Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think a grandparent should want to spend time with their grandchild/grandchildren?

183 replies

Woopwoo · 08/11/2022 11:18

I understand grandparents shouldn’t HAVE to babysit grandchildren but why would they not WANT to (if they are physically able to do so)?

There are lots of threads on here from parents who struggle to get childcare due to various reasons, one being that grandparents can’t/won’t help out.

When I was younger I used to love going to my grandparents houses for dinner/sleepovers and they were always just as excited as me!

My parents don’t bother with my children and I feel really sad for them. They never ask to have them round at their house for dinner and I can count on 1 hand the amount of times they have had a sleepover (they are primary aged children)

If my children choose to have their own children when they grow up I would love to be the grandma and do lots of activities with them and have them for sleepovers! I just don’t understand why so many don’t?

OP posts:
Floordilemma · 08/11/2022 14:20

Both my parents and in laws are amazing, they'd undoubtedly have the kids more (if I asked).

My 2yr old didn't sleep until a few months ago, and I was always very reluctant to ask them to babysit as I felt it wasn't fair on them to have a sleepless night with her.

But, I am my mother's child. It's important to her that I'm happy and well. She's happy for the kids to have sleepovers anyway, but moreso knowing I'm getting some well needed rest.

Being a parent doesn't stop when they turn 18/move out/have their own kids. The way you support them might change.

It's absolutely the Grandparents right to say no though. Whether we understand it or not.

I'd never ask parents or inlaws if I thought they didn't want to do it. But it would impact the relationship if they never wanted to.

CaptainMyCaptain · 08/11/2022 14:16

gobblefiend · 08/11/2022 14:14

@CaptainMyCaptain

Of course I had to make 'sweeping generalisations' as I can hardly comment on everyone's individual circumstances. My parents generation were, on the whole, more likely to get more help from their parents than my generation does today. Your circumstances, as do many others, may differ and that's fine. I'm hardly unreasonable for stating it.

Everybody's situation differs which is exactly why you can't make that kind of generalisation.

gobblefiend · 08/11/2022 14:14

@CaptainMyCaptain

Of course I had to make 'sweeping generalisations' as I can hardly comment on everyone's individual circumstances. My parents generation were, on the whole, more likely to get more help from their parents than my generation does today. Your circumstances, as do many others, may differ and that's fine. I'm hardly unreasonable for stating it.

hiredandsqueak · 08/11/2022 14:13

I had no childcare help from my parents or in laws either. I went back to work when ds1 was 12 weeks old he went to a childminder that I paid for. I don't remember any of my friends having childcare from their parents or in laws either, it wasn't expected. That said I paid ÂŁ35pw for ds1 to be cared for from 7.30 to 5.30 five days a week including all meals.

CaptainMyCaptain · 08/11/2022 14:07

gobblefiend · 08/11/2022 13:28

Our parents generation are hypocrites really. Most had significant help with the kids (us) from their parents which was the done thing back then. But now they are unwilling to do the same for their grandkids for whatever reason. Women nowadays feel like failures if they can't hold down a full time 40 hour week job, parent 2 kids and look after the home. But how is this even possible without additional family help?

I'm not sure which generation you are referring to. My parents had no help with us as they lived too far away, I was born abroad due to my father's job. My parents helped me with odd days like school INSET but lived quite far away from me so couldnt help on a regular basis. I helped my daughter as much as I could because we lived quite close although I worked until I was 60, and spend a lot of time with my grandchildren.

I imagine you are most likely to be of my daughter's generation but YABVVU to make sweeping statements condemning whole generations. People and their situations differ widely.

DeedIDo · 08/11/2022 13:59

I grew up without grandparents. Three died before I was born and the fourth was an old witch who thought I should have been aborted (I've seen the letters she wrote about this).

My ILs were wonderful GPs, always happy to help, but never interfering or undermining us. My DPs had no interest whatsoever. They were an hour away, but never came to see us. I used to visit them at my instigation twice a year.

We would love to help with our DGS but requests are turned down and offers ignored. DH feels it - a lot.

SeasonFinale · 08/11/2022 13:55

I think our own grandparents became grandparents at a significantly younger age than we do nowadays so age, a busier lifestyle and a desire for more peace has kicked in.

BankseyVest · 08/11/2022 13:55

But why would they not want to

Because they don't want to, they don't have to have a reason. Nothing wrong with wanting, or not wanting to spend time with your grandchildren. Different people like different things.

tiktokontheclock · 08/11/2022 13:53

No one is under obligation to I guess. My parents LOVE their grandkids to bits, can't get enough of my two. But I know I'm lucky.

