Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think a grandparent should want to spend time with their grandchild/grandchildren?

183 replies

Woopwoo · 08/11/2022 11:18

I understand grandparents shouldn’t HAVE to babysit grandchildren but why would they not WANT to (if they are physically able to do so)?

There are lots of threads on here from parents who struggle to get childcare due to various reasons, one being that grandparents can’t/won’t help out.

When I was younger I used to love going to my grandparents houses for dinner/sleepovers and they were always just as excited as me!

My parents don’t bother with my children and I feel really sad for them. They never ask to have them round at their house for dinner and I can count on 1 hand the amount of times they have had a sleepover (they are primary aged children)

If my children choose to have their own children when they grow up I would love to be the grandma and do lots of activities with them and have them for sleepovers! I just don’t understand why so many don’t?

OP posts:
SugarSandWitch · 08/11/2022 15:53

I have been a sahm for nearly 20 yrs, youngest is starting reception next year. No grandchildren yet, but I have no desire to be childcare for them when they do come along. I’ve done my bit raising children (and no I haven’t had any help from grandparents, mine are dead, MIL lives hours away) so am looking forward to getting back to work and when they are all older travelling with soon to be DH.

Onlyforcake · 08/11/2022 15:51

I hear grandparents complaining a lot about expectation being put on them. My own parents were pretty shit at that, some people just aren't good with children.

lemmein · 08/11/2022 15:51

I look after my DGS a lot; I love having him - he has his own room/toys/clothes here.

Not sure I'd be so keen if I had lots of GC though - one knackers me!

LadyApplejack · 08/11/2022 15:49

You'll get loads here calling you unreasonable but I'm with you 100%.

My parents love seeing my children and do what they can as regards the odd babysit/sleepover (nothing mega regular/reliant!). But as a result the kids adore them, and DH and I get the odd desperately-needed break and time together. My own GPs mucked in with us as kids and now as an adult I regularly Ioad the kids on my days off and visit them of my own volition. I do it because I want to, but also I feel a duty to the time and effort they spent supporting my hardworking parents and fussing us kids.

The in-laws are retired, youngish, fit and able-bodied. Nothing but time on their hands. But they'll move mountains to avoid seeing the kids without us, even on the rarest occasion/emergency. My DC are well past the baby stage and very well behaved but I've realized the ILs simply CBA. I find it odd as hell but hey Ho. They'll reap what they sow.

Runnerduck34 · 08/11/2022 15:41

It varies between GPs as everyone is different.
Neither set of GPs were particularly hands on when my DC were little and one GP usually forgets their birthdays doesn't bother with Xmas gifts ( DC they are in their teens)
I have friends whose parents have been really involved with their GC and love seeing them, been very supportive and have a close bond with GC. Sadly we haven't had this but I've just learnt to accept it.

Lozzybear · 08/11/2022 15:38

It actually breaks my heart when I read about grandparents not wanting to spend much time with their grandchildren. My mum was terminally ill when my DS1 was born. She survived until he was 22 months old and spent every second that she could with him during those precious 22 months. I still get very upset about the fact that she never met DS2 (who is now 9) and that she hasn’t got to see what a special young man her oldest grandson has grown into. My dad spends so much time with his grandchildren. He says that he keeps him young.

Yellowcakestand · 08/11/2022 15:37

My sons grandparents on fathers side cut contact a year after his dad assaulted me.
I just couldn't believe they would do it to a second grandchild. Though I don't know why I was surprised

bigfamilygrowingupfast · 08/11/2022 15:31

I think this all the time - my parents get so much out of looking after their grandchildren! It's a whole new lease of life for them! So many of my friends have parents or in-laws who point blank refuse to have them for even half an hour. I find it very hard to relate to personally

Chailatteplease · 08/11/2022 15:29

DarkKarmaIlama · 08/11/2022 13:22

Their choice but you reap what you sow.

Both my nans were different one was involved and the other barely. Doesn’t take a genius to work out which one we were all devoted too well into old age with frequent visits etc. She was surrounded by us all at her death bed, the other one wasn’t.

This. I helped my elderly grandparents with care a lot and spent the last days of one’s life by their bedside.
My own parents won’t get that level of commitment and closeness. You definitely reap what you sow.

Coyoacan · 08/11/2022 15:28

takealettermsjones · 08/11/2022 11:27

It can be more difficult looking after someone else's children than your own - absence of normal routine can disrupt meals and sleeping, different rules at home might mean children act up/misbehave or try to "get away with" stuff, parents might disagree with the way the babysitter has done things so could cause arguments...

This is so true. Also not every grandparent has boundless energy

FickleFingerOfCake · 08/11/2022 15:23

MonkeyPuddle · 08/11/2022 11:34

DP and me were chatting about this last night. His parents have absolutely no desire or drive to see their grandchildren. DSD is early teens and they’ve probably met her about 6 times in her life, nothing since she was 5/6 years old.
Theyve only met our 2 year old maybe 3 times. They just don’t care. Never have, never will.
They will only see the children if we take them to their house, no health concerns, both still working.
I asked them once not to smoke just while newborn DD had been taken to see them and they kicked off. Like I get that it’s their house and they can do as they want, but 45 minutes without smoking 2 meters away from a newborn isn’t asking too much. DP
doesn’t push it with them, he gave up on them a long time ago.
Their loss, my family is wonderful and DP is a much better parent than his parent ever were.

I could have written this exact post, DHs parents only live a couple of hours away, DD1 was not their first grandchild however she was the first grandchild to live on the same continent as them and it still took them until she was 5 months old to grudgingly come and visit. DD1 is now 12 and hasn't seen them for years but both DH and I are absolutely fine with that; they were pretty useless parents and have proved similar as grandparents. My DC are fortunate to have a lovely set of grandparents on my side and various other brilliant family and family friends of the same generation who adore them and fulfil a grandparent type role 😊

Bananarama21 · 08/11/2022 15:15

Alot is circumstances are diffeence many grandparents are still in full time work when previously they weren't so they are shattered and don't have the energy to care for young children. There's nothing stopping you from taking your dc to see your parents and have a relationship that doesn't involve babysitting

ANiceCupofTeaandaScone · 08/11/2022 15:11

My mum lives over 300 miles away. She hasn’t so much as spoken to DD on the phone since we visited her in July (5.5 hrs on the train with 3 changes and a short drive each end). I know she is exhausted as she still works, but am hugely sad for DD not to really have a relationship with her granny. Fortunately DD seems oblivious and is delighted to see her when we do visit.

FuckNuggets · 08/11/2022 15:05

YABU everyone is different. I've very recently become a grandmother, (DGD is 3 months old). I've babysat a few times for a couple of hours whilst DSD has had things to do. But, whilst I absolutely adore DGD one of the the joys of being a grandparent is handing them back!

I hated the early years with my own kids, it was so bloody hard! My youngest is now 16 and life so much easier now.

hiredandsqueak · 08/11/2022 14:59

RidingMyBike · 08/11/2022 14:52

I don't enjoy spending time with children, it's boring and relentless, even though I love DD. And that's why I can't imagine not helping her out when she has children and I become a grandparent. Not regular childcare but being prepared to have GC for a few hours once every month or so. That sort of support would have made such a difference to me when DD was tiny.

I also suspect my mum finds small children boring and relentless and too much like hard work. The difference is that she chose to have two close together (I stopped at one) and then dumped them on her own housebound infirm mum for a few hours every week!

I also don't get how you can avoid the children when they're small and actively avoid doing anything with them, then expect them to have a relationship with you as teenagers or older?!

My children didn't have childcare provided by parents or in laws but we visited regularly as a family. They loved all of them but adored FIL especially. When they were teens and FIL lost MIL they took it upon themselves without any prompting to go and spend time with him most weeks. My boys spent many weekends helping him in the garden or garage and my daughter went shopping with him not because it was expected or because he had done childcare but because they genuinely enjoyed his company and wanted to be there.

Chailatteplease · 08/11/2022 14:55

YANBU OP.

I too spent loads of time with my grandparents and grew up very close to them. My own parents never had to worry about childcare, but when it came to me needing help with childcare, I was always made to feel like it was a burden and as though I should be hugely grateful. Even though they definitely took for granted the amount of help they had with me. I’ve never understood the double standard.

RidingMyBike · 08/11/2022 14:52

I don't enjoy spending time with children, it's boring and relentless, even though I love DD. And that's why I can't imagine not helping her out when she has children and I become a grandparent. Not regular childcare but being prepared to have GC for a few hours once every month or so. That sort of support would have made such a difference to me when DD was tiny.

I also suspect my mum finds small children boring and relentless and too much like hard work. The difference is that she chose to have two close together (I stopped at one) and then dumped them on her own housebound infirm mum for a few hours every week!

I also don't get how you can avoid the children when they're small and actively avoid doing anything with them, then expect them to have a relationship with you as teenagers or older?!

summermode · 08/11/2022 14:51

It also depends on how many grandchildren...

Mylittlesandwich · 08/11/2022 14:46

Untitledsquatboulder · 08/11/2022 14:41

Not really so much ironic as logical. If she struggled to cope with her own child day to day I guess she's not suddenly going to find it easier some 30 years later with someone else's.

No I mean I get it. I just find it dryly amusing that she got the support of my grandparents but I’m supposed to be the perfect mother without hers.
Spoiler alert I’m far from perfect but I do my best.

Tiredalwaystired · 08/11/2022 14:45

My mum would have adored babysitting her grandchildren but she died before they were born. My dad didn’t even remember their birthdays.

Untitledsquatboulder · 08/11/2022 14:41

Mylittlesandwich · 08/11/2022 11:27

My mum doesn't like to look after DS. Considering the amount of time I spent at my grandparents as a child I find it quite ironic. But it's her choice. She doesn't want to, she doesn't have to. Thankfully my DSis and her wife love having him so he has an amazing relationship with them and I can get some help if I need it.

Not really so much ironic as logical. If she struggled to cope with her own child day to day I guess she's not suddenly going to find it easier some 30 years later with someone else's.

Bideshi · 08/11/2022 14:34

illiterato · 08/11/2022 12:41

Some people just don’t really like children, and some of those people do have children of their own but once they’re done, they’re done. I suspect I might be a bit like that if I’m honest. I like my own children but generally much prefer adult company/ spaces. Unclear how if feel about grandchildren but I think my dc can probably assume that regular childcare is not going to happen.

This. I really can't be arsed to play Top Trumps for hours or dreary board games that I can't grasp the pointless rules of. When they're in their teens and I can have a proper conversation with them, fine. Happy to spend time with them. But, much as I love my grandchildren, I find the under 12s boring.
I think the assumption that grandparents have some sort of duty to be hands on is pretty insulting actually. I do have my own life.

whumpthereitis · 08/11/2022 14:32

gobblefiend · 08/11/2022 14:14

@CaptainMyCaptain

Of course I had to make 'sweeping generalisations' as I can hardly comment on everyone's individual circumstances. My parents generation were, on the whole, more likely to get more help from their parents than my generation does today. Your circumstances, as do many others, may differ and that's fine. I'm hardly unreasonable for stating it.

I’m not sure how they’re hypocrites. Presumably if they had help they accepted it from parents willing to offer it. Conversely, they’re not willing to offer it, so they don’t.

It’s entirely different people making entirely different decisions.

StillMedusa · 08/11/2022 14:25

I'm a Granny...and love it, and dropped to part time at work so that I could fill in the child care gaps as my DD2 and her dh are nurses so standard child care doesn't work.
But what drives me is I had no help when my four were small...no support from any grandparent and it was tough. So I am very happy to help, and I love the bond I have with my little grandson. I'm also in my 50s , quite fit and healthy and able to do it.
In 10 years it might be a different matter!

I know my DD2 is grateful that she can drop off my grandson at 6.30 am and go to work knowing he is happy to be with me, but I completely understand that some grandparents do not want to go through child rearing...which it is... all over again!!!!

I'm knackered by the end of the day!

gobblefiend · 08/11/2022 14:20

@CaptainMyCaptain

So if everyone's situation always differs, then when is it ever appropriate to make a generalisation? Never?

Swipe left for the next trending thread