Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think a grandparent should want to spend time with their grandchild/grandchildren?

183 replies

Woopwoo · 08/11/2022 11:18

I understand grandparents shouldn’t HAVE to babysit grandchildren but why would they not WANT to (if they are physically able to do so)?

There are lots of threads on here from parents who struggle to get childcare due to various reasons, one being that grandparents can’t/won’t help out.

When I was younger I used to love going to my grandparents houses for dinner/sleepovers and they were always just as excited as me!

My parents don’t bother with my children and I feel really sad for them. They never ask to have them round at their house for dinner and I can count on 1 hand the amount of times they have had a sleepover (they are primary aged children)

If my children choose to have their own children when they grow up I would love to be the grandma and do lots of activities with them and have them for sleepovers! I just don’t understand why so many don’t?

OP posts:
Rebelmcstreettuff · 08/11/2022 18:58

Love my inlaws,they looked after both my kids and enabled me to go back to work.
My kids have such a great relationship with them and they are very close.
My DM was never much bothered and it used to upset me as I never had any Grandparents growing up.
It was such a relief to have someone on hand when the kids were sick or needed picking up from school etc to know I could rely on them.
I really feel for parents on here who have no support and rely on childcare.
I hope to have Grandchildren and will be retired by then,I will certainly offer my services if needed.

ilovepixie · 08/11/2022 18:48

These grandparents who don't help out or mums who say they won't help with future grandchildren, will you expect help in your old age?

ilovepixie · 08/11/2022 18:18

It's a shame some families aren't closer. My best memories from childhood were staying with extended family. It was a real treat and we looked forward to it so much. I don't have kids but my mum looked after and had my sisters kids all the time as did I. They loved and still do love staying with me and their granny.

Glittertwins · 08/11/2022 18:10

PILs couldn't give a damn about ours because we wouldn't dance to their tune anymore - we had our own life. Even when we did go there, they didn't actually do anything with them either, they were just used to parade to the neighbours 🙄

Maggie178 · 08/11/2022 18:08

One set of grandparents provide childcare for work and have sleepovers. The other set of grandparents see them every few months and rarely babysit. The children have very different relationships with their grandparents. The children are very close to the set they spend time with. Shy with the ones they barely see. You get back what you put in.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 08/11/2022 17:55

Yellowcakestand · 08/11/2022 15:37

My sons grandparents on fathers side cut contact a year after his dad assaulted me.
I just couldn't believe they would do it to a second grandchild. Though I don't know why I was surprised

My father died when I was 13 and we moved to a city because my mother had to go out to work.When I asked if I could go back to visit my paternal grandmother in our old town she told my mother that there was no point as 'we had nothing in common.' I've often wondered if that was aimed at me or my mother (whom GM didn't like at all for marrying her golden boy) for taking us a couple of hundred miles away.

Clovacloud · 08/11/2022 17:49

@forlornlorna1 I’d say my Dad has looked after my DD as many times as my Mum. In all honesty he’s probably better at it, as he’s a lot more laid back with her. DD’s definitely learnt her love of the outside and gardening from him. DD went to their house recently to help him move wood for the winter, which I thought was pretty sweet for a 20yo to do.

happiertimes123 · 08/11/2022 17:34

It is sad. I had a wonderful relationship with my DGM growing up, she is alive now and truly my best friend. It's such a special relationship.

DW and I have no children yet but I know my mum won't be very interested. However PIL are brilliant :-)

I don't think grandparents should feel as if they need to do childcare but I think it's really sad when they don't make an effort to build any form of relationship at all.

forlornlorna1 · 08/11/2022 17:32

I'd like to know if there's any grandfathers out there helping with childcare etc? Let's face it when people are saying grandparents they mean the grandmother don't they. Or is it yet another thing only women are supposed to do.

