability he would grow out of it as many do.

Hes a well respected, published, head consultant psych so if he says many kids grow out of it then many kids do.

But the academic literature on the subject also supports this. The leading studies quote different figures some saying 50%, some 40% but even the most conservative figure acknowledges that a minimum of 10 -15% completely outgrow it with no symptoms whatsoever and over 30% would no longer obtain a diagnosis as symptoms are only residual. Given the substantial numbers affected then signifcant numbers do indeed outgrow it based on the research figures.

We can argue figures till the cows come home but its semantics as the academics all acknowledge some do grow out of it and that is the crux.

Adhd is not lifelong for some. Its common sense that if our brains dont fully develop until our mid 20s then its perfectly possible they grow out of it.

differentnameforthis · 04/12/2022 09:23

Willyoujustbequiet · 04/12/2022 08:56

Our consultant when dc was diagnosed used the term so I"m happy to accept his opinion.

People can also freely google the relevant academic studies. As they develop many children are no longer affected/experience symptons so many do indeed grow out of it.

Many do not indeed "grow out of it"... it's a neurological condition and cannot be grown out of.

My dd has autism, she is in a really good place right now because we have worked for YEARS on how to "fit into" a world that isn't built for her. Not because she is growing out of it. Currently she isn't affected by her deficits/symptoms (her terminology) but that doesn't mean it's going away.

It means she is coping. She will also have days when she isn't coping. Not being affected by "symptoms" doesn't = no longer ADHD.

Consultants can be wrong too. Our state's top paed told me dd wasn't autistic.

ADHD children become ADHD adults.