SlouchingTowardsBethlehemAgain · 08/11/2022 13:51

I loved being a mum, but now I am of grandma age with no grandchildren and none likely. I am delighted to have my time to myself again and get on with some interesting projects. I really feel for some of the elderly women I see wrangling toddlers, it is hardly ever elderly men. I understand childcare costs are a nightmare for this generation of parents and consider myself fortunate that I am not needed for such a role.

hiredandsqueak · 08/11/2022 13:50

UsernameIsCopied · 08/11/2022 13:42

An afternoon once a week or so is hardly doing the grunt work of childcare!

I provided childcare three full days plus a half day a week plus extras so a lot more than half a day so yes I would say I did a lot of the grunt work for dgs and will continue no doubt during holidays and illness.

Scottishskifun · 08/11/2022 13:43

gobblefiend · 08/11/2022 13:28

Our parents generation are hypocrites really. Most had significant help with the kids (us) from their parents which was the done thing back then. But now they are unwilling to do the same for their grandkids for whatever reason. Women nowadays feel like failures if they can't hold down a full time 40 hour week job, parent 2 kids and look after the home. But how is this even possible without additional family help?

I do flexible working, bit the bullet and got a cleaner once a fortnight which although added costs means that my husband does more tidying and we use private nursery, financially it doesn't make sense for both of us to work but it's better for everyone's sanity that we do!

We don't have family support nearby so it's not really a choice anyway. But I wouldn't put my DCs to my MIL regardless she refuses to follow instructions, gives our toddler sweets which we then have to deal with the sugar craze and refuses to do naps. Not a chance I would want to rely on her!

UsernameIsCopied · 08/11/2022 13:42

hiredandsqueak · 08/11/2022 11:54

Well I have provided childcare for my dgs although he is now in pre school full time. But I can say I much prefer spending a couple of hours on a Saturday morning with him when his mum (my dd) is here to any of the days I spent taking care of him whilst dd worked.
Caring for little ones is hard work and largely tedious which is probably the reason that parents bemoan the lack of grandparents' input as they want to offload some of it elsewhere.
I feel I did my turn when my children were little and I have no desire to do it again to be frank. My parents or in laws didn't provide childcare, I never asked because it was pretty much expected that if you had children you cared for them or paid for childcare.
No idea why there is now an expectation, even from my own daughter, that grandparents should want to spend hours each week doing the grunt work of raising their children's children for them.

An afternoon once a week or so is hardly doing the grunt work of childcare!

geraniumsandsunshine · 08/11/2022 13:41

gobblefiend · 08/11/2022 13:28

Our parents generation are hypocrites really. Most had significant help with the kids (us) from their parents which was the done thing back then. But now they are unwilling to do the same for their grandkids for whatever reason. Women nowadays feel like failures if they can't hold down a full time 40 hour week job, parent 2 kids and look after the home. But how is this even possible without additional family help?

I could cry reading this @gobblefiend On top of all that I have my MIL emailing to tell me how awful we are for not visiting her (4hrs) away. Her emails are full of If you had done this or someone else did this - feels like an attack all the time and then she wonders why I don't feel enthusiastic about calling her.

Tryingtokeepgoing · 08/11/2022 13:41

As people have children later and later, grandparents get older and older. When I was little we went to stay with my mother’s parents for a week in the holidays, and they seemed to enjoy it…. But, my parents had us in their mid 20s and so my grandparents were mid to late 59s when we first went to stay. Whereas now, with parents having children in their mid or even late 30s grandparents can be mid 70s before the grandchildren are old enough to stay over - it’s no wonder they’re not so keen in all cases!

forlornlorna1 · 08/11/2022 13:39

I watched my dear friend work so hard and raised her children. Then took early retirement to become childcare for her dd. She found it exhausting. But was pressured to keep doing it as her dd "needed" the break/quality of life her wages gave her. Just as her gc went up to secondary and didn't need her anymore her lovely dh was diagnosed with Alzheimer's. Now she's caring for him too. She always wanted to travel, study, ah just bloody enjoy life. But all she's done is care for other people who now that she needs some support, haven't returned the favour.

I'm there for my dc/gc if they need me but I'm not ever going to provide regular childcare, I do take my gc for days out etc. I adore them but I've done my time bringing kids up.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 08/11/2022 13:37

I guess people want what they want and you can’t change them.

However

It always tickles me when people say "it's so weird that my mum doesn't want to spend time with her grandkids, we spent loads of time with our grandparents growing up!"