Clovacloud · 08/11/2022 17:26

My DD has a very close relationship with my parents. They’ve not done a massive amount of childcare, but they have always taken interest in her life. As she went into her teen years they talked and texted with her and have meals together. It’s a warm loving relationship.

My in laws on the other hand, not one iota of interest in 20 years. No childcare whatsoever, not even an hour when we’ve been desperate, like for a hospital appointment. They don’t talk to her, don’t communicate even when she visits. She’ll get a cursory ‘hello’ and then ignore her for the next 2 hours. It’s not just her they are like it with, they are with their seven other grandchildren and even their great grandchildren now. However they will moan about how no one visits or calls them, can’t think why??

It’s such a shame. There doesn’t need to be a lot of childcare to have a warm relationship. But being completely disinterested in your grandchildren, I think is just very odd.

LadyApplejack · 08/11/2022 16:59

Rinatinabina · 08/11/2022 16:39

I think there is a middle ground between NC and childcare. Many people spent time with their grandparents with their parents and developed a good relationship. You don’t need to provide babysitting to develop that. The babysitting and overnights is for the parents to have a break. The relationship between grandchild and grandparents is about grandparents taking an interest and being present. Quality time is what’s important.

Totally agree there's a middle ground but would have thought a bit of babysitting (not regular fixed childcare!) is pretty close to it. It doesn't take over anyone's retirement but it's 1:1 with the kids that also gives the parents the odd break.

My ILs will only ever come to us to see the GCs, so it becomes an effort/obligation for us to host them on our weekends, in addition to working full time. I resent it as my youngish ILs could easily cope for a couple of hours whilst DH and I benefit from rare time alone, even just to run boring adult errands! Why should I give up my weekends so perfectly able GPs can say they've made an effort with the kids? But we always have to be available, if we weren't present they would literally never see the GC.

Mommabear20 · 08/11/2022 16:53

Because they're not their kids, and they've done their child raising years and don't want that responsibility again 🤷‍♀️

What I don't understand, is why so many people have children, just to hand them off to grandparents when they realise that being a parent is hard and can't be bothered to do the time themselves!

SnitterBug · 08/11/2022 16:50

I've noticed Great Grandparents are not so much in to their GreatGrandchildren . They are just too old to do anything with them and are likely to die when they are very small so GG will have no memories of them so they don't put much effort in . That's my mums explanation .

glasshole · 08/11/2022 16:50

I'm a 44 yo woman and I've spent the last 26 years parenting.... in fact I've still got a teenager at home. I love my grand kids but I'm exhausted after raising 4 kids and my nephew. The very idea of having a baby/toddler overnight makes me feel physically unwell. It was absolutely my daughters choice to have kids but that doesn't mean I have to look after them over night and take them on holiday. I have the toddler for One 4-6 hour period a month with my husband and that is mainly because I feel guilted into it. I do occasionally choose to pick him up if I'm going shopping but that's only because he sleeps in the car and I only have to "care" for him in the trolley- but it means she gets 2-3 hours respite. We sure would if she hasn't just had another baby. Don't get me wrong, I'm the future as he gets older I might feel very differently and could even take the kids away for a weekend or something but it will be because it's MY choice.

PWV · 08/11/2022 16:46

We didn't spend too my time with our nan because she died by the time I was 5. Both grandads were dead before we were both.

My parents spent a lot of good quality time with my children, including taking them on holiday. They had then overnight fairly regularly (offered). They never had them for 'childcare'.

My own Grandchild is now so far away (150 miles) and it breaks my heart that I'll never be living close to them. I'd love to have them lots.

nutbrownhare15 · 08/11/2022 16:46

Understanding how hard parenthood is, and having had quite a lot of support from my own parents, I will do what I can for my own daughters if they start a family from wanting to help them out as well as spend time with my own kids. Do I think people should be obligated? No? But I do think that part of a loving family is to support those who have a lot going on in their lives and to want to get to know the younger members

Rinatinabina · 08/11/2022 16:41

Often its grandmothers who are expected to pick up the slack, women who often worked and took the brunt of childcare then elder care then grandkids.

Rinatinabina · 08/11/2022 16:39

I think there is a middle ground between NC and childcare. Many people spent time with their grandparents with their parents and developed a good relationship. You don’t need to provide babysitting to develop that. The babysitting and overnights is for the parents to have a break. The relationship between grandchild and grandparents is about grandparents taking an interest and being present. Quality time is what’s important.

Wildmamma · 08/11/2022 16:30

Inwas sent to grandparerts for the whole weekend lots and lots of times . Likewise to other relatives

so my dm knows what it is like to have a break and wanted this from
her relatives , but never offered to lool after her dgc. That seems strange to
me .

frippit · 08/11/2022 16:26

I love spending time with my 4 granddaughters. They live in a city 2 hours away, and the eldest 3 (4, 7 and 8) come to stay every holiday and half term. We live near North Wales and I've bought them walking boots, we climb hills and mountains, go camping, stomp through forests, streams and fields, have beach breakfasts and watch the sunrise, and dip in the sea with hot choc after. Its just fantastic and my life would be very boring without them. They keep me fit and young. It's hard work at times but so rewarding, they're such good company.
I would never miss out on any opportunity to see them.
I cannot understand grandparents who have no interest in their grandkids. Anyone can retire and do retirement activities, have a clean tidy house etc but to have grandkids is such a fantastic gift, grab it with both hands. They're just wonderful.

CaptainMyCaptain · 08/11/2022 16:23

gobblefiend · 08/11/2022 14:20

@CaptainMyCaptain

So if everyone's situation always differs, then when is it ever appropriate to make a generalisation? Never?

It's certainly pointless to generalisation about a whole age group especially when you don't even say which age group it is you are calling hypocrites. And, yes, I am against blanket generalisations with no evidence.

Getoff · 08/11/2022 16:20

Judging by threads on here, there are many things that some women think other people "should" want. This time it's grandparents, but sometimes it's men who apparently are exhibiting some sort of moral failure by not wanting something it would suit an OP for them to want.

The is no "should" when it comes to "wanting." People want what they want.

RedWingBoots · 08/11/2022 16:07

I think you are unreasonable but then I come from a big family and my DD has no grandparents.

The people who go out of their way to help me with DD are either younger family members who are childless or older family members their children aren't at the stage of giving them grandchildren.

When my own parents were alive they made it clear they wouldn't look after my nephews and nieces because they were or had just finished looking after their own children. They did like their company but the hands on care when their parents needed help was left to me, my other siblings and cousins who didn't have children.

BogRollBOGOF · 08/11/2022 16:05

I never expected childcare of any description due to distance and age which is fair enough. It's been disappointing that DM has so little interest in my DCs though, and can barely muster token polite enquiries about them.

Looking at family relationships over the years, it's become clear that she's very selective about who she likes depending on how they fit her vision of how people should be. DS1 doesn't fit that at all and she clearly likes DS2's disposition more.

I have to travel to her, but there's few invitations and no reason to be in the county to "pop by". There's that many hoops to jump through that visiting often isn't practical. By the time she's worked to her timescales it's time for me to head home anyway.

I thought she'd value me and my family more. It is hard when you're surrounded by people with family support/ interest, and that makes it harder to build mutually reciprocal relationships with peers over things like babysitting when that is done within their families. Plus the whole grandparent thing gets so romanticised anyway. The DC's other GM was older, much further away and has died, and both GDs died long before they were born.

lemmein · 08/11/2022 15:54

lemmein · 08/11/2022 15:51

I look after my DGS a lot; I love having him - he has his own room/toys/clothes here.

Not sure I'd be so keen if I had lots of GC though - one knackers me!

I should add that I'm a young GP (in my 40s!)

I think it's unreasonable to expect older GPs to look after young children - even the best behaved kids are hard work!