Yeah, in all likelihood, you spent lots of time with your grandparents because your mum doesn't enjoy looking after small children.

This is probably true!

It does seem a bit rough when those who benefitted from their own parents being hands on don’t pass down the favour though.

That said, having worked full time through out raising my kids, as a single mum, in a high stress job, with the added hell on Earth of lockdowns having happened, I feel I’m unlikely to be in as good health as my mother has been throughout my kids’ childhood when I am a grandparent!

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 08/11/2022 13:37

There is a big difference between spending time with a grandchild, and providing childcare for that grandchild. I became a granny for the first time earlier this year, and I love spending time with my granddaughter, though we can't see them that often, because they live a long way from us. We go down as often as we can, and spend as much time with the family as we can, whilst we are there.

But in all honesty, even if we lived close by, I don't think we would be able to offer regular childcare - dh works 3 days a week, and I have long covid and mobility issues, so I'm not sure I could safely care for a young child. We would obviously be available for one-off childcare or emergencies - and when my DIL had to go into hospital, when the baby was only a few weeks old, my dh went down there to help ds1 with looking after the baby, so he could also spend time with DIL.

I do appreciate how difficult it is for young families at the moment - the cost of living crisis, on top of the cost of childcare must be absolutely horrifying, especially if you are only just keeping your heads above water. But it is also hard for grandparents who have raised their own children, and who may not be in particularly great health - and who may be knackered and looking forward to a gentler pace of life as they head towards retirement and beyond.

I don't think it is reasonable to expect/demand that your parents provide childcare for your children - you can ask, and I am sure many grandparents would be happy to help out - but if they can't do it, they have the right to say no.

As regards spending time with your grandchildren - I do agree that it seems sad if grandparents don't want to spend time with their grandchildren - I think they are missing out, and so are their grandchildren.

My parents didn't spend much time with my dses - they lived a long drive away, and had interests that made them want to spend most of their time at home - but I did feel that we were right at the bottom of their list of priorities, and that did hurt. My ILs lived close to us, when we had ds1, and couldn't wait to come and see him when he was born - I think he was only about 4 hours old when they first met him. Obviously I didn't expect my parents to get into the car and drive 5+ hours to meet their new born first grandchild, but I got the definite impression that they weren't bothered about seeing him. I don't think they met any of them when they were babies, and even when they were a bit older, they only saw my parents if we packed up the whole kit and caboodle and went to visit them. It didn't seem to occur to them that, with dh working full time, and the boys in school, it was harder for us to visit them than for them to come to us - dad had taken early retirement before ds1 was born.

Cameleongirl · 08/11/2022 13:37

Odile13 · 08/11/2022 13:32

Looking after children is a lot of responsibility and effort. I can see why people wouldn’t want to do it, particularly long days on a regular basis and for overnights.

I can too, @Odile13 bit when they never invite them over, never suggest meeting up (you always have to make suggestions to see them), etc., it’s just weird, IMHO. Especially if their own parents were interested in their gc. My DH can’t understand why his parents are so remote.

whoamI00 · 08/11/2022 13:34

I think you get confused about the difference between occasional visit and regular childcare. I presume any normal grandparents would be happy to see their grand children. However it's physically demanding to look after grandchildren regularly like every week.

Itsanemergency · 08/11/2022 13:33

Both sets of GP here have shown us how not to be when we become GPs. Disappointed in both sets to say the least.

Odile13 · 08/11/2022 13:32

Looking after children is a lot of responsibility and effort. I can see why people wouldn’t want to do it, particularly long days on a regular basis and for overnights.

gobblefiend · 08/11/2022 13:28

Our parents generation are hypocrites really. Most had significant help with the kids (us) from their parents which was the done thing back then. But now they are unwilling to do the same for their grandkids for whatever reason. Women nowadays feel like failures if they can't hold down a full time 40 hour week job, parent 2 kids and look after the home. But how is this even possible without additional family help?

DarkKarmaIlama · 08/11/2022 13:22

Their choice but you reap what you sow.

Both my nans were different one was involved and the other barely. Doesn’t take a genius to work out which one we were all devoted too well into old age with frequent visits etc. She was surrounded by us all at her death bed, the other one wasn’t.

Norma27 · 08/11/2022 13:22

Age is definitely a factor too. I have stepchildren and my mother in law was much younger when they were small and she did lots of sleepovers and days out with them.
We have to remember it is not easy looking after youngsters as you get older. There are 23 years between my eldest step child and my youngest child. It is no wonder they were treated differently in that respect.

Swipe left for the next trending